5 ms·
The problem described in the article is a short term problem. The reason for the increase in congestion is that the new services, Uber and Lyft, have added vehi
by pdonis 9y ago
The problem described in the article is a short term problem. The reason for the increase in congestion is that the new services, Uber and Lyft, have added vehicles, not displaced them. The taxis and buses that were there before are still there, plus now there are ride sharing vehicles.
But that situation won't last. If usage of taxis and buses decreases, fewer of them will be needed, so the number of them on the city streets will gradually decrease. That hasn't happened yet because those services are propped up by fees and taxes, so the fact that they are being out-competed can be hidden--for a while. Sooner or later that will cease to be feasible.
The real question is whether, after all this has shaken out, congestion on city streets will be better than it was before ride sharing services came along. It seems like it ought to be, since ride sharing seems like a more efficient way to allocate vehicle space. But we won't know for sure until the experiment is done.
- rocky1138 9y ago> If usage of taxis and buses decreases Buses are way cheaper than Uber. Until it's cheaper for me to use Uber, there's still a good place for a city bus.
- pdonis 9y ago> Buses are way cheaper than Uber. Only because they're subsidized, so that the price you pay per ride is well under the operating cost.
- stevenwoo 9y agoUber and Lyft current pricing is currently subsidized by VC's.
- pdonis 9y agoEven if this is true (which it might well not be--VC investment money for a startup usually goes to build infrastructure, not to enable under-cost pricing; the former increases your runway while the latter decreases it), it's only for the short term; if Uber and Lyft don't start operating at a profit at some point in the near future, the VC investment will be gone and they will have a hard time getting more. Public transportation, by contrast, has been subsidized for decades, because it doesn't have to answer to market forces, only political ones.
- twblalock 9y agoIt's not just about price. It's also about speed and convenience. An Uber can go anywhere a car can go, and get there a lot faster. That's a better experience, and better experiences are worth more money than lesser ones. My commute to work is about 7 miles. I could get there faster on a bicycle than I could on a bus.
- eatbitseveryday 9y ago> there's still a good place for a city bus. Not if bus routes don't go where you need them to, they are late, congestion makes bus rides impractical, etc. Mostly this is perhaps outside of the center of a city. Even in suburban areas where there is an influx of residents, buses are the last option because you could bike where you need to faster than taking the bus during rush hour. What if a short distance meant having to transfer? If the wait is 10-20 minutes, and if the bus comes too early, then that just compounds time wasted using the bus. If bus rides take a long time, nearly zero of them have wifi to enable work to be done. And if they don't drop you off or pick you up near your source / destination, you spend twice as much time walking. It's just impractical until localities start taking this seriously. Cities and surrounding suburbs really need to increase bus lines (accessibility), and buses per line (frequency). In many places I've lived, buses were what the poor and disadvantaged rode.
- ccozan 9y agoSeriuously, you don't have 4G in the cities? Why share a painfully slow Wifi connection when I can have my one private channel and fast enough to do almost any work? And with the hotspot option on smartphones, is even simpler...
- eatbitseveryday 9y ago> share a painfully slow Wifi connection This is the problem. Having WiFi available does not mean it's availability is implemented well. If a bus provides WiFi, it should not suck; if it does, it's effectively not available. I don't want to use my 2 GiB cellphone data plan on work-related emails and files (together with my phone's usage, can exceed 2 GiB), and draw all the power from my phone everyday doing so.
- acabal 9y agoOh I certainly hope usage of buses doesn't decrease. One person hailing an Uber takes up an entire car's worth of space on the road: 4 seats, an engine, and a trunk. One person riding a bus takes a single bus seat on a vehicle that can hold 20+ people in a minimum of space. If each individual hailed a single Uber for each ride, it's obvious congestion would greatly increase versus each individual taking a bus, simple because one person in a private car takes up much more physical space than one person on a shared bus. (I hope Uber doesn't continue to increase for many other reasons, congestion being just one of them.)
- lopmotr 9y agoThat's not simply wasted congestion. Ride sharing provides better service than busses as evidenced by people paying more to use it. So that's a good thing - people getting what they want. Congestion is caused by all road users, not just the latest group to join, so it's not fair to blame them any more than the people who still drive the same way they always did.
- wutbrodo 9y agoThis is entirely ignoring the externalities: congestion, localized pollution[1], more inefficient use of subsidized resources like roads (and the expansion of said subsidies). It's certainly not "simply" wasted congestion, but it's very much on-net wasted, by the same cost argument you make (which doesn't include externalities). [1]Regardles of your views on macro environmentalism, the detrimental effects of localized air pollution is pretty well documented IIUC
- zaarn 9y agoIt's not a better service just because people pay more or it costs more. A service can be better and cheaper. If congestion starts to worse, I'd also definitely not blame the people who haven't changed behavior when there is another group that has changed behavior in a way that can directly impact this problem.
- ballenf 9y agoThe only time public transport is efficient space-wise is during rush/peak hours. But the same buses/trams are used during off-peak hours. Haven't we all ridden nearly-empty public transport many times? Maybe just restricting ridesharing during peak hours and reducing public transport during off-peak (even subsidize ride shares like has been tried).
- erispoe 9y agoFrom a space efficiency perspective, you can put much, much more people in a bus than in a car. Nothing is going to change that fact. Buses are not creating traffic jams.