3 ms·
You get to do that. Others get to do what they are doing too. It's not about that. I'm not gonna tell you what to do, but I will absolutely tell you somethin
by ddingus 9y ago
You get to do that. Others get to do what they are doing too.
It's not about that. I'm not gonna tell you what to do, but I will absolutely tell you something about what it means.
Maybe you don't know.
Frankly, your preferences are toxic. The toxicity is rooted in lack of consideration for others.
Nobody is objective. Even you.
And that lack of consideration actually undermines your stated goal of objectivity. It's not really viable to attempt objectivity without actually considering others and the social dynamics in play.
Those carry a lot of implications for everyone involved, even you.
Now, trans people simply are the gender they self identify as. Manning didn't switch.
What she did was actualize herself better, and that means being able to present as who she is better. Would you have others live lies so you, personally feel better about who they are?
I wouldn't, and for one reason: What if it were me stuck with a bad deal like she got?
What is that bad deal?
Rather than always parsing every move, interaction, expression for gender norm compliance, essentially living a lie, she now simply is and does as any of us do. Who wants to live an act, facade like that?
Nobody, and that is a basic human truth. Nobody. It's hell.
Your attempt to connect things back to an identity that is a more or less a lie, a forced construct, does nothing but reinforce the lies and severe inhibition she just escaped from.
Further, by doing that, you also inhibit acceptance and amplify severe and personal pain and for what?
I will leave that for you to answer, save to say it's self serving and this world isn't just about you.
Consideration due is consideration given. You aren't giving any, leaving yourself due very little, which should explain the frank and blunt nature of my comment, which I really should not have to write.
Maybe it helps. Hope so. The world will be just a bit better, and that is my intent here.
Give a little, and 'ye shall receive.
Oh, and no response required or expected. I don't care about that. No need. Just think, and then consider acting on the product of those thoughts.
Cheers.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSo, person B who was born male chooses at age 30 to identify as some other gender. You then say they were a different _sex_ their whole life, and consider that objective truth? Now, as happens occasionally, person B realises they now wish to identify with their birth sex and not their assumed gender. What's the objective truth now. Isn't the whole "well in a different gender" completely sexist, why do I have to fall in line with someone's quantised buttons of gender because they choose to self-identify in a different way to me? Perhaps instead of people demanding others rewrite the past they should get over themselves. Accept what's true and can't be changed and get on with it. Now I can be condescending to you and tell you to think about it if you like ...?