2 ms·
It's a little sad, but OpenID implementations ended up being rather one sided. Everyone wanted to be an OpenID identity provider, but fewer wanted to be on the
by mrweasel 9y ago
It's a little sad, but OpenID implementations ended up being rather one sided. Everyone wanted to be an OpenID identity provider, but fewer wanted to be on the consumer side. For OpenID to succeed that relationship needs to change.
There was simply no benefit for the larger sites to access OpenID as an authentication mechanism. Perhaps the EUs General Data Protection Regulation can change that to some extend for smaller sites that wish to store almost nothing about the users, while still authenticating them.
- sebazzz 9y agoAs I see it, it has been replaced by OAuth, which is created for a different purpose but works just as well for login and authentication.
- JepZ 9y agoI doubt that. Its just that everyone wanted to use those fancy facebook/google/whatever logins and nobody really cared for the decentralized login concept. In fact, the few websites which supported OpenID allowed to use custom providers while OAuth mostly limited to handful of social media providers. So OpenID was a way to decentralize the web and prevent password reuse while OAuth is a strategy by large Social Media corporations to increase your dependence on their brand. In the end they both might be able to authenticate and to prevent password reusage to some extend, but their motivations and implications are very different.
- willow9886 9y agoNo, OpenID has been replaced by OpenID Connect, a profile of OAuth 2.0 written to specifically address user sign in. OAuth 2.0 is an authorization framework, not an authentication protocol. OAuth 2.0 can be used for a lot of cool tasks, one of which is person authentication. OpenID Connect is a “profile” of OAuth 2.0 specifically designed for attribute release and authentication. For more info, see our blog: OAuth vs SAML vs OpenID Connect. [1] [1] https://www.gluu.org/resources/documents/articles/oauth-vs-saml-vs-openid-connect/ https://www.gluu.org/resources/documents/articles/oauth-vs-s...
- snuxoll 9y agoOpenID Connect is still not in any way comparable with traditional OpenID.
- willow9886 9y agoNobody said it was... > OpenID has been replaced by OpenID Connect Replaced != compatible. Also, "traditional OpenID" is very ambiguous phrasing... are you referring to OpenID 1? OpenID 2? or OpenID Connect?
- tedunangst 9y agoWhile we're playing inequality, comparable != compatible.
- willow9886 9y agooops! i've been staring at the screen too long!!
- tomc1985 9y agoOpenID was also notoriously difficult to implement
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI used a project called phpmyid, some time ago, but it was quite easy to use and allowed me to run my own identity from my server.