6 ms·
What Record-Low Unemployment Looks Like in America
- monkmartinez 9y agoThey just stopped counting the people that don want to work.... and let me tell you there are a LOT of them. Ask any police officer or firefighter about apartment complexes full of people who do not want to work, can not work because drugs, or are on disability.
- space_fountain 9y agoAs far as I know those people have never been counted. Certainly not recently. Unemployment is really hard to calculate
- Bartweiss 9y agoThey're not included in 'unemployment' as commonly cited, but they're regularly counted. The labor force participation rate describes how many people of working age are trying to work. 'NEET' stats remove from that number education or vocational training students. And economists use multiple definitions of unemployment accounting for many different things. U3 is commonly cited, but misleading for this purpose. U4 captures people who want to work but assume it isn't available, U5 captures other unattached workers, and U6 even adds part time workers seeking full time work.
- phyzome 9y agoIt also doesn't count people who want to work, but have given up after years of trying. IIRC, unemployment is calculated based on the number of people who are actively filing unemployment paperwork.
- peterstjohn 9y agoU4: U3 + "discouraged workers", or those who have stopped looking for work because current economic conditions make them believe that no work is available for them.
- pkaye 9y agoIsn't that called discouraged workers and covered under U5 unemployment? Unemployment is not based on the those who filled out the paperwork... it is based on a population survey. They call up random people and ask a series of questions. There are different levels of unemployment like those who are discouraged or underemployed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bureau_of_Labor_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bur...
- phyzome 9y agoThe term "unemployment", said by itself, is ambiguous. I was annoyed that the Bloomberg article didn't specify. (If it did, I missed it.)
- snarf21 9y agoThis is also the risk with "official" statistics. The under employed and "gave up"s are wrongly excluded.
- fastball 9y agoTo me, that makes sense regardless of how true your make (which I find suspect) may be. A nation's unemployment rate should be a reflection of the economy's ability to employ it's populace. Not how many people actively have jobs.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThis is precisely it. (Employed / seeking employment) is the U3 employment rate - it's a perfectly legitimate statistic for understanding how the job search is going. When economists want to count the temporarily discouaged, they use U4. And when they want to count those not working for other reasons, they use U5. It's annoying that we treat U3 as "the unemployment rate" for political discourse, but it's a perfectly reasonable metric for economic analysis, and I wish people would stop pretending it's some kind of trick.
- matte_black 9y agoIf that’s true why wouldn’t this have been done in the past where the perceived unemployment was even worse? I’ll tell you why – because it’s not true.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThose are also counted, the Fed releases multiple unemployment numbers, the one everyone thinks of as "the unemployment number" is U3 but you might want to look into U6 which includes discouraged workers and those who want to work but haven't looked recently and the underemployed.
- dsr_ 9y agoSpecifically, you are looking for various measures of "not in the labor force" -- called U1 through U6. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t15.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t15.htm U6 is: Total unemployed, plus all persons marginally attached to the labor force, plus total employed part time for economic reasons, as a percent of the civilian labor force plus all persons marginally attached to the labor force The national U6 right now is 9.2 (unadjusted).
- copper_think 9y agoIt says 8.6 on the page
- protomyth 9y agodsr_ followed the column down a bit off and got the Feb 2017 seasonally adjusted number (they are one column apart) - they should really separate those better
- anthony_romeo 9y agoAlso worth noting that U-3 is an international definition of unemployment. If different countries use different definitions, then comparing rates among countries would be pretty much meaningless.
- williamscales 9y agoThey didn't stop, these folks have never been counted in U3, the most commonly cited measure of unemployment. BLS publishes multiple unemployment rates, six in fact, that capture different aspects of the issue: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bureau_of_Labor_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bur...
- tunesmith 9y agoI found this graph helpful[1]. U6 has come down along with the other unemployment numbers, but it also shows how historically bad the recession was. For those affected by it, that's six years they will never get back - they might be "employed" now, but with prospects that are far worse than if the crash hadn't happened. [1]: http://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate http://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate
- kaycebasques 9y agoI skimmed the article, so I may have missed it, but the article doesn’t seem to mention that official numbers exclude long-term discouraged workers. Apparently they were removed from official numbers in 1994. http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-charts http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-chart...
- adventured 9y agoThe US - the BLS - commonly tracks multiple variations of employment. The two most common are the U3 and U6. They're very well known and easily accessible. Just punch in "u6 unemployment rate" into Google.
- rockinghigh 9y agoU3 is the official unemployment rate but U5 and U6 numbers include discouraged workers.
- icantdrive55 9y ago1. I thought the government included these people in their questionable statistics. I don't doubt what you say though. Those unemployment have always baffled me. If they were rigged, I wouldn't be suprised. 2. My biggest gripe is anyone with eyes knows certain sectors of the economy are doing well, but it's still dismal out there. So many union jobs were just obliterated. 3. That "abled bodied, but not working number" is so high. I believe it's higher than ever? Higher than when women had the luxury of staying home to raise their kids? 4. I constantly remember Janet Yellen commenting on that sticky unemployment number of people who just weren't working. Why? We all knew why. 5. Yes--some gave up, but so many of the jobs being are just aweful. Slick Tech firms getting desperate people to use their vechicle to carry the wealthy around, deliver their toys, and put their food on the doorstep. All Independent Contractors of course. Daddy needs to make his nut, and live like them? Be more foxy than the next guy, but talk a liberal game. And so many really lousy jobs. Jobs that immigrants are passing on. So good luck America. This is the lovely new economy. The poor catering to the wealthy. Maybe it's always been this way, but in the past, it wasen't so noticeable. There was a time where being the cleverest rat wasen't cool. Now they put them on a stage? I pity the day the the money runs dry in tech. I guess most of you will have a spare room to retreat to? Big Head got elected because he said what everyone was seeing with their own eyes, especially in reguards to the horrid economy. Absolutely nothing has changed in 420 days. Nothing. If anything he's just making it worse. What I find more depressing the wealthy have brainwashed people into thinking this is all just fine, and dandy. Let's help out those poor people that country. "What you're better than them?" Being a American has always been about denial. That is what use to make living here feel like a dream. The dream is diluted, and their will never be a revolt. Cheap tech, and a questionable educational system solved that minor worry that used to keep the wealthy boys on edge. "Just put a spin on the abuse. They won't notice. Even if they catch on, what power do they have?"
- alex_young 9y agoThe unemployment rate is still over 8% if you count those who have dropped off because they haven't found work in 6 or more months. This measure was well under 7% at our last period of nearly full employment. http://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate http://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate
- IncRnd 9y agoU-6 unemployment has been trending down not up over the last year. Looking at specific dates, raw U-6 is .9 less than a year ago. Seasonally adjusted U-6 is a full point less than a year ago. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t15.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t15.htm
- Bartweiss 9y agoFor all the talk about different unemployment rates, U3 - U6 track each other shockingly closely. That said, OP's complaint still applies for LFPR or NEET percentage, which as far as I know are moving opposite U3-6?
- IncRnd 9y agoLFPR has been mostly unchanged since the end of 2013. https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 I agree, though, the U numbers are basically the definition of "fake news" from the standpoint of what you mentioned.
- tj-teej 9y ago"if you count those who have dropped off" - I thought the definition of unemployment doesn't include those who're not looking?
- opportune 9y agoThere are multiple different notions of employment (e.g. U1 through U6). The US government uses U3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bureau_of_Labor_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#United_States_Bur...
- dalbasal 9y agoUnemployment rate might be the most important indicator politically, but it really is the wrong one for most of the things we care about. What it tells you is (mostly) how much unemployment will be paid out and (to some extent) how available workers are. Anyway, "healthy" unemployment rate is usually 4%-7%. The "right" metric is "employment rate," which is not the inverse. This is just the people working out of the working age population. It doesn't care whether people are unemployed, unable to work, retired, students, stay at home parents... Just how many people work. This is usually around 60%-70%. ...so obviously "unemployed" leaves out the vast majority of non workers. If you want to compare one area to another, for example, compare employment rates. Worried about techno-"unemployment," monitor employment rates. Slower, steadier societal effects will show here.
- rockinghigh 9y agoThis metric is called the labor force participation rate. It's currently at 63%. The Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes the times series since 1948: https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000
- dbatten 9y agoNot quite. Labor force participation counts those that are employed or _want_ to be employed...
- dalbasal 9y agoOECD countries compared in the link. You can toggle to participation rate or some other variant. https://data.oecd.org/emp/employment-rate.htm https://data.oecd.org/emp/employment-rate.htm
- protonimitate 9y agoIs there any metric that includes a "livable employment rate"? I.e. does employment count if you aren't making enough to get by on? With the growing class divide and inflation, how much does being employed matter if you need two or three jobs to get by?
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoI'd like to understand how record employment affects 401k contributions and thereby, fuels the already heady stock market. And what's happening with home ownership and real estate prices across the nation? For example, my development has 115 homes. Zero are for sale, and the last sale was nearly 1 year ago. There is no inventory. Does it constitute a virtuous cycle for the economy? Next up, inflation and increasing interest rates as the fed works to keep the economy from overheating.
- tartuffe78 9y agoIt's not record high employment, its record low unemployment.
- adventured 9y agoIt is in fact record high employment. It hit 155.2 million in February. The highest number of people that have ever been employed in US history. By comparison, that number was 143 million just five years ago. The prior peak before the great recession ten years ago, was 146 million. It's not the record for labor force participation rate obviously. That will never be hit again, thanks to the US aging.
- dv_dt 9y ago> It's not the record for labor force participation rate obviously. That will never be hit again, thanks to the US aging. Maybe, but not necessarily. The Labor force is defined as those of "working age", so if they age out of the tracked range, then they no longer accounted for in the labor force participation rate calculation. There may be a general population participation rate (not sure if I have the right term here) for which your comment could be projected if current demographic trends hold, but that can be shifted by things like shifting immigration or fertility rate trends.
- adventured 9y agoIt'd be theoretically possible, however the rate at which the US is aging, puts a very low likelihood on it happening. We'd need an extraordinary burst of immigration, or perhaps to start counting robots as workers and taxing them accordingly (which we may yet do). This was a big headline the other day: "People over 65 years old would outnumber children by 2035, a first in U.S. history, according to updated projections released by the Census Bureau on Tuesday." https://www.wsj.com/articles/elderly-in-u-s-are-projected-to-outnumber-its-children-for-first-time-1520967362 https://www.wsj.com/articles/elderly-in-u-s-are-projected-to...
- danceparty 9y agoCan anyone explain how to reconcile this with the massive explosion in homelessness in SF and LA?
- tjr225 9y agoI can't confirm this with data but my guess would be that even though unemployment is low, people are generally doing more work for less money - and everything costs more (especially housing)...but that's just what income inequality looks like.
- pixl97 9y agoHomelessness is the lowest ever in my city, we give all the homeless one way bus tickets to San Fran ?Downvoting for the truth? https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/20/bussed-out-america-moves-homeless-people-country-study https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...
- adventured 9y agoThere hasn't been a massive explosion in homelessness in San Francisco. SF's homeless rate hasn't changed much in 15-20 years, it was just as high during the last economic boom in 2005-2006. It was nearly as high on a population ratio basis during the peak of the economy in 2000 as well, despite a lower U6 unemployment rate at that time. General homelessness was 5,376 in 2000. It was 6,248 in 2005. It was 6,686 in 2015. SF is doing an extraordinarily poor job of managing its homelessness, despite their affluence and vast resources. That's the fundamental problem.
- sp332 9y agoI thought that was because of increasing housing prices. So people who are employed might still be priced out of housing.
- sgift 9y agoSure: Employment and "has enough money to live" are not the same thing. The second one is a far more interesting metric, but also far more sober for most governments, so they don't use it.
- roymurdock 9y agoKashkari (Presidnet of Minneapolis Fed): "We were at maximum employment. We are now at maximumer employment." Michael Lebowitz: "So explain why monetary policy is still in emergency mode. Funds at 1.25-1.50 and over $4 trln balance sheet." Kashkari: "I thought the "tongue-in-cheekiness" of my tweet would be obvious. Allow me to translate: We keep saying we are at max employment and then all these people choose to work. It suggests we weren't really at max employment." Reggie Palatty: "Dude I loved you in the Mummy Returns" Kashkari: "I was better in the original" https://twitter.com/neelkashkari/status/972142317162369024 https://twitter.com/neelkashkari/status/972142317162369024 To take a step back, the official unemployment # is only important in so far as its in the Federal Reserve's dual mandate to maximize employment while keeping inflation steady and moderate. Kashkari's comments suggest that we haven't hit max employment, and that not even high ranking members of the Fed have a firm grasp on what "max employment" looks like in the contemporary economy. Fed wants to wait until we hit "max employment" to begin normalizing, which is akin to pumping the economic brakes. Normalizing = raising interest rates + removing bank liquidity = increasing cost and friction of borrowing/loaning = slows down economic activity. The real question remains: how will employment and the overall economy change when the Fed starts to normalize interest rates and reduce the securities holdings from QE on its balance sheet. In theory it should reduce the rate of job creation. More info on normalization here: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/policy-normalization.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/policy-normali...
- zachguo 9y agolow unemployment have preceded crises https://www.theatlas.com/charts/BJ0j99abM https://www.theatlas.com/charts/BJ0j99abM
- mnm1 9y agoSo even with "record-low unemployment", most people still don't make decent, living wages. At least that's what the article seems to be saying. Salaries aren't going up significantly. Workers have more choices, but clearly, even at record-low unemployment, the market fails most workers. That's an interesting insight as it might lead to more people to question the idiocy of letting chaos run markets by leaving them unregulated.
- djrogers 9y ago> most people still don't make decent, living wages. > the market fails most workers. Neither of those assertions is either in the article, or supported by fact. The vast majority of workforce members are employed and live well above the poverty line. I truly don't understand why there seems to be a belief that every single job that exists should provide a 'living wage'. There is such as thing as a starter job, and there types of jobs that don't provide 25-50K/yr in value to either the employer or market. It's just not reasonable to presume (or enforce a policy such ) that any amount or type of work a business owner needs done should automatically result in the employee being completely taken care of.
- pasbesoin 9y agoLies, damned lies, and statistics. "Unemployment" has been such a gamed term, especially since the Great Recession (at least, from my current perspective), that someone would have to argue me back to believing, to any significant degree, the numbers they are posting and stories they are telling about same.
- adventured 9y agoWell you can easily drill down through the murk, the BLS provides a plethora of data. For example, a common criticism about the US employment picture, on sites such as zerohedge, is to claim that it's all part time work. We have these numbers however, so there's no need to speculate. Part-time workers as a percent of the total employed, is at the same level it was in 1999. Around 17.7%. That rate continued to move lower until mid 2000, when it hit around 16.7% before the recession. Employment for 27 weeks or longer (1/2 year or longer), is back to a healthy level, where it was during the good times in 2005-2006 and matching 1996-1997. Employment for the other duration periods has seen a similar recovery. The long-term unemployed as a percentage of the total unemployed, is back to 1995 and 2005 levels. All the more impressive, these vast improvements are coming down off of an extreme hammer to the labor market from the great recession. The ~2001-02 recession was a blip by comparison, and yet the labor market has managed to get back to what would be considered healthy numbers in both the mid 1990s and mid 2000s. In fact, compared to the 1970s and 1980s, current numbers would be considered amazing. And further to the positive side, the benefits of this labor improvement have been entirely wide-spread. Black, white, asian, hispanic, everyone is seeing a labor boom. https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cps_charts.pdf https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cps_charts.pdf
- refurb 9y agoIt's the rare comments like this, from someone who actually looked at the data, that keep me coming back to HN.
- pasbesoin 9y agoThank you for taking the time to respond. As an aside, politically, I'm entirely unwilling to credit this to the last year. My own prior reading (ok, mostly of news articles, albeit reasonably well-informed ones), described such effects as typically being a minimum of a year out from policy initiatives. 18 months being a more typical minimum. The Great Recession hit me hard, and I've not seen the bounce back. Nor have others I know in my age bracket (later middle-age). That may color my perspective. The country spent years digging out from the last financial disaster. And not the messaging seems to be, if you didn't grab as much as you could, it's your own fault. P.S. And I do recall, a few years ago, the emphasis upon short term unemployment rates, avoiding discussion of the long-term unemployed and those who'd, from the perspective of the parameters of the statistical exercise, exited the labor market. Thank you for addressing that to some extent. I do wonder, though, within specific demographics, what the levels of such may continue to be. Have an upvote. I'm not complaining about your response -- to be clear. :-)
- JustAnotherPat 9y agoWhat I gathered from this article is that there isn't enough interest in Maine made chocolate to cover decent wages. Ship production to China or Mexico like everyone else. America has become a globalist society, and that means there's no room for lower middle class jobs like the ones explored in this article.
- himom 9y agoIf both unemployment were low and job satisfaction, it would seem to follow that opioid abuse would subside due to the fact most people use for escapism. Perhaps unemployment is low but with shit jobs and/or low pay, people are still miserable and going to use. The stat of low unemployment therefore maybe a pyrrhic victory.
- russdill 9y agoThe national average for unemployment is low. Certain areas are higher, much much higher.