4 ms·
But new developments lower rents, since they increase the housing supply. But a lot of people simply don't understand this and fight development despite it bei
by BurningFrog 9y ago
But new developments lower rents, since they increase the housing supply.
But a lot of people simply don't understand this and fight development despite it being in their best interest.
Then again, I see that one of the two studies was done in San Francisco, and if the renters are in rent controlled apartments, they don't have much reason to care about housing prices and can oppose development because they don't like change.
- newnewpdro 9y agoThat greatly depends on the kind of development.
- crooked-v 9y agoNot really, as long as the housing isn't going literally empty because of absent Chinese investors or the like.
- newnewpdro 9y agoIf the new development is luxury low-density bullshit, it burns finite development space on low-density occupancies while raising average rents because they're expensive on top of it. If this situation also started with the demolition of low-end high-density housing, it compounds in the direction of increased rents. Rents don't go down when a neighborhood gentrifies... How is this not obvious? I get the impression the HN crowd is so solidly in the demographic of the gentrifying forces being overpaid tech folks that these types of discussions will always be strained.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe luxury stuff in California is often actually relatively high density, the run-down cheaper places they are replacing are often lower density, so density is still going up. Since after the Johnson era, high density low income housing has been taboo.
- BurningFrog 9y agoYou're of course right that if you tear down 50 units and "add" 20, rents will go up. My unstated assumption when writing "new development" was that it's a net addition of new development. I think that was obvious to most, but now I've spelled it out. Aside from that, none of your caveats hold. Even adding high end luxury housing lowers the average rent, compared to if it wasn't added. If you don't understand that, you don't understand basic supply-and-demand economics, and will struggle understanding a lot of what happens in society!
- drb91 9y agoThey only lower rent if they meet demand. If demand far outstrips supply, rent will continue to rise, just slower with new development.
- xvedejas 9y agoSlower rises are still better than faster rises
- BurningFrog 9y agoThey always lower rents, compared to if they hadn't been built.
- drb91 9y agoNot if they increase demand, as gentrification does!
- BurningFrog 9y agoI know people think that happens, but economists haven't been able to see it. What does happen is that both housing construction and gentrification increase when the economy is going well. It's easy to think that one is causing the other when in reality they're both caused by an underlying factor.
- raincom 9y agonew development lowers the average rent, but doesn’t lower the rent for those who have been living in rent controlled apartments for the last ten years, when their apartments are replaced with fancy ones.