12 ms·
Questions for TSA after reports of laptop and phone searches on domestic flights
- derefr 9y agoA devil's advocate argument, for people to have something explicit to rebut here: One of the guises state police operate under in America is the "highway patrol"—a force that searches for terrorists and drug trafficking and the like. And presumably, air travel is a privilege, not a right, just like driving a car is. (Or is it? Taking public transit is a right that can't be denied to someone unless they explicitly break a rule of the system. But airports are private companies...) So, given that, is there a legal reason that there is no "airway patrol"? I'm not suggesting they have the powers of random search & seizure that the TSA seems to have, mind you. But should there be state police that are stationed at airports, who search people when they have probable cause?
- anthonybsd 9y agoThat seems reaching to me. After all, highway patrol cannot simply start going through your belongings without probable cause which has a potential to be tested in court. Same rights are clearly not afforded to the air travelers in TSA interactions which seem to exist in a legal limbo right now.
- solotronics 9y agoactually they can and do every day! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States#Traffic_stops https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United... "In May 2010 a couple was driving from New York to Florida and they were stopped by police because of a cracked windshield. During questioning, the officer decided that $32,000 cash in the van was "probably involved in criminal or drug-related activity", seized it, shared it with federal authorities under equitable sharing. The victim hired a lawyer to get back the seized money who urged settling for half of the seized amount, and after the lawyer's fees, the victim got back only $7,000."
- alehul 9y agoAs a followup to this (and response to preceding comment), a quick Google search shows that all airports aside from one in the US are owned by the government, which I believe must meet certain standards that we don't require of private entities in terms of rights of access.
- dawnerd 9y agothat quick google search brings up a site that cites no sources for that claim... Digging around found a source but I highly doubt its the one that site used. https://www.faa.gov/airports/airport_compliance/privatization/ https://www.faa.gov/airports/airport_compliance/privatizatio...
- jMyles 9y ago> Presumably, air travel is a privilege, not a right, just like driving a car is. Freedom of movement is a privilege, not a right? What can you possibly be talking about? Did I miss a memo? The United States (and other common law societies) have a long history of enshrining freedom of movement as a fundamental right. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_United_States_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_Unit... Also, be reminded that the USA voted in favor of the UDHR, which reads in part: * a citizen of a state in which that citizen is present has the liberty to travel, reside in, and/or work in any part of the state where one pleases within the limits of respect for the liberty and rights of others and * and that a citizen also has the right to leave any country, including his or her own, and to return to his or her country at any time.
- brokensegue 9y agofreedom of movement \neq freedom to fly though
- my123 9y agoIn a modern society, disallowing to fly doesn't give full movement rights for a person. You are much less likely to travel to Europe if you have to use a transaltlantic boat for example. :p
- brokensegue 9y agoyes but you could say that of cars too (and courts have ruled mandatory DUI tests legal)
- acct1771 9y agoJust because courts have ruled something legal doesn't make it Constitutional. See: 100 mile border zones that are "exempt" from the 4th Amendment. Not to mention, just because something is legal doesn't make it right.
- ctrl-j 9y ago> It occurs to me that America has, in every state, a state-run "highway patrol" that searches for terrorists and drug trafficking and the like. The state-run highway patrol is still subject to the 4th amendment (search and seizure.) If you get pulled over by a LEO - they need consent, probable cause, or a warrant in order to rifle through your belongings.
- cryoshon 9y ago> they need consent, probable cause, or a warrant in order to rifle through your belongings. which they can invent with no problem if they feel like it. nobody who declines to a search gets away with it; they just call a drug dog to alert and then they can search anyway.
- pdkl95 9y agoNot consenting to a search isn't really about preventing the search. The police are, by definition, they application of force; if they want to search you, they will. However, not consenting forces them to make up some sort of justification for their actions and gives your lawyer a much better chance of getting the fruits of the search thrown out.
- maxerickson 9y agoHow come that thing that is a thing isn't a thing? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Air_Marshal_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Air_Marshal_Service 4,000 law enforcement officers. But that is separate from what powers we as a society should allow them.
- derefr 9y agoThe Air Marshals are literal peace officers—there to stop crime that happens in the air. Completely separate from the idea of a highway patrol, which is there—in essence—to be a permanent dragnet for BOLOs, and to (probabilistically) be witness to statutory crimes/regulatory violations (e.g. dumping of industrial waste) where no individual victim is going to report them.
- robotresearcher 9y agoSo the Highway Patrol is there to stop crime that happens on highways, and that's totally different?
- testvox 9y agoMy city Boston will tresspass you from the subway and bus system if you refuse to submit to a search of your bags at the checkpoints they set up at certain stations. So I don't think you are correct about public transportation.
- iwalsh 9y agoIt's possible the TSA will claim that taking a device for some amount of time and giving it back doesn't qualify as a (4th amendment) search. However, from a security perspective it would be awful if they could disappear with your device whenever they wanted - that certainly makes me uncomfortable.
- justinjlynn 9y ago> taking a device for some amount of time and giving it back doesn't qualify as a (4th amendment) search If it's optional and I can and will refuse, fine. If it's not,and I'm not attempting to cross a border, they can get stuffed. For domestic travel, they do not need to examine the data - only the physical device needs to be examined to rule out security risk. They can do that non-intrusively with imaging and chemical analysis technology. The idea that someone could claim that a limited intrusion into the contents of my communications isn't an intrusion at all is absurd.
- pentagonpapers 9y ago...
- pentagonpapers 9y agodeleting this comment as i will by flying a few weeks
- justinjlynn 9y agothis is exactly what you shouldn't be afraid of.
- justinjlynn 9y agoI should clarify: If them looking through my data is not optional and I can't refuse, and I'm not at a border crossing (which is still bullshit imo, but well trodden precedent), they'd better have goddamn signed warrant.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoI am TOTALLY ok with TSA reading my last text messages before I go on a flight. Those last few texts someone sends before committing a terrorist action, could send an extremely strong signal to authorities and possibly prevent a disaster. If the extra security results in a strange TSA agent getting to enjoy some surprise dick pics, well that's the price of freedom Jerry.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 9y ago>If the extra security results in a strange TSA agent getting to enjoy some surprise dick pics, well that's the price of freedom Jerry. I wouldn't say that someone has 'freedom' if they're being forced to possibly have their body visibly exposed to strangers against their will.
- opportune 9y agoIf regular people wanted freedom, they would just fly private!
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThis guy get it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y ago"The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread." ( https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France )
- pentagonpapers 9y ago
- jMyles 9y agoDomestic flights? Wow. Since this is a different agency than typically conducts (similarly intrusive and seemingly illegal) searches in the case of international flights, I wonder if they are following a common protocol? If so, who creates that? I'm about to fly internationally for the first time in a while; anybody have any advice on how to handle my devices?
- ep103 9y agohidden partitions, and/or storing all your important data off-device are the two pieces of advice that get suggested the most.
- lisper 9y agoI would strongly recommend the latter. Hidden partitions are trivial to find. I recommend one of these: https://www.amazon.com/MyDigitalSSD-480GB-SuperSpeed-Portable-Support/dp/B00N0V4JG2/ https://www.amazon.com/MyDigitalSSD-480GB-SuperSpeed-Portabl... Keep it encrypted and in your pocket.
- benmmurphy 9y agoThe bigger problem with hidden partitions is the TSA agent asks you if there is a hidden partition and then if they are able to find out they you have lied you have committed a crime.
- gumby 9y ago> TSA agent asks you ... and then if they are able to find out they you have lied you have committed a crime. Not sure that's the case: TSA agents are not police or any other law enforcement any more than the gate agent is,and can't make arrests or anything like that. Pretty sure you can say what you like (though please, be polite!). I once pulled out my phone to photograph the badge of an agent who was particularly obnoxious, not just to me but to others. I planned to fill out the complaint card. He freaked out, told me photography was not allowed, grabbed me by the arm and called for the cop. The cop came over and told him in no uncertain terms to let go of me, that photography is fine, asked me if I got a clear photo and made sure I got a photo of the badge. And handed me a complaint form. I assume he already knew that the TSA guy was a jerk.
- warcop 9y agoSurveillance Self-Defense https://ssd.eff.org/ https://ssd.eff.org/
- pjc50 9y ago> "One woman who shared her story with the ACLU told the Guardian that in the last year, she has twice had her electronics searched while flying within California. The 64-year-old, who works in nonprofits and requested anonymity for fear that she could face further scrutiny from TSA, said that on one occasion last year, TSA agents pulled her aside to pat her down multiple times and eventually asked to see both her iPhones – a work and personal one." I suspect it would be very revealing which nonprofit is involved here; this kind of harassment through scrutiny is a classic tactic against progressive groups.
- gowld 9y agoIt's also a classic tactic against conservative groups. https://www.npr.org/2017/10/27/560308997/irs-apologizes-for-aggressive-scrutiny-of-conservative-groups https://www.npr.org/2017/10/27/560308997/irs-apologizes-for-...
- chillwaves 9y agoWhat a non story. The real story is that congress passes impossible to enforce legislation that cannot properly define which groups are political and which not. https://www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/liberal-groups-got-irs-scrutiny-too-inspector-general-finds/2017/10/04/e9b6e3c4-a929-11e7-850e-2bdd1236be5d_story.html?utm_term=.286d1270a2fa https://www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/liberal-groups-got-... > A federal watchdog has identified scores of cases in which the Internal Revenue Service may have targeted liberal-leaning groups for extra scrutiny based on their names or political leanings, a finding that could undermine claims that conservatives were unfairly targeted under President Barack Obama. This is the kind of scandal the right clings to -- gov't bureaucrats trying to do their job. "Classic tactic" for the gov't to target conservatives? You need to provide some real evidence or another example that pans out before making those kind of claims.
- kbenson 9y ago> "Classic tactic" for the gov't to target conservatives? You need to provide some real evidence or another example that pans out before making those kind of claims. In case you didn't notice, that was a repeat of the exact words used in the comment that was being responded to. Unless you're planning to call out the initial comment in the same way, since it actually provided no evidence, whether you think it worthwhile or not, perhaps you should consider why out of the two statements, you felt compelled to respond to the one that actually provided some backing. It's a little disturbing that I had to vouch for gowld since they were flagged and dead. I may not necessarily agree with them, but voting to oblivion and flagging them does not seem the appropriate response.
- mikeash 9y agoThis article seems like it’s written to be deliberately confusing. If I understand it correctly, the TSA is not forcing anyone to unlock devices. They take the devices away for some period, but if they’re securely locked, TSA won’t be able to get anything from them. However, the article drops border searches which do require an unlock right into the middle of the article, then goes on to say that they have no specific examples of TSA doing the same thing. This implies that they have reason to believe it’s happening, but as far as I can see there’s no justification for that. The big question is: what are they doing with these things? If it’s some fancy explosives sniffing (like they already do to my contact lens solution) then it’s nothing interesting. If it’s an electronic search if unsecured devices, that’s bad. If it’s an attempt to force travelers to unlock secured devices, that’s horrible. The article seems to want to portray it as the last one, while only giving evidence for one of the first two.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> If I understand it correctly, the TSA is not forcing anyone to unlock devices. I'm sure they also don't shrug their shoulders and say "Locked? Oh well.". Varying degrees of coercion, threat, implicit or otherwise, relying on passenger ignorance to their rights. I wonder how many have unlocked it at their request too, which is specifically different from "forced".
- mikeash 9y agoWhat makes you so sure of that? I’ve had them swab electronics for explosives before and they never even try to turn the things on. I’m pretty sure I’ve had them ask me once or twice to prove that a laptop was real by turning it on, and they never asked for it to be unlocked. That’s my whole point: this article appears to be written to make you assume that a lot more is going on than they actually describe.
- dordoka 9y agoI have been always asked to turn my devices on after a search for explosives (and whatever other substances they look for). They do that "to be sure you don't only carry the structure of the device to hide stuff inside". This happens in european flights.
- coldcode 9y agoThey can have my device if necessary, however I will not give them the passcode without torture. They can add it to the pile.
- mulmen 9y agoThey can't have my device without a warrant. I'm not comfortable with them even taking it out of my sight or connecting it to anything. This is an agency that absolutely cannot be trusted.
- lopmotr 9y agoYou'll miss your flight if you refuse. That's a lot of power they have over many people. It's expensive and you might not get to whatever was so important you flew there for.
- baxtr 9y agoThe number of searches has increased quite a bit from 2016 to 2017 https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/national-media-release/cbp-releases-updated-border-search-electronic-device-directive-and https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/national-media-release/cbp-rele...
- russ_ross 9y agoNo special knowledge, but willing to bet they are doing this on the basis of a specific threat. Much theatre, hoping it gets press, and intended as a deterrent based on information they've got they are concerned about. Otherwise its a lot of work for nothing.
- cryoshon 9y agoidea: scrub all data and accounts from your electronics before flying. leave your phone unlocked, but primed with a goatse booby trap so that the agents get an unpleasant surprise that's totally legal and comes with total deniability -- hey, you just loved goatse so that's why it's on your phone and laptop. if the agent is offended, perhaps they should have minded their own fucking business.
- onetimemanytime 9y ago>> so that the agents get an unpleasant surprise YOU will get the surprise: if you're a US citizen they cannot deny you entry to the USA but they can make your life miserable by searching and delaying you every single time. If you're not a US citizen and try to be a "smartass," they have all the power to deny you entry in the USA. No appeals.
- cryoshon 9y agowhy would i get a surprise? i'm just an innocent citizen who loves goatse. there's no reason to single me out for harassment -- or if there IS, there's a lawsuit ready to go
- onetimemanytime 9y agoOf course you are. And they're just doing their job, they suspect you might try something. Just suspect, so to protect and to serve they have to check you, every single time. Better safe than sorry. A lawsuit for being searched more carefully? Good luck.
- jstarfish 9y ago> if the agent is offended, perhaps they should have minded their own fucking business. Exposing government agents to obscene or indecent content is not going to improve the outlook of your day.
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago
- skrowl 9y agoRemember the 5th Amendment applies to passwords. No law enforcement officer may EVER compel you to log in to a device with a password / pass code / unlock pattern, for any reason.
- greensoap 9y agoIn other words, don't enable touch id or face unlock.
- cmsimike 9y agoon iOS anyway, you can enable face id/touch id but specifically disable it from being able to log into the phone with it. You can then use face/touch id for authentication in apps.
- komali2 9y agoI'm trying to find the article now, but I recall reading that in the USA it's a lawful order to have you unlock your phone with a thumbprint, but not to unlock with a PIN code. God knows why. Here: https://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/10/31/judge-rules-suspect-can-be-required-to-unlock-phone-with-fingerprint/ https://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/10/31/judge-rules-suspect-... Unsure about federal application, actually. We as country need to get our shit together regarding device privacy. You should need a warrant to look at a phone, laptop, whatever, with or without a password. The security of the device should be meaningless. As for me, I'm grateful that I have the resources to push back should this ever happen to me, jailtime or included. That's a luxury probably very few Americans can realistically afford (seeing as they can just throw you in jail for 48 hours).
- saagarjha 9y ago> I recall reading that in the USA it's a lawful order to have you unlock your phone with a thumbprint, but not to unlock with a PIN code. God knows why. I believe the rationale was that they can't ask you to incriminate yourself (give up your passcode), but you don't have to say anything for them to force you to give your fingerprint.
- pdkl95 9y agoI guess they didn't read Riley v California[1]. In the opinion of the SCOTUS: > Modern cell phones are not just another technological convenience. With all they contain and all they may reveal, they hold for many Americans “the privacies of life". The fact that technology now allows an individual to carry such information in his hand does not make the information any less worthy of the protection for which the Founders fought. Our answer to the question of what police must do before searching a cell phone seized incident to an arrest is accordingly simple -- get a warrant. Given that the SCOTUS unanimously ruled searching a phone without a warrant is unconstitutional incident to an arrest, the same requirement must also hold for Terry stops and simple safety inspections. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riley_v._California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riley_v._California
- ProAm 9y agoIm not sure that matters. They may make it a condition of travel; you do not have to let the TSA search your phone, but you will not be allowed to proceed into the airport without doing so. That is what all the TSA searches have appeared like to me. Just a denial of service for maintaining a level of privacy.
- John_KZ 9y agoThis kind of argument is starting to piss me off. "You can express your freedom of speech, but not in this public park, because it's privately owned" "You can state your opinions, but not on this website, because dispite being a major communications hub on the internet, and despite advertising ourselves as a place of free expression, we actively derank, ban or erase any opinion we dislike" "You can decline the EULA, you just have to stop using our vital service" "You can maintain your privacy, but not if you want to travel" "You can buy a phone that doesn't collect metadata about you, you just have to break a $50 billion dollar lobby and manufacture your own IC. You still have the freedom of choice" You know what, you really don't. Your rights aren't supposed to be just a legal burden to circumvent with various tricks, they're supposed to hold in all domains of public life. I want to be able to fly in a plane without having some asshole dig through my personal life. You think someone is dangerous? Check for bombs. Check for weapons. Why are they checking for beliefs? What kind of bullshit is this?
- r00fus 9y agoWho here thought this was eventually going to happen for domestic flights after this started happening on international flights?
- Taniwha 9y agoYet another reason to not fly through the US
- sg0 9y agoIf office issued electronic devices (which presumably have to undergo routine organization-specific scrutiny, and may contain non-public info) are snatched by the TSA for random sniffing, why can't an organization sue the TSA for compromising security?
- greggarious 9y agoI wonder if they're imaging the device for later analysis. I suspect they're not installing implants but it would make me nervous all the same about using that device in the future...
- JshWright 9y agoIf I bring any personal equipment when I travel it's a "burner". I have a Chromebook running Debian that never has anything on it I care about (and only access personal stuff remotely via SSH, using a PGP key on a YubiKey). I carry an old phone, again with nothing on it I care about. Both devices are encrypted and powered off through security (and left off as much as possible when at the airport in general). The most important characteristic of these devices is that I'm 100% happy to just walk away from them (and there are no easily recovered credentials for any "cloud based" services I use). If I'm traveling for work (and have equipment that belongs to my employer with me), I am equally happy to walk away from those devices (though I'll also leave the contact info for my company's lawyer).