4 ms·
It's actually off-the-shelf tech now. I've been in a number of supermarkets where they use this to beam ads at you while standing in line for the checkout. (All
by jerf 9y ago
It's actually off-the-shelf tech now. I've been in a number of supermarkets where they use this to beam ads at you while standing in line for the checkout. (All of which have since stopped doing it, for what it's worth. YMMV.)
There was some hope for a while that this might turn out to be a way to hack sound so that you could produce a flat speaker full of those tiny ultrasonic speakers, and then use non-linear interference to produce deep, booming bass sounds, without having to have the much-larger speakers you need today for that to work correctly. Unfortunately, either nobody could crack the technique, or it's simply impossible, because the real speakers that emerged are quite tinny. Here's a commercial offering, where they're only willing to promise down to 150Hz in the text: http://ultrasonic-audio.com/acouspade-technical-specification/ http://ultrasonic-audio.com/acouspade-technical-specificatio... "The sound is of high-quality, with low noise and great frequency response, which includes authentic reproduction of bass notes and frequencies as low as 150 Hz." Which, if accurate, is better than the speakers I've heard, but still a long ways from "thumping bass" coming out of a square that could be hung on the wall as casually as a picture frame.
- eveningcoffee 9y ago>I've been in a number of supermarkets where they use this to beam ads at you while standing in line for the checkout. This is more than creepy. It should be made illegal along with using cameras for anything else than security.
- jerf 9y agoI would have thrown a bigger fuss if they didn't disappear as quickly as they did. I assume other people threw a fuss for me, for which I thank them, whoever they are. The f'ing stupid thing is that the checkout line is already one big ad. It advertises all the things that the stores have already figured out you're likely to buy at the end of a shopping trip; candy, drinks, SD cards (dunno why but it's pretty consistent), etc. It is the most effective possible ad, since everything it is advertising is literally within arm's reach for immediate purchase. You'd think that would be enough!
- c22 9y agoI think the SD cards might be more about discouraging shoplifting of a small easily liquidable good.
- IntronExon 9y agoWhat we really need are highly tunable and directional EMP generators, which can be easily concealed. You could “solve” everything from annoying drones, to people listening to Peppa a pig on their iPads, through the speaker. Of course you could also fry a car’s ECU, but um, swings and roundabouts right?
- flukus 9y agoIf you think that's creepy, imagine it with good voice synthesis along with a voice profile of yourself. I wonder if they could get close to making it sound like your internal monologue saying "I should buy that impulse item in front of me"?
- vectorEQ 9y agorecent new improvements in voice synthesis could make this happen soon enough tbh.., capture you speaking in the super market, filter your voice out, then beam that shit in. i like the idea :D i can already see us all comming home... why the fk did i buy this milk, why do i keep drinking this milk.. wtf :D (paranoia 1.0) wonderful world!
- sneak 9y agoWhy should the supermarket playing any sort of music on any sort of speakers they want inside of their own building on private property be made illegal? Who is it harming? Is your association with the supermarket not entirely voluntary?
- wruza 9y agoI think this is a subject of 'customers rights' or something like that, depending on the country. You cannot call yourself a store and do whatever you want inside it because it is yours. Maybe this music/ad is legal (or legally uncovered) for now, but customers are definitely the source of the entire business and have a right to have rights.
- amelius 9y agoYou could produce that deep bass if you knew exactly where the listeners are. Throwing some computer vision/ML in the mix could solve the problem. PS: It can't be patented now, cause I mentioned it on HN first :)
- ssivark 9y agoHaha! What if we had a website where people could post such ideas and discuss them? The process of discussing and refining an idea would make it un-patentable? That would be an interesting forum for geeks / problem solvers AND would kill stupid/obvious patents as a side effect, and act as a repository of prior art! Since such discussions might articulate at least the broad ideas (even if they don’t get to a specific implementation) this might discourage at least overly broad patents. PS: Did I just make this idea un-patentable by anyone else? :D
- garmaine 9y agoUnfortunately that is now how patents work.
- jerf 9y ago"You could produce that deep bass if you knew exactly where the listeners are." I'm unsure what you are trying to say. The problem with deep bass, as far as I know, is not that it only works in certain places; it is that it can't do it at all. See the frequency response chart in the page I linked, which I suspect if anything is probably overselling its bass capabilities. As I said, I don't know if it's merely that nobody has cracked the problem, if it is somehow fundamentally impossible with this technique, or I'll add a third one here, if it's possible but impractical (i.e., "requires a 100x larger piezoelectric array" or something). If you've really never heard one, they have a very characteristic tinny sound. Usually when you have a conventional tinny speaker, the speaker has a relatively narrow range and is missing both the low and the high ranges. With the ultrasonic speakers, the bass is entirely gone, but the response up through the higher frequencies is pristine pretty much all the way up the human range. So you get voices with no bass at all, but that are extremely, extremely clear and easy to understand because all the higher harmonics are intact, if not outright emphasized. Very distinctive sound, even if you don't notice the highly directional and sharp sound immediately the acoustic signature is unmistakable.