8 ms·
Stack Overflow: Support for OpenID Ends on July 1, 2018
- mrweasel 9y agoIt's a little sad, but OpenID implementations ended up being rather one sided. Everyone wanted to be an OpenID identity provider, but fewer wanted to be on the consumer side. For OpenID to succeed that relationship needs to change. There was simply no benefit for the larger sites to access OpenID as an authentication mechanism. Perhaps the EUs General Data Protection Regulation can change that to some extend for smaller sites that wish to store almost nothing about the users, while still authenticating them.
- sebazzz 9y agoAs I see it, it has been replaced by OAuth, which is created for a different purpose but works just as well for login and authentication.
- JepZ 9y agoI doubt that. Its just that everyone wanted to use those fancy facebook/google/whatever logins and nobody really cared for the decentralized login concept. In fact, the few websites which supported OpenID allowed to use custom providers while OAuth mostly limited to handful of social media providers. So OpenID was a way to decentralize the web and prevent password reuse while OAuth is a strategy by large Social Media corporations to increase your dependence on their brand. In the end they both might be able to authenticate and to prevent password reusage to some extend, but their motivations and implications are very different.
- willow9886 9y agoNo, OpenID has been replaced by OpenID Connect, a profile of OAuth 2.0 written to specifically address user sign in. OAuth 2.0 is an authorization framework, not an authentication protocol. OAuth 2.0 can be used for a lot of cool tasks, one of which is person authentication. OpenID Connect is a “profile” of OAuth 2.0 specifically designed for attribute release and authentication. For more info, see our blog: OAuth vs SAML vs OpenID Connect. [1] [1] https://www.gluu.org/resources/documents/articles/oauth-vs-saml-vs-openid-connect/ https://www.gluu.org/resources/documents/articles/oauth-vs-s...
- snuxoll 9y agoOpenID Connect is still not in any way comparable with traditional OpenID.
- willow9886 9y agoNobody said it was... > OpenID has been replaced by OpenID Connect Replaced != compatible. Also, "traditional OpenID" is very ambiguous phrasing... are you referring to OpenID 1? OpenID 2? or OpenID Connect?
- tedunangst 9y agoWhile we're playing inequality, comparable != compatible.
- willow9886 9y agooops! i've been staring at the screen too long!!
- tomc1985 9y agoOpenID was also notoriously difficult to implement
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI used a project called phpmyid, some time ago, but it was quite easy to use and allowed me to run my own identity from my server.
- bambax 9y ago> Of our 9,813,747 accounts around one-tenth of a percent are actively using OpenID I created an account on SO using an OpenID provider in 2009. In 2014, the provider disappeared and with it, the ability to log into the account. I was never warned about this and have never been able to access that account again. Since then I only access SO via web searches (didn't create another account). I wonder how many people are in the same situation.
- igor47 9y agothis happened to me too, and I wrote up how I recovered from it, here: https://igor.moomers.org/recovering-openid https://igor.moomers.org/recovering-openid it's fairly painless
- JepZ 9y agoNice write up!
- teh_klev 9y agoWhen I was a mod on the site, I know that you could email the dev team or ping a mod to ping the dev team to fix this. They were usually pretty quick about it.
- mooreds 9y agoYes, they combined a couple of accounts (that all belonged to me) with an email or two (and some validation, IIRC).
- JepZ 9y agoI created my SO account via OpenID too, but somehow I am still able to login via email. I don't know, maybe I did something to enable that, but in general there should be no problem using an old OpenID account with SO.
- fabian2k 9y agoYou're probably talking about myOpenID, that shutdown affected quite a few people as far as I remember. You can get back access to the account by contacting SE support in many cases (https://stackoverflow.com/contact https://stackoverflow.com/contact).
- ReverseCold 9y agoTangentially related: The openid.net website is blocked by some popular web filters as "virus/malware". Anyone know why?
- tedivm 9y agoWhich web filters? I can't see any reason why it would be blocked, as I couldn't find any history of malware infection on it and they don't even have ads (so no history of their ad network pushing exploits).
- tannhaeuser 9y agoI don't get why OpenID was introduced in the first place then. The point of using an open auth protocol is to not become dependent on monopolies, isn't it? The figures being what they are isn't supportive of this decision when using OpenID is considered a strategic decision. I thought you could use Google at least (but not Fb) as OpenID Connect provider, so wouldn't it make more sense to deprecate support for Google-proprietary login schemes instead? Also, as remarked on the followup stackexchange discussions, this will make stackexchange login (against Google, Fb) JavaScript-only, won't it? Could somebody with more know-how clue me in about the state of affairs of OpenID and web auth?
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoI don’t think OpenID connect is the same thing as OpenID
- WorldMaker 9y ago"OpenID" Connect is absolutely not the same thing as OpenID and should never have had OpenID in the name.
- billpg 9y agoJust wait until you hear about Javascript and C#.
- willow9886 9y ago> I don't get why OpenID was introduced in the first place then. Because the Internet needs standards to work. If all domains implement authentication differently, we do not have an interoperable network. As is customary, standards must evolve to keep up with requirements. OpenID 1 and 2 weren't built with the idea that smart phones would be in every persons pocket, or Internet connected devices in every home. The latest iteration of OpenID--OpenID Connect--is essentially Google's playbook for authentication. It's of huge value to the rest of the world. To put it simply: having your own OpenID Provider at your domain (e.g. idp.example.com) allows you to operate a similar authentication infrastructure as Google. What does that mean? - Single sign-on (SSO) across web and mobile applications - Ability to support a variety of strong authentication mechanisms (a.k.a 2FA), like U2F security keys and OTP mobile apps, in one place for many apps If all apps and services were to align with OpenID Connect, we would have a truly scalable and interoperable identity layer for the Internet.
- milkmiruku 9y agoFWIW, I've used OpenID for login on my personal wiki [1] for a few years and haven't had a spam issue [yet]. To forgo the bother of managing being provider or even relayer, I just use a Dreamwidth (the LiveJournal fork) profile [2]. Always interesting using a url as a login. For those who say that's confusing for the masses, there was a method of mapping e-mail address to OpenID profiles. [3] I was a bit confused as to why OpenID Connect turned out the way it did, moving focus from federated to the closed "Login with Facebook/Twitter/GitHub/Dropbox/Google" thing (if they is Oauth/OIDC based?). I guess the above could be related - I get no spam because federated OpenID didn't take off, and federated OpenID didn't take off because companies wished to sidestep a future spam problem. [1] https://wiki.thingsandstuff.org https://wiki.thingsandstuff.org [2] https://www.dreamwidth.org/openid https://www.dreamwidth.org/openid [3] https://mashable.com/2008/09/30/openid-email-addres https://mashable.com/2008/09/30/openid-email-addres
- willow9886 9y agoIt's a bit strange that nowhere in the post does SO mention OpenID Connect... OpenID 1 & 2 have been dead and deprecated for some time...Google deprecated support in 2016. All domains should move to supporting the latest iteration, OpenID Connect, which, by all indications, looks like it will be stable and relevant for many years to come.
- dfabulich 9y agoOpenID Connect is stable, sure. But relevant? I'm not aware of any major identity provider or consumer who uses OpenID Connect.
- willow9886 9y agoSeriously? How about Google? https://developers.google.com/identity/protocols/OpenIDConnect https://developers.google.com/identity/protocols/OpenIDConne...
- kstrauser 9y agoAnd they compensated by finally allowing users to add new email/password authentications to their account. Woo-hoo! I'd originally signed in with Google but I'd much rather have personal per-system logins, and now this is possible.
- djsumdog 9y agoI am one of the 13k that is that little red guy. I just migrated my openid provider to a docker container and changed the certificate to LetsEncrypt. Slashdot removed support, as did shirt woot and deletionpedia. Freecode and gitorious are gone. After this, the only things I'll have left on openid will be pipy (which doesn't seem to work) and openstreetmaps. I understand why and the technical debt involved, but this still makes me very sad. We're moving in the wrong direction. We're going away from open, federated, distributed standards and back to closed, wall-gardened, proprietary, massive identity providers.
- nathan_long 9y ago> We're going away from open, federated, distributed standards and back to closed, wall-gardened, proprietary, massive identity providers. I'm not. I just create an email and password for each site I use. A password manager means that's not a big deal. EDIT: I meant to say I create an account based on email and password. I don't actually create a separate email address per site.
- abricot 9y agoI create an email for every site. I can recommend it.
- jackweirdy 9y agoDo you do this programmatically? Or with the +suffix@.... trick?
- ibz 9y agoNeither nor. I have my own domain. Every website gets <website>@mydomain. Every email @mydomain gets forwarded to my primary email. As simple as that.
- jackweirdy 9y agoNice! Another domain owner here. Never thought to have a sink-all mailbox. Thanks for sharing.
- DanHulton 9y agoHuh, I'm one-tenth of one percent. AMA, I guess. But yeah, this got me into trouble a couple times. I actually have a /openid URL on my site that redirects to Google, but forgot. This, mixed with accidentally having two accounts (back when Careers was it's own thing) meant some poor SO rep had to do a whole bunch of untangling one day. I'm glad they're consolidating systems into an easier-to-understand thing. If it had just be email/password from day 1, I don't think I'd have had half the troubles I did by trying to be "future-compliant".
- bloudermilk 9y ago> Of our 9,813,747 accounts... Stack Exchange has less than 10 million registered users? That’s surprisingly low even for Stack Overflow alone. I wonder how many MAUs they get...
- jfriend 9y ago~50 monthly visitors. The key here is you don't need an account to get the value. https://stackoverflow.com/company https://stackoverflow.com/company
- lucideer 9y agoThis isn't a big surprise, if anything it's surprising it lasted as long, but some thoughts/comments: > The reality is OpenID support has created a ton of complexity in our codebase I don't doubt this is true but I do find it surprising. I would be interested to see a breakdown of this from a technical perspective. I'm sure it adds complexity, but in the context of the overall complexity of SO I would have expected it to be relatively overshadowed. > Users have spoken with their actions. You prefer Google, Facebook and Stack Exchange (aka email/PW) based account auth. No, they haven't. OpenId use in SO has declined for two reasons: (1) providers shutting down and (2) Stack Overflow UI changes to hide the option from users in the login form (making my logins require extra clicks). > around one-tenth of a percent are actively using OpenID (defined as having visited a site in the past 12 months). If you include all the inactive accounts it is still less than 2.9% of all accounts. 0.01 up to 2.9 is a massive jump and seems to indicate a high active user turnover. I wonder what the user activity retention rates are on SO. What percentage of currently active users are very recent joiners.
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoAh, Stack Exchange (and Overflow) Meta never stops to make me smile : they used a post closed as 'non constructive' as a reference in an official announcement.