3 ms·
History does not repeat itself but it rhymes. Strong rhymes from the 80's and 90's when Japan was the boogieman. Replace Japan with China to update into the p
by nabla9 9y ago
History does not repeat itself but it rhymes.
Strong rhymes from the 80's and 90's when Japan was the boogieman. Replace Japan with China to update into the present moment.
1) Fear of Japanese AI was real in the 80's. The fifth generation computers (massive parallelism with prolog programs)[1].
2) Fear of Japanese buying the rest of the world [2] and unfair trade tactics.
3) Trump attacking Japan for trade and considering a presidential run with trade war and tariffs [3].
4) The war with Japan is inevitable [4].
5) Under all this Japan had 'demographic time bomb' and real estate boom reaching the maximum.
China will undoubtedly face many of the same problems as Japan did, but the scales are different (both time and magnitude). China has still at least two decades to go. The country is still undergoing urbanization and has to fit over 100 million people into cities. While Chinese growth can't be as high as in last decades, their growth will still outpace the West for a long time.
It's very unlikely that China just fizzles and stays paralyzed for more than a decade like Japan did. Either Chinese solve their problems or the problems will destabilize China internally.
---
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer
[2]: http://www.businessinsider.com/japans-eighties-america-buying-spree-2014-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/japans-eighties-america-buyin...
[3]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/over-four-decades-trumps-one-solid-stance-a-hard-line-on-trade/2018/03/07/4b1ed250-2172-11e8-badd-7c9f29a55815_story.html?utm_term=.591792e550ca https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/over-four-decades-tr...
[4]: The Coming War With Japan by George Friedman , Meredith Lebard
https://www.amazon.com/Coming-War-Japan-George-Friedman/dp/0312058365 https://www.amazon.com/Coming-War-Japan-George-Friedman/dp/0...
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIt would be ironic if the fourth AI winter came about because China over invested in AI. China's real estate boom has already hit peak Japan.
- nabla9 9y agoI'm certain that AI business will plateau and there will be yet another AI winter without new big breakthroughs in fundamental research. We are currently living in a era where the results from Hinton & Canadian Mafia are still begin adopted and refined. It's just alternating layers of affine transformations and nonlinearity with lots of tricks and improved routing. There needs to be fundamental theoretical breakthrough in every decade or so, and not just refinements and new applications. Hinton made his "What is wrong with convolutional neural nets" speech years ago "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTawFwUvnLE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTawFwUvnLE I believe that Hinton's capsule networks type attempts are what we need more. They may not deliver immediately impressive results because fundamental research involves lots of setbacks.
- clvcooke 9y agoI think we have a lot to learn from the human brain still. I am continuosly fascinated by our ability to learn quickly and use previous experience to bootstrap learning. I think the next breakthrough has a high chance of being a collaboration between the neuroscience community and CS. What is really interesting about Hinton is his background, experimental pyschology.
- m3kw9 9y agoNo one can be certain, unless you are one of those that keep saying a company will go down eventually, one day you will be right.
- nabla9 9y agoWe can avoid AI investment boom and bust cycle only if: 1) hype and expectations <= reality constantly and 2) R&D time horizon <= investor time horizon constantly Has that ever been the case? Technology advances but there are always periods of over-investment and lost fortunes. Dot-com bubble didn't burst because internet was a fad, it bursted because expectations and reality did not sync. It took over a decade for Amazon stock to return it's previous level. There has already been two AI winters one in early 70's and another in late 80's early 90's.
- m3kw9 9y agoWith all the funding into AI meaning we have way more human capital involved and with real tangible AI benefits being demonstrated, it is unlikely AI winter will arrive anytime soon, I say revisit again in 5 years
- vinn124 9y ago> It's just alternating layers of affine transformations and nonlinearity with lots of tricks and improved routing. and a computation is just 0s and 1s, with lots of if/then statements.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago
- sgt101 9y agoThere will be a shakeout - but the Deepnet boom is useful because there are several other significant technologies that have been produced since the late 80's which are ready for mainstream adoption: answer sets, tractable bayesian reasoners (MCMC), SAT solvers.. and one of the technologies that enabled deep nets has enabled these massively : big data. And now streaming systems are mainstream they are enabling for another raft of applications using AI.
- solomatov 9y agoIf we think about possible real world applications of DL and related techniques, currently at most 5-10% of possible applications are introduced. We have many years of work ahead until the current technologies will achieve their benefits in real world applications.
- staunch 9y agoJust because the boy cried wolf last time doesn't mean there isn't an actual wolf this time. You're comparing the hysteria around Japan to the hysteria around China. If you compare the facts about Japan to the facts about China, you get a completely different picture. Facts: 1. China is implementing a massive military build. 2. China has started to expand its territory. 3. China has repeatedly hacked the most sensitive US gov departments and industries. 4. China recently had an all powerful dictator rise to power. 5. China has covertly supported North Korean's ICBM program in a proxy war against the US. 6. China has allied itself with Russia against the US.
- nabla9 9y agoTwo last things are not true. China has not supported North Korean ICBM program. North Korea apparently has blueprints of early Chinese nuclear design, but they received it trough Pakistan. North Korea has received more help from freelancing Russian rocket scientists than it received from the China. China is not allied with Russia. At best they are exploiting the conflict between Russia and US to get military technology transfer and cheap energy from Russia. Russians don't trust Chinese and the feeling is mutual.
- whytaka 9y agoAlso, China has a few hundred million people without adequate housing.
- woodandsteel 9y agoAlso China has over ten times the population of Japan.
- geeostation 9y agothe scale at China can do things is different from japanese as a function of its population. 10% of japanese population investing abroad in an under connected world in the 80s is vastly different to 10% of Chinese buying up real estate in an connected world with access to lots of resources and information Japanese in the 80s simply didn't have. Chinese also immigrate into other countries in vastly higher numbers than Japanese. The japan, china comparison is close to false equivalence