5 ms·
Some of that depends on how you want to define commonly. White and asian Americans have a near 40% chance of becoming millionaires with a graduate level educati
by adventured 9y ago
Some of that depends on how you want to define commonly. White and asian Americans have a near 40% chance of becoming millionaires with a graduate level education.
Without a high school diploma, white Americans have a mere 1.7% chance of becoming a millionaire. A 20+ fold difference.
"What Are Your Odds of Becoming a Millionaire?"
https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-millionaire-odds/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-millionaire-odds/
"Bloomberg News asked economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis a question: Would it be possible to calculate the odds of being a millionaire for anyone in the U.S., based on age, education and race?"
"According to the sample, a black person’s odds of being a millionaire increase from less than 1 percent if he or she doesn't complete high school to 6.7 percent with a graduate degree. White Americans without a high school diploma start out with slightly better chances—1.7 percent—that rapidly improve with more school: A graduate-level education increases their probability of amassing a net worth greater than $1 million to 37 percent."
- nosefrog 9y agoThat's correlation, not necessarily causation.
- adventured 9y agoNo, it's very obvious causation. The variance is extreme, not subtle, and it shows dramatic improvement for all races. It moves upwards step by step with education attainment. Incomes similarly follow that path. Which is another way of saying, everything aligns. The income you can reach on average without a high school diploma, will radically implode your chances of ever being able to amass millionaire status. Need to save $50,000 to start a business? Good luck without a high school diploma. You're going to spend your life barely getting by, much less generating a surplus of savings. Want to become a millionaire via a mixture of 401k, company stock grants, savings, real-estate investment? You have a near zero shot at that without a high school diploma.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIt's correlation. The cause is rationed access to the cultural - never mind the economic - resources needed to get into a graduate program. Success after the program is an effect - and partly down to luck, as the SA article suggests. Of course you'll have problems if you don't have a high school diploma. But by the time you've failed to get your diploma, the chances are excellent that your access to resources will have been severely constrained and rationed for your entire life, even if you start off with exceptional talents.
- adventured 9y agoIt's cause. What you're referring to is the cause of education deprivation. That education deprivation is the cause of the far lower likelihood of reaching higher wealth status. A chain of things or events can - typically does - possess multiple causes along the pathing. A cause of a cause, is a legitimate, normal and required logical concept. Practically any outcome or condition you can name has a cause, which has a cause. Alternatively you'd have to claim that there can only be one cause in an entire chain of events. An absurd notion.
- abecedarius 9y agoIt can be causal and still be a wasteful signaling game. I think that to first order that's what's going on.
- misja111 9y agoThat doesn't prove causation. There can be many underlying causes that explain the success of educated people just as well. For instance, as already mentioned, it might be that kids that are smart or work hard tend to finish a higher education. It could also be that kids who are born in wealthier families do both get access to better education and get more opportunities afterwards because of their better network. That last possibility does a much better job at explaining what the Bloomberg article is about: the different chances of success based on the color of your skin. Black students that graduate still have only 6.7% chance of becoming millionaires comparing to 37% for white people.
- derivt 9y agoWhy is American capitalized and asian isn't?
- mywittyname 9y agoBecause white is the first word in that sentence.
- derivt 9y agoSorry, I am not a native English speaker, but I think it should be White Asian, do you say white americans? Also, Google accused in lawsuit of excluding white and Asian men in hiring to boost diversity https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2018/03/01/google-accused-lawsuit-excluding-white-and-asian-men-hiring-boost-diversity/387532002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2018/03/01/google-a...
- leereeves 9y ago> I think it should be White Asian, do you say white americans? We do say "White Americans", meaning Americans who are "white", which means people whose ancestors were Europeans (including Russia), or from Arabia, Persia, Afghanistan, North Africa, or some (but not all) other Muslim areas. Then "Asian" includes everyone else whose ancestors were from Asia: China, Japan, India, Vietnam, Korea, Indonesia, etc. When combined with nationality or geographical location, race is said first, so "White Asian" would mean someone living in Asia whose ancestors were European, most likely, though it's not a phrase I've heard.
- autokad 9y agoI am not great with grammar, however I think its always supposed to be capitalized. that being said, i dont read too much into it in a hn post. Its sort of random for me, depends how tired my fingers are to leave the home keys
- jcranmer 9y agoEnglish grammar generally follows the rule that proper nouns and derivations thereof are capitalized. So the proper way to write it would be white, black, Asian, Hispanic (also Latino/Latina), Native American (or Indian or Amerindian), Pacific Islander, etc. Note the difference between native American and Native American.
- jpadkins 9y ago> Without a high school diploma, What is the cause of not completing high school? what about lack of IQ. There is a hidden variable that causes both not passing high school and not being a millionaire.
- huehehue 9y agoI don't think it's as simple as that. Plenty of intelligent people don't finish high school for a number of reasons -- medical issues, problems at home, some simply drop out because they need to start working full-time to afford living. That's not to say that all of those people would have necessarily gone on to become millionaires, but it's really hard to improve your situation if you don't have that momentum.