19 ms·
How Inmates Play Tabletop RPGs in Prisons Where Dice Are Contraband
- jfries 9y agoI was waiting for the article to mention using those 6 sided pencil stubs in the first image as dice. Seems like a good way to disguise a die.
- scrumper 9y agoWe used these at school. We punched indentations in the sides using a compass point. Obviously that isn't going to work in prison, but you could make marks with a fingernail easily enough. (Of interest, note how the pencil is short in the photo - makes it harder to use as a shank.)
- walshemj 9y agoSurprised that prisons ban dice but not cards which can be used to substitute for dice. Interestingly some of the early board games used spinners as dice where seen as sinful, normally by the more hard core protestants.
- aerotwelve 9y agoI'm ready to take the hit for asking a very stupid question: why are dice considered contraband? Wouldn't it make more sense to allow inmates access to dice and real spinners? They're human beings with brains. Wouldn't correction officers prefer that they spent their time playing games instead of thinking of ways to escape or "cause trouble"?
- vkou 9y agoBecause gambling is a moral failing, and prison is supposed to give inmates time to reflect on their moral failings.
- walshemj 9y agoNot sure my "scary" great great uncle who was an off course book maker in brumigum pre ww2 would agree with you Then again not every one has quite the same take on peaky Blinders as I do ;-)
- politician 9y agoThe prisons want to ban gambling and currency counters (coins, chips, etc) in order to disrupt the rise of debt-based gang activity. "The house always wins" turns a prison into an organized structure of debtors and owners fairly rapidly, I'd imagine. And you can't fault the far fewer security guards from wanting to avoid a face-off with a unified enemy.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The prisons want to ban gambling and currency counters (coins, chips, etc) in order to disrupt the rise of debt-based gang activity. Well, also because in most states gambling is itself (entirely or, at least, without a whole lot of bureaucratic compliance stuff) illegal, and it would be very odd to reverse that prohibition in prisons.
- pessimizer 9y agoWell, there's no house in non-casino gambling; it's just in the nature of gambling that some people will lose and some people will win, and some people will borrow money to continue to play when they shouldn't. The only mechanism to force repayment of loans without government is violence or monopoly.
- nybble41 9y agoThe only mechanism to force repayment of loans without government is violence or monopoly. Nonsense. First, while this is phrased to position government as an alternative to violence, forcing repayment of loans with government involves both violence and a monopoly—a monopoly on "legitimate" violence being the main factor which all governments have in common. Second, government cannot be relied upon to force repayment of loans (e.g. they allow debts to be discharged in bankruptcy). Third, social pressure can effectively force people to repay their loans without resorting to violence. As things stand today, the main factor that keeps people from skipping out on loans is not the threat that the government might get involved, or a more general fear of violence, but rather the impact it would have on their credit score—in other words, the risk of acquiring a reputation as someone who does not repay their debts, and consequently losing access to future credit.
- VLM 9y agoI was in both two large corporations and the Army all of which sometimes are disturbingly similar to prison. The way the world works is someone does something stupid or incomprehensible where the most minor detail includes topic X. The report of the foolishness goes up the infinite hierarchy of micromanagers to someone who wants to make a statement to his superior of his great leadership skills by permanently "solving" the problem by banning whatever topic X is. Then months or years later the individual event of stupidity is long forgotten but the weird written order against topic X will remain for all eternity...
- paulie_a 9y agoAnd cynically this is how a bill becomes a law forever I can't find the relevant video clip, but it's from a school house rock parody
- IIAOPSW 9y agoI think it was Stallman who described the basic politicians syllogism. Something must be done I am doing something Therefore something is being done
- Spooky23 9y agoBecause craps and other dice games swing quickly and cause problems. Also the plastic can be sharpened into a point.
- labster 9y agoWell obviously dice are sinful, because they're made from platonic solids and that Plato guy was a pagan. Maybe those cylindrical ones are ok, though. This brought to mind the fact that in Japan, cards were considered to be the more pernicious influence on gambling, which eventually led to a card deck that was pessimized for gambling[0]. Of course, people can gamble on anything they can play, so it didn't exactly work. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanafuda https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanafuda
- walshemj 9y agoApparently puritains and others of that ilk regarded dice as instruments of the devil
- tachyoff 9y agoWhich is interesting because in the Old Testament, "casting lots" was considered an appropriate way to divine God's will [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleromancy#In_Judeo-Christian_tradition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleromancy#In_Judeo-Christian_...
- seren 9y agoThis fits with the recent serie of articles about ancient dice probabilities. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/dice-evolution-fate-fairness-archaeology https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/dice-evolution-fate-fa... In summary, even if the old dice were not fair, it was not an issue because they were a manifestation of the divine.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoDisappointing to hear that some prisons are cracking down on D&D, like the Idaho State Correctional Instutition whose rules are quoted ITA. It seems like a productive outlet to me. Locking someone up for a few years with nothing interesting to do sounds like a good way to make someone come out the other end worse than they were before.
- cr0sh 9y ago> Locking someone up for a few years with nothing interesting to do sounds like a good way to make someone come out the other end worse than they were before. Given the (growing) number of private, for-profit prisons - that would be seen as a feature, not a bug. Because if they leave worse off, they'll likely be returning - thus generating a steady income stream courtesy of taxpayers. Cynical, yes - but likely true.
- Buttons840 9y agoThings like this don't even have to be someone's concious evil plan. The system simply selects prisons that do this over the long term because they will tend to be more profitable and more likely to survive and be able to build more jails and lobby more politicians for contracts.
- paulie_a 9y agoDo you have any info on the growing aspect of private prisons. The last time I looked they were statistically insignificant. Even then I don't agree with the concept but if my hazy memory is correct it was close to 5 percent
- fenwick67 9y ago> Broken down to prison type, 19.1% of the federal prison population in the United States is housed in private prisons and 6.8% of the U.S. state prison population is housed in private prisons. > the overall trend over the past decade has been a slow increase > In the past two decades CCA has seen its profits increase by more than 500 percent.[22] The prison industry as a whole took in over $5 billion in revenue in 2011.[23] > A 2016 report by the U.S. Department of Justice asserts that privately operated federal facilities are less safe, less secure and more punitive than other federal prisons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#Development_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#Development_2
- pesfandiar 9y agoWell, they can't ban 1-bit random number generators (e.g. coins) and with a bit of time, you can simulate any of dice used in RPGs.
- jlgaddis 9y agoYes, coins -- all forms of currency, actually -- are banned.
- dalore 9y agoOk a leaf? Or a piece of toilet paper.
- logfromblammo 9y agoScrabble tile, letter up vs. letter down. Bonus in that the flips may be done all at once and ordered alphabetically.
- slaymaker1907 9y agoDo some sort of simple pseudo-RNG then (DM seeds it obviously). Icky math, but you could probably just generate a bunch of rolls as part of your prep work.
- kibwen 9y ago"With a thunderous roar, the colossal red dragon envelops the party in a cruel wave of fire! You each take 24d10 damage, but while I'm sitting here flipping this coin six hundred times please do let me know if you make your reflex save for half..."
- setr 9y agoIf you converted the rules to be powers of 2, each coin representing a binary digit, it shouldn't be too bad 24d10 becomes 0-240, so change it to 0-256 and you've got 8 flips (8d2?) Distribution won't be correct but hey, 8 flips
- batmansmk 9y agoThis article is extremely well documented. It must have taken a lot of time to investigate the matter. It becomes rare enough to notice this!
- chisleu 9y agoWe used to make them with toilet papier-mâché. Just add water and push them into the corner of the locker. When it dries, put on dots and wrap it in clear tape to protect the dots.
- walshemj 9y agoWould not using cards (which appear to be allowed) be simpler
- kibwen 9y agoEven though the section on cards mentions that "many prisons" do allow them, what the article is trying to emphasize there is that playing cards can be used to simulate dice if the prison happens to allow them (while also implicitly demonstrating that the rules against gambling are often inconsistent and arbitrary). The implication seems to be that there are more prisons that disallow cards than that allow them, and indeed earlier on the article quotes a prison handbook that explicitly mentions cards as contraband. Furthermore, even if cards are explicitly allowed by the rules, that doesn't mean that cards (along with pretty much anything else) can't be confiscated at any moment. For those instances, it's good to have a backup that involves materials that are always on hand.
- Notorious_BLT 9y agoI guess I can understand the dice ban (sort of?) but the fact that some prisons have apparently have banned games like D&D altogether is bizarre to me. It seems like a healthy, relatively peaceful way to pass time and do something creative. I can't see it having a negative effect that other prison activities don't already make possible.
- protonimitate 9y agoAs far as pastimes go it seems pretty innocent, but I guess one could argue that because jail is supposed to be punishment time passing actives aren't a priority (not saying I do or do not agree with that stance).
- euler_ 9y agoAren't dice and coins banned because they can be sharpened into a shiv? That would explain why cards are allowed.
- an4rchy 9y agoIf that were true though, then they wouldn't confiscate any of the makeshift dice, made of paper/cardboard etc.
- VyseofArcadia 9y agoNah, sometimes stuff is confiscated just to make life more miserable for the inmates.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- an4rchy 9y agoFascinating read, didn't know this was a thing in prison, but makes total sense. Also, now have a few more ideas of how to get creative when pieces of games are missing. Creativity FTW.
- stryk 9y agoAt the prison I was in (northern Indiana), dice were banned as "tools for gambling" -- yet playing cards were OK. Yea, it didn't make sense to any of the staff either. We carved our own out of bars of "state soap" (the cheap Barker brand inmate soap that gets distributed in just about every institution). We carved out the little divots on each side for the numbers and used Kool-Aid to stain them. Some of the older guys who had been incarcerated for a long time were so good at making them[1] that they were damn near indistinguishable from the real thing until you felt them of course (they were made out of soap after all). They actually rolled fairly true as well. ----- 1: they could also carve out some very intricate chess pieces. I mean these were damn near works of art. You couldn't use state soap for those though, it's far too thin and brittle. You needed the good Ivory-brand stuff from the commissary.
- VyseofArcadia 9y agoFor a semester, I taught in a state prison for a prisoner educational program. Every time I went in, I was struck by how punitively petty so many of the rules and corrections officers were. The environment is carefully crafted to suck out all joy and hope from the inmates. Azkaban with its dementor guards is a pretty good illustration of an American prison. Guards are as likely to confiscate gaming materials (and punish inmates) for breaking the rules as they are to do the same because they stubbed their toe or someone looked at them funny. Thankfully we do have some more progressive correctional programs making a little headway like the one I taught for, but nothing about this article surprised me. edit: I accidentally a word.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoI'm just giving anecdata here so I'm curious to see if you agree with me. Having known two people that went to prison, my opinion on the system is that I think people usually go to prison for the legally correct reason. That being said, a lot of people I meet seem to associate going to prison with deserving to live in a hellhole. No one considers the social exclusion itself a hellhole as evidenced by the ubiquitousness of rape jokes about prison. The reason I mentioned that the point about the prisoners deserving it from a legal perspective is because I think this is the point where most people lose sympathy for the prisoner population, it's the moment when they just sort've assume that anything that comes after being found guilty is just more of a reason not to commit a crime in the first place which is a horrific outlook in my opinion.
- pmarreck 9y ago> I think people usually go to prison for the legally correct reason Or not, if most of the incriminating information was eyewitness testimony, the #1 cause of wrongful convictions: https://www.innocenceproject.org/ https://www.innocenceproject.org/ MY opinion of the US criminal justice system is that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation is almost definitely not being followed, with the bias far into the false-positive conviction camp. Come to think of it, why is the criminal justice system not "tested"? In other words, set up a mock situation where you know in advance who is innocent and who is not (because it's a setup), and run a mock trial by all the rules using actual jurors, and compare the outcome of the trial to the actual innocence or guilt of the actor?
- aphextron 9y agoI have fond memories of playing D&D in the barracks with my fellow "volunteers" during US Army basic training. For those not aware, the conditions for enlistees are very similar to prison. We made a d20 out of wadded up toilet paper and a sharpie that had to be kept hidden until late at night. Our "rulebook" consisted of the hazy memory of our DM who had memorized most of 5E (He also had a separate project going at the time of writing down word for word the entire script of LOTR: Return of the King in a notebook, from memory, to pass the time.). It's one of the few things that kept me sane during that time.
- ishi 9y agoThis reminds me of the semi-relevant story about the first translation of "The Hobbit" to Hebrew: four fighter pilots who were POWs in Egypt from 1970 to 1973 decided to translate the book so that their non-English-speaking friends could enjoy it too. It took them 4 months, and filled 7 notebooks. Even though their translation was not a professional one, it got published in 1977 and became pretty popular.
- cease 9y agoThis is a refreshing read that I can relate to personally. I have never been to prison, but myself and a group of fellow soldiers played D&D in army basic training. We drew all maps on notepad paper, played using rules someone either recalled or made up on the spot, and carved bars of soap into dice. It always sticks out in my memory as a great example of how humans can figure out a way to find joy in an _extremely_ bleak environment.
- dumbfounder 9y agoOr they could simulate dice by each person picking a number, adding them all up, and then modding by 6 (+1). Could lead to interesting results methinks...
- kibwen 9y agoThis would be a variant of Odds and Evens (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odds_and_evens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odds_and_evens ), though Odds and Evens is kept honest by the fact that it's an adversarial game, so there's no point in players colluding to fix the outcome. To obviate any concerns of player collusion you'd need to ensure that the GM is one of the people picking the numbers, and once you've gone this far you actually only need two people to pick the numbers (the GM and one player), which will be just as random as having all players pick the numbers (setting aside the human tendency to pick "random" numbers non-randomly, which is hopefully mitigated by the adversarial nature of the choice). You'd also need some way for the adversaries to prove that they chose their numbers before the other number was revealed, which, as in Odds and Evens, you can do with your fingers (don't fret about the d20, you can count to 20 on your fingers with enough imagination).
- dumbfounder 9y agoI have never played any of these games, are some of them without competition? Like everyone is on the same side? It wouldn't work in that case. But all you need is one person picking numbers to be on an adversarial team in order for this to work.
- ufo 9y agoThe typical D&D game will have a group of players working as a team and exploring a monster-filled dungeon. A different person is the Dungeon Master and is responsible for crafting the plot of the adventure and presenting challenges to the players (monsters to battle, though choices to make, and so on). However, it isn't really an adversarial thing. A good DM doesn't "play to win" as their goal is to create the most fun experience for everyone.
- rootw0rm 9y agoWhen I was a teen I hung out with a SHARP crew in SoCal, we played D&D all the time. We had some members go to prison and they started up their own games inside.
- radarsat1 9y agoI understand the dice ban somewhat, I mean, gambling is principally what they'd be used for, but why is chess of all things banned? Seems.. counterproductive.
- snakeboy 9y agoNo dice? Sounds like they'd be better off playing Diplomacy instead.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jp57 9y agotl;dr - they make dice.
- drdrey 9y agoYou can also use the last digit on a stopwatch stopped randomly (hundredth of a second), or open a book on a random page
- SN76477 9y agoI did this in the 90s, we just used card and referenced a table for whatever card was drawn.
- pure-awesome 9y agoPersonally, I would probably have just played a simple, diceless RPG, like Archipelago: https://norwegianstyle.wordpress.com/2012/09/20/archipelago-iii/ https://norwegianstyle.wordpress.com/2012/09/20/archipelago-...
- farnsworthy 9y agoSome of those dice are beautifully designed--it wouldn't surprise me if people would buy them (if able).
- jernfrost 9y agoComming from Norway where we have a very different attitude towards prisoners, I never cease to being amazed at the sheer pettiness towards prisoners in the US. Are they not supposed to have an ounce of enjoyment in life? A dice is contraband!!! Seriously!! Is the point of prison to be miserable every single day? How is hating yourself, your life and everything every day supposed to make somebody a better person? It often feels like the US is mentally speaking where we were 100 years ago in Norway. It is just bizarre how such a modern innovative country is so backwards with respect to how people are treated. Norway legislated national maternity leave over 100 years ago. It still doesn't exist in the US. Somehow it seems like the US is regressing. Many of the progressive ideas we use came from the US originally. Liberal American professors have spread ideas which have benefited Nordic countries a lot, such as Harvey Milkman which solved the drug and subsistence abuse in Iceland.
- Beltiras 9y agoI'm fascinated by this as a problem. I had an idea how to solve it. Books are not contraband and you can pick two random words from, say the Catcher in the Rye or to name a less controversial book, the Bible and use the first letter of each one to "roll the die". Wrote a small script that tries to balance the odds given the frequency of first letters of words in the English language (odds taken from [1]). Script can be found on Gist [2]. This can of course be adapted to provide tables for common probabilities (say 3d6 for example). All of the methods the prisoners are using is "good enough". Having a table that is not accurately 5% for each number should not be a problem. It will depend on the books used as well. Sample output: a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z a 6 15 14 16 18 4 12 16 11 5 7 13 9 3 7 1 11 9 5 2 4 16 20 13 20 20 b 18 13 5 16 3 13 8 5 20 1 15 18 20 20 6 12 3 9 2 15 11 3 9 1 13 14 c 18 10 12 6 1 18 1 1 11 11 8 15 14 20 20 19 19 17 17 19 17 10 1 4 7 10 d 13 6 3 10 17 15 10 12 6 15 20 2 11 1 8 3 3 7 11 19 6 3 13 2 8 17 e 1 4 12 19 17 12 13 6 3 15 9 14 14 9 10 11 19 4 15 10 16 3 14 4 1 9 f 2 2 2 14 7 5 6 13 14 14 16 12 13 13 9 2 9 12 16 11 20 1 12 5 12 20 g 16 8 7 5 1 18 12 8 1 13 13 8 13 2 17 10 12 1 9 11 10 13 5 18 17 12 h 17 13 6 13 17 16 14 1 10 5 6 19 20 1 6 16 16 10 6 12 3 13 15 19 16 6 i 15 12 20 3 6 12 9 17 4 7 1 9 19 9 11 7 5 5 7 9 12 6 5 1 1 10 j 14 12 19 11 1 12 14 12 14 10 12 8 18 4 9 4 13 4 10 13 1 1 2 14 19 14 k 19 1 7 17 5 4 15 9 14 5 7 3 2 12 14 20 14 15 8 12 10 8 5 19 16 3 l 4 15 7 7 1 4 6 6 15 15 15 15 6 15 3 17 9 6 10 15 18 13 20 16 19 20 m 14 19 13 14 14 5 12 5 11 5 16 7 18 10 14 16 16 19 7 4 7 16 15 2 15 9 n 11 6 17 15 5 2 17 13 17 8 8 10 16 2 13 6 3 9 13 4 11 19 6 17 18 7 o 20 13 6 3 1 20 4 7 2 12 19 9 19 2 4 2 16 4 1 10 18 15 15 14 7 2 p 19 19 20 3 4 6 14 18 11 1 19 3 9 7 10 14 13 14 12 17 7 4 3 2 6 15 q 12 20 7 15 17 20 20 2 12 20 13 11 19 14 16 12 9 17 7 4 8 10 19 5 13 4 r 8 2 9 14 13 2 18 19 20 18 19 10 14 11 5 7 20 14 5 1 12 11 9 19 2 9 s 17 1 10 4 5 18 5 13 16 15 2 17 9 18 14 12 18 9 4 8 11 9 3 6 17 16 t 3 5 7 7 3 13 5 14 19 3 16 15 16 9 16 1 1 17 18 8 11 17 18 16 4 18 u 12 5 6 17 20 16 15 6 19 5 8 5 9 14 8 7 10 2 5 14 12 16 15 8 14 5 v 17 16 19 4 12 10 2 16 5 13 12 17 2 7 16 15 8 11 18 10 17 4 2 7 11 4 w 5 11 8 20 7 13 18 17 20 20 20 11 5 13 12 4 5 13 12 10 11 17 1 11 13 12 x 3 10 12 10 10 2 9 13 13 3 1 12 2 14 1 14 15 12 6 19 7 18 14 6 13 12 y 13 6 13 8 15 19 9 17 13 7 12 3 18 10 20 6 4 14 14 12 4 8 16 4 16 12 z 16 18 11 12 6 7 2 15 8 5 20 13 4 16 10 9 18 9 7 17 11 5 19 13 19 19 Difference between maximum and minimum odds: 0.004783609999999994 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_frequency#Relative_frequencies_of_the_first_letters_of_a_word_in_the_English_language [2]: https://gist.github.com/arnists/d23194c4c48880979ed0993bd3ec4b7c
- fenwick67 9y agoThere is an enthralling article in The Intercept by incarcerated hacker Barrett Brown about his time playing DnD and other RPGs in prison. He also details the spinner: > With unlimited paper and pencils provided by the federal government, we had everything we needed except for a set of variously sided dice. It turned out that this was generally handled by making a spinner out of cardboard, a paperclip, and the empty internal plastic tube from an ink pen. This latter item is impaled loosely on the paperclip, itself positioned in the center of the cardboard, on which has been drawn a diminishing series of concentric circles divided into 20, 12, 10, 8, 6, and 4 equal segments, respectively. https://theintercept.com/2016/10/16/i-am-fully-capable-of-entertaining-myself-in-prison-for-decades-if-need-be/ https://theintercept.com/2016/10/16/i-am-fully-capable-of-en...
- Fjolsvith 9y agoWe used cardboard spinners. A thumbtack was pushed through and bent over to form the pivot. We got the cardboard from the back of notepads of paper. Concentric circles had equal divisions to form the d4, d6, d8, d12, and d20 ranges.