6 ms·
Apple's Jobs says 'onerous terms' kept Facebook ties out of Ping
- alexyim 16y agoUnless I'm missing something, this title is misleading. The article itself doesn't say anything about Jobs making that statement, only the fact that Cult of Mac speculates that FB's terms became onerous.
- CodeMage 16y agoThe article links to the following article: http://kara.allthingsd.com/20100902/steve-jobs-on-why-facebook-is-not-part-of-apples-new-ping-music-social-network-onerous-terms/ http://kara.allthingsd.com/20100902/steve-jobs-on-why-facebo... Here's the relevant quote from that article: When I asked Jobs about that, he said Apple had indeed held talks with Facebook about a variety of unspecified partnerships related to Ping, but the discussions went nowhere. The reason, according to Jobs: Facebook wanted "onerous terms that we could not agree to."
- alexyim 16y agoThanks
- joey_bananas 16y agoI suspect the fact that Ping seems to be engineered to be strictly top-down has more to do with it.
- mrkurt 16y agoComing up with a broad sample of "terms that would be considered onerous by one Steve Jobs" turns out to be a fun mental exercise.
- andreyf 16y agoWild guess: facebook wanted Apple to have an open API to retrieve users' music listening preferences.
- brownleej 16y agoThat seems unlikely if the breakdown in negotiations was as last-minute as others have speculated. Asking someone to implement an open API the night the product ships would be a bit extreme. It's possible that Apple had implemented such an API, but cancelled it at the last minute, but I don't think so. If Jobs didn't want an open API, he wouldn't agree to it in the first place. With these two companies, it's hard to say who was in the wrong until we have details on what the sticking point was. It could be privacy, it could be advertising, it could be revenue-sharing, etc.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWhat percentage of those terms would be "terms offered by one Steve Jobs" to users?
- andreyf 16y agoObvious question the author was somehow too lazy to research: what kind of terms could facebook ask for that Apple wouldn't agree to? Is anyone qualified enough to chime in?
- minalecs 16y agothis is the exact question all should be asking.. how do we know that apple was looking for terms that facebook wouldn't agree to. To me.. Apple already knows the terms prior to implementing FB connect. I find it unlikely that Facbook is changing their terms from company to company.
- siglesias 16y agoLast night's delay of iTunes 10 may well have been due to some last minute hardball negotiating by Apple to get their terms. Facebook must have drawn a line in the sand, forcing Apple to flip off the FB connect button.
- aditya 16y agoWhoa. What? Apple agrees to onerous terms from the studios, who are about as decidedly on the extreme side of onerous as anything on the planet, and failed to negotiate with Facebook? Jobs probably yelled at Zuck and they got into a fight.
- jsz0 16y agoApple needs the movie studios and music labels. They don't really need to make a deal with FB.
- pchristensen 16y agoI would bet that no matter how onerous the terms Apple has with the studios, they're better terms than anyone else has.
- Axelnm 16y agoIn related news. Irony is apparently dead.
- jonknee 16y agoThe irony of Steve Jobs not liking onerous terms for getting app approval is almost too much.
- tptacek 16y agoNot really. Jobs didn't set up a lobbying effort to get Facebook to change its mind. He doesn't appear to have even blinked. Instead, he just implemented his own social network. What's happened here appears entirely consistent with Apple's worldview. They own iTunes and their (huge) slice of the online music sales channel. They're going to do things their way. They'll suffer or succeed accordingly.
- jasonlotito 16y agoBut you don't see him posting on HN crying about Facebook's closed garden.
- korch 16y ago^this (thread over, you won :P)
- jiganti 16y agoApple seems to be one of the few companies facebook won't be able to push around so easily.
- Qz 16y agoFacebook seems to be one of the few companies Apple won't be able to push around so easily.
- trevorcreech 16y agoI guess they deserve each other.
- kristopher 16y agoWhen I first launched Ping it asked me to connect via Facebook -- I did, and it worked perfectly. I noticed that immediately after I had connected that the connect button and surrounding UI to that feature had become a search box. The Ping community on Facebook is still up and running[1], so isn't this just a problem with Ping and its UI? [1] http://www.facebook.com/apps/application.php?id=146879158663523 http://www.facebook.com/apps/application.php?id=146879158663...