8 ms·
E.O. Wilson on Introversion, the Limits of IQ, and Where Ideas Come From
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWilson suggests that too-smart people tend to be lazy There is some truth to this. Bright students often don't have to work that hard at getting good grades. Some kids who just knew all the answers without studying until high school or college never learned how to study. It isn't uncommon for them to have a really tough adjustment period when they suddenly do need to study. Though maybe lazy is not the best word for it.
- KMag 9y agoWe can mean many things by lazy. One meaning is actively avoiding work, and another is not being disciplined. I knew quite a few of my classmates at MIT who never learned to focus and direct their energies. Even advanced/AP/IB classes in high school didn't require them to focus for very long at a time. It's not that they disliked work, it was that they had never before practiced focusing for very long. Also, being obviously smart, teachers and administrators had always made exceptions for them. My old room mate was a regional US chess champion and widely regarded as one of the smartest in our MIT peer group. He really enjoyed difficult problems, but lacked the ability to steer his intellect. When he was in high school in Atlanta, there was a school program where the government would pay the AP exam fees for any student who signed up, as long as they didn't sign up for two exams that were concurrently administered. There was no requirement that the student take the corresponding course. Partly to demonstrate the wastefulness of the program, my old room mate got a schedule, signed up for all of the exams corresponding to his classes, and also filled in his schedule with as many exams as possible. When the administration discovered his little demonstration, they called him in and told him that he would be actually taking all of the exams, and there would be stern consequences if he didn't pass all of them. I think the threat was to bill his parents for the exam fees for intentionally wasting school resources. They told his teachers what was going on and that he was to be excused from normal classroom activities in order to sit in the corner of the classroom and study from a textbook for a different subject. He passed a full slate of exams, most without benefit of instruction, and most with background distraction of an unrelated class going on in the background while he studied. He wouldn't have been able to do this if he were merely adverse to work or unable to focus. However, the motivation to focus was externally applied. At least until his early 30s, he never gained the ability to will himself to focus, and he never got an undergraduate degree.
- newbear 9y agoWhat did he end up doing for a job?
- KMag 9y agoHe poured over the fine print of online poker sites and found a couple that didn't forbid bots, and then wrote a poker bot that gave him income for a while. Now he writes data mining software for a hedge fund.
- gowld 9y agoThat's not a rare story. AP exams are highly gameable by people with high general intelligence, strong memory, and a good high school education. Memorizing a textbook to the point of scoring well on a multiple-choice test and writing short formulaic essays is standard for a very bright high-school student, and is very different from solving a week-long or month-long problem.
- mcguire 9y agoI don't know. Lazy is a pretty good description, but then it's also a combination of not knowing how to study, and not understanding that studying is a skill, something you have to do. Just suddenly finding that you don't immediately understand something, and having nowhere to go to remedy it.
- vanderZwan 9y agoSpeaking as someone who has definitely had lazy tendencies in the past and did very well before college while doing almost nothing, this does feel very fitting to my personal history. Although I would argue that the failure is one of the educational system - not that I try to avoid taking responsibility, but children in this context are the innocent participants in a system set up for them by adults. Innocent as in that they don't know any better until they're older. The problem is one of understimulation. I do actually like to work hard, and always have. But for topics that bore me, where I don't see the point, why would I invest more than the minimum amount of effort to pass the grade, so that I can focus on things that I do care about? Of course I realise now that I was pubescent ignoramus, but you can't expect a teenager to realise that. That's the responsibility of the adults around them. Again, that is what I mean with teenage innocence. Also, I remember one time another very bright classmate in middle school told me "being gifted is a mental illness of the parents". I don't know if he came up with that or if he stole it from somewhere, but it always stuck with me: a lot of kids (mostly guys, I suspect) who think they're oh so smart are really pampered by their parents - for one, it made me realise my mom praised my abilities way too much (luckily early enough to realise she was wrong quite often). I can't find the article right now, but later I read somewhere that praising children for being gifted - "wow, you must be really smart to get this!" - discourages them from practising hard. Praising them for their accomplishments - "wow, you must have worked really hard to solve this!" - does the opposite.
- paulryanrogers 9y agoDo you mean praising them for effort, not accomplishments?
- vanderZwan 9y agoYes, sorry. It was late when I wrote that
- jacobolus 9y ago> The problem is one of understimulation The problem (for all the students, not just the cleverest ones) is that school curriculum is necessarily insipid, and school pedagogy provides very little direct practice and delayed, often unhelpful feedback. A huge amount of time is wasted on organizational overhead, other students can be tremendously distracting, and meaningful learning is often cut off by scheduled class changes. The primary focus is on memorizing and regurgitating atomized and decontextualized definitions, factoids, and formulas, and students are discouraged from asking and answering their own questions, solving their own problems, or doing their own research. Perhaps worse, there is an excessive focus on getting the “right answers”, which discourages risk taking. Motivated students who have learned some meta-cognitive skills can often learn entirely independently without any human interaction more efficiently than they can from a typical classroom studying a typical school textbook and doing assigned homework. Working 1:1 with an expert tutor/mentor/coach for at least a few hours per week (and then spending the rest of the time on independent practice) is dramatically more effective. Of particular note for clever students, this allows for students to try problems and projects of much larger scope and much greater difficulty than the typical curriculum has room for. But nobody has figured out how to scale this affordably to the whole society. One lucky thing in the software industry is that the tools are very interactive and there are lots of opportunities to get various kinds of feedback even when working independently.
- b0rsuk 9y agoIt's called the curse of the talented, and every intelligent person suffers from it. For me the realization came pretty late, although I already stopped getting top math grades in my 8th year of school, despite an earlier 2nd place in a school wide math contest. The 2007 HN link about Inverse Power of Praise was the eye-opener for me. a.k.a. "How not to talk to your kids" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6999481 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6999481 The takedown is "praise for effort, not for intelligence". Because intelligence is perceived as something you can't change. --------- Our university programming teacher liked to say a good programer should be lazy, because then he will think how to do the job with least effort. How to apply the least amount of force and still get the job done.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoI wonder about this, in that it's a common trope, yet it does not really seem affirmed by evidence. In seeking evidence, there's of course a major problem of bias - yet presumably we'd expect some significant number of these lazy geniuses to achieve and garner some place in history yet they are conspicuously absent. When we think of individuals of substantial intellect there often tends to be an associated abnormally obsessive work ethic. Elon Musk is the typical example today who needs no further elaboration, but he's far from unique in this. Consider autodidacts such as Srinivasa Ramnujan - he not only greatly expanded mathematics but 'reinvented the wheel' in vast chunks of the field before he died... at the age of 32. Maybe the best example is Einstein, if only because he's been falsely spun as this sort of trope. I'm not sure where the myth of Einstein doing poorly at math at an early age came from, but it's fake. Instead of just being whimsical and bored, he sought out a challenge when his assigned courses were unable to provide that. A quote from Einstein when asked of this rumor is, "I never failed in mathematics. Before I was fifteen, I had mastered differential and integral calculus." And his notes and works were prolific driven by another incredible work ethic. I think the wandering mind is certainly fair, but that wandering is often directed towards finding challenges to which an unprecedented level of energy is put forward, often for years or decades at a time, to great achievement.
- rnabel 9y ago> "the father of sociobology" I will never understand why people write articles without a spell-checker.
- oh_sigh 9y agoHey, at least the author didn't misspell the first word in the title of their thesis: https://repository.library.georgetown.edu/handle/10822/528049 https://repository.library.georgetown.edu/handle/10822/52804... , http://www.cddc.vt.edu/feminism/Birke.html http://www.cddc.vt.edu/feminism/Birke.html Strangely enough, which I didn't know when first writing this post, is that my aunt knows this lady as they overlapped during their tenure as professors at the university of warwick
- btrettel 9y agoThat appears to be a journal article, not a thesis, and the title is correct in print: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4236129 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4236129
- mcguire 9y agoI would like to make a tribology joke here, but I can't because it's from the Greek τρίβω, tribo, "I rub".
- rdiddly 9y agoYou haven't heard of sociobology? It's the study of social interaction patterns among oboe players.
- interfixus 9y agoSpell-checkers are a huge distracting pain. My first official act on any kind of text-producing equipment is to turn the damned things off. For typos and suchlike, I know I ought to run them manually before going public with anything - HN comments included - but usually I either forget or can't be bothered, because I know the real errors will drown in a sea of red underlining - me using strange words or simply writing in another language than the checker is set up to expect.
- montrose 9y agoI know a fair number of people who've done important new things, and this seems right on the mark: "There is also an introversion in the innovator that keeps him from team sports and social events. He dislikes authority, or at least being told what to do. He is not a leader in high school or college, nor is he likely to be pledged by social clubs. From an early age he is a dreamer, not a doer. His attention wanders easily. He likes to probe, to collect, to tinker. He is prone to fantasize. He is not inclined to focus. He will not be voted by his classmates most likely to succeed." An interesting conflict arises when these people become startup founders. If their companies succeed, they're forced to become leaders, whether they want to or not. But they rarely learn to relish it. And yet these founders are usually the best leaders for their companies, if they can make themselves do it. It's one of the only examples I know where the people who are best at something don't like doing it much.
- yters 9y ago"But the chief penalty is to be governed by someone worse if a man will not himself hold office and rule. It is from fear of this, as it appears to me, that the better sort hold office when they do, and then they go to it not in the expectation of enjoyment nor as to a good thing, but as to a necessary evil and because they are unable to turn it over to better men than themselves." - Plato, Republic, Book 1, section 347c
- hyperpallium 9y ago“The major problem—one of the major problems, for there are several—one of the many major problems with governing people is that of whom you get to do it; or rather of who manages to get people to let them do it to them. To summarize: it is a well-known fact that those people who most want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it. To summarize the summary: anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job. To summarize the summary of the summary: people are a problem” - Douglas Adams, The Restaurant at the End of the Universe
- musage 9y ago
- cmdli 9y ago> Anti-social, passive aggressive, and a hyperactive imagination? That’s a lot different from the image most of us hold. On the contrary, I think that's precisely the stereotypical image of smart people (e.g. Turing in The Imitation Game). I think a bunch of people who think they are smart would agree with this self-evaluation; I'm tempted to see myself as the intelligent loner who is right while others are wrong. However, I think that view is more narrative than having an actual bearing on aptitude.
- mkl 9y agoThe article is talking about our image of "successful" not "smart".
- cleong 9y agoThe problem with articles like this is that it's in our natural tendency to think "oh this is me". Everyone thinks they are smart and we're not particularly good at successfully finding others who are smart (hence the hiring problem in this industry ). Instead we hire based on whether someone is like us, because we think we're smart so if they like me, they are also smart. Articles like this will perpetuate that belief. Bad soft skills? Lack of a structured lifestyle? Cannot focus? Many people will relate to these because they take effort to build. Though Wilson touches a good point. Medium levels of intelligence is require for most jobs, even in Investing you do not need to be that bright to be "the best" in the field. Additionally, we know now that novel ideas comes from a background process in your brain that takes a lot of time and domain knowledge to develop.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIn psychology there is a concept called the big 5 personality traits. The three most highly correlated to success are: highly disagreeable, highly conscientious, and high stress tolerance. So depending on what you mean by bad soft skills, that might be an asset since being highly disagreeable correlates to success.
- dsacco 9y ago
- ilamont 9y agoIt has occurred to me, after meeting so many successful researchers in so many disciplines, that the ideal scientist is smart only to an intermediate degree: bright enough to see what can be done but not so bright as to become bored doing it. And: There is also an introversion in the innovator that keeps him from team sports and social events. He dislikes authority, or at least being told what to do. He is not a leader in high school or college, nor is he likely to be pledged by social clubs. From an early age he is a dreamer, not a doer. His attention wanders easily. He likes to probe, to collect, to tinker. He is prone to fantasize. He is not inclined to focus. He will not be voted by his classmates most likely to succeed. This is not the type of person the elite universities are looking for. Whether it's Harvard, Stanford, Sorbonne, Beida, IITs, etc., they're looking for high-scoring, blindingly bright geniuses for undergraduate and many graduate programs, too. If they're confident extroverts, i.e., "natural leaders," even better. Are they doing it all wrong?
- api 9y agoThey are looking for future high earners who will pad the endowment. Inventors are often not the highest earners. Tesla died broke.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 9y agoSpeaking for myself, with limited experience, the best scientists don't make good managers or leaders, but the universities are looking for managers or leaders, not scientists. The best scientists probably won't be recognized during their lifetimes. The scientists you do recognize while they're alive, are probably not the best at "science".
- wallace_f 9y ago>The best scientists don't make good managers This brings up an important point. People are good at different tasks. Some people are exceptional with gleaning and regurgitating information from texts and lectures. This is what we mostly label as "smart" today. Others can be great at different things, such as any of the vast sets of social skills, critical thinking, maths, strategy, etc. The problem is that while intelligence in one skill is correlated with intelligence in another, it is not necessarily the case. We probably all have met engineers who openly admit they're not the greatest writers. Another example was one I learned from my interest in chess. Bobby Fischer was one of the greatest at the game, but notoriously struggled with memorizing opening game lines and theory. I am sure many of us here have also met engineers and academics with a lot of knowledge in their field, but whom also hold missconceptions, or easily come to factually erroneous conclusions on things which they have not studies. When I read the story, I was a bit incredulous at the author's words that "IQ is real and it does matter," not because it's such an obvious over-simplification. However, universities will be reluctant to disavow their beliefs in the mystical IQ--an idea which rests in the scholarly literature as an estimation of G, general intelligence--as this is a set of institutions which benefits from their faith not just that it is something which can be measured on a test, but that they do accurately measure it. They're running in circles with this "medium brilliance" because they're out of ideas about why their faith's predictions failed. Turns out those who score the best on IQ tests are those who are the best at scoring well on IQ tests--not the same set of skills needed to be the best scientists.
- kamalkishor1991 9y agoPsychology says there is no correlation between IQ and consciousness. So you will find both lazy and hard-working people with same IQ spread over the normal distribution of consciousness. Seems to me this is a biased observation based on own personality.
- throwaway34231 9y agoThe traits mentioned in the article seem much too similar to those mentioned in the 'Bipolar Lisper' , http://www.shenlanguage.org/lambdassociates/htdocs/blog/bipolar.htm http://www.shenlanguage.org/lambdassociates/htdocs/blog/bipo...
- trakam 9y agoThis may not be the instructive guide to genius that many will read it for since it omits one very important point: You either have it or you don't.
- PeterStuer 9y agoQuick aside on 'Eureka' places. The article notes 'Real progress comes in the field writing notes, at the office amid a litter of doodled paper, in the corridor struggling to explain something to a friend, at lunchtime, eating alone, or in a garden while walking' Am I the only one that has this relation between ideas and temperature? If I take a sauna, it is like my brain shifts into a completely different gear, new ideas and deep insights are generated at high speed. When I'm cold, I can barely do basic math.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIsn't the title a little misleading? I thought the article was actually written by E.O. Wilson- shouldn't it be more like "About E.O. Wilson on... " etc?
- red_admiral 9y agoAn interesting read, matches my own experience in academia well. I hope that one of the good things to come out of today's "information age" is that a bright but bored-with-school student can easily access materials more appropriate to their level, for example learn to learn some programming or more advanced maths in their free time. One point that I think is not particularly well made: "the ideal scientist is smart only to an intermediate degree" - immediately followed up by examples of people (including Wilson himself) estimated at least at the 90th percentile. That's not "intermediate" by any reasonable definition of the word!
- dasmoth 9y agoWhen looking at one tail of a distribution, a somewhat-logarithmic view can often make sense. The 90th percentile of a normal distribution lies almost as close to the mean as it does to the 99th percentile. See also, the UK definition of “middle class” (which isn’t entirely about income, but certainly doesn’t mean “close to median wage”).
- qxzw 9y agoTransire suum pectus mundoque potiri. Life is unfair, a lot of rules are arbitrary, phony people thrive. Get over it, get over yourself. Focus on something worthy and specific, and grind.
- musage 9y ago> Try not to become a man of success but rather try to become a man of value. -- Albert Einstein
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI found myself wanting so desperately to accept what the article says that I realised it's basically just mollycoddling its reader. "Don't worry if you're only mediocre, you don't need to be excellent to excel". I guess the article is trying to say that being a genious is demotivational, in some counterintuitive (not "unintuitive") way. I get that- but so is always being the last in class in grades and the first in the pricipal's office. If geniouses find it hard to advance in life because they never learn to do the hard work - well so do the kids who always get all the D-'s, but for the opposite reason. The genious kids learn that rewards don't require hard work. The "antisocial dreamer" kids learn that working hard brings no reward. They both stop trying, after a while- but the bright kids still get ahead, without trying. And don't get me started on the "antisocial" part. Maybe that's the mark of a true scientist- but it's also the mark of the kid who'll spent most of her school years ostracised, once the other kids' parents get the message that she's "disruptive", who'll finish school with bad grades and struggle to get into the good universities, or the good jobs, and generally find all the doors closed and everyone's back turned. Yeah, sure, you can make it to the top even so. But if every day is an uphill struggle, you'll find you can do a lot less, just because there's only so much motivation a person can have and you'll need to spend most of it just to stay on your feet. This is what I have to say: life is a series of Quick Time Events. If you don't push the right buttons, at the right time, in the right order- you're screwed for ever more. Don't waste your school days being that kid who's always the first to take the blame and the last to receive any praise. And don't let your kids be that kid, either.
- simen 9y agoA bunch of unsubstantiated claims that boil down to "mediocre is good." Who doesn't want to be a misunderstood genius rather than a failure, or just a roughly average person who dreamed of something more? This is feel-good pandering, and it's the sort of thing that's very easy to identify with because you want it to be true.
- sunstone 9y agoVery often a situation requires analysis that leads to creating a plan. IQ is pretty good at assessing someone's ability at analysis. IQ does not really address the "creating a plan" part. In most situations its more effective to be "pretty good" at both aspects rather than super good at just one of them.
- ScottBurson 9y ago[T]he ideal scientist is smart only to an intermediate degree: bright enough to see what can be done but not so bright as to become bored doing it. This reminds me of a piece I once read on Freeman Dyson — can't find it now, sorry — which had a couple of interesting nuggets. As I recall, Dyson was once at lunch with a couple of Nobel laureates, when someone mentioned a puzzle they had heard, some question in number theory. Everyone at the table was stumped except Dyson; and once he gave the answer they were baffled as to how he had come up with it so quickly. On the other hand, he was asked, as I guess he occasionally is, why he had not won a Nobel. His answer was something like, "To do that you have to work on the same problem for a decade. I don't have that kind of attention span." So it seems like Wilson may have a point here.