5 ms·
People should check out the actual complaint [0]. It includes a lot of things the article doesn't including: A screenshot of an email from Allison Alogna to "T
by gpm 9y ago
People should check out the actual complaint [0]. It includes a lot of things the article doesn't including:
A screenshot of an email from Allison Alogna to "Team" stating
> Please continue with L3 candidates in process and only accept new L3 candidates that are from historically unrepresented groups.
Another stating in part
> And we should only consider L3s from our underrepresented groups.
It also tells us that this wasn't the first time the plaintiff had issues with his manager over this topic. He had the same issues with the previous manager, the previous manager was found by internally by Google to have retaliated against him for his complaints, and Allison Alogna was hired to replace that manager.
[0] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4391847-18-CIV-00442.html#document/p4/a407608 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4391847-18-CIV-00442...
- wheaties 9y agoThis definitely changes the tone of things. That's pure discrimination. It would be one thing to set quotas that favor a group, it's another to exclude any group at all. Sounds like someone above the manager is responsible for this and the manager is carrying out orders. You don't get a historic paper trail like that by not being told to continue on.
- masterleep 9y ago> It would be one thing to set quotas that favor a group, it's another to exclude any group at all. Both of those are illegal.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoAffirmative action is definitely not illegal, regardless of whether it should or shouldn’t be.
- ashelmire 9y agoAffirmative action literally means the opposite of what you think it means. It means that there will be efforts taken to ensure no discrimination in hiring on the basis of race, sex, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_11246 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_11246 etc
- mental1896 9y agoHow do you know what he thinks it means?
- ComputerGuru 9y agoThat’s a very selective and intellectually dishonest defense. That was the original law, then extended by Johnson and taken in a different direction altogether by future leadership. The current Department of Labor on affirmative action [0] clearly paints a very different picture that more accurately reflects the current meaning: For federal contractors and subcontractors, affirmative action must be taken by covered employers to recruit and advance qualified minorities, women, persons with disabilities, and covered veterans. And here’s the dictionary entry for “affirmative action:” efforts to make education and employment available to people who have traditionally been treated unfairly, for example because of their race or sex, by giving them some advantages over people who have traditionally been more powerful https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/affirmative-action?q=Affirmative+action https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/affir... [0]: https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/hiring/affirmativeact https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/hiring/affirmativeact
- hindsightRegret 9y agoNot for jobs, but for higher education it is in a few states already. So there is precedent.
- magnetic 9y ago> It would be one thing to set quotas that favor a group, it's another to exclude any group at all. Any sufficiently low quota is equivalent to exclusion (ie a quota of 1 is pretty much like a quota of 0, which really means "nobody"). The very notion of quota implies exclusion (of those who are "past the quota").
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoAnother interesting thing there is that it's only L3's, which (it seems) are juniors / new people; you could argue that that too is discriminatory and it enables the "white male" stereotype to remain in leading positions while the "grunt work" is done by underrepresented groups.
- greenshackle3 9y agoMy guess it that for more senior roles they do not have the luxury to be so selective.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- HelloNurse 9y agoApart from the difference between not hiring aspirants and driving away old employees, the metrics of diversity are probably based on pure head count, not on having quotas on important roles (which would also be unlikely to be satisfiable).
- sitkack 9y agoWhenever there is a panel discussion, it is always a bunch of dudes.
- 0xfeba 9y agoI don't understand how this didn't raise red flags from legal/HR. From the article: > In a statement, Google said [...] it has a "clear policy to hire candidates based on their merit, not their identity. At the same time, we unapologetically try to find a diverse pool of qualified candidates for open roles[...]" You can't have it both ways. You're either based solely on merit, or on merit and how non-male and non-white they are. Which is discrimination. EDIT: Sorry -- Finding pools in "diverse" areas is fine, but dropping resumes in the bin when they are not "diverse" enough is not. I hate that "diversity" has been politicized like this and I feel like it's one of the failings of the left's identity politics bent that will come back to bite them. Getting minorities in your company to win some diversity points is great, but missing the actual benefit to society. The goal should be, for society, to equally encourage minorities to get STEM degrees and jobs so that companies don't have to play this stupid "look how diverse we are!" game. And it won't happen overnight. Companies should just hire on merit[1]; be completely blind to their workforce's background. They should enforce this neutrality like they enforce neutrality toward anyone's religion. "I don't care as long as you can do your job". If they are concerned about monoculture, then advertise and advocate in areas that they think will improve that. But just leave hiring to merit. Eventually diversity will trickle-up. It shouldn't just be up to companies. EDIT [1]: Yes, merit can be an ambiguous term. And I should have also stated they can hire based on "fit", which is another ambiguous term. But sorry, if your devote beliefs restrict you from using any electronic devices, then no, you aren't getting the web developer job. It's not a good "fit".
- chuckcode 9y agoCompletely agree about missing the actual benefit to society of focusing on better education and opportunities for all. Amazing how quickly things can go off the rails when you start evaluating middle management off some metric like "number of diversity hires" which seems like a good idea but then backfires into something ridiculous like this. I hope this sets a fire under Google's management to keep better track of HR
- macintux 9y agoGood luck defining and hiring purely on merit. Good luck separating merit from unconscious biases related to where you've seen merit previously. And typically most of what you've seen previously is people like you. I've seen plenty of excellent computer engineers who started out as physics majors, or astronomers, or music majors...but they were universally white men (mostly because I've only ever been around white men in this business). If a black woman came to me with a background in East Asian linguistics, would I naturally associate her with the success stories I've seen, or would I think she's unqualified and needs to get more experience elsewhere? I suspect the latter.
- ashelmire 9y agoYeesh. Documentation of quotas and racial/gender discrimination in hiring. This is as clear-cut as it gets.
- Eridrus 9y agoThanks for finding this, this seems different than what the article alleges. This actually seems more likely, since it lines up with what Google has said previously - that they do not alter the hiring bar for anyone, i.e. that interview/hiring committee is independent, but they do ask recruiters to focus on finding diverse candidates, and they have also said they coach diverse candidates about what to expect from interviews. I think how this will play out depends on whether this applied to all recruiters in the company/all recruiters filling a set of specific roles, and/or if non-diverse candidates could still apply to Google and get into the funnel.