3 ms·
Like every other country, they want a healthy economy, which requires innovation. China's proposed social credit system would be counterproductive to innovatio
by walterbell 9y ago
Like every other country, they want a healthy economy, which requires innovation.
China's proposed social credit system would be counterproductive to innovation, i.e. the cost may be too high.
- Mvandenbergh 9y agoPeople have been hoping for this link between freedom and economic development for years about China. It turns out that it's just wishful thinking. China is much richer and no more free than it was decades ago.
- walterbell 9y agoChina has benefited from external IP/technology "inspiration" which is about to result in new trade barriers with the US. If their future growth depends on homegrown (instead of foreign) innovation, they could experiment with freedom within economic development zones.
- pishpash 9y agoThe eras of growth have been the most free in the history of China. People allowed to own land, allowed employment of their choice, allowed to move, and allowed to start private enterprises. There is a one-to-one correlation between how much people are allowed to do and ... what they do.
- scrumption 9y ago>most free >People allowed to own land Not sure the mental gymnastics you have to go through to convince yourself private ownership of land == freedom American by chance?
- SamReidHughes 9y agoIf you own land you can do what you want with it.
- cornholio 9y agoActually, that's not a surprise; throughout history, dictatorships often failed when economic conditions where dire, see the Eastern block, while economic prosperity always consolidated strongmen - Hitler and Putin for example. But the social changes technology and development produce are far reaching, and usually well correlated on the long term with a democratic society. It's hard to care about liberty when you don't have food on the table, and a lower educated and poor person is much more likely to accept authoritarianism as an acceptable compromise. I'm very hopeful for China's future and Hong Kong's peaceful resistance is a model that wil spread.
- api 9y agoThere's an easy solution to this: create a two-tier society in which the wealthy, highly educated, and highly productive / inventive are permitted to exist under relative freedom in "economic development zones" or similar while the rest of the population is kept under totalitarian rule. In other words create comparatively free theme parks for the professional class.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoNot too far off from the rural/urban divide in America. New York City is a great place for a person with an upper middle class backgrobud to become a millionaire. Yet in the Southern Tier of upstate NY you have people who have lived for decades without electricity at home. There is straight-up Hunger Games poverty up here and it’s rarely reported on by the big newspapers downstate that would rather talk about tech and Trump.
- gwenzek 9y agoInterestingly, in 19884 the government do the opposite. The workforce have some leeway (booze and sex) while the middle class (the one that could see through the party lies and revolt) is under permanent surveillance.