5 ms·
Clicking Facebook "Like" Buttons Gives Owner Permission To Spam You (w/ demo)
- patio11 16y agoI mentioned this the other day in a comment, but I figured it gets a lot more visceral punch if you actually see it happen, so I wrote up the consequences in an article and wired together a working tech demo. I haven't seen anybody exploit this misfeature "in the wild" yet, but then again I'm not exactly plugged into the social networking scene. It astounds me that somebody thought making the Like button be silent opt-in to "permission" marketing was a good idea. Added bonus points (not covered in article): this creates a security hole in every Liker's account, because it slaves the security of their News Feed to the security of every site they have ever liked. Pretend you like something published by Scrappy Startup A. Six months pass. Scrappy Startup goes out of business and their URL gets grabbed, or Scrappy startup gets their server owned, or Scrappy Startup merely permits defacement of the contents of their HEAD. This lets the attacker immediately assert publishing privileges for all connections created by Likes (6+ months ago), and then spam the connected Facebook News feeds with live URLs carrying an endorsement from Scrappy Startup. Now pretend Scrappy Startup is, or purported to be, Obama. (Thumbnail sketch: you and 10,000 other people favorite a picture of Obama hugging two puppies titled "Obama Gives Constituents a Lift", six months later the Facebook login crowd sees "Obama Gives Constituents a Lift: Click here and put in your bank account details to receive your instant stimulus package".)
- Sukotto 16y agoI'm a bit surprised that you published this to your bingo blog and not Kalzumeus.com. Aren't you worried about your stereotypical user clicking it by accident?
- patio11 16y agoThe only way in is via direct link to that URL. I put it there because I happened to have Rails code written to do most of the work here (back from when I implemented Like buttons for the site, prior to understanding what they actually do), and because I'm positive Nginx can take the load (it is 100% static content after the first access) but less than sanguine about my Apache setup.
- mikeknoop 16y agoYour "takeover" scenario isn't true and cannot happen simply by having a URL change ownership. You need access to both the domain AND the Facebook user account or application to which the open graph objects (websites) are tied to. Also, if you can get access to a Facebook user account or application, you don't even need the domain name.
- patio11 16y agoI'm pretty sure, but not positive, that I did it to myself earlier today: edit the page, add in a new og:app_id pointing to an application that you control. The documentation mentions the object's title and type being durable, and I wasn't able to successfully overwrite those, but you can change the other parameters and then just call the Lint tool on the page again. (n.b.: If you have something as og:type="article", that apparently causes there to be no OpenGraph node created for the page in spite of what the docs say. That might be a bug. Anyhow, the upshot is that this means that everything tagged as an "article" is safe.) But I think I remember being able to add an app to my "cause" after it was first liked.
- natrius 16y agoIt is indeed a bug: http://bugs.developers.facebook.net/show_bug.cgi?id=10448 http://bugs.developers.facebook.net/show_bug.cgi?id=10448
- edanm 16y agoIs there some kind of limit to the number of postings an application can make on your wall? I.e. "x posts per hour"?
- webwright 16y agoI clicked it and haven't gotten my note yet... By "spam", I think you're saying they can put something into my news feed, right? If this opted me into email communication or even facebook messages, I might be alarmed. Related: I generally trust things that I "like" to behave in a polite way... And know that if they don't they are going to quickly eat a social media backlash. I can see some nice ways this could be used-- for example-- I "like" Bingo Card Creator and you say, "Thanks Tony! I see you just bought your copy of BCC a few days ago. Holler if I can help!" I agree that this is an odd/dumb thing for FB to do, but I'm not sure it's that scary.
- tptacek 16y agoKind of agree; also, I'm just not as possessive of my Facebook feed as I am of my mail spool. I really don't feel like I own my feed. Also, Facebook acts against its own interests if they allow random sites to pollute the feed.
- pyre 16y agoI have to agree that it's against Facebook's own interests. If they let random sites spam away, then pretty soon it will turn into MySpace, and competitors will eat its lunch.
- patio11 16y agoSo I think that is not technically speaking impossible but you have to really, really contrive it to make Like facilitate a BCC-to-Tony narrowcast. You can create "groups of one" by altering the URLs being liked to make them unique, saving the association that "Tony" => "uniqueUserID" somewhere outside of Facebook, installing a callback function to let your website know when one of your unique URLs gets liked, and then broadcasting a Tony-pleasing message to Tony's group of one. But what is actually going to happen is Tony is going to favorite the front page / the product / etc (those two aren't necessarily the same thing), and then the only option for talking to Tony is to take out Ye Old Megaphone and blast everyone who likes the front page / product / etc.
- sstrudeau 16y ago
- natrius 16y agoThis really doesn't seem like a big deal. You can click the 'X' next to the spam to end it forever. If a certain publisher is getting removed frequently, Facebook could block them from posting to anyone's news feed. I doubt this functionality will negatively affect many people unless Facebook fails to police it properly.
- e1ven 16y agoI'm sorry to hear that this behavior was a surprise to you- Perhaps FB could do a better job at making it clear what this does, but to me this was always the expected (and desired!) behavior. The Facebook "Like" button is akin to "Follow" on Twitter. It subscribes you to their feed. That's the whole POINT of the like button. The "Tell your friends" is ancillary; It's akin to twitter telling your feed "Colin is now following .... CocaCola" It's a VERY useful feature, and the name makes sense to me; If you Like AntelopeFurniture.com, and they have a new sale running or something, you'd want to hear about it. You already said you like them ;) With that understanding in mind ("Facebook:like == Twitter:Follow"), it starts to become clear that seeing their posts isn't spam- It's the entire point!
- jonknee 16y agoTo me the Like button seems used like it's more similar to a Digg this button (they are frequently next to eachother even). While I expect that my Digg friends can see my Digg, I don't expect the article I just Dugg to be able and spam me later on. It's a huge invasion of privacy and Patrick's comparison to email opt-ins is on point.
- e1ven 16y agoFB has no ability to control where third-parties put the like button, but the functionality itself is very useful. I can't agree that it's an invasion of privacy- If I follow Dell on Twitter, I see everything Dell posts. That's the point. If I "like" Dell on Facebook, I see everything Dell posts. Again, that's the entire idea. You can argue the name isn't perfect, but neither is "Follow", for that matter. Subscribe, perhaps. Take a look the HELP section- There is a big button for the Like feature, and what it means. http://www.facebook.com/#!/help/?faq=17115 http://www.facebook.com/#!/help/?faq=17115 What does it mean to "Like" a Page? When you click "Like" on a Page, you are making a connection to that Page. The Page will be displayed in your profile, and in turn, you will be displayed on the Page as a person who likes that Page. The Page will also be able to post content into your News Feed.
- ErrantX 16y agoIt's a huge invasion of privacy Oh come on. That's stretching into silly territory.
- mrduncan 16y agoMaybe I'm missing something here, but this seems like much ado about nothing. I mean, I get it, if I "like" something then that site now has the ability to leave me messages. I just don't see this as much different than following someone on Twitter - once I follow them, they have the ability to DM me all they want (until I unfollow anyway). Liking anything lets the owner spam you. This just sounds like a scare-tactic to me. That's like saying "following anyone lets the owner spam you", or "emailing anyone lets the owner spam you". I guess the real point here is to only "like" things that you trust. Just as I won't start following shady looking accounts on Twitter or handing out my email address to every website I visit, I won't "like" shady looking websites.
- CodeMage 16y agoI certainly wouldn't expect that kind of side effect at all, but maybe it's because I'm used to having a greater degree of control over who gets a claim on a slice of my attention. For me "like" is not a binary concept -- either you like it or you don't. I might like something enough to put it in my bookmarks, but that doesn't necessarily mean I'll want to recommend it to all of my friends or subscribe to its RSS feed. If signaling that I like something will automatically imply "subscribing" to it, then I'd like to be informed about it beforehand.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>For me "like" is not a binary concept We're not talking about like the English language word we're talking about "like" the Facebook specific action indicating that you wish to be associated with a particular page of content on that site.
- mattmanser 16y agoI think a lot of people don't realise this at all. It's a random website, it's not the facebook page. The whole like thing is a massive security and privacy disaster waiting to happen.
- CodeMage 16y ago
- char 16y agoI'm confused. Hasn't this always been the case when you 'Like' (previously 'Become a Fan' of) something? Pages I became a Fan of well over a year ago (maybe longer!) have been publishing updates to my stream ever since. (The ones I don't want to get updates from have either been removed or blocked.) The Page-to-User relationship is absolutely no different than the User-to-User one. By becoming Friends with someone, I'm letting them publish as frequently as they'd like to my stream. They can spam me if they want, and if I don't like it, I can block/remove them. Saying that 'Like' buttons give Page owners permission to spam you is grossly misleading, and leaves out several important pieces of information that allow one to understand what is actually going on.
- nl 16y agoYeah, it's always been the case. It's annoying when you don't realize it, but it's the kind of mistake you make only once.
- pilif 16y agoSeing that there's this "Mark as Spam" functionality, I would guess that Facebook would quickly revoke the spammers ability to add like buttons to their page once enough people clicked that spam button (or even make any further business with Facebook) IMHO, not that big a deal. Then again, I don't use Facebook, so I can't really know.
- jcl 16y agoWow... I wonder how far we are from having a marketplace for widely Liked sites to sell their ability to post to their audience. (Unsavory startup idea!)
- patio11 16y agoGiven that widely linked sites are frequently bought after being abandoned and used by spammers (for link equity and direct traffic), I don't think that is far fetched at all. A startup can reasonably achieve a metric truckload of likes (to the startup, to content, whichever), fail to achieve revenue, and fold in an N month period. The assets of a failed startup are worth close to nothing, and can probably be acquired for close to it. (Who at a shuttered company is in charge of re-registering the domain name, after all?) All you have to do is one blaze-of-glory phishing scam, or something like "Save Twitrliciously! Donate $5 to help keep us open!", etc. (Not a unique risk, given that you could do that with just the web page, but it gets you instant distribution to a highly targeted audience and that is 90% of the battle.) Facebook getting the memo and shutting down the site N hours later does not necessarily help all that much.
- nl 16y ago* how far we are from having a marketplace for widely Liked sites to sell their ability to post to their audience.* Minus a couple of years (ie, it's been pretty common for a while) Eg: (Warning: about as spammy as you'd expect) http://usocial.net/facebook_marketing/ http://usocial.net/facebook_marketing/ Prices: 1000 for $197 up to 250,000 for $8997.20
- Tichy 16y agoIf users would actually understand it, it might actually make for interesting behavior. It would raise the price of Likes.
- rumpelstiltskin 16y agoIs the publishing of updates automatic? As in if a user 'likes' a blog page and the blog publishes a new article, does that new page get pushed into the user's news feed automatically? Or does the blog have to do something extra to keep pushing updates?
- Wilfred 16y agoI would argue this already being taken advantage of (though 'exploited' seems a bit strong). There are pages such as this one: http://www.facebook.com/pages/96-percent-of-people-cant-figure-out-how-this-is-real/145455405484685 http://www.facebook.com/pages/96-percent-of-people-cant-figu... that require the user to 'like' it before they can see whatever it is. It would be interesting to see what sectors are targeting this new spam avenue. Facebook's anti-spam approach is largely effective though -- as a centralised service they have a lot of behaviour metrics to characterise misbehaviour.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoThis was obvious during the conversion of random lists and groups into data-ized Like graphs. They made it known this was possible. That's why I saw the blip from Futurama when they post a clip from their new episode, etc... It's intended, and for all intents and purposes, desired. If you don't want to see the New Items from a band/artist/website, don't like it. Not sure what was expected.
- geuis 16y agoI clicked the like button and I don't see any kind of notifications.
- sstrudeau 16y agoIf you have Facebook Mobile (iPhone or Android) check there -- I'm not seeing it on the web but it took over my mobile news feed.
- ErrantX 16y agoI think the problem is simply in the name of the button. I ran this by some of my less technical friends who use Facebook and they said some variation of "yes, that's what it's for isn't it? It's just got a confusing name" Something like "Follow" would be more descriptive. EDIT: the problem stems from Facebook trying to switch from being a "person-to-person" social network to a Twitter-esque community network.