19 ms·
Paternoster Lifts: Cyclic Chain Elevators with No Buttons, Doors or Stops (2016)
- icebraining 9y agoPrevious discussions on the Paternoster: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9284672 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9284672 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058885 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058885
- tomxor 9y agoInteresting, If it could be made inherently safe somehow this would be so much more efficient, but I just can't help the persistent image of Resident Evil "the lift scene" from entering my head.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoI'm not sure how inherently unsafe they are compared with regular elevators that have shaft doors but not cabin doors. They can theoretically squish you between the floor of a rising cabin and the ceiling, and between the ceiling of a cabin going down and the floor. To prevent this, you could place a movable board coupled to a sensor at ceiling of the cabin and the ceilings of the entry "doors". If the cabin starts squishing someone while going down, the board gets pushed upwards, and triggers an e-stop. If it starts squishing someone going upwards, again, the outer board at that floor gets pushed, and again, triggers the e-stop. (The board would have to be able to move more than the elevator needs to stop, obviously). At that point, the remaining risk seems to be similar to regular elevators that don't have inner doors. (Existing installations seem to have solved this passively with breakaway panels and gaps, which is probably good enough, but would make it possible to jump from the cabin into the shaft while it is between floors.)
- rtkwe 9y agoThey're not good for people with movement disabilities or anyone moving things using the elevators so you'll need a set of regular elevators too.
- Odenwaelder 9y agoThere are 3 places left in Germany where they're allowed to operate. One of those places is Leica in Wetzlar. It's absolutely fun to ride it, much faster than conventional lifts, but it's understandable that they're being shut down for safety reasons.
- hnhg 9y agoThere's one at the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung in Berlin but visitors aren't allowed to use it.
- kuschku 9y agoReally, only 3? Because there’s two alone in Kiel (old city hall and the Landtag)
- TomMarius 9y agoI guess it's similar to the Czech Republic - old ones are allowed to remain in operation, but you can't build new ones except for the places GP listed.
- Odenwaelder 9y agoThen this information might be wrong, I only heard it from some employees.
- hobofan 9y agoYeah, it's a factoid that you usually hear from people surrounding places that have one installed, but given that I've seen more than 3 in person, it's certainly not true. There is a list in the German Wikipedia[0]. [0]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_von_Paternosteraufzügen https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_von_Paternosteraufzügen
- schoen 9y agoThat's quite a few! A lot of those show up on the list as "nur für Mitarbeiter" and "nicht öffentlich"; is there a nice list anywhere of those few that are open to the public? I'd like to try one sometime while they're still operating.
- MarcScott 9y agoI did a work experience placement at a UK hospital about twenty five years ago, and they had an operational paternoster lift. It took about two days of regularly riding the thing before I plucked up the courage to ride it all the way over the top.
- ehnto 9y agoOh my I hadn't even thought about what happens at the top or bottom. Was it completely enclosed? Do you end up going behind the lifts that are facing the opening or is there a divider? What if the power shuts off at the peak? Or worse, at the bottom in the less trafficked basement level? So many questions.
- userbinator 9y agoIt's like a conveyor belt - one side goes up, the other side goes down. Going over the ends means you reverse direction and continue on the other side. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Paternoster_animated.gif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Paternoster_animated.gif
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoYou get to see a sign that this is not dangerous, then the wheels driving the machine, and the cabin may shake a little bit. However, it does not flip over, and a few seconds later, you'll be on the way down and able to get off at whatever floor you like. > What if the power shuts off at the peak? Or worse, at the bottom in the less trafficked basement level? Then you're stuck in there just like you'd be stuck in most other elevators (or slightly less, since you might be able to get into the engine room if you don't mind the fact that it could restart at any time).
- tom_mellior 9y agoFor questions of this type, YouTube can be good. Here is a random video I found by typing "paternoster over the top" (it's one of the suggestions once you type "paternoster") into the search box: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoCQ6tq5wJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoCQ6tq5wJE
- jthacker 9y agoThe article mentions that it's a problem to ride the elevator past the top or bottom floor, but it is unclear why. I don't see why this should be an issue.
- billfruit 9y agoThe cabin becomes upside down as it loops around at the top or bottom, i.e, if some one fails to get out at the top floor, they will be tossed around as the the lift loops around to the bottom floor, so I guess.
- icebraining 9y agoNo, no, the cabins keep their orientation. See the animation on the Wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternoster#/media/File:Paternoster_animated.gif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternoster#/media/File:Patern... Even in the care-free days of the early 20th century I don't think a device that would casually throw you around like that would be open to the public!
- smoyer 9y agoWhen working in Deutsche Bank in the '90s I frequently used one of these in the building and had the same question (but no Wikipedia). We put a piece of tape on the floor of a car that was going up and saw it on the floor when that car was going down. (Note this was necessary because the cabins were completely carpeted and there was no discernable wear). There were also no signs stating that you shouldn't ride over the top ... so we did and probably would have even if they flipped.
- twic 9y agoI remember reading that as a practical joke, people would ride over the top, then stand on their heads before the cabin came back down to the top floor, so bystanders would think it had turned over.
- matt4077 9y agoThe one I know has several signs on the exposed inside walls above the topmost floor all assuring you that you will not be turned upside down, or folded, or run through a meat grinder. Based on the adage that every (non-)warning sign is there for a reason, I can only assume that there have been incidents of people panicking after they realized they had gone to far. Just to be clear: it’s absolutely safe to go around. Any other stories you may hear are the inside joke of those five beaurocrats on the top floor enjoying their tiny fiefdom of chaos. Edit: could people downvoting this please give a reason? I’m really not complaining, just terribly curious what could possibly stroke people the wrong way in this benign post. Or is this the Paternoster conspiracy coordinating to keep their secret?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI saw one of these at a bicycle shop in Bern circa 2006; was too scared to try so took the stairs.
- murukesh_s 9y agoSince it's non-stop, wouldn't this take more power than modern elevators? Why to keep running large number of them despite other concerns including safety? One or two kept in a heritage museum is understandable, but this large number is a bit hard to digest.
- the-dude 9y agoI wonder about the effiency as well : gravity is continuously working.
- kbutler 9y agoLowering platforms in a loop with the raising platforms makes a net work-against-gravity of zero (loading differences excepted). Thus the continuous force to overcome is just friction.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mrob 9y agoDo modern elevators use regenerative braking? If not, then I'd expect the paternoster to use less power, because it's not stopping and starting all the time.
- abricot 9y agoI work in a building with one. It takes 15.5 seconds between floors, wich is a bit slower than our elevators, but because there is no door, buttons and usually no queue it really is very quick. In the course of the day it makes moving between adjacent floors for meetings completely effortless.
- discoursism 9y agoUnless you are disabled, moving between adjacent floors is pretty easy with stairs. And lots of types of disabilities that would prevent the use of stairs would seem to make these risky or impossible to ride. All in all, I'm pretty happy these never caught on.
- abricot 9y agoAdd 15.5s per floor, no perspiration, bring a cup of coffee. Sure, if you love stairs by all means take them. But no, it's just not convenient on the same level.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- interfixus 9y agoThe Danish parliament building, Christiansborg in Copenhagen, built just around one hundred years ago, has such a contraption for MPs and their entourage flitting between floors. The article's main photo could almost be it, and possibly is, though something about wood and marble looks slightly off.
- moocowtruck 9y agoglad these are on their way out other than some eccentric toy
- nagVenkat 9y agoI had the “pleasure” of using one in Germany. I had the worst sense of dread when I was getting into and out of them. But I think I just needed to get used to them I guess.
- enriquto 9y agoIf you think about it, it is orders of magnitude less dreadful than walking on a street with hundreds of cars around you, driven by strangers.
- closeparen 9y agoCars are periodically made to stop to let you through. This is more like trying to cross a freeway.
- Johnny555 9y agoI think you mean "cars are periodically requested to stop", at least, I haven't seen any crosswalks around here with physical barriers that make the cars stop. But unfortunately, that's not the only hazard pedestrians face from cars, not too long ago I saw a car jump the curb and run into a (fortunately) empty bus shelter. If anyone was waiting at that shelter, they'd have ended up under the car. So yeah, I'd feel safer taking a paternoster every day than walking to work... at least then, my safety is in my own hands.
- johnday 9y ago> I think you mean "cars are periodically requested to stop" What a pointless and nonsense distinction to make. I was made to eat my vegetables as a child. They weren't physically forced down my throat.
- mannschott 9y agoWe had a pair of Paternoster in my place of work (in addition to two pairs of elevators) until a year ago. They've since been replaced by a small pair of elevators, which work fine, but the paternoster just had more character. Power usage was given as the reason for replacing them.
- empressplay 9y agoThere's paternosters in Babylon Berlin, an awesome show BTW
- mrchicity 9y agoSounds similar in operation to a Shabbat Elevator (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbat_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbat_elevator) which visit every floor automatically, but still have traditional doors and don't run on a looped circuit. The debate over whether such devices violate religious rules is pretty interesting. I have to imagine if there's an omnipotent deity looking upon on his followers from on high, he'd be thinking something like: Very clever, humans, but you know exactly why I made the rule, and it wasn't so you could win on a slight technicality by not pushing any buttons.
- the-dude 9y agoI was under the impression Jewish people are actually enjoying bending the rules through such clever hacks. There are also Shabbat ovens. Turn on/off automatically, so you are not operating the machine!
- mrchicity 9y agoTalmud scholarship in general is an important part of some Jewish people's culture. They have a rich history of debating rules/their interpretations and applying them to hypothetical or actual life situations. It's a great way to practice critical thinking skills. A Shabbat oven could square with the spirit of the law if you do all your prep the day before and put it in a timed oven to enjoy later. Pretty similar in principle to people in an agrarian society harvesting before their day of rest so they can enjoy a meal together without laboring. Islamic finance is a similar work-around, since charging interest (riba/usury) is against some interpretations of Sharia law. Banks structure special products that don't make guaranteed interest payments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_banking_and_finance#Sukuk_(Islamic_bonds) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_banking_and_finance#Su... I actually quite like the idea of setting aside some time for family and community without work, modern machinery or electronics.
- askvictor 9y agoThis all makes sense, but having to create a special oven to work around your strict interpretation of this rule just seems silly. Just work within the spirit of the rule, and turn the oven on for when you want to cook your pre prepared meal.
- jadell 9y agoHow easily these can be used by people with disabilities? Someone in a wheelchair or on crutches who can't move fast enough would be frustrated or, at worst, seriously injured by one of these.
- majewsky 9y agoI believe this is the reason why, at least in Germany, no new paternosters are allowed to be constructed, and existing paternosters are usually converted to conventional elevators during renovations.
- sannee 9y agoThe (admittedly just two) places I have seen had a "normal" elevator for this purpose.
- jjuhl 9y agoWhy is that relevant? Of course they cannot safely be used by such people - they'll just have to use something else - like stairs or regular elevators.
- mikeash 9y agoWhy is that not relevant? Accommodation for disabilities is an important purpose of most elevators, and it's a reasonable question to ask.
- etblg 9y agoLet me just hop up all those stairs in a wheelchair
- InclinedPlane 9y ago"Like stairs." Did you take the time to put any thought into that? Also, jamming multiple elevator shafts into a building is usually non-trivial. If you have to choose between a paternoster and a regular elevator you will always pick a regular elevator because it helps people with movement disabilities (among other reasons).
- 9y ago
- gambiting 9y agoIt's not a paternoster, but I actually wonder how common is this in the world - almost every lift in every apartment block in Poland I've ever visited only had outside doors but no door inside(so you could see the floors moving past and yes, had to be very careful not to lean on that side). Have other, non ex-soviet countries ever used such design? They look like this from the inside: https://youtu.be/I4hg_jGzO3U https://youtu.be/I4hg_jGzO3U
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThese are actually common for apartments in Europe (well, Switzerland at least). Even UW (in Seattle) has one of these old elevators in the library when I was an undergraduate (staff used them, at least).
- stevekemp 9y agoFor what it is worth these are pretty common in Finnish apartment buildings too. The building I live in, and the second flat I own for renting out are both like this.
- userbinator 9y agoThey seem to be quite common in Sweden too. There's a rather infamous warning sign associated with those: http://i.imgur.com/2AphUVF.jpg http://i.imgur.com/2AphUVF.jpg It even inspired a game: https://www.linusakesson.net/games/klamrisk/index.php https://www.linusakesson.net/games/klamrisk/index.php
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoThey're being phased out, but were common even in non-ex-soviet countries (I've seen some in Switzerland for example). I also think they're faster because less time is spent waiting for doors opening/closing.
- ams6110 9y agoSome years ago I stayed at a hotel in Copenhagen that had an elevator like that. Though there was a interior sliding screen door that had to be closed manually before it would move.
- sannee 9y agoThree of these were scheduled to be replaced several years ago at my university - the administration however pulled the "voluntarily call the historical conservationists" trick and they are still operational.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe MULTI seems potentially awesome; even when used as a pure vertical lift, it looks like it could be used to make something that had multiple cars with passing, allowing a safe stops-and-doors system with the density of a paternoster but reduced opportunity for and severity of traffic jams, which is kind of the best of all worlds.
- Taniwha 9y agoThis what not what I expected - I spent a summer as a student working in a space with a manual cargo lift with no buttons, instead there was a hole in the wall with a chain. To go up you pull down on the chain, when you reached your floor you grab the (stationary, but the lift is moving) chain, which pulls it up and it stops, pull it up a bit further and it goes down - you have to guess the stop height to pull the chaiun at just the right spot
- lsc 9y agoI watched 'Metropolis'(1927) the other day[1]; The rich main character lived in a building with these; I was not aware it was an actual thing, rather than just "The most future looking elevator that the effects team could cobble together" - The movie really did have some other amazing effects, so it was reasonable, I guess, to assume that this, too was a trick. [1]I joked that it was more a dark warning of the dangers of bad civil engineering than the social commentary it's generally thought to be.