10 ms·
And once again fucked incentives are at risk of screwing us over. In fact the article notes exactly that two-thirds down: > To be clear: For both economic and
by masklinn 9y ago
And once again fucked incentives are at risk of screwing us over. In fact the article notes exactly that two-thirds down:
> To be clear: For both economic and environmental reasons, it is good that US power demand has decoupled from GDP growth. As long as we’re getting the energy services we need, we want overall demand to decline. It saves money, reduces pollution, and avoids the need for expensive infrastructure.
> But the way we’ve set up utilities, they must fight that trend. Every time they are forced to invest in energy efficiency or make some allowance for distributed generation (and they must always be forced), demand for their product declines, and with it their justification to make new investments.
> Only when the utility model fundamentally changes — when utilities begin to see themselves primarily as architects and managers of high-efficiency, low-emissions, multidirectional electricity systems rather than just investors in infrastructure growth — can utilities turn in earnest to the kind planning they need to be doing.
edit: replaced expectations by incentives which is what I meant
- crdoconnor 9y agoThere's no good reason for networks or last mile infrastructure to be privately run in the first place because competition does not come about naturally. The incentive of a private owner will always be to sit on the network and collect rents and spend as little on maintenance and infrastructural investment as possible.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIs that because the product is 100% fungible? Electrons are electrons and there’s no such thing as “better electrons” once you hit a certain quality threshold? I’m trying to understand why your characterization doesn’t apply to, say, programming talent. Once I have stable of coders working for me, what’s my incentive to do more than the bare minimum of maintenance work for them, and just collect rent on their productivity? To me, it seems like you’re just describing capitalism: cash seeks rent.
- cptskippy 9y ago> To me, it seems like you’re just describing capitalism: cash seeks rent. He is and pure capitalism is the problem. When shareholders demand growth the companies are forced to cut corners and start charging more for less. Take a look at Verizon and it's copper POTS lines for a great example of capitalism in action.
- jes 9y ago> He is and pure capitalism is the problem. Can you say, briefly, what you mean by "pure capitalism?" To me, pure capitalism would be laissez-faire, within the context of a rights-respecting society. > When shareholders demand growth the companies are forced to cut corners and start charging more for less. Sometimes, companies respond by innovating solutions that deliver more value at a lower price. Thoughts?
- cptskippy 9y ago> Can you say, briefly, what you mean by "pure capitalism?" > To me, pure capitalism would be laissez-faire, within the context of a rights-respecting society. I mean withOUT the context of a rights-respecting society. The capitalism that we have only respects the rights of others when compelled to do so. > Sometimes, companies respond by innovating solutions that deliver more value at a lower price. Yes when there's competition or the consumable isn't a necessity. In many municipalities it's a legal requirement to have running water and/or electricity, particularly if you have children or the elderly in the house; which means not buying is not an option. Utilities are commodity service providers; Southern Company's electricity is no better than Duke Energy's. They do not have any competition because markets have been carved out and consumers do not have a choice. They mostly don't develop the delivery technology, they just purchase it from others (e.g. GE). With all that in mind, what is the motivation to innovate? So that the customer will be less angry at you as they write you the check each month? What's the motivation to reduce costs? Lower costs might drive up demand which might put additional strain on infrastructure (look at the issues in Australia) and drive up maintenance costs. Lower costs might also require additional capacity which means capital investments. The best place for a utility is to convince to you use as little as possible while charging you as much as possible in static fees each month.
- cptskippy 9y agoWhich is why any service or utility required to maintain the standard of living and comfort we all expect should be tightly regulated or non-profit in nature to remove the incentive to extract the most profit while providing the lease service.
- rhino369 9y agoIt's all quasi-privately run in the US. They aren't expected to compete because like said it isn't natural. But governments are generally incompetent at building and maintaining power grids. In the past, investment was been encouraged by allowing these companies a set rate of return on capital investments, but allow no profit on expenses. Thus, the energy company would get 10% return on any investment. This actually lead to over-investment in infrastructure--called gold plating. You need a new power tower? Build it as expensively as possible, with all the bells and whistles. Now, there are newer forms of price regulation designed to eliminate gold plating. >The incentive of a private owner will always be to sit on the network and collect rents and spend as little on maintenance and infrastructural investment as possible. Governments have exactly the same incentives. And the results are clear. US public infrastructure is fucking terrible. Puerto Rico is one example of public energy company. Didn't do so hot.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>governments are generally incompetent at building and maintaining power grids. When you strip out the market discipline imposed by competition, governments are usually more efficient than equivalent private sector operations. Privately run monopolies are - similar to governments - only kept in check by democratic accountability. The difference with a privately run regulated monopoly is that that democratic accountability is one step removed. As you said, it's quasi private - because the system would collapse under the weight of unchecked rent seeking behavior if it weren't heavily regulated. >Governments have exactly the same incentives. Believing that elections and power seeking does not motivate government decision makers is an odd opinion.
- rhino369 9y ago>Believing that elections and power seeking does not motivate government decision makers is an odd opinion. Only if the people want better infrastructure. They do not. People want lower prices, which means less investment.
- crdoconnor 9y ago
- mseebach 9y agoWe'll see about getting screwed. It seems to me the most effective way to get households to use a lot more electricity is to encourage them to get electrical/plugin hybrid cars.
- 2sk21 9y agoAgreed - quite a lot of the power from my solar panels is currently being fed back into the grid but this will change in a few years when I replace my hybrid car with a full electric. Electric transport is definitely the main source of growth in electric power consumption.
- fooker 9y agoI would hazard a guess that people buying electric cars are also more likely to buy solar panels and in the near future, large-ish batteries.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThey've already bought a large battery - bolted under their electric car. Perhaps one day our cars will drive us into work, we'll plug into the grid there (or have it drive itself home), and home solar will talk to the grid and tell it how much to,charge our car during the day. Then we'll go home and run our house off the car battery overnight, making sure to leave enough battery power to get to work the next morning. Or party on Friday night because it was sunny and we have a couple dozen extra kilowatts that don't need to be saved for commuting in the morning!
- checkyoursudo 9y agoNeat ideas. What happens when my wife has the car with the big battery at work while I'm at home on a cloudy day?
- stale2002 9y agoThe same thing that happens now. Some energy sources will be low directing certain times of the day, and others will be high, causing it to mostly average out. And for the stuff that doesn't average out, there is peaker plants. Things could be further made better using varying electric pricing, such that when energy is plentiful it is cheap, and when it is scarce it is expensive.
- gowld 9y agoThat's a bizarre gripe. Everywhere I live, utility companies beg subscribers to use less power, because they want to keep output within the hard limit of their current (ha!) capital outlay, in the face of population growth.
- driverdan 9y agoThey want to reduce peak power demand but see overall use grow at a steady, predictable rate.
- Rebelgecko 9y agoWhen the drought was at its worst here in CA, there was a concern that LADWP would have to jack up their rates because people were doing such a good job conserving water. They have lots of fixed costs (salaries, pensions, infrastructure improvements) but their incoming $ is tied pretty tightly to consumption
- pmiller2 9y agoMy water bill is always something like $50 for various "service fees" and surcharges, and $30 for water. EBMUD even charged me $36 to set up an online account with them, so I could have the privilege of using autopay.
- djrogers 9y agoWhen I moved to LA in 1990, we were in a drought and DWP did raise it's rates to both accommodate for and encourage lower usage. After the drought though, oddly enough they didn't go back down... My local water district here in NorCal raised it's rates 2 years ago during the height of the last drought as well...
- martin-adams 9y agoFrom a consumer point of view, it's probably easier to take a price hike when you're forced to use less water, than if you were using a lot of water.
- 9y ago
- surfmike 9y agoCalifornia actually changed the incentive structure for PG&E to deal with this issue. One of the reasons California has had flat demand despite growing a lot.
- cryptonector 9y agoI love the "(and they must always be forced)". Very naked display of political power, that. It's very far from obvious that forcing utilities to subsidize others is a good idea.
- toss1 9y agoIt is neither a "naked display of political power" nor "forcing them to subsidize others". The utilities have been granted a monopoly by the govt, and in exchange, are subject to regulations. If anything is a "naked display of political power" it is the granting of a monopoly. The reason the monopoly is granted, is that it is most efficient as a society to have a single successful power distributor than to have multiple failing ones with redundant infrastructure (power poles, lines, etc.). And, for monopolies, to regulate them to reasonable profits instead of allowing any winner of the failing competitors to establish a rapacious monopoly. With new developments in rooftop solar and batteries making it economical, it is sensible that these distributed modes be supported, and the system migrated towards distributed power. I've always wondered why this wasn't done sooner as a civil defense measure (as the interstate highway system was built as a defense measure, to transport troops to either coast in 24h). As such, they are only being forced to subsidize their customers' ability to either generate power or live at greater efficiency.
- cryptonector 9y agoThat the last-mile costs are so extreme that utilities must be monopolies is not obvious either. We've built out the last mile in the U.S. many times over for many things, and where we've allowed it (as opposed to preempting it a priori) we've had competition (e.g., cable). Even where we don't have direct competition, we do have indirect competition where consumers can vote with their feet (e.g., power rates vary regionally).
- IdeaHamstir 9y agoMy local utility charges users $5,000 per installed pole for last mile connection. I've priced poles and wire, they are turning a hefty profit for last mile connections.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThis is one of those cases where I wonder if the traditional Chinese Healthcare Payment Model might be something that could be applied to other industry sectors. That is: traditionally in China, you paid the doctor when you were well. When you were sick, treatment was offered without payment. The alignment of incentives is for patients to be healthy (or, for the cynical amongst you: for the doctor to be able to credibly claim this). If various services were offered not on the basis of inputs consumed (as with electricity), but on the basis of outputs enabled, this dynamic would change. For employees, this is the difference between measuring based on hours worked (or worse: present), and on deliverables achieved. There's some complications to this: piecework payment is something that's long been criticised (Adam Smith argues against this in Wealth of Nations, 1776), largely in that it tends to overwork, even in the absence of overt coercion. Prices ultimately are meant to cover costs of provisioning, and there's the need to see that those costs are met. Measuring what is directly transacted is easier than measuring either complex inputs or often-at-a-remove outcomes (Smith also discusses the former, the latter is the topic of many decades of Monitoring and Evaluation theory and practice).
- goldenkey 9y agoI totally agree with the sentiment here. If the utility is public, it exists to serve the people electricity, all of the people, whatever their needs may be. So it seems like the fair thing to do is for the utility to charge the rate it needs in order to maintain and upgrade its equipment. Then just divide that into the total usage and make the people pay the total adjusted for their individual use compared to the average.