3 ms·
You can't put a figure on it. The system interfaces with every area of life, and with capitalism. Western Capitalism says the amount spent on healthcare should
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
You can't put a figure on it.
The system interfaces with every area of life, and with capitalism. Western Capitalism says the amount spent on healthcare should grow until all available money becomes profit for the Capitalists.
Meanwhile there's always some new area of life that impacts health - spend on sport, then on encouraging sport by paying for teachers, then on improving colleges where the teachers train, ... before you know it the NHS is funding a deep mine in Siberia because it mines the metals that make the earphones used in mp3 players by students training to be teachers, to encourage them to teach more sport to children so that when those children grow up they'll need less heart bypass surgery.
Meanwhile the Siberian mine leads to contaminants in the ocean that cause excess cost to all health regimes around the world ...
Health encompasses all parts of life, it needs selfless, holistic, planet-wide approach. You could spend £150 Trillion in health and still find more areas of spending to address.
- justinmk 9y ago> Meanwhile there's always some new area of life that impacts health - spend on sport, then on encouraging sport by paying for teachers, then on improving colleges where the teachers train, ... before you know it the NHS is funding a deep mine in Siberia In other words, central planning doesn't work[1]. NHS was a "special case" that tends towards the general case, as is the tendency of all untouchable mandates. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- DanBC 9y agoThe NHS (in England) hasn't been centrally planned for some time now. That's what CCGs are for. Also, a bunch of stuff (drug and alcohol services, weight loss, smoking cessation, suicide prevention, sexual health, etc etc) isn't even NHS any more, and is part of Public Health which is part of local authorities.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI'd go with "you can't centrally plan health within a system of Western Capitalism". Look at the trains in the UK - government was running one major line at a large profit, but they prop up the system as a whole with tax monies, why? It certainly seems like trains (maybe transport) could be centrally planned if you define the limits of the sector carefully.