4 ms·
>and its enshrined immutable in the public record // I know you file a document, but the public record is the content, and increasingly access to content is no
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
>and its enshrined immutable in the public record //
I know you file a document, but the public record is the content, and increasingly access to content is not done in the form the content was originally created.
In my opinion it shouldn't "look nice" but should comply with a standardised format (which hopefully has reasonable aesthetic qualities) which was developed by an field-experienced document design specialist.
- rayiner 9y agoThere is a standardized format: it's called PDF. Everything else is total crap. (And legal technology that doesn't grok PDF is by consequence total crap.) Everything else doesn't do what a universal standardized legal document format needs to do. Legal information systems have to be able to handle everything from briefs prepared by attorneys, to copies of documents that only ever existed in hardcopy, such as wills, birth certificates, etc., to scanned-in copies of pleadings filed on paper by tenants getting kicked out of their apartments. PDF handles this all marvelously, and Word integrates reasonably well with PDF.
- tatersolid 9y agoPDF is just about the worst choice here. It represents a piece of paper conceptually and not the actual content. PDF is a presentation format, not a content format.
- rayiner 9y agoAs explained above, the separation of content and presentation is conceptually desirable, but not at the expense of being able to capture all the content you need to capture. What other format lets you capture everything from a prisoner’s pro se habeas petition (scrawled with pencil in a prison library) to legal briefs from Fortune 500 corporations? If I were designing a court document system from scratch, I’d still use PDF, and not for lack of imagination. It’s incredibly powerful technology. I actually ran into this while looking for comprehensive note taking solutions for my legal practice. A lot of modern web-based tools don’t embrace PDF, and they’re toys as a result. I can’t scrawl notes on a deposition transcript? I have to handle key evidentiary documents as second-class attachments? Useless. I settled on an iPad Pro (great PDF markup support) and emailing myself files to my Exchange account.