4 ms·
Nothing ticks me off more than the drive by downvoters, ninja downvoting anything that could be considered an answer (or question) that violates some meta requi
by alkonaut 9y ago
Nothing ticks me off more than the drive by downvoters, ninja downvoting anything that could be considered an answer (or question) that violates some meta requirement.
If a downvote cost 10 rep and also took a while to take effect (with any edits in the meantime canceling the downvote effect) I think the site would be a better place.
Especially - when you see a question you should be able to extrapolate what the asker was trying to do.
The idea of a “questions and answers” site is broken to begin with. No one has a question, what we have is a problem, and what the person with a problem needs is a solution not an “answer”.
The best answer to a question (which might be initially best posted as a comment to get clarification if it’s not obvious) is this:
“You are asking how to do X. In this situation I think it would be best to avoid doing X alltogether and to solve your problem which I assume is Y - you should probably try doing Z”
This type of answer invariably gets two things
1. Thank you comment from the asker, for solving the problem
2. Downvotes from nitpicking drive-by moderators for not answering the question
- Avamander 9y agoAttaching an username to every downvote could also fix the situation, makes it impossible to just be negative without any consequence, the very least it allows people who actually want an answer to ping the user(s) downvoting for a reason.
- alkonaut 9y agoAgree. And a mandatory suggestion could also be required. “I think you should clarify in more detail why this is NOT a dupe of question xyz” “It’s not clear what you tried and what problems you encountered” A nitpick could give a time frame to address and fix, and the downvoter would have to review and accept reject the changes in order for the downvote to apply.
- GordonS 9y agoI think this is a great idea - it should also encourage downvoters to leave a comment explaining why. This has long been considered good etiquette on SO, so it should be encouraged somehow, or maybe even mandatory.
- codinghorror 9y agoDownvotes do cost 1 rep already. They have for almost a decade now.
- alkonaut 9y agoYes. It's clearly not enough. Perhap if downvotes with comments cost one, and downvotes without explanation cost more? And downvotes should be both signed (by user) AND motivated. Then the community could rate the downvote as well. A poor downvote should be worse for your rep than a poor question.
- shagie 9y agoWhile you are suggesting something stronger (1 rep for with a comment and 1+N rep for without a comment), give https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/276440 https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/276440 a read. The short version of it is it has problems with the design and you'll get even more junk in comments along with disparaging remarks. Down votes are not a problem. They're a form of moderation of content. They are a signal to other readers that this material has an issue. They are a suggestion that the question shouldn't even be read because. They increase the perception of "this is an attack on the person and not a review of the content."
- alkonaut 9y agoI agree it’s a form of moderation and has long term value, there are issues with how voting is applied (quickly and without feedback), leading to questions being buried or closed instead of improved. As an example: I read a poor question where I can decode what the problem they are having is, but it’s not obvious from the question, so it should be improved. Since I know a good solution to this problem, I don’t downvote or close-vote because I don’t want to bury or close the question while I answer. Instead I suggest how to improve the question in a comment, and start writing my answer. When my answer is finished after 10 minutes, the question is -4 and has multiple close votes even though the author has already improved the question, and my answer was accepted. The question isn’t even an hour old, it’s now a perfectly acceptable question with an accepted answer - but it’s now closed and has score -4 with votes applied to a question that looked nothing like it does now. So the biggest issues are - too easy to downvote with no moderation effort - too easy to end up with improved questions still closed - Fundamental improvements doesn’t reset score (why should asker be encouraged to write a new Q instead of changing old?) In short the problem is that everything happens at once, and the system is designed around questions being final when in reality the first 24h sees significant change. So I’d suggest some simple fixes: - close votes and downvotes removed (by moderation queue confirmation) if a question is sufficiently rewritten in the first (say) hour. It should simply count as a new one. - downvotes registered but not shown during the first (say) hour. Herd mentality seems to make the threshold for downvoting lower. - clicking downvote should at least have an optional comment or a selection among issues (like the close votes already have). That the material has an issue is content moderation but it isn’t feedback. I agree with Jon’s goal that the site should aim to make better askers - not just a better Q/A site. It should even be an explicit goal.