10 ms·
Australia could become first country to eradicate cervical cancer
- otakucode 9y agoSure they might eradicate cerival cancer - but at what cost? Parents having to deal with the fact that their kids just might not be reduced to terrified neurotic messes when it comes to their own sexuality! Certainly that might be OK in some nations, but not in the USA. Our neurosis, especially when it comes to this, is far more important than any reduction in suffering or saved lives such vaccines might promise. (This comment has been sarcasm, but bears the unsaid words believed by the groups in the US who oppose these vaccines because they are terrified adolescents might have healthy active sex lives.)
- coldnose 9y agoThat's a pretty clickbaity title. It's really an article about increasing HPV vaccination and plummeting cervical cancer rates. But I'm skeptical that you can ever "eradicate" cancer as a form of disease, even a particular type of cancer.
- jacobkg 9y agoI believe they are discussing eradication of the HPV virus, which the article states causes 99.9% of cervical cancer. We do have proof of humanity once before successfully eradicating a virus, namely smallpox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Eradication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Eradication
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoAn interesting titbit: >In 2017, Canadian scientists recreated an extinct horse pox virus to demonstrate that the smallpox virus can be recreated in a small lab at a cost of about $100,000, by a team of scientists without specialist knowledge. This makes the retention controversy moot since the virus can be easily recreated even if all samples are destroyed. //
- Analemma_ 9y agoThey're talking about eradicating all reservoirs of HPV, akin to what several countries have successfully done with rabies. The headline is perfectly accurate.
- coldnose 9y agoAs of the time of writing, the headline was, "Australia could become first country to eradicate cervical cancer" not, "... eradicate HPV". I'm skeptical a form of cancer can ever really be "eradicated".
- stochastic_monk 9y agoYou’re right. It could have been more nuanced about the HPV eradication. Still, if only 1/1000 cervical cancers have other etiologies, that does take them out of the most common cancers and make them rare. As a broad public health concern, it will be pretty close to eradicated. And yes, no cancer can be eradicated, ever. Life finds a way.
- maxerickson 9y ago0.1% is pretty good as far as headline exaggerations go.
- astura 9y agoHPV can actually cause other cancers besides just cervical. https://www.cdc.gov/hpv/parents/cancer.html https://www.cdc.gov/hpv/parents/cancer.html >HPV cancers include cancer of the cervix, vulva, vagina, penis, or anus. HPV infection can also cause cancer in the back of the throat, including the base of the tongue and tonsils (called oropharyngeal cancer).
- tialaramex 9y agoBecause we tend to classify cancers by which organ was affected, _technically_ eradicating cervical cancer isn't possible without getting rid of the cervix (which you can technically do, but it's major surgery). However, practically all cervical cancer is caused by HPV. Without HPV cervical cancer would be extremely rare, because it's going to need several quite uncommon random events to coincide, the virus is "deliberately" meddling with the copying mechanics inside cells, that's how a virus propagates, without a virus those changes have to happen entirely by accident, maybe a series of cosmic rays. So it's not _that_ hyperbolic to say this eradicates the cancer itself.
- ejstronge 9y agoIt does sound too good to be true. But in this case, it is true. HPV is probably the best example that exists of an infection being linked practically 1:1 to a cancer. See more information here[1]. If you have knowledge of any other significant sources of cervical cancer, please share them. 1. https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cervical-cancer.html https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cervical-cancer.html
- jacobkg 9y agoThis is amazing! "As a result, the HPV rate among women aged 18 to 24 dropped from 22.7% to 1.1% between 2005 and 2015."
- masonic 9y agoNot amazing at all to me, considering that they are completely different populations. The youngest subject at the start of that window dropped out of that population 7 years ago (3 years before the last survey). The figure doesn't count cures, or even reduced transmissions, among the original subjects. That said, I find the quoted statistic suspect. First of all, the first vaccine wasn't even licensed until 2006, and there wasn't a vaccine that addressed more than 4 of the cancer-causing subtypes until 2014[0]. Second, they only targeted girls of age 12-13 (although they provided free vaccinations on manual request through age 19), leaving out girls in the upper 70% of the age range altogether from the survey population. So, I don't take those numbers at face value, although I don't debate the safety or efficacy of these particular vaccines, being genetics-based. It's the profiteering by the planned-obsolescence model of the manufacturers that bothers me. If you're a parent and you followed the public-health experts' recommendations, and you wanted the full (nonavalent vaccine) functionality, you would have given a three-injection treatment of the bivalent spanning 6 months, then (later) a three-injection treatment of the quarivalent spanning 6 more months, then another cycle of the nonavalent vaccine... giving the manufacturers a lot of money out of your public health budget and a proof-of-concept for the drug companies to do this in lots of other vaccines and drugs in the future. [0] http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/255353/1/WER9219.pdf?ua=1 http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/255353/1/WER9219.pd... Human papillomavirus vaccines: WHO position paper, May 2017
- Lewton 9y ago> That said, I find the quoted statistic suspect. First of all, the first vaccine wasn't even licensed until 2006, and there wasn't a vaccine that addressed more than 4 of the cancer-causing subtypes until 2014[0]. Second, they only targeted girls of age 12-13 (although they provided free vaccinations on manual request through age 19), leaving out girls in the upper 70% of the age range altogether from the survey population. I'm guessing herd immunity kicked in at some point between 2005 and 2015
- jimjimjim 9y agoThis is fantastic. I have a friend that recently had a cervical cancer scare (reasonably small op to remove some worrying cells). When someone you know gets something like this you tend to gather a lot of info about it. And in this case it is remarkable how closely linked it is to a single cause (hpv)
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoI think this shows that a technical solution trumps social solutions. If Australia had relied on telling children not to have unprotected sex, the HPV rate would not have moved much. Now, a simple vaccine is eradicating cervical HPV. Malthus made a big deal how people should have fewer children and the population still grew. With the invention of safe, effective, convenient birth control, world population levels are stabilizing, and even starting to shrink in developed countries. We need more "fire and forget" solutions. If we want to save our environment and slow down global warming, we need solutions that at most require people to do something relatively painless 1 time. Anything that relies of persuading humans to change their long term behavior is doomed to failure.
- mabbo 9y agoJeff Bezos semi-famously worded this as "Good intentions don't work- mechanisms do".
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>We need more "fire and forget" solutions. If we want to save our environment and slow down global warming, we need solutions that at most require people to do something relatively painless 1 time. Yeah, make sure to let the world know when you figure out what that solution is, because it will win you Nobel Prizes in multiple categories.
- rz2k 9y agoIt has always seemed like Malthus simply made the mistake that a logistic function looks a lot like an exponential function early on during a transition to a new equilibrium. Maybe he was saying that a decrease in fertility had to be an explicit goal, without realizing that decreases in fertility could be a side effect of other social developments.
- danieltillett 9y agoMalthus was not wrong at all, we just got lucky in that we were able to grow production faster than the population. The reason he said fertility had to be an explicit goal is he lived before we learned how to grow the economy faster than the population. I guess you could blame him for not seeing the industrial revolution coming, but given nobody else at the time did either I think it is a little harsh.
- tedsanders 9y agoI'm confused. Maybe a dozen strains of HPV cause cancer.[1] Only two are covered by Gardisil (~70% of cancers), and seven are covered by Gardisil 9 (~90% of cancers).[2] Therefore, with a vaccine that only vaccinates against ~90% of HPV cancers, how can we hope to eradicate cervical cancer? Additional reading: [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_papillomavirus_infection#Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_papillomavirus_infection... [2] https://arstechnica.com/science/2015/02/new-hpv-vaccine-is-effective-against-9-strains-of-the-virus/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2015/02/new-hpv-vaccine-is-e... [3] https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/infectious-agents/hpv-fact-sheet https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/i...
- stmfreak 9y agoThis is as much a marketing press release as an interim report on the efficacy of HPV vaccinations. For the points you mention as well as the 70+ lifespan ahead of vaccine recipients.
- pm90 9y ago90% is still a ginormous reduction over 0%. And as with most communicable diseases, once their incidence falls below a certain threshold, they fail to spread in effective numbers to keep themselves alive.
- neaden 9y agoYou're misunderstanding though, it only works on certain strains of HPV, for the unaffected strains we wouldn't expect a reduction in incidence. You are thinking of Herd Immunity, which is what allows for a disease to be wiped out and protects unvaccinated/immunocompromised individuals in a population.
- sjwright 9y agoThe article indicates that the vaccine provides a minimum of 50% reduction in all variants of HPV.
- caio1982 9y agoJust a sidenote from the other side of the world: Brazil has been offering free HPV vaccines for girls under 15 for a while and since last year to all boys at 12; they plane to have it available to both sexes between 9 and 15 in the next couple of years. It is estimated that nearly half of young people (16-25 years of age) have some form of the HPV in the country. I don't have any results numbers to share or source from now, however, my apologies. Let's hope Australia is not the only country to do that though!
- dorfsmay 9y agoSame (possibly different ages) in Canada (Alberta at least), it's not mandatory, but offered in school, and most people go with it.
- ShorsHammer 9y agoAustralian parents lose their childs tax benefits if they refuse vaccination, it's an enormous incentive (thousands per year) for the average wage earner. The article seems to not mention this. Sadly it still doesn't stop entire communities of well-off antivaxxers forming, these particular areas are now ravaged by whooping cough outbreaks, a disease that was almost eliminated ten years ago.
- joncrane 9y agoSo basically, only people that are rich AND dumb fall though the cracks? So what percentage are we talking? Single digits, I hope.
- chris_wot 9y agoConsiderable numbers of parents in wealthy suburbs have not vaccinated their children: https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/melbournes-antivaccination-hot-spots-rich-suburbs-have-low-immunisation-rates-20151214-glmuv0.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/melbournes-antiv... The next pressure point will be that if parents don’t vaccinate their children, child-care centres will be forced to refuse to take children. This will actually work because the vast majority of these wealthy suburbs have both parents working, and they must use child care.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Paraesthetic 9y agoYou bet your skippy we're gonna eradicate it
- Gatsky 9y agoWhen HPV vaccination in Australia was first being considered, there was a bit of debate - of course it works best if given prior to any sexual activity, which meant telling parents of young girls you were vaccinating their child against a sexually transmitted disease (eg see [1] for typical concerns). The policy makers were undeterred, and strong advocacy from doctors and scientists pushed things forward. The vaccine was partially developed in Australia which also helped. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2016/jan/11/why-is-there-opposition-hpv-vaccine-cervical-cancer https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2016/jan/11/why-is-...
- rabboRubble 9y ago>... works best if given prior to any sexual activity,... Not entirely correct. The HPV vaccine works best in the young for the best immune response. If I were a 40 year old virgin and wanted the shot, the vaccine probably wouldn't be effect as my immune system would not respond. Yes the shot should be administered before sexual activity, and it just happens the best immune response happens in these youngish teenage years, far earlier than a lot of parents are comfortable.
- Gatsky 9y agoBy 'works best' I'm talking about preventing HPV infection, so giving it before one encounters HPV is pretty important.
- andyjohnson0 9y agoI agree. But it is worth noting that there are multiple types of HPV and an initial infection may be with one not targeted by the vaccine. So receiving the vaccine after that may still provide protection against subsequent infections.
- muriithi 9y agoGood progress, while in Kenya a national roll-out was postponed because of high global demand for the vaccine. https://www.nation.co.ke/news/Demand-for-cervical-cancer-vaccine-grows/1056-4309132-jyirbfz/index.html https://www.nation.co.ke/news/Demand-for-cervical-cancer-vac...