10 ms·
I think this shows that a technical solution trumps social solutions. If Australia had relied on telling children not to have unprotected sex, the HPV rate woul
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I think this shows that a technical solution trumps social solutions. If Australia had relied on telling children not to have unprotected sex, the HPV rate would not have moved much. Now, a simple vaccine is eradicating cervical HPV.
Malthus made a big deal how people should have fewer children and the population still grew. With the invention of safe, effective, convenient birth control, world population levels are stabilizing, and even starting to shrink in developed countries.
We need more "fire and forget" solutions. If we want to save our environment and slow down global warming, we need solutions that at most require people to do something relatively painless 1 time. Anything that relies of persuading humans to change their long term behavior is doomed to failure.
- mabbo 9y agoJeff Bezos semi-famously worded this as "Good intentions don't work- mechanisms do".
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>We need more "fire and forget" solutions. If we want to save our environment and slow down global warming, we need solutions that at most require people to do something relatively painless 1 time. Yeah, make sure to let the world know when you figure out what that solution is, because it will win you Nobel Prizes in multiple categories.
- rz2k 9y agoIt has always seemed like Malthus simply made the mistake that a logistic function looks a lot like an exponential function early on during a transition to a new equilibrium. Maybe he was saying that a decrease in fertility had to be an explicit goal, without realizing that decreases in fertility could be a side effect of other social developments.
- danieltillett 9y agoMalthus was not wrong at all, we just got lucky in that we were able to grow production faster than the population. The reason he said fertility had to be an explicit goal is he lived before we learned how to grow the economy faster than the population. I guess you could blame him for not seeing the industrial revolution coming, but given nobody else at the time did either I think it is a little harsh.
- rz2k 9y agoI think it would be more accurate to say that human population growth rate has never been exponential and was never going to be, than to say that production has grown at a faster exponential rate. Malthus has historically been excused with "just wait and see" explanations about his ideas, but no one seems able to say what is the kernel of truth in his theory or framework remains after you wipe away the details that were based on misunderstandings about his own time or about the actual dynamics of population growth. For instance he paid almost no attention whatsoever to mortality rates or the disposition of ages within a population and their effect on growth rates. He also paid no attention to the relative fertility of families with different levels of wealth identified by Adam Smith long before him. One way to summarize his work is that people's biological capacity to reproduce exceeds their physical capacity to increase the food supply, and that food supply is the ultimate constraint on human population that will be hit without other active constraints on population growth. Of course humans have the ability to grow faster than their conditions support, or they would not be able to grow when conditions improved, or recover from traumas to a population. But they also have the capacity to not reproduce, and not replace people as quickly as they are dying. It seems like a real leap of faith, to claim that people can only be actively constrained in their fertility, since there hasn't been any evidence that people only limit family size when actively compelled to. It is also strange to say that if there is no other limit on population growth, food will limit population growth. That's like arbitrarily stating that the only limit on fire is fuel, or that the only limit on fire is oxygen, or temperature. Population growth is a function with many inputs, and populations would approach some equilibrium even if food was hypothetically limitless. Maybe the excuse is that food is just a metaphor for the basket of all resources that people need, and that it can still be argued that populations without active constraints on growth increase exponentially until they inevitably result in famine, plague or war to decrease their numbers. What human populations work that way? They tend to ebb and flow in size around an equilibrium, then with a technological advance or environmental improvement they shift from one equilibrium to another at an increasing rate then a decreasing rate, just like a logistic function. Even with a collapse of a civilization the numbers decline like a logistic function. The curve might be steep, but it starts slowly, decreasing faster and faster then more slowly again as it gets close to zero.
- Jedd 9y ago> I think this shows that a technical solution trumps social solutions. If Australia had relied on telling children not to have unprotected sex, the HPV rate would not have moved much. Now, a simple vaccine is eradicating cervical HPV. We know telling people to not have sex doesn't work (this is what most people hear, and for many young people is functionally the same, as don't have unprotected sex). We have HSV, high teenage pregnancy rates, etc in countries that have pushed those approaches as would-be solutions. Taking a very specific case of trying to suppress young human sex drive with words, and extrapolating that to the general case around technical hacks versus knowledge and informed decision making is a bit disingenuous. And 'simple' vaccine? We just last week got rid of the deputy Prime Minister who, at the time this was being debated (debated!) claimed that the proverbial 'some people' didn't like the idea of giving their twelve year old daughters a licence to be promiscuous. I shit thee nay.
- andrewstuart 9y ago>> licence to be promiscuous From Barnaby Joyce? Ahem.
- thiagocsf 9y agoThis Hitchens quote is so relevant right now: “Whenever I hear some bigmouth in Washington or the Christian heartland banging on about the evils of sodomy or whatever, I mentally enter his name in my notebook and contentedly set my watch. Sooner rather than later, he will be discovered down on his weary and well-worn old knees in some dreary motel or latrine, with an expired Visa card, having tried to pay well over the odds to be peed upon by some Apache transvestite.”
- Intermernet 9y agoYep, So ironic I want to cry. For anyone not from Australia who doesn't understand this, feel free to Google his name for a timeline of world-class hypocrisy. Still, why are we discussing his personal life and not his abysmal policy decisions?
- 9y ago
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoOr in other words solutions that are applied have a possibility of working. The solution of no genital contact with others isn't inferior, it wasn't applied. I find it interesting that, AFAIA HPV is a sexually transmitted disease but that, certainly in the UK, healthcare professionals seemingly lie (by omission at least) in order to further vaccination. Also, that insistence on screening seems likely to have been a major cause of widespread infection (eg https://obpmedical.com/resource-center/blog/non-sexual-transmission-of-hpv-101-what-you-need-to-know/ https://obpmedical.com/resource-center/blog/non-sexual-trans...), though I've never heard of this from a major news outlet? It amazes me that until 2016 it seems no-one bother to check that sterilised reusable gynaecological instruments were actually sterile, mind-blowing.
- madeofpalk 9y ago> but that, certainly in the UK, healthcare professionals seemingly lie (by omission at least) in order to further vaccination. I mean, you can't just leave a claim like that dangling. A source would be ideal, but at least explain the claim of what the lie is would be nice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- shaki-dora 9y agoThe US has thankfully provided us with more data on the effectiveness of abstinence only education than we could ever need. Just check the data on teenage pregnancies in the Deep South.
- RobAley 9y agoYou may get less downvotes if : - you link to peer reviewed science, rather than the manufacturer of devices who have reasons to profit from misleading information (hint : there's a reason you haven't heard about it from major news outlets). - you back up inflammatory statements (like "healthcare professionals seemingly lie (by omission at least) in order to further vaccination.") with some evidence, particularly where the common narrative disagrees with your statement. - You avoid misleading arguments ("The solution of no genital contact with others isn't inferior, it wasn't applied" - this is misleading, many have attempted to apply it, it's their attempts that have failed).
- ant6n 9y agoImmunizing every child seems like a social solution to me.
- zasz 9y agoMaking the vaccine free is a social solution. Getting people to subsidize the vaccine is inherently political.
- barry-cotter 9y ago> Malthus made a big deal how people should have fewer children and the population still grew. The demographic transition long predates the pill. The pattern was marry early, have children all through marriage, marry late, have children all through marriage, marry late, show obvious signs of controlling fertility. The first definite case of the demographic transition is 1800s France. And while Malthus was right as a historian, he was wrong as a futurist. Things have been getting better worldwide since the Industrial Revolution even as population increased.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> The pattern was marry early, have children all through marriage, marry late, have children all through marriage, marry late, show obvious signs of controlling fertility. Western Europe hasn't married early for hundreds and hundreds of years, since long, long before the demographic transition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_European_marriage_pattern https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_European_marriage_patt...
- EggsOnToast 9y agoI don't know that your conclusion really follows. Technical progress rarely happens in completely isolation form social mechanics. Things like government funding for research, subsidies for deploying or developing particular renewable energy technologies, and even the environment in which private innovative companies operate are entirely influenced by the government which in turn is ultimately influenced by social action. You're discussing a very particular kind of social action.
- elifive 9y agoI learn great many things in this forum. If you find my comment below as an effort of trolling, it is not. I wanted to ask this question every time I see this idea of > how vaccines and tech are decreasing population. If it is statistically and empirically true, then it probably is true.If people smarter than me by any measure agree with it, then it probably is true after,all. That said: I don't doubt that, it works in a first world nation. But third world , at least India is a different thing, people like to have two kids around here, because it looks whole some. It doesn't matter what the financial situation is , people like to have at least two kids in India(I don't have any metric for it,just a casual observation). What if people see their kids don't die out of diseases and could take food ,education,electricity,clean water and clean air and a good public transport for granted and now want to make more babies? The decrease of population if you pump these resources seems counter intuitive to me. I am not suggesting if Bill Gates should pull out of Africa, I am just not getting the logic here.
- te_chris 9y agoI don't have stats for this, but I don't think it's families with 2 kids that are causing a population explosion. That's literally just an even replacement for the parents (assuming 2 people who don't remarry before death).
- brownbat 9y agoHans Rosling tackles that question better than anyone in What Stops Population Growth: https://youtu.be/ZnexjTCBksw https://youtu.be/ZnexjTCBksw His first TED talk on the best data you've ever seen is also worth watching. It's an important question, but our understanding of what causes population spikes, and how people respond to improved wealth and health in a country, can make us a little more optimistic.
- pjc50 9y agoIt definitely works that way in poor countries; the "poster child" is right next to India in Bangladesh: https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21565617-bangladesh-has-dysfunctional-politics-and-stunted-private-sector-yet-it-has-been-surprisingly https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21565617-bangladesh-... It turns out that educated women with more other options almost always want to have fewer children. This should not be surprising; they don't call childbirth "labour" for nothing.
- DrScump 9y agoIf Australia had relied on telling children not to have unprotected sex, the HPV rate would not have moved much. But HPV is only one of many infections that use unprotected sex as a vector. The one danger of this kind of policy-making is giving children an illusion of being protected from adverse effects of unprotected sex in general without combining it with advocacy of protection.
- olliej 9y agoYou're right -- but every single study has shown that teaching sex ed properly (covering safe sex, how STDs actually transmit rather than fear mongering) is the most reliable way of reducing STDs, unwanted pregnancy, abortions (largely due to the reduction in unwanted pregnancy), sex abuse, ... The policy of "teach abstinence" fails people much more so than vaccinating against a single vector.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI think this is a key point. To say "X has failed" when the truth is "X was done wrong / badly and it failed." While a vaccine might not be a license to _____, it also fails to address education, personal responsibility, etc. Sure there are health benefits but if everyone gets a trophy so to speak when and how will the lack of learning Y manifest itself later? That is, give the vaccine. Sure. But don't be so naive to think that education in some form isn't still necessary. Furthermore, Mother Nature is clever and crafty. It's only a matter of time, now that protection is less necessary, before she comes up with something new. I'm not a Luddite. But there are two sides to every advance, and we almost always igrore the unintended consequences until it's too late.
- shaki-dora 9y agoAnd yet we’re surrounded by complex social solutions to large problems: democracy, money, rule of law, families, religion, insurance, traffic lights, meat inspectors, patents, contracts, etc etc The fact that Australia is close to achieving this, while many other countries are far off, also points at social factors playing a role. The vaccine works the same everywhere.
- olliej 9y agoactually the vaccine doesn't -- the standard HPV vaccine in the US for instance is not effective for the strains of HPV common in black people.
- bornonline1 9y agoAll of these work because of language in the first place. It's a technology.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]