10 ms·
Intelligence studies : Left :: Climate science : Right The Left views the expert consensus on intelligence in much the same way that the right views the expert
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Intelligence studies : Left :: Climate science : Right
The Left views the expert consensus on intelligence in much the same way that the right views the expert consensus on climate change. The consensus view is rejected not because of evidence, but because of what it does to their model of the world and fear that it will open the door to great abuses in the future (increased government regulation for climate change, and increased racism and discrimination for intelligence studies).
- goodroot 9y agoI find it unusual that one can use a polarized axiom as the basis for what's considered rational thought. Life is deep, unfathomably complex, nuanced, and believe or not, bipartisan. You can introduce more flavour by expanding your window beyond two disparate colours.
- hueving 9y agoIt's commentary on how politics quickly interfere with rational thought when things hit too close to a key pillar. Particularly after this last presidential election people have made their political leanings a core part of their identity so anything that's a threat to a political belief is an attack on their identity.
- gilbetron 9y agoClimate Science and Psychology are very different types of science. Linking intelligence and race is anti-science, not science. Climate science doesn't need consensus, because it is actual science (not on the level of physics or chemistry, but much closer than Psychology)
- quadrangle 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law
- gilbetron 9y agoSo am I downvoted because the downvoters believe race and intelligence is linked, or because we have some staunch Psychology defenders?
- gilbetron 9y agoSo just going to downvote and not try to engage? That's pretty anti-Hacker News. Feel free to actually, you know, present an argument if you disagree with me.
- grzm 9y agoRegardless of why members may have down voted your comment above, in my experience commenting on voting will attract downvotes because it's against the guidelines: > "Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gilbetron 9y agoIndeed, but also: "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." A downvote with no comment is a shallow dismissal.
- flukus 9y agoDown voted because you dismissed a whole discipline as not "actual science". It certainly has it's issues, the replicability problem is a stain on the whole discipline for instance, but in many ways it is a truer science than climate science is. Psychology is much more experiment driven than much of climate science due to the difficulty of creating planets to test with that allow us to isolate factors.
- gilbetron 9y agoDownvoted, but also older comments of mine on unrelated topics were downvoted. That is "shallow". I don't see how Psychology is truer science, mostly because of the ethics. I studied Psych a great deal in undergrad, and while it is experiment driven, it is no where near the "hardness" of climate science.
- kongojack 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_intelligence There is an entire scientific debate about it in the field of psychology. Claiming it is anti science is willful ignorance.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoWithout a randomized experiment on babies of different races born to surrogates, it is difficult to say that observed differences in intelligence between races is due to genetics or to prenatal and postnatal environment. 50 years ago, it was assumed that Chinese and Indians were stupid according to the correlational data available at the time, and Chinese Americans whose ancestors arrived in the US in the 19th century still perform poorly in tests of general intelligence, but it is now abundantly clear that this isn't due to a genetic racial disadvantage. The left would say that environment can and should be fixed.
- tansey 9y agoThis is why people do twin studies. Orphaned twins that were separated at birth are as close to a natural instrument as one could ever hope to get.
- dredmorbius 9y agoUnless you can control for the surrounding culture and allow for ~150 years of development of same, even twin studies will be of limited power.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoTwin studies have shown that at least 30% of intelligence is determined by post adoption environment. (This is a lower bound because adopters must meet a minimum bar, limiting the differences in adoption environments.) Add that with prenatal environment, and you could have differences in intelligence distributions across races entirely explained, but again, twin studies aren't enough to show that.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoThere is an iconic study that is exactly what you're looking for, and may be the reason such studies are also no longer carried out. It is the Minnesota Transracial Adoption Study [1]. They had an array of children broken into transracial, black, and white all be adopted by wealthy white families in Minnesota. Everything was controlled so much as possible including adoption age (less than one year in all cases), family selection, and so on. They even controlled for geography - every single child within the sample living within a 150 mile radius of a fixed point. It then measured the IQ of the children at age 7 and at age 17. At age 7 the difference in IQ between a adopted white child and adopted black child was 20.1 points. At age 17 this changed to 17.8 points. The difference for a half black child and a white child was 6.1 at age 7, and 8.3 at age 17. The goal of the study was to show the opposite of what it ended up showing. Consequently many individuals, including the authors of the study themselves, have still tried to argue that this is not evidence of a genetic link to IQ. Arguments against it have run the gamut from environmental factors from before the children were adopted (which again was less than 1 years old in all cases) to skin color causing environmental effects. These certainly could be contributing factors, however they would undermine any and all results of the study - which is indicative of a 'nuclear' after-the-fact effort to undermine their own results, rather than a reasoned concern. That concern is also mitigated by an an unbelievably fortuitous 'accident' that helped create a further control sample. A number of the parents of the interracial children believed that the biological parents of these children were both black. And consequently these children certainly would have believed the same, which would lead one to believe that any environmental affects that would have affected black children more negatively than transracial children would also have affected these children similarly. In reality, they ended up scoring comparably to the interracial children whose parents knew they were interracial. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnesota_Transracial_Adoption_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnesota_Transracial_Adoption...
- api 9y agoBoth sides are right about their concerns. The fears are legitimate. Governments can and do use climate change as a pretext to seize additional power, and increasing the price of energy is unquestionably a regressive "tax" that harms the poor and working class a lot more than it harms the wealthy. History demonstrates that if you legitimize any rationale for considering any group of people superior to one another, people will run with that all the way to the death camps. The PC doctrine of equality is a "noble lie" of sorts and a reaction to millennia of bloodshed and unbelievable suffering. This has no bearing on the truth or falsehood of the research but I'm not entirely convinced these things should be ignored when discussing it. If climate change is real and manmade and if IQ is mostly genetic and a significant predictor of success, does it follow that the poor should be made poorer through more costly energy and should be discriminated against on the basis of IQ scores?
- mcguire 9y agoWait... If IQ is mostly genetic and a significant predictor of success, how could the poor be discriminated against on the basis of IQ scores?
- api 9y agoIs it a perfect predictor of success? If someone knows you have a low IQ they might not even give you a chance to try. In the real world this reasoning applies to things like studies on gender differences and performance in different disciplines. Let's imagine there really is a solid scientific case that women are, say, 20% less likely to be good at programming. (Just making up a number.) If this became common knowledge, companies just wouldn't bother hiring women for programming positions. As a result the women who are as good at programming as men don't get a chance. Rinse and repeat for evidence of racial differences in IQ, etc. If it were in fact true that blacks had on average 5-10% lower IQs than whites (making up another number) and if this were common knowledge, nearly all blacks would face intense discrimination including those with IQs the same as or higher than average whites. These examples might sound like typical "social justice warrior" fodder. Let me throw out a totally different kind of example to escape that framing. There's a stereotype out there that male programmers and other male science/engineering types are on average more socially awkward and less socially intelligent than the general population. Now let's say there emerges actual solid scientific evidence for this, and let's say that evidence becomes common knowledge. Would this cause, say, women to just reflexively avoid dating men in technical professions? Would it cause men in technical professions to be passed over for management roles on the perception that they just "don't have the social skills?" A case can be made that biological differences in ability should be somewhat verboten in public discourse because human beings are terrible at statistics and will lazily extrapolate averages to entire groups. Scientific evidence for a statistical bias in ability that applies to any identifiable sub-group of humans can easily lead to blanket discrimination against that entire sub-group regardless of the strength or mutability of the effect or the long term reliability of the science. Edit: The long term reliability issue may actually be a stronger argument than the statistical innumeracy of the average person. Once something like this becomes "common knowledge" it is very hard to educate people otherwise even if the science is revised. Take fat for example. I still know people who eat margarine because "butter is bad" in spite of the fact that we've known for over a decade that fats aren't necessarily so bad for you and that trans fats (present in margarine) are much worse. Unless you have certain metabolic or circulatory issues butter is much better for you than margarine, but try telling your grandparents. Let's say some systematic difference in ability becomes common knowledge and then the science is found to be faulty or -- as is often the case with such things -- reality turns out to be a lot more complex than we thought. How many generations would it take to de-educate the population and how many lives would be ruined in the meantime? We don't generally publish the latest research on biological weapons synthesis or implosion geometries for compact nuclear weapons that use very little fissile material. Studies on race and gender and how they relate to IQ and ability aren't quite as dangerous as these but they should probably be discussed in obscure journals in coded language and should never ever be reported in the popular science press. Society just isn't mature enough to deal with this stuff. Edit #2: I'm not arguing it should be illegal to discuss such things or anything like that, just that several good arguments can be made that it's irresponsible to popularize it.
- danharaj 9y agoI'm on the far left, and while I am comfortable with whatever the scientific consensus on intelligence is at the moment and how it develops in the future, I am very recalcitrant about allowing that understanding into politics, policy or most discussions I want to have about anything. Looking towards the past on how (pseudo)science about intelligence has been leveraged to commit atrocities, and looking at the reasons why so many on the right really really really like bringing up IQ and whatnot, I'll pass. At best the conversation dissimulates the urge to justify hierarchies of dominance-- the same fucking reason why the right likes to bring up anything from biology. At worst you get enthusiastic eugenicists; meeting such people at, say, conferences or other programmer venues (i'm sure programmers skew both towards higher IQ and views that the strong should crush the weak) is like stepping on a cow pie. Not to mention, I know plenty of people who would score high on intelligence tests, perhaps much higher than I would. Some of them seem to leverage that intelligence to be far stupider than anyone dumber than them could manage (us programmers again...). The point being-- the gap between scientific research on intelligence and what it means for A) society, and B) my personal life is a chasm I have no reason to bridge.
- golergka 9y agoCouldn't a conservative say exactly the same about climate change research? How historically climate change research has been used to justify increasing government powers? What would you feel if someone said about climate change something like "I am very recalcitrant about allowing that understanding into politics, policy or most discussions I want to have about anything"?
- danharaj 9y agoDo you honestly, truly think this is a productive question? Yes, someone could make structurally the same post I did about any topic instead of intelligence research, even right down to the grammar. Turns out that completely changes the meaning of the post! The answer is that I think climate research has clear and obvious input into not just state policy but how we structure large scale human activity in general. So, I would think such a conservative was wrong, and perhaps an asshole too depending on how earnest they are. But you could have already guessed, so did I miss the point of your question?
- root_axis 9y ago"Races" as they exist at all are essentially crude amalgamations of phenotypes and regional groupings, they are not genetically precise labels that we can use to draw definitive conclusions regarding genetics. This doesn't mean that we cannot observe patterns or make predictions about racial groupings, only that those observations are ascribed to a grouping that does not account for the complexity of genetics beyond what can be detected by the naked eye.
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe fact that "race" is such a blurry thing should make potential statistical differences wash out, and yet they persist. They persist in both visible and non-visible traits such as height and disease patterns.
- mcguire 9y agoWell, the last time intelligence studies achieved political importance, we ended up with the eugenics movement, which was 1. the kind of issue that the 'left' considers a problem, and 2. just a wee bit embarrassing. On the other hand, if what some would describe as the consensus view is true, then a suitable breeding program, perhaps even forced, would be a moral imperative. Next time on Hacker News: Brave New World: dystopia or utopia?