4 ms·
I'm going to straight up disagree that open source communities should use Discord. Michael Greer lists a lot of great advantages over Slack, but that is not suf
by swyx 9y ago
I'm going to straight up disagree that open source communities should use Discord. Michael Greer lists a lot of great advantages over Slack, but that is not sufficient. In particular I think open source communities should have 1) threaded discussions that are 2) searchable results on google. (for hopefully self evident reasons)
Discord has neither.
I don't have any influence over these giant communities but if I were starting them from scratch I would put them on https://spectrum.chat https://spectrum.chat because it explicitly solves these issues. (no affiliation) Now the network effect makes it a lot harder. I would encourage -new- open source communities to check Spectrum out.
- Mononokay 9y agoYou can search for things that've been said on Discord, albeit not with Google. Spectrum looks similar to a 2011 text message client, and a niche platform is less welcoming than something that a good portion of people already have an account on.
- dorian-graph 9y ago> Spectrum looks similar to a 2011 text message client This just isn't true. Compare [1] to [2]. Nor does it look like VB, phpBB, etc. from 2011. [1] https://thenextweb.com/apps/2011/08/30/the-top-6-best-instant-message-client-apps-on-any-platform/ https://thenextweb.com/apps/2011/08/30/the-top-6-best-instan... [2] https://spectrum.chat/sketch?thread=5ee6de28-e347-4c0f-950d-d515c2fe4455 https://spectrum.chat/sketch?thread=5ee6de28-e347-4c0f-950d-... > .. a good portion of people already have an account on. Ah yes, my N accounts for N communities on Slack.
- lambda 9y agoIt has the bubbles around what each person says, which is the style that many of the chat apps in your link have as well. OK, they are flat bubbles now rather than shiny blobby ones, but it's the "bubble for everything someone says" that makes it look dated. I hated the "bubbles" look back then and always used themes that just presented text as text, with possible unobtrusive delimiters between people's comments. Like Slack and Discord do.
- swyx 9y agoyes search within-app is not enough. i would like universal search for issues/errors that i encounter with a particular technology. this is one thing stackoverflow definitely got right. im not concerned with the looks. and this niche argument is pretty weak, every platform incl discord starts somewhere.
- Waterluvian 9y agoJust today I experienced the frustration of a pull request linking to a conversation on slack that I couldn't read.
- swyx 9y agolol, how did the PR submitter expect you to be able to access his slack messages
- Bizarro 9y agoVuej and React have traditional forums. But I get what you're saying. When I was using Aurelia, I had huge problems because it was just on gitter.
- swyx 9y agosee, i'm a professional react dev and i didnt even know about the react forum until you just mentioned it. why is there reactiflux AND this thing?? how does that make sense?
- acemarke 9y agoSomewhat different use cases? Reactiflux is all about real-time discussion and helping answer questions (although admittedly there are times when the answers come in asynchronously several hours later). The React.js forums are... well, I guess for discussion, but really haven't ever gotten much attention. Besides, Reactiflux is a totally independent group - started by the community, run by the community. We've had several Facebook employees come in for Q&A chats, but we're not an "official" part of React in that sense. (Note: I'm a Reactiflux admin.)
- flukus 9y ago> In particular I think open source communities should have 1) threaded discussions that are 2) searchable results on google. (for hopefully self evident reasons) So mailing lists then? OSS communities have been using them for years, they even have offline browsing and offline search. There are a number of user interfaces available from online ones like google groups or gmail, desktop readers, terminal apps and even editor plugins.
- u801e 9y agoThe best one I've found is using a news reader with the gmane NNTP endpoint for browsing those mailing lists.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoI'm a fan of the open source Zulip for how it does threading. Those threads should be linkable and searchable, but I'm not sure.
- tabbott 9y agoZulip's threads are linkable and searchable. https://zulipchat.com/for/open-source https://zulipchat.com/for/open-source has more detail on Zulip for open source projects.
- acemarke 9y agoI'm a Reactiflux admin. We are VERY happy with Discord! I had this discussion with Max Stoiber (founder of Spectrum.chat) on Twitter a couple months ago [0] . I agree that threadedness and searchability are nice features of Spectrum, but I'd say that both a forum-like searchable model and a real-time chatroom model have a place, and that the use cases only partially overlap. [0] https://twitter.com/acemarke/status/953804604046749696 https://twitter.com/acemarke/status/953804604046749696
- swyx 9y agoand i totally respect that you are happy with it. this is merely my opinion, and why I've tried Reactiflux a couple times and it has not stuck for me. Key question for you is: how many of me are there out there?
- blocked_again 9y agoI don't get it. How does a chat without a threaded conversation model able to manage a large number of people effectively? Have you ever taken a look at chat that is fully threaded? As far as I know, Discourse was built by keeping gamers in mind who care mostly about what is happening right now which is not the perfect fit for an open source project.
- acemarke 9y agoSometimes if there's a bunch of people chatting at once the conversation can get a little crossed-up, sure, but most of the time there's only one or two specific discussions going on in any given channel. It helps that we have a _lot_ of different channels for different topics: #general, #need-help, #redux, #webpack, #functional-programming, #testing, etc.
- swyx 9y agoits not like the mass community of users get to decide, the people who started reactiflux got themselves on the react docs first and so it becomes pseudoofficial. then over time you just get the benefits of network effect.
- 9y ago
- u801e 9y ago> In particular I think open source communities should have 1) threaded discussions that are 2) searchable results on google. (for hopefully self evident reasons) Open source communities that communicate via mailing lists do have threaded discussions that can be found via a Google search. Though the websites they link to have a rather limited interface for viewing the discussion. NNTP gateways like gmane make it much easier to read through the threads (though it would be better if the web pages presented a more HN or reddit type view of the discussions).
- swyx 9y agosounds like you agree?