4 ms·
> However, there is a chasm for them to cross fully where they are no longer a revolutionary technology, but actually a good car company. This kind of stuff ma
by MBCook 9y ago
> However, there is a chasm for them to cross fully where they are no longer a revolutionary technology, but actually a good car company.
This kind of stuff made sense when they were making the original Roadster and hand assembled them (?). But the model S is now 6 years old and this is still happening.
Fine, it was their first ‘real’ car. The Roadster was very low volume.
But the X has the same problem. And now the 3.
At what point does Tesla start acting like a ‘real’ company and decide these kinds of defects aren’t acceptable?
The stuff I hear about Tesla’s process for this stuff sounds like the descriptions of GM factories in The Machine That Changed The World. Just make the cars, fix the worst of it at the end of the line, let service centers do more after delivery to the customer.
- na85 9y ago>At what point does Tesla start acting like a ‘real’ company and decide these kinds of defects aren’t acceptable? Just as soon as people stop lining up to buy their cars. edit: downvote if you please, but they're selling cars faster than they can make them. Tesla has zero financial incentive to start focusing on stopping those defects until the pre-orders dry up and people start voting with their wallets. Corporations understand exactly one thing.
- MBCook 9y agoThe problem with that strategy is the instant the line disappears they’re screwed. At that point they have to compete with all the normal cars plus all the new electric cars that manufacturers are trying to release. Their quality doesn’t seem to be able to stand up, and their service reputation is terrible. Where as if they learn to fix these kind of quality control issues years ago on the model S (the way they should’ve) we wouldn’t even be talking about this right now and there wouldn’t be anything to worry about when the pre-orders stop. Of course they wouldn’t HAVE pre-orders except the only reason THAT is going on is because they don’t seem to be able to build the cars at a volume close to what they claimed. So the question is: are they doing the best they can on quality and that’s slowing down their production, or are they going as fast as they can and ignoring quality? Neither one of those would be a good answer.
- dlwdlw 9y ago6 years is really long for many fields e.g. software. It may be really short for cars though, especially if you are up against incumbents. The massive demand probably doesn't help either. It's not like it's intentional... It's simply the best there is currently and it's competing against idealized thoughtforms. Of course reality can't match the perfection of what can be thought.
- selectodude 9y agoThe incumbents aren’t going into their factories and sabotaging their build quality. Tesla is just not making it a priority either via ignorance of how to do it, or willfully not spending what it costs to do the job correctly.
- MBCook 9y agoI’m not asking for a platonic ideal. I’m asking for what multiple other car companies do every day. Even the ‘bad’ carmakers can do better on fit and finish than Tesla.
- robryan 9y ago> At what point does Tesla start acting like a ‘real’ company and decide these kinds of defects aren’t acceptable? They aren't even close to having a production line that can push out the preordered cars in any reasonable amount of time. Probably some time after they can do that.