14 ms·
MoviePass CEO says the app tracks your location before and after movies
- darkstar999 9y agoCan't you just revoke the location permission?
- jastanton 9y agoYes, all up until you need to check in for the movie. You have to be physically located within a set distance of the theater in order to load up funds on the credit card.
- mon22 9y agoWithout setting location access to "always", this shouldn't be possible, right? He might only be talking about the customers who have it enabled. So yeah, will wait for the clarification.
- product50 9y agoOn Android, that is not a setting you get.
- sp332 9y agoAn Android, it also asks for permission to read all your photos and you can't use the app if you don't accept. I only run the app on an old iPhone I had lying around for that reason.
- cryptoz 9y agoIs there a use case in the app that makes that somewhat reasonable? If not, it sounds like grounds to be reported and removed from Google Play as malware. I thought that would be 100% against the developer rules. Maybe it is just a guideline to only ask permission for things you need, and to let the user use the app even if permission isn't granted. Maybe it's just that Google won't feature you or something. But it should be against Play Store rules if it isn't already.
- stickydink 9y agoFrom experience, Google does flag up permission usage as part of featuring. Insofar as listing all the ones that are used and requesting an explanation of why each is needed.
- sp332 9y agoNot that I know of. It's never even asked for that kind of thing on the iPhone version so it's pretty confusing. Edit: according to old posts on a support forum, it might ask for a photo of your ticket stub. That doesn't explain why it wants access to your own photos, which is a different permission on Android from getting access to your camera.
- paulcole 9y ago> Is there a use case in the app that makes that somewhat reasonable. Maybe image recognition to see the kinds of things you're eating/considering buying before/after going to the movies? This seems pretty reasonable to me. I consider it a fair trade for the monetary discount they're offering on their services. I don't want to spend $10-$15 whenever I want to go to the movies. But I'm more than happy to provide access to my data and photos which I have no way to easily convert to monetary value. If I didn't feel this way, I just wouldn't use their service.
- FireBeyond 9y agoIf only it were that harmless. No, the reason for accessing your Photos is to get the location and timestamp off of every one and build a nice little trail of where you are and where you go.
- castlecrasher2 9y agoTo what end? This kind of hyperbole just desensitizes me to concerns about data collection.
- simias 9y ago
- olympus 9y agoI know that you didn't go out and buy the iPhone just for this purpose, but dang, this might be the pinnacle of modern consumerism. "I have a spare smartphone to use for apps that I don't want on my main smartphone."
- sp332 9y agoHeh. I prefer Android and my wife uses iPhones, so if I want to run any iOS apps I have to make do with her old iPhone 5. So maybe not the pinnacle of consumerism, but I'm certainly lucky to be able to hoard old tech.
- OJFord 9y agoYou can disable location access completely, or while in background, or prompt every time.
- wvenable 9y agoOn Samsung devices you can put an app to sleep -- it gets no cycles when it's not running and can't even send you notifications. It's great for these kind of apps that you want to use but otherwise don't want running in the background.
- sp332 9y agoMy guess is that they don't collect the data themselves, but buy the location data from some other company. Then they can combine the location data with the movie data they collect themselves. Then they could either use that for advertising, or sell the bundled data along to advertisers for more money.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoBy they do you mean the NSA or the CIA? ;)
- passivepinetree 9y agoThe way TechCrunch presents this, it seems even shadier than Uber's "we'll track you for the 5 minutes after you get dropped off" tactic from last year. With no language addressing such tracking in the EULA, how is that legal?
- dahdum 9y agoSure they expressly said they don't in their Privacy Policy but then the CEO admitted they do in fact, but the T&C allow forced arbitration and no class actions. Unless the government wants to make a statement by pursuing them, there is no recourse except public shaming.
- peteretep 9y ago> Uber's "we'll track you for the 5 minutes after you get dropped off" Ah, is this how Uber knows my preferred pickup point near my condo? It's an excellent feature.
- passivepinetree 9y agoYeah, I believe the rationale was to know better where entrances and exits are to certain buildings. The idea is a good one, but many people were up in arms about tracking that wasn't expressly during the interaction with Uber the company.
- mcescalante 9y agoFrom my understanding, the bet that MoviePass is making is that they will be able to sell user/usage data to studios (or others) to make back the money that they're losing paying full price on the tickets; they've even admitted this in other interviews... just without specifying what data. Even if it's not location data, I would imagine that any/all data they can associate with a user they will.
- castlecrasher2 9y agoOff the top of my head I'd say they're looking to see what other things people do after movies, like go out to eat, shopping, or go home.
- Spooky23 9y agoI doubt it. That data isn’t worth more than the movie admission. The real goal is probably more like ticket scalpers... see how pricing motivates behavior and now demand can be shaped. The value generator would be either tiering the service offering or charging a premium for certain movies. If they can demonstrate that flat rate pricing generates demand for movie viewing, even for shitty movies, they could buy excess inventory and give away shit movies or slack times and charge a premium for good movies or peak times. It is almost certainly achievable. Back in my high school/college days I had access to unlimited free movies through various means. I saw every movie in the theaters from 1996-1999. We could get into hot movies the first week, so we watched whatever was available.
- joncrane 9y agoSomeone in an earlier thread about Moviepass posited that they are banking on making money on data, because they are losing money on the ticket portion. The surprising thing is that the CEO admitted it so readily.
- vlovich123 9y agoWhy is that surprising. They were always up front about the data when they got acquired & dropped it to its current price. The new part is the location tracking (which thankfully you're now in charge of on an iPhone).
- lghh 9y agoI'm really over trying to fight companies on this on an app-by-app basis. If we want this to stop, it has to be through legislation. Either we allow companies to do it and stop acting shocked when it happens, or we legislate the possibility away.
- ibdf 9y agoI don't know why everyone is always so shocked. People want smart devices/services that understand them. Where do you think the data comes from? From you!
- alexandercrohde 9y agoNobody is asking moviepass to understand them...
- parfe 9y agoNo, they just want subsidized tickets, but then whine that MoviePass gets something out of the deal.
- throwaway2048 9y agoyeah not like they are being paid or anything. The market equilibrium rests where you can extract maximum value, if they can get away with tracking, they will do it, it has absolutely nothing to do with it being a fair deal or not.
- ben_jones 9y agoMoreover how can our government condemn commercial data mining while at the same time expanding domestic surveillance? "Don't share your data its harmful! Unless you share it with us!".
- lghh 9y agoJust because we have not made progress in domestic surveillance does not mean we can't make progress in commercial data mining. It may be hypocritical to have one at the rate we do and legislate the other (though I don't think it necessarily is), but it's better to do that than to have both.
- technofiend 9y agoLoad app - present ticket - uninstall app.
- sgroppino 9y agoIt's getting close to a point where you should just bundle all of these apps onto an old android phone and use it just ad-hoc when you absolutely need them.
- hartator 9y agoI don't see the big deal really, Google maps and the like has probably 100x the data plus the mean to make it evil. I don't really see what extra data they will have compare to just ticket sales. It seems just a bad VC bet, and you can take advantage of it.
- dawnerd 9y agoSome people here are hilarious. Bad if moviepass goes it - Fine if google/Facebook/Apple/etc does it.
- slg 9y agoMoviePass announced their their new, improved, and unrestricted plans in August. We all knew the $10 a month plan was not going to be profitably by itself. In the last week they have started blocking out specific movies, requiring some users to provide photographic proof of their ticket purchases, and bragged about collecting data outside what is described in their TOS. This is after already locking out customers from using the service at some of AMC's flagship theaters. Who had it had it at roughly 6 months before MoviePass started running out of money and needed to resort to trying to milk every last cent out of the theaters, studios, and moviegoers?
- JustAnotherPat 9y agostill worth it
- EggsOnToast 9y agoThis was my feeling too. I don't want to live in a world where everyone is expected to freely give away their data, but if I can do it voluntarily to get get a deal as good as MoviePass then that's a win/win to me. It's $15 for just -one- ticket in my area. MoviePass has been a game changer for me.
- craftyguy 9y ago> but if I can do it voluntarily The catch here is that no customers of theirs were given a chance to do so voluntarily. They purposefully misled customers so even though it's nice you don't care, others who do fell into the trap. That's fucked up.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoDo you have a link on that or are you talking about the current article? I believe you but I wasn't one of the early adopters of MoviePass so by the time I joined I skimmed the contract, nodded, and thought "Got it, you spy on me and I get cheap stuff."
- whoisjuan 9y agoAny app that asks for your location can and will track you. This is so lucrative that Foursquare pivoted the whole company around the concept of location data as a service (https://enterprise.foursquare.com/ https://enterprise.foursquare.com/). Fortunately, you just need to revoke the permission (or don't grant it in the first place) if you want to avoid being tracked. If you're concerned about this, I'd definitely suggest doing a quick check of the apps that track your location and disable the permission in the ones that you distrust.
- jnnnthnn 9y agoOne thing that is clever about MoviePass, is that in order to use their membership, one must have location services activated at least for a brief instant every time they are going to the movie. Indeed, you need to “check in” in the app when you’re within a 100 yard radius of the theater in order to be able to charge the ticket price to the MoviePass-provided payment card. Odds are, most people won’t want (or remember) to turn location services on and off every time they purchase a ticket.
- ChadMoran 9y agoiOS 11 introduced the ability to allow apps to only access your location while you're actively using the app. Using this method should be a good mitigation.
- walrus01 9y agoThe oneplus variant of android, oxygenOS, allows you disable location services granularly per application. They continued the granular permissions system from CyanogenMod.
- pashabitz 9y agoYes, this is kinda annoying and yes, we're losing our privacy little by little but please, give me a break with the fake bewilderment. It's an explicit permission (on iOS at least) to use GPS when you're not in an app. This journalist is in total shock that the app actually uses this permission to try to make money. Come on.
- gergles 9y agoAnd it doesn't even ask for the background location permission, so unless it has magical superpowers, it isn't going to be able to track you unless have the app open. This is a really bad article, and I am shocked, just shocked, to see reporting of such poor quality on TechCrunch.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoA monthly subscription cost for "unlimited" movies priced lower than the price of a single movie? Mind you, my mum wouldn't understand that at that point she's the product. However, the ol' "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is" is something everyone should know. I don't agree with MoviePass' approach - which is the reason I haven't subscribed - but unless it's blatantly illegal I think it's safe to presume they'll do anything to make a buck. MoviePass is too good to be true. Let's not be naive. Let's cut back on the fake outrage.
- cityzen 9y agoUnfortunately it's the world we live in now. Unless iOS is so compromised (wouldn't be surprised) that MoviePass can read data from other apps, an app that runs temporarily for me to check into a movie and I can turn location services on/off and see unlimited movies for $8/month is pretty great! Sure, a little more work (few seconds?) to turn location services on/off a few times a month but in general I think it's worth it. The more value I can get circumventing businesses where the model is to collect and sell data, the better. I love the niche model of pay a little bit of money, get more value back and have the option to be tracked by a device that I control better than a lot of the shady "free" companies (facebook, pinterest, instagram, nextdoor, google, etc)
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI think that's the thing people are upset about: Many of these deceptive practices are not illegal, and probably should be. The EU has a good start with their new data privacy legislation; the US needs to adopt that.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThey're upset because...they're getting something for next to nothing (in terms of hard dollars)? Should there be more transparency? Sure. But even so, being naive is only going to manifest itself somewhere else. The Nanny State will never win that race.
- 9y ago
- findjashua 9y agonot sure about Android, but on iOS you can customize which apps have access to location data all the time (eg google maps) and which ones have it only while using (eg moviepass). So if you open the app only to check-in in the theater, they shouldn't be able to access your whereabouts before/after that.
- kc10 9y agoI was a MoviePass subscriber for about 4 months. But I noticed that international movies and few theaters are blocked, can't reserve tickets ahead of time as per TOS. With all these restrictions I didn't even watch any movies for a couple of months. So I just cancelled and subscribed to Sinemia (I am in no way related to this service).
- csmiller 9y agoNever heard of Sinemia. How is it different?
- mynameisvlad 9y agoLooking at their plans (https://www.sinemia.com/new-plans/ https://www.sinemia.com/new-plans/) it's capped at 2 or 3 movies a day, available at any theater and in any format. You can also apparently buy advance tickets, which is a huge limitation for MoviePass. Their business model seems more sustainable than MoviePass, too. Well, at least when it's not heavily reduced due to the Oscar promo.
- mcast 9y agoPer MONTH*, not per day. That’s a huge difference to MoviePass.
- mynameisvlad 9y agoYes, which makes it far more sustainable.
- kc10 9y agoThe main advantage is reserving tickets via fandango or any other website that sells the tickets. Personally we didn't watch more than 2 movies a month in theaters, so this works great for us.
- jakebasile 9y agoYou know, maybe I'll just pay for the ticket.
- amorphid 9y agoIt's also draining the heck out of my battery.
- linsomniac 9y agoAs far as I'm concerned, it would hardly matter if the theaters charged $0 for movies. My family almost always goes to the movies for a "family date night". Last night our concession stand bill was over $60, and that's just because I din't have a drink and we didn't get popcorn. The theater we pretty much exclusively go to is one of those fancy places with the power recliners and food, so we will usually eat dinner there. I know, this is choices we make when seeing a movie. But, I can't AFFORD to get unlimited movies for $10/month. :-)
- r00fus 9y agoHuh. All the folks I know bring their libation (beer even sometimes) and even food into the theater. My wife and I always eat first, then take a small snack in her bag and that's it. Of course, we don't go to an upscale theater.
- milesokeefe 9y agoWhat theater lets you bring in outside food/drink? I've never heard of the practice, outside of theaters that let you bring your own growler for them to fill.
- sixothree 9y agoI received one as a gift and it's definitely cost me in concessions...
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoThe quantities of money are so low, and the deal I'm getting back is so good I barely care. Then again, I was paying 30/month for moviepass when it just came out years ago. The sad part is that AMC doesn't have an unlimited plan. Growing up in France I had the UGC illimite pass[1]. Moving to the US killed my movie-going habits from twice a week to maybe once every other month. Then of course moviepass came along and I was confused at how cheap it was. I mean, can't we have a regular pass for 50/month no imax from AMC and call it a day? Someone, either the studios, AMC, or me, is brain-dead and I can't figure out which one it is. [1] https://www.ugc.fr/les-offres-ugc-illimite.html https://www.ugc.fr/les-offres-ugc-illimite.html -- it still exists which means this business model has proven to make sense in France for at least 15 years.
- Moru 9y agoI go maybe once every two years. Afterwards I feel empty asking myself "Was this really worth 12 euro?". Then I don't go for another two years until I forget the feeling. It was always like this even when I was a kid. I preffered Lego and books (and computer when that got available). Movies were always a letdown.
- tetrahedr0n 9y agoOverall, MoviePass is a step forward for privacy advocates and a benefit to "netizens". MoviePass just set the price for your data; an abstract possession that people are barely beginning to value as an actual possession of theirs. The going price for tracking your purchasing behaviors before and after attending a movie is the cost of however many movies you can see in a month minus $10. Facebook paid with a social networking platform to connect you to an unimaginable number of people you probably wouldn't be connected with otherwise. For that, you gave them your history and your super-ego. Google gave you a map, an email, a phone number, and a bunch of productivity tools. For that you gave them everything. The value of your data is holding steady or going up, depending on your perspective. Also, MoviePass took a step in the right direction towards disclosure of intent when their CEO opened his mouth about it. Their TOS is typical, but the CEO is more transparent than most. They should be the brave first company to make their intention transparent.
- baddox 9y ago> The going price for tracking your purchasing behaviors before and after attending a movie is the cost of however many movies you can see in a month minus $10. Well, it's the value to you of however many movies you can see in a month, minus $10. That's likely very different than the nominal cost of all those movies, since MoviePass is likely to cause you to see more movies than you otherwise would.
- NotQuantum 9y agoJokes on them, I've purchased all of my tickets via an Android Emulator and GPS spoofing. I've got it setup such that I text my home box that it's "movie time" and I get a response as soon as the app says the card is loaded.
- ironjunkie 9y agoHalf jokingly , I thought about doing the same thing and "Milk" the service. That is use as many subscription as you have family members//friends, buy one ticket a day and sell them all back on Craigslist for 25% less. I would never do it of course, but I'm surprised nobody is doing it.
- hanoz 9y agoSlight tangent but is it the case that the vast majority of Android apps (like >99%) which ask for superfluous permissions that cannot be denied or revoked, are about to become illegal under GDPR?
- Silhouette 9y agoIt looks like much of what's going on here would already be illegal under the existing EU data protection rules, even without the GDPR. But does MoviePass operate within the EU?
- mike_n 9y agothey also try to get permission for android's "body sensors"
- max937 9y agoJust log out of the app after purchase. If that’s not enough, delete the app and reinstall each time you are at the theatre. Love MoviePass!
- halfjoking 9y agoMoviepass is going to get more and more desperate as their money runs out. I don't have Moviepass but it's fun to think of how they could sell out their users in the future. Like maybe they could force users to write 500-word reviews? Or better yet record their faces so sentiment analysis algorithms can track users every feeling during a movie? Maybe ask users to spot product placement in movies - you don't get the movie free unless you enter every product spotted and write your thoughts about it. Maybe they could force women users to sit next to creepy men users who pay for that "extra service?" There's no limit to how you can innovate when you have no respect for your users.
- datahack 9y agoWe've stopped going to the movies since this service came out, and bought a bigger TV. We don't want to pay the movie food tax, movies are now packed with people and unpleasant to watch in our area, and it's just not an enjoyable experience. Location-based tracking is totally common, and a serious business these days. This dataset will provide MoviePass with a huge and unique database, and they will prosper. What nobody is talking about in this thread is that once they combine it with all of the other databases (profile, interest, etc), they will be able to track every single movie consumer from cradle to grave, from home to work, and on to the theater. They will know how your friends are, who you go to the movies with, where they live, who they know... this is all stuff that companies have been doing now since the early 2000s. My point is that not only is this not illegal, it's relatively common. It might feel creepy, but this is the new normal. It's just not talked about very much. Google has a ton of this data, so does every cell provider, and of course someone mentioned foursquare, who realize that the location business was a better business than anything else they can build. Also, the more we allow social media into our lives the richer these profiles become, because the qualitative data from social networks is the foundation of location networks. Where meets who meet when = datapoint. In case you were wondering where all the mobile advertising revenue transitioned, start reading the T&Cs on the apps you download friends. :)
- yorby 9y agoin other news, Ford Executive says he can track you anytime you drive... http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1
- chapill 9y ago>It sure isn’t in the company’s privacy policy What they are doing is illegal in the state of California.
- abalone 9y agoThey will DEFINITELY run into trouble with Apple's app store policy. Apple doesn't outright ban apps that do this but they have to clearly state what they do when requesting location services permissions. There is a string called "app explanation" that has to state what they will use it for. Theirs says: "Find Theaters and movies near you, and be able to use the app to get tickets and the theaters."[1] There's nothing about tracking you outside of that purpose. Nothing about your drive to the theater, nothing about where you go after. So if they're doing that or start doing that, they should and probably will get kicked out of the app store. Having said that, I wonder if this is true for their iOS version or just Android. The privacy policy in their TOS is probably sufficiently vague to pass legal muster.[2] [1] On iOS go to Settings > Location Services > MoviePass [2] "we ask you to supply us with personal information so that we can provide, enhance and personalize our services and marketing efforts" https://www.moviepass.com/privacy/ https://www.moviepass.com/privacy/
- bobbles 9y ago"be able to use the app to get tickets and the theaters." is this simply a typo that should be "and TO the theatres"? That would make sense if it actually gave you directions to get there at least...
- taurath 9y agoThis is why a company "privacy policy" doesn't mean anything - they can change it with no warning or just plain lie about it. The only purpose is to placate their users.
- Silhouette 9y agoMaybe that's true in say the US, or some states in the US, but it isn't true everywhere. The EU is probably the biggest counterexample, with relatively strong privacy and data protection rules already, and almost draconian new rules for organisations that are working with personal data coming into effect later this year with the GDPR. A privacy policy is a part of the rules there, and misleading with one could get you in trouble with the regulators if someone complained.
- taurath 9y agoGiven the state of data management throughout the US and the world, I welcome some draconian rules if they actually protect people's data.
- 0xmohit 9y agoHasn't it been demonstrated that apps can track user location even without requesting location or WiFi access? Android apps can track a user's location and glean potentially private, personal information – such as where you work or live – just by monitoring the internal sensors. More importantly, they can do this without ever needing access to a device's GPS or Wi-Fi permissions. Source: Are your apps secretly stalking you? Android phones can be used to track you without permission [1] [1] https://www.wired.co.uk/article/android-apps-can-track-you-without-using-gps-or-wi-fi https://www.wired.co.uk/article/android-apps-can-track-you-w...
- erikb 9y agoNot too tough. I guess "in front of cinema" in both occasions.
- JazCE 9y agoIn the UK we have a chain of cinemas called Cineworld, they have a card that allows you to go to any movie, any time, for a 12 month sub of £17.90 a month. I'm practically always at the movies with this card. Between this, netflix and my parents sky account, it's rare that i'll miss a movie for the year. I'm surprised the USA movie chains haven't aped this (or even that Cineworld wasn't aping the USA chains).
- mirchibajji 9y agoAnother happy Unlimited subscriber here. Odeon also started a similar one called limitless
- Feniks 9y agoI never understood the concept behind this app anyway. You save money with tickets but are supposed to buy more overpriced food in the theatre? Thats not how you save money. Must be an American thing.
- nickster 9y agoYou don't have to buy any food.
- awad 9y agoiOS explicitly lets me give location access to an app only when it is open. I was under the impression that it's a literal definition and that apps can't track me in the background. Is this a mistaken view?
- trisimix 9y agoWhat a dumbass
- thomzi12 9y agoI don't get the outrage over this -- haven't Uber and Lyft and Google been doing this for years?
- auggierose 9y agoNever heard of MoviePass before (or are they connected to these strange Arnold Schwarzenegger meercats commercials)? It seems cinemas are doing this already by themselves, for example Cineworld with its Cineworld Unlimited program for about £200 a year.
- saudioger 9y agoOf course it does, why wouldn't it. The only thing preventing most companies from doing this to you is their ability manage the data effectively enough to turn a profit. Pure capitalism.
- CodeSheikh 9y agoThey can't be collecting data continuously if the location privacy setting is set to "While Using the App" on iOs. I remember Uber removed "While Using the App" option and provided only "Never" and "Always" options. And they got a lot of heat because of that.
- Taylor_OD 9y agoTheir CS is very poor. The app, even the updated one, doesnt work very well and will sign you out randomly. You're allowed to check into sold out movies. They got rid of the largest supported AMC theaters. The company has so many downsides now. Before I was telling everyone to sign up now I'm talking about all this type of stuff.