6 ms·
Examining overlooked clues reveals how ultrasound could have caused harm in Cuba
- mkempe 9y agoUntil and unless they actually test their "reverse-engineered" device with live subjects under similar conditions to what has been reported in Cuba, how valid is that claim? Edit: this is, of course, a rhetorical question. The "reverse-engineered weapon" claim is clearly false.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- robotkdick 9y agoI was also looking for the results of a human experiment. Math is great and all, but if there's no human symptoms that mimic the original reports, this thesis is just a science experiment.
- Firerouge 9y agoBut what University is going to approve a human testing study of a weapon with possible lasting health implications...?
- robotkdick 9y agoHow can they really know they "reverse engineered" the "weapon" unless they have sync with actual human symptoms. It's not the study (or university policies) I take issue with, it's the way they present their study as conclusive. It's not conclusive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- corpMaverick 9y agoUniversidad de la Habana ?
- smogcutter 9y agoThey make this point themselves in the article: they can account for the unusual recording from Cuba, but not for people's symptoms. >> While the math leads us to believe that intermodulation distortion is a likely culprit in the Cuban case, we haven’t ruled out other null hypotheses that may account for the discomfort that diplomats felt. For example, maybe the tones people heard didn’t cause their symptoms but were just another symptom, a clue to the real cause.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> While the math leads us to believe that intermodulation distortion is a likely culprit in the Cuban case, we haven’t ruled out other null hypotheses that may account for the discomfort that diplomats felt. For example, maybe the tones people heard didn’t cause their symptoms but were just another symptom, a clue to the real cause. Unless what I read was just plain lies, I don't see how this is plausible. Just reading The Guardian's article [1] I see no room for other plausible explanations in every case... remember there were at least 21 US victims (!!): The blaring, grinding noise jolted the American diplomat from his bed in a Havana hotel. He moved just a few feet, and there was silence. He climbed back into bed. Inexplicably, the agonizing sound hit him again. It was as if he’d walked through some invisible wall cutting straight through his room. Soon came the hearing loss, and the speech problems, symptoms both similar and altogether different from others among at least 21 US victims in an astonishing international mystery still unfolding in Cuba. The top US diplomat has called them “health attacks”. New details learned by the Associated Press indicate at least some of the incidents were confined to specific rooms or even parts of rooms with laser-like specificity, baffling US officials who say the facts and the physics don’t add up. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/14/mystery-of-sonic-weapon-attacks-at-us-embassy-in-cuba-deepens https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/14/mystery-of-son...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoSounds a lot like some sort of constructive interference. Or highly directional microwaves of course.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- flatline 9y agoIt seems like the ultrasonic emissions were more likely a byproduct of whatever caused the physical symptoms, though the article makes a hand-wavey reference to people getting ill from such emissions.
- make3 9y agoYou don't need to burn someone alive to know that putting someone under certain heat conditions is going to kill them. Similarly, you don't need to actually expose people to crazy powerful sonic waves to know that they would suffer from it; just knowing that the waves were there and inferring how to generate them is enough. All of this is obvious though; you aren't being rational about this, like you have a dog in the race.
- mkempe 9y agoWhat's with the ad hominem? The authors themselves admit that their design and hypothetical weapon cannot account for the actual symptoms. Edit: when my kids finally convince me to get a dog for the family, I'll name it Truth, Facts, or Parmenides.
- mkempe 9y agoNote: the HN title has been changed from the original "How We Reverse Engineered the Cuban “Sonic Weapon” Attack" which is the actual title of that IEEE Spectrum article.
- Negative1 9y agoThe other attack they described ("DolphinAttack") is intriguing. I've yet to read the paper (but plan to), but the idea of Voice control being ever more present and likely extending to control of more parts of our lives (Banking, Vehicle Controls, Home Security...) could make this a pretty effective attack vector.
- akira2501 9y ago> could make this a pretty effective attack vector. Until we start putting high order low pass filters in everything.
- rurban 9y agoThis is the last movement of Jean Sibelius Symphony No 1 in E minor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCIw_4oJ4Gg&t=27m20s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCIw_4oJ4Gg&t=27m20s At about 36m you can hear the rumbling IMD effects.
- sjburt 9y agoCouldn't they obtain a 7khz tone by mixing any two tones seperated by 7khz and applying a low-pass filter? I don't see how this proves anything. And the 155dB number cited by the Canadian government would require considerable (hundreds of watts) of power to produce at close range. This whole case defies logic. The early reports were of mysterious symptoms not associated with any obvious exposure. Once ultrasound/infrasound began being mentioned, people began reporting hearing mysterious sounds. The recording makes even less sense: If the sound levels were really sufficient to cause physical trauma, surely they would overwhelm the phone's microphone?
- tossaway1 9y ago> Couldn't they obtain a 7khz tone by mixing any two tones seperated by 7khz and applying a low-pass filter? I don't understand this comment. Are you implying that a low-pass filter would shift the frequencies of part of the signal rather than (mostly) filtering some of the frequencies away...?
- sjburt 9y agoWhen they are mixed they produce a beat frequency. When it is sampled at a lower frequency only the beat frequency remains. I may be wrong but I think a filter would have the same effect in this case. My point is that any number of inputs could produce the observation, so their claim of reverse engineering is rather questionable. In fact they have no evidence of ultrasound at all.
- kaoD 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterodyne#Mixer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterodyne#Mixer > In the most common application, two signals at frequencies f1 and f2 are mixed, creating two new signals, one at the sum f1 + f2 of the two frequencies, and the other at the difference f1 − f2. Then the low pass filter is used to remove the original signals and the sum, leaving only the difference.
- amelius 9y agomixing = multiplying, not superimposing I know, it's confusing ...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mycall 9y ago> Xu’s 2017 paper “DolphinAttack: Inaudible Voice Commands” describes how we used ultrasonic signals to inject inaudible voice commands into speech recognition systems such as Siri, Google Now, Samsung S Voice, Huawei HiVoice, Cortana, Alexa, and the navigation system of an Audi automobile. So cool. I had this idea a long time ago but never approached it. Kudos to them for some follow through.
- icantdrive55 9y agoI repair watches. I use a Bulova Watchmaster to clean the movements. It's an older all metal ultrasonic cleaning unit. When I heared the sound on the website's first video, I immediately recognized the sound. A sound I have only hear on my cleaning machine. On my unit, I put cleaning fluid in metal cups. I then put my movements into the baskets. I turn on the machine, and that buzzing sound comes out. I'll experiment more night. Right now, I'm pretty sure that buzzing sound is only present when I put the movements in the baskets. I assume the buzzing/rattling sound is my watch parts banging against the metal cleaning cups. I can offer this, I have only heard that sound on my machine, and today on this website.
- slr555 9y agoJust a brief question from a non-engineer: Is this the same kind of phenomenon that produces the illusion of a fifth voice in a barber shop quartet? Thanks!
- trdtaylor1 9y ago1. They cannot claim they discovered constructive/destructive intereference 2. They cannot claim they discovered interference that shifts frequency. 3. They cannot claim to have "Reverse engineered the Cuban "Sonic Weapon" attack" They instead PROPOSE the U.S. Embassy in Cuba has brain-altering levels of noise in the ultrasonic region somehow caused by two or more simple,low level and possibly common ultrasonic emitters without malicious intent and THAT'S why some people can hear it... Xu's other recent works has been lacking meat and are better at fear-mongering (Tesla ultrasonic 'hack', Smart grid 'hack'). Xu's ultrasonic Tesla 'hack' showed how dangerous the pedestrian avoidance system was by wrapping one of her graduate students in Michelin Man-sized ultrasonic dampening material. Tesla had to make an uncharacteristically brusque comment stating they couldn't reproduce anything of risk to Tesla drivers in the world. She is the equivalent of the National Enquirer in the security research world and steadily increased her ability to clickbait.
- dang 9y agoAn earlier version of this work was discussed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16515552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16515552. Since commenters here are objecting to the article title as misleading, we've replaced it with the subtitle (with s/Havana/Cuba/ to fit in 80 chars).
- trdtaylor1 9y agoNot you nor submitters fault. The ire of the intelligent community is towards the people behind the obvious click-bait paper and article.
- aaron695 9y agoSnopes had blown this out of the water half a year ago yet HN still goes on about it. I think this says a lot. We know what it is but these conspiracies keep on coming and getting lapped up on HN. It is funny how the US kicks diplomats out on mass for having crickets in their home country, for the Brits is for using a nerve agent in their country.
- foobarbecue 9y agoWhat a weird, rambling article. I read the whole thing and I'm really not sure what point they were trying to make. Two ultrasonic signals can interfere to produce lower wavelength sound? That's kind of obvious to anyone who has studied signals...
- alexandercrohde 9y agoI agree it was poorly written. I believe the intent was to say: A) We have recording from Cuba, therefore there's proof of ultrasonic noise. B) This noise we have is in the audible spectrum, but we have reason to suspect it's from the interaction of two ultrasonic frequencies that together produce a very whiney audible frequency C) Ultrasonic noise can be used for spying and voice-injection, so there's a potential motive for the US to use such technology at an embassy.
- jnaulty 9y agoA much better source... https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ldquo-sonic-weapon-attacks-rdquo-on-u-s-embassy-don-rsquo-t-add-up-mdash-for-anyone/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ldquo-sonic-weapo...