6 ms·
Google Maps has found a better way to navigate India’s chaotic roads
- deanCommie 9y agoDon't we already have a system for mapping worldwide geographic coordinates? Or is this essentially an easier to read/remember version of latitude/longitude? I thought this would be about more clever pathfinding optimization in a part of the world where typical shortest-path optimizations are much harder.
- mtmail 9y agoI don't think I could remember 8GC2 CMXR+X6 (from the plus codes homepage) any better than latitude and longitude. Or spell that over the phone without using the NATO alphabet.
- mbesto 9y agoWhich is why w3w is a really novel approach to this: https://what3words.com/ https://what3words.com/
- theDoug 9y agoAs far as I can see, this seems to be a "global solution" which only outputs English
- jpatokal 9y agoNo, they're already localised into 22 languages: https://support.what3words.com/hc/en-us/articles/203105501-How-many-languages-are-you-in- https://support.what3words.com/hc/en-us/articles/203105501-H... But what3words is proprietary and requires licensing, while Google's codes are open source. Disclaimer: I used to work on Google Maps, including geocoding, but not this initiative.
- eat_veggies 9y agoThey're private, proprietary, and online (it can decode regular three word combos offline, but the one word special locations need web access). Switching the order of words results in totally different locations. Google gave the example of "banana rabbit monkey" being in Argentina, "banana monkey rabbit" in Russia [0]. And while it's localized to more languages than just English, the friction when exchanging location data across language barriers seems problematic. For example, giving an English speaker something like "пропан.зачет.некий." in an image, spoken, or written on paper would be totally opaque and hard to even enter with a US keyboard, let alone commit to memory. [0] https://github.com/google/open-location-code/wiki/Evaluation-of-Location-Encoding-Systems#web-based-services https://github.com/google/open-location-code/wiki/Evaluation...
- telotortium 9y agoThere are features of the plus codes that make it easier than you think to memorize and communicate them, however: - Similar to a phone number, the code can be reduced to the last 4 or 6 digits in practice, because the "area code" (in this case, "8GC2") selects a large region (approximately the size of a metropolitan area) and thus can be omitted if referring to destinations in your local area. - The letters are selected to be minimally confusable with each other, so you don't need to use the NATO alphabet.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoCoordinates are hard to get across without messing them up - any number corresponds to something in the vicinity and there's no checksum. This is supposed to be an alternative.
- cdirkx 9y agoA couple of years ago I visited a startup which also tried mapping worldwide coordinates, what3words [1]. They map 3x3m squares to a combination of three words (language customizable). For example: the Eifel tower would be at combos.cove.split. They had some clever tricks for mapping short memorable words to densly populated areas and longer ones to the middle of the ocean. Their aim was similar, to enable talking about a place without the existing infrastructure of adresses and streetnames and for example make it possible to deliver mail in slums. [1] www.what3words.com
- superlopuh 9y agoIt's a shame that google didn't go with this approach, although I assume it's because of the lack of portability between all the languages in that area. Maybe what3words should pivot into what3emoji.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thinkloop 9y agoGood point about the portability and the emojis idea is clever, but I think the main purpose was to be able to speak then easily.
- pwinnski 9y agowhat3words is terrible technology, and also proprietary. Quick, what direction do you go to get from combos.cove.split to reindeer.steak.rules? I made up the second address, but it highlights how completely useless what3words is for directions. Worse than useless.
- dalemyers 9y agoQuick, what direction do you go to get from 123 Main Street to 456 Birch Street? Quick, what direction do you go to get from 12.34567N, 12.34567W to 56.43210N, 23.87654E? Not being able to immediately determine direction between 2 addresses isn't a failing.
- onetimemanytime 9y agoThe government of that state has to adopt them to be really "it". Otherwise Google can adopt X solution, Here.com Y solution, Bing Maps Z and so on. Does it matter that Google has a "solution" when the government sends me the bill at another address?
- rlpb 9y ago> Or is this essentially an easier to read/remember version of latitude/longitude? It's more like the hierarchical telephone numbering system. If you know it's local, the code can be much shorter. It doesn't need to be globally unique; just unique in the same city.
- mtmail 9y agoThe article doesn't talk about navigation, but referencing start or end point (geocoding, geohashing). The plus codes are also called open location codes and the pros and cons were recently on the frontpage https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16594188 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16594188
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The article doesn't talk about navigation, but referencing start or end point That's an essential part of navigation, and one that falls down in many places.
- theCricketer 9y agoPlus Codes is a "system is based on dividing the geographical surface of the Earth into tiny ‘tiled areas’, attributing a unique code to each of them. " The original blog post: https://india.googleblog.com/2018/03/searching-for-indian-addresses-on.html https://india.googleblog.com/2018/03/searching-for-indian-ad...
- kylehotchkiss 9y agoHow much shorter could this system be with Emojis? Can they contain enough info to limit it to 3-4 emojis? That would be easier to remember. Emoji adoption for any smartphone issue wouldn't be an issue.
- RustySpottedCat 9y agoEach symbol of the 11 characters in the plus code is in base 20. There are about 2500 emojis, meaning that you can encode 2 symbols from the plus code with one emoji (20*20=400, if you try to encode 3 symbols, it becomes 8000, which is way more than the current emoji count). So that would become 5 emojis, instead of 11 characters, which in my opinion would look quite nicer.
- superlopuh 9y agoGiven the data Google has, I'm sure they could come up with an efficient encoding scheme that would use far fewer emoji on average by prioritising popular coordinates.
- bkohlmann 9y agoGoogles solution sounds very familiar to what we used in the military: GRGs or geographical reference grids. Every point on earth was contained within a box named with two letters. Within each box was a theoretically infinite number of digits that could be assigned. Practically, we had immense precision with as few as 8 numbers - 4 each for the horizontal and vertical axes on the map. While flying Close Air Support missions, we could be flying 30k feet overhead and within seconds have our sensors on whatever the ground controller wanted us to look at. It was a version of Lat/long, but far more intuitive with each digit representing a different order of magnitude of the base measurement unit.
- stouset 9y agoFor those interested, this is the Military Grid Reference System (MGRS): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Grid_Reference_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Grid_Reference_Syst...
- colek42 9y agoMGRS is a pain to program. So many edge cases.
- pouta 9y agoCan you elaborate? I'm really interested in knowing more...
- colek42 9y agoPolar regions are tough, not many libraries support them. Lat/Lon represents a point, MGRS represents an area. This causes issues when converting between MGRS and lat/long and back again. Also, a single location can be represented by several MGRS coordinates since the numerical value is an offset from a line, the letters represent where this line is. Then we get into other issues. When converting from lat/lon we need to know what projection the data is in. I often have to make assumptions here, if my assumptions are wrong it could cause an error of many km, depending on how far away from the equator you are. There are several other edge cases I am probably no stating. If you are interested there is some pretty good sample code here: https://svn.osgeo.org/gdal/trunk/gdal/frmts/nitf/mgrs.c https://svn.osgeo.org/gdal/trunk/gdal/frmts/nitf/mgrs.c
- walrus01 9y agothese "plus codes" sound sort of like a DNS system because humans are not good at remembering or typing purely numerical coordinates. For example decimal degrees in a common system: 48.756071,-122.482410 (a randomly chosen location in Bellingham, WA) in WGS84 datum decimal degrees, six decimal places is accurate to about 0.11 meter, which is close enough for pretty much any human land navigation needs, and considerably better than the actual accuracy of a modern GPS+GLONASS+WAAS receiver. if you really want to be super accurate for navigation purposes go for seven decimal places. Anything beyond seven is in the range of high precision GIS/surveying tool needs only. https://gis.stackexchange.com/questions/8650/measuring-accuracy-of-latitude-and-longitude https://gis.stackexchange.com/questions/8650/measuring-accur... so the question is how to take a string of lat/long coordinates such as the one above for bellingham and turn them into some sort of geographical code which humans can remember and type. Sort of like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What3words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What3words the commentary elsewhere in this thread on the private, proprietary nature of what3words is quite valid. I'm not saying that this specific implementation is the best possible idea, but that the general idea of geocoding numbers into a consistent word-based system is something that is more easily remembered and written down by ordinary humans who do not interact with IP addresses and long strings of numbers on a daily basis. try to remember a full ipv6 address vs. remembering a DNS hostname, for example.
- ouzu 9y agoWhat3words (https://what3words.com/ https://what3words.com/) offers a better solution IMO. It offers a system to represent coordinate as 3 words and is localized in many languages.
- dingo_bat 9y agoHorrible title. This has nothing to do with navigation. Google didn't want to invest money/effort into properly mapping addresses in India. So they reinvented the lat/long system and call it "plus code".
- jpatokal 9y agoNo, there are no proper addresses for large slabs of India. The status quo is people using things like "Vijay Nagar, IFFCO Chowk, behind Maruti showroom" even for mailed correspondence.
- jogjayr 9y agoFor non-Indian readers "Vijay Nagar" is a neighborhood named "Vijay", "IFCCO Chowk" is an intersection named "IFFCO" (yes sometimes intersections have names and the names often have nothing to do with the streets that join there) and "Maruti" is an automobile brand.
- dingo_bat 9y agoWhy is that not a proper address?
- sumedh 9y agoI guess because the govt does not have a proper standard especially in rural areas. Some areas don't have proper roads so nobody from the govt visits those areas.
- bingobob 9y agoPlus code isn't new Google talk about them before as there where developed at Google's Zürich engineering office and release in 2014 there also called open location code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Location_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Location_Code
- nonamechicken 9y agoAnybody knows whether Google's or MapMyIndia's is better? http://www.mapmyindia.com/eloc/ http://www.mapmyindia.com/eloc/
- LeoPanthera 9y agoIn the world of amateur radio, coordinates are converted into short strings of letters called the Maidenhead Locator System: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maidenhead_Locator_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maidenhead_Locator_System I always wondered why this system hasn't "escaped" amateur radio and found uses elsewhere.
- telotortium 9y agoLooking at the FAQ (https://github.com/google/open-location-code/wiki/Evaluation-of-Location-Encoding-Systems#maidenhead-locator-system-mls https://github.com/google/open-location-code/wiki/Evaluation...), it appears that Plus Codes are very similar to the Maidenhead codes, except in these respects: - Maidenhead codes contain vowels, which the Plus code designers didn't want to use in order to avoid having codes spell words (which might have negative associations or be profane). - The addition of the "+" character is felt to make it easier to autodetect addresses when provided to Google Maps or similar systems.
- ChaitanyaSai 9y agoAnyone know how they get traffic data in India? I am quite amazed by how accurate and near-realtime their traffic maps are. While India is heavily Android, it can't all be from crowdfarmed GPS data, or is it?
- sumedh 9y agoPretty sure its all data from Android phones, why do you think it would be something else?