6 ms·
Tim Berners-Lee on the future of the web: 'The system is failing'
- denzil_correa 9y agoFull Text of the Open Letter from Tim Berners-Lee here : https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/mar/12/tim-berners-lee-web-weapon-regulation-open-letter https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/mar/12/tim-be...
- amelius 9y agoI wonder what the web would have looked like if TBL had the visionary powers of RMS.
- TomMarius 9y agoOr if RMS himself was in place instead of TBL.
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoIt would be used by 1% of the population, with the other 99% using something else that looks much like what we have today.
- mseebach 9y agoI was going to say something like this, except without the assumption that what we have today would exist. For all the concerns about walled gardens, I can still link to a Facebook post in a Slack message and vice versa. The hypothetical non-web-world would probably consist of Compuservs and MSNs, with very limited notions of links.
- 908087 9y agoYou pretty much described Facebook's "internet".org / "free basics" in your last sentence.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoCan you link directly to a Facebook video? That has gotten extremely hard unless you are using their app for some reason.
- mseebach 9y agoThe timestamp is usually a direct link, I've used it to share a video a few times.
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoYou have a lot of faith in our current system
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoI wouldn't say so. I'm distraught by it, actually.
- contravariant 9y agoSince Richard Stallman was around when sir Tim Berners-Lee developed the web, I guess we found out.
- anonymousDan 9y agoHas there been any effort to objectively measure the supposed centralization of the web over time? Although I've no doubt it is happening, the article doesn't seem to provide any hard evidence for the claim. Interesting to think about how to do it, e.g. you could measure clustering in the global page rank graphs over time, but that wouldn't incorporate info about Facebook etc.
- cwkoss 9y agoCould compare the ratio between average pageviews of sites alexa ranked 1000-900 vs avg pageviews of sites ranked 1-100. If the long tail of websites are getting proportionally less traffic, would be evidence of centralization.
- emilfihlman 9y agoWasn't our dear Tim for disbanding net neutrality or some other very stupid thing recently?
- dredmorbius 9y agoDRM. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170712/10262037770/eff-officially-appeals-tim-berners-lee-decision-drm-html.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170712/10262037770/eff-o...
- mulmen 9y agoDo you have a source on that? Here are the first three Google results I got for "Tim Berners-Lee Net Neutrality": https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/dec/11/net-neutrality-vint-cerf-tim-berners-lee-fcc-letter https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/dec/11/net-neutr... https://www.wikitribune.com/story/2017/12/04/internet/nine-questions-with-the-world-wide-webs-inventor-tim-berners-lee/26054/ https://www.wikitribune.com/story/2017/12/04/internet/nine-q... https://webfoundation.org/2017/04/sir-tim-berners-lee-responds-to-us-net-neutrality-threat/ https://webfoundation.org/2017/04/sir-tim-berners-lee-respon... These all seem to show support for Net Neutrality. I would at least do a Google search and post a source with a quote before calling Tim Berners-Lee "very stupid".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- originalsimba 9y agoWhat centralization? The web isn't centralized. Consumer culture is centralized. Consumer culture on the web is what's failing. Facebook and Google and similar services are not "The Web" and they are not "The Internet" and the people who can't exist outside of those bubbles will burn down with them, so what? The internet will survive it, the web will survive it. These things happen in nature all the time, it's interesting to see it happens online, a non-natural man-built ecosystem, as well.
- kerkeslager 9y agoIf net neutrality dies, the web absolutely becomes centralized. Facebook and Google aren't the web, but they will be the web if they're the only ones that can pay to have their data passed over the wire.
- chasote 9y agoI'm in full support of net neutrality (as it seems everyone but the telecom companies is yet here we are, but I digress) but I like to think if this "doomsday" scenario were to happen then the outcry would finally be swift and effective in tearing that down for good. People won't accept it because they have already experienced what the open web can be.
- twblalock 9y agoNet neutrality would be nice to have, but the way it's been overhyped is silly. The internet developed without it. We've never really had it -- people like to cite a few years before the recent FCC decision as a period of net neutrality, but it had so few effects that the average consumer did not notice it being implemented and did not notice it going away. It certainly didn't prevent anything Google or Facebook wanted to do. If you're worried about centralization, net neutrality won't help much. Facebook and Google are large enough to crowd out other players with or without net neutrality.
- kerkeslager 9y ago> Facebook and Google are large enough to crowd out other players with or without net neutrality. "crowd out" is a vague term. Maybe they make the most money, but money isn't the only thing that matters. The forums I frequent and the DuckDuckGo are doing just fine, but I'm not sure they would be if net neutrality falls apart completely.
- moocowtruck 9y agois this the same guy that signed off on DRM YAY?
- 9889095r3jh 9y agoI'd prefer to assess the ideas in this article on their merits. Not waste time criticizing the imperfect author.
- dalbasal 9y agoFor the most part, I think the conclusion that "a regulator is needed" is usually reached by people who have very little experience with one. Regulators are more flexible than legislatures, but are still not very flexible in practice. The difference is mostly that they can enforce rules more effectively, but the rulemaking itself is not generally very good. Causation runs at least partially the other way, but think of the current industries that are heavily regulated: banking, medicine, tobacco... First, they regulate relative to very legible rulesets. Even if they start with broad mandates, once enforcement gets going, a specific ruleset emerges. A common goal is "better inform the consumer." Pharmaceutical side effects, banking fees, how we use cookies. This nearly always becomes a joke. The company does not want to highlight information, but they have too. Regulators chase, fine, and sanction. Eventually, we get popups, small print, and quickfire lists of "disclosure". All that stuff becomes essentially mandatory. Second, "compliance" becomes a power word, within companies. The lawyers and bureaucrats get much more powerful. Also, regulating industries is almost always big firm and incumbent friendly. Calling these businesses hard to enter is an understatement. You basically can't start a tobacco company or bank unless you already are one, or are well connected and wealthy. Idk what the solution is, but I doubt it is this. We'll see how GDPR plays out, but I'm not holding my breath. The problem (imo) is that the internet is a communication technology. These have network effects, and centralisation tendencies. In a perfect world, the solutions to the problem (I agree with tbl about the problem) are protocols, browsers and the like. If email wasn't a protocol/standard, it'd have been invented as a proprietary service. But, since the standard existed and was popular...it lives. Building onto emails, in an open way, generally failed. So, email lists gave way to proprietary services. There are still parts of the internet that are open like this. Podcasts is an interesting one. It gained a lot of ground recently in the mature web era. On the business end, podcasts seem to be much better for the content makers than YouTube or other distribution methods. Interesting. They seem like an echo from an older internet. A lot of things could have beeen standards, app stores, social networks.. a lot of things could have been solved by the browser, including half the stuff "regulators" are trying to fix now. Ultimately, online tracking works because browsers & standards let it happen. It's just hard, and the incentive to grab a little internet fief is too strong. In some ways, it's surprising the web is as open as it is.
- poletopole 9y agoNo mention of the semantic web. I wonder if developments in AI replaced the need for it.
- iamleppert 9y agoProps to the guy who was the human vessel that brought us concepts like HTTP. But I don’t buy into his hero worship. His solution to the problem of centralized control is to add more control (most likely in the hands of a few) via a regulator? Let me guess...that regulator should be him? It sounds to me more like someone who is struggling for relevance in a changing world he doesn’t understand.
- gue5t 9y agoWhich aspects of HTTP strike you as particularly elegant or well-designed?
- hinkley 9y agoAmong the things I care about are clock skew issues in distributed systems. Over and over again I've had to explain to people that they don't need their hand-rolled solution because a better solution has been in HTTP since 1.0 for purposes of cache invalidation. It's as accurate as NTP without opening up an attack vector (hijacking NTP or NTP DOS). Any time you contact a server your User Agent tells it what time it is. Any time the server responds it does the same. Both parties can calculate offsets just fine with just the HTTP headers. The only consensus that matters is between the hub and one spoke. When the server says "It's 12 noon and this response document was generated at 11:58:50" you know it was 70 seconds ago. Nevermind that your browser thinks it's currently 4:30 pm. The age of the file is 'now' - 70 seconds. If you PUT a file at 4:35 the server will say it was created at 12:05. Anyway, this is my favorite thing about the HTTP protocol. Human readable from traffic dumps was #2.
- kadenshep 9y agoNice platitude salad.
- alexashka 9y agoThis reads like an unbearable collection of news headlines, combined with political slogans that mean absolutely nothing. One example: I remain committed to making sure the web is a free, open, creative space – for everyone. That vision is only possible if we get everyone online, and make sure the web works for people. The web is not free - I have to pay an ISP to access it. Who is 'everyone' in this instance? I don't know what 'open' means exactly, and creative how? Because I can post pictures of cats on reddit? What is creative about 'the web' specifically? What 'vision'? Why is it only possible if 'we', who is we? get everyone online? Why is that a prerequisite? 'Make sure the web works for people'? What does that even mean?
- duncan_bayne 9y agoYeah, I heard some bunch of assholes green-lit DRM in the Web. Oh wait, that was Berners-Lee and the W3C. He must be taking about some other systemic failure here.