4 ms·
Solution: Toll roads.
by jseliger 9y ago
Solution: Toll roads.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoor just ban Uber and Lyft
- closeparen 9y agoWhy would TNC passengers have less of a right to the space than car owners driving themselves?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoBanning Uber/Lyft doesn't take away their right to the space?
- swozey 9y agoI live in a city that banned U/L for about a year. Nothing was improved. A bunch of companies popped up to replace them but they were absolute jokes and so much worse. DWIs went way up. People stopped going out. I don't think there were any net positives from it.
- iamdave 9y agoHrm. This sounds a lot like a certain city I just got away from. By chance, did your state legislation come down pretty much immediately and strip away the power of cities to regulate TNC's in their city limits? That was a real fun session of The Lege.
- swozey 9y agoYup. I'm actually on my way out myself at this point. I loved this place 6+ years ago. I haven't been happy here in the last few years.
- iamdave 9y agoYou sound so much like me. Are you me? Are we both talking about Austin? I'm coming back in a couple of days to throw things into a big truck and say my final goodbyes. LET'S COMMISERATE
- swozey 9y agoDude between paying $400k for a 1975 3/2 house that I also have to spend $700/mo in property taxes on (thanks to the Leges robinhood tax scam) and just generally antagonistic anti-Austin policies.. I'm done here. I've got some interviews in Seattle/PNW going on but I'm also interviewing in Dallas this week. I really just want out of TX. The fact that it's an 8 hour drive minimum just to go to another State or go see a forest kills me. 2011 Austin was amazing. Traffic wasn't the best but it didn't ruin my day. I'd go out and listen to bands at least a few times a week. Now everything's an hour minimum. Need a hose from Home Depot 3 miles away? 2 hours. I don't want to leave my house. I can't figure out if it's because I'm getting older and saltier or if the town has actually changed that much. Where are you going? Also seeing Austin pop up as some amazing place to live in every HN thread is just weird. I stay out of those because maybe it is just my experience but this place is nothing like it was when I first came here. The city council being vehemently anti-density means there are NO townhouses or duplexes in the city (they were illegal until 2016 because of SFH minimum lot laws, every SFH had to be on a 5700sqft lot). It's synthesized real estate scarcity. Houston and Dallas are the polar opposite. I can buy an incredible townhouse in Deep Ellum with a roof top patio, 3/3, year old for less than my old crappy house here 12 miles from downtown.
- iamdave 9y agoNo I know how you feel, completely. I'm in the middle of transitioning back to my hometown of Indianapolis. Worse roads, less of a music scene, but the cost of living is much more tolerable...and it's my home. It's where I want to be right now. Funnily enough, I agree 200% with what you said about Houston and Dallas. Austinites LOVE to hate on those two cities, but...at least it seems like they've figured out how to actually be cities.
- donatj 9y agoThe freedom of travel now being open to all, you declare 'Tax the poor! They're clogging up the roads.'? If anything I see this as a remarkable step forward for equality.
- Eridrus 9y agoI see your point about taking the poor, but when a good is free, demand often outstrips supply, and when we're talking about city congestion, expanding supply is usually impossible, so the natural thing to do in a capitalist society is to increase the price. I think congestion pricing in NYC is inevitable, I just hope we also get more funding and competent management and contracting reform for public transport.
- arcticbull 9y agoWhy shouldn't cars be a premium product? Buses and subways are so much more efficient, and if Europe or Hong Kong is anything to go by, they can be nice, clean and faster than driving. If people want to spend the extra money to drive by themselves that is a luxury not a right, and we should be open to charging it accordingly. I feel ridesharing services have a place, but less so than then Zipcar. Lastly, I don't think that it's fair to call this a step forward for equality, as free parking throughout town is a tax on everyone who doesn't own a vehicle, or takes public transit, paid out to those wealthy enough to afford cars and their own parking spots at home.
- IntronExon 9y agoWhen Parisian subways show up in NYC, then make your argument about shafting the poor because you’re currently not one of them.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoNYC has fantastic transit. Maybe not as good as Paris, but that is an extremely high bar to meet. Poor people already don't drive in NYC because it is already too expensive for them, so it is disingenuous to suggest that they are being shafted by making it more expensive.
- nradov 9y agoIdeally it should be dynamic congestion pricing so that the cost of driving on a particular road at any time is based on how busy the road is. Right now major roads are a classic "tragedy of the commons" situation.
- notatoad 9y agotaxing a particular road will only divert traffic onto other nearby roads that are probably less able to handle high traffic volumes. I wouldn't want hundreds of cars driving down my residential street just because the nearby arterial street has switched over to congestion-pricing mode. congestion taxes need to be regional, not per-road.
- chad_oliver 9y agoThe best approach is to have congestion pricing applied to all roads, but with each road (or road segment) having its own price. After all, 'hundreds of cars driving down a residential street' is a case of demand exceeding supply, so we can fix it by increasing the cost and therefore decreasing the demand.
- mrep 9y agoIn a society with perfect information [0], I agree. However, people don't have perfect information so how would you coordinate millions of drivers about their different driving paths and their various costs? Not everyone has smartphones running GPS all the time. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_information https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_information
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Ideally it should be dynamic congestion pricing so that the cost of driving on a particular road at any time is based on how busy the road is. Congestion pricing is like trying to put out an oil fire by pouring water on it. And then charging the poor 15% of their paycheck for the water. The primary reason there is congestion is that where people live and where people work are too far apart, i.e. there isn't enough housing near the jobs. Solve that and there is no congestion. Don't solve it and every other solution will be a new problem. You can't get people to take a bus to a place the bus doesn't go, and you can't build mass transit from everywhere to everywhere across a thousand square miles of sprawl. You can build multi-story housing near multi-story offices, and build both next to subway stations.
- BurningFrog 9y agoPaying for road usage is the solution to all traffic problems!
- AckSyn 9y agoToll roads aren't a solution. That's what the taxes are for when you pay for gas.