13 ms·
Doctors, Revolt
- tensor_rank_0 9y ago>Despite his reputation, Dr. Lown was treated like just another widget on the hospital’s conveyor belt. “Each day, one person on the medical team would say one thing in the morning, and by the afternoon the plan had changed,” he later told me. “I always was the last to know what exactly was going on, and my opinion hardly mattered.” yes, this is what it is like to be a patient at a hospital these days. And good luck if the patient wants to speak to a physician. and don't ever go to a teaching hospital if you have the choice. some intern will have the brilliant idea to adjust every medication you are taking.
- Spooky23 9y agoYou have to bring an advocate who is able to sniff out bullshit, establish rapport with senior nursing staff and be a pushy asshole when necessary. A modern hospital is a zero trust environment.
- Parcissons 9y agoOh, the old ones where too - the stories just never circulated. Someone i know worked as a surgery nurse - by now almost 40 years ago. The surgeon was quite choleric - and once, when a cotton -wad was unaccounted for threw a sewn off hip joint twoards those who dared to assist him. All praise be upon the anaesthetist.
- muninn_ 9y ago> implying doctor’s don’t want 6-figure salaries The manufacturing operations-ization of hospitals is both good and bad. Good because that means we have standard care (as desired by regulators and single-payer advocates) but bad because doctors lose the ability to perform customized care solutions. I’m in favor of single-payer but we have to guard against turning healthcare into a manufacturing operation while also bouncing out bad actors and poo-quality physicians.
- aaavl2821 9y agoThe issue with hospitals controlling healthcare is that they are the group with the least incentive to lower the cost of care Hospitals account for the largest chunk of healthcare spend (30%). Hospitals make money by increasing inpatient admissions, particularly for profitable surgeries. The standardization of care in hospitals is intended to maximize profit under the constraints of various regulations around readmissions penalties, reimbursement limited length of stay, etc. If you look at the financials of public hospital companies like HCA and Community Health and Tenet, their major metrics are growth in admissions and surgeries. Even non profit hospitals are driven by this The expansion of hospitals into owning tons of formerly independent specialist and generalist physicians is scary. Once in a hospital's system, these physicians act as loss leaders funneling patients into the hospitals profit center Having hospitals in charge of the healthcare system is like having a fox in charge of the proverbial chicken coop
- nugget 9y agoFor better or for worse, everything in America is a business -- healthcare is no exception. Helpful to keep in mind when you think about potential improvements or solutions.
- lkrubner 9y ago"everything in America is a business" If by "business" you mean a public/private hybrid in which profits are privatized while losses are socialized, then you are correct, in so far as health care goes. And that seems to be the model that is now being adopted in more and more areas of economic activity.
- wyager 9y agoI don’t like that wording because it implies that hospitals somehow benefit from government involvement; in reality, it just sucks for everyone. In general, I agree - very few medical institutions in the US actually get to be private. I will say that truly private medicine is, in my reasonably broad experience, excellent. I use a private subscription-only medical service in the US which is excellent (and procedures are generally cheaper than they would be in a public hospital, whether I’m paying with insurance or out of pocket), and my experiences with private medicine in SE Asia and Mexico have been excellent (and affordable) as well (to a greater degree than can be explained by labor cost differences).
- jdminhbg 9y ago> it implies that hospitals somehow benefit from government involvement But they very clearly do. A huge proportion of their income comes from government sources (Medicare/Medicaid/VA), they are subsidized by tax exemption for health spending, and government grants them the power to deny competitive entrants into their markets via "certificates of need."
- chimeracoder 9y ago> But they very clearly do. A huge proportion of their income comes from government sources (Medicare/Medicaid/VA) Hospitals lose money on Medicare and Medicaid patients on the margin. They have to overcharge private insurers to make up the difference. It's so bad that Medicare has not one but multiple programs to compensate hospitals that don't see enough private patients to make up the difference, because otherwise they wouldn't be able to sustain themselves on Medicare reimbursement rates. I don't know why you're even mentioning the VA; it's not relevant here at all.
- motohagiography 9y agoThe health sector is the Afghanistan of the tech business. It's entire history is of empires arriving to solve its problems, and after a decade and massive losses, they leave, mystified at how something so contained could be so intractable. The only people who survive there are the ones who don't try to change it. When you can send your diagnostic images to get a consult from 2 clinics in India and an expert system for less than the price of a three block ambulance trip in the US, prices for domestic care will come down.
- HillaryBriss 9y agonot sure where your confidence comes from, though i hope you are correct. i don't see it yet though. in the US healthcare market the payment model will have to change before Indian healthcare market prices have an impact. in other words, US legislation that takes money away from the current system of providers would need to be passed. (i mean, why doesn't the US medicare/medicaid system take advantage of the lower costs you're describing by flying US patients to hospitals in other countries for major, expensive procedures and other treatments? they could save a lot of money, but US law does not currently allow payment to providers all over the world.) US hospitals, doctors, pharma, etc have created a closed system wherein they are the only service and product providers. i think they like that aspect of the current system. they've built themselves a moat and globalization cannot enter.
- motohagiography 9y agoTell me more of your impregnable fortresses and unsinkable ships. I agree that the barriers you mention are real, but those are in the domain or class of solvable problems. Apps like Figure1 are a good example of how doctors are moving around this. To borrow from Nial Ferguson's new book, the big CMS/EHR players (nightingale and another one here) control the integration points and hierarchical relationships, but I think they are vulnerable to networks.
- araes 9y agoHealth care and education are IMO the next two major car wrecks coming for America. Both are like patients with similar symptoms (indicative of the general disease of America.) - They treat the customers like replaceable widgets - Costs are spiraling out of control. ($2-3000/day hospital, $3.4 TRILLION in total health spending [this equals the entire federal budget]) - Doctors / teachers often don't seem to communicate / care. (Friend's mother was recently in hospital, multiple doctors thru a single day, each one had to completely relearn what was going on.) - The infrastructure systems are counter motivated (hospitals, drug companies, ect.. are profit not care motivated corps w/ "high" administrative overhead, schools are often public, yet view students as revenue and spend large amounts on noneducational costs to attract "talent". [$500k-$1.5M admin salaries]) No wonder many just want to self educate these days, and their health would be about as well served going to a shaman who cared about them.
- kbenson 9y ago> Friend's mother was recently in hospital, multiple doctors thru a single day, each one had to completely relearn what was going on. What's the alternative? 24 hour shifts for the doctor and the new doctor each day needs to relearn everything? Having to relearn everything might be a problem, depending on what it actually means, but as long as we want a normal human being as a doctor, they will cycle over time as people start and end shifts, and they will need to learn what happened before their shift started (and they may receive patients from multiple doctors leaving over their shift, making 1-on-1 hand-off infeasible). It's easy to call this out as a problem, the question is what's the alternative that's better?
- mikecsh 9y agoIn addition to this, many doctors want to re-take the history from the patients and re-examine them for themselves, rather than rely on a brief handover or potentially sub-optimal notes from another doctor. Clinical signs can be subtle, as can points in a patient's history that may point to a diagnosis. I see patients often frustrated at being asked the same questions by each doctor they see, but most of the time this is in their best interest.
- sampo 9y agoGoing to a doctor in America, for whatever reason, the first thing that happens is that a nurse comes and takes your blood pressure. I wonder why? Never happened to me in Europe.
- bryan11 9y agoWhen I asked, they said the insurance company forces them to collect two metrics or the insurance will reject the claim. That's why a nurse always gets your weight, temperature, and/or blood pressure regardless of the reason you're seeing a doctor.
- mikecsh 9y agoIn the UK (not an insurance-based system), many GPs ("family doctors") will aim to take a BP reading if there is time. This is partly because there is a system called the Quality Outcome Framework that incentivises practices to do so, but the route of it is that those incentives are in place because high blood pressure is extremely common, under-diagnosed, and has huge health consequences if left untreated, which in turn is extremely expensive for a national health service. A BP check is quick, simple, and cheap, and can help to identify problems early on when simpler interventions can stave off bad outcomes.
- slededit 9y agoHigh blood pressure has been a major problem in North America for decades. Its part of early screening.
- hellofunk 9y agoThey did that for me in Germany too. EU insurance.
- Spooky23 9y agoIf it’s medical and consistent, must be Billing and liability.
- Thriptic 9y agoTwo reasons. First, it's a clinical quality measure that needs to be collected by law. The government mandates that you collect certain data about X% of patients you are in contact with and transmit that data to relevant parties or else you will be penalized financially by Medicare. Also, BP, weight, and temperature are important diagnostic indicators
- dr_ 9y ago>The medical team was concerned that because Dr. Lown was having trouble swallowing, he was at risk for recurrent pneumonias. So we restricted his diet to purées. Soon the speech therapist recommended that we forbid him to ingest anything by mouth. Then the conversation spiraled into ideas for alternative feeding methods — a temporary tube through the nose followed, perhaps, by a feeding tube in the stomach. Maybe not the main point of this article, but there are numerous occasions where I’ve encountered just this. Allied health professionals, all of whom are very well intentioned, making recommendations that physicians readily follow without taking into consideration the needs or desires of the patient and family. If as a physician you are being advised to declare a patient NPO or to send them off to a skilled nursing facility instead of home - please remember that this is just a recommendation and that it’s your job to look at the patient as a whole, including their general medical condition, likelihood of their family supporting them, etc. before following through.
- da02 9y agoThis article might also help too: "Life in Yorkton before Medicare came along" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1269399/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1269399/
- OliverJones 9y agoLet's be careful about nostalgia for the "good old days" of medical practice. Keep in mind that standardizing medical care process has done more to get physicians to WASH THEIR HANDS than all kinds of exhortations about relationships, partnerships, and healing. And washing hands has, since Semmelweis's discoveries 150 years ago, been known as the easiest way to promote healing that medical people don't do. Why do the overnight shift of nurses take vital signs every four hours? So they catch rapid unexpected changes in patient conditions more quickly. Put more crudely, so they don't accidentally leave a corpse in a bed for the next shift. Having to write, or type, the patient's blood pressure into a log is a way to help the overnight nursing shift remember to pay detailed attention to each patient, at least for a few moments. If their instructions were "stop at each door and listen for the patient breathing" those nurses might well miss important changes. Hospital care these days is not only about the towering figure of the heroic superhuman doctor, Harvard Medical School lore to the contrary notwithstanding. It's about all the folks who look after patients, from the community primary care doctor to the RN, to the chaplain, to the "hospitalist" physician, to the person who cleans up, to the person who maintains all the electronic gear. The challenge is getting all these people to cooperate with the patient and for the patient's benefit. The superhuman healer approach to medicine demands superhuman people to be doctors. They aren't, any more than the rest of us are. They have to sleep, and to eat, and to see many patients. So, a good hospital needs to be organized like a good company: where each person's skills and passion complement the others, and gets an extraordinary result from a collection of ordinary people. The buzzword for that is "synergy." Good discipline--good and predictable process--is part of synergy. And, at the end of all that excellent care on our behalf, each and every one of us will become a corpse. A nineteen-year-old with a broken leg can be cured. A 90-year-old with cancer and pneumonia, not so much. It doesn't matter how towering a figure the doctor is, or how kind the nurse is. A radical move in medicine would be to come to terms with death as a natural part of life rather than as a failure of the system.
- candiodari 9y agoThis. Every healthcare system in the world needs to choose. We simply cannot have healthcare for everything, including rare, expensive and/or hopeless diseases (or all 3 at the same time). As long as that's what we demand, healthcare will go wrong. And let's please just stop pretending that this is somehow an America-only problem, caused by whatever (democrats: by not being public conservatives: by public largesse. And yes, despite how it sounds I do think both arguments have merit). True, America has it bad, but healthcare is failing, financially or otherwise everywhere in the developed world [1]. And healthcare in the non-developed world ... well, this was in the newspaper 2 days ago [2]. Healthcare is failing in the developed world for economic reasons. Those are not about to change, so it will get worse unless we figure this thing out with major changes (which ARE going to include limiting treatment). [1] https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-health-care-systems-on-life-support-special-report-drug-pricing-medicines-public-services/ https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-health-care-systems-o... or more specific https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/aug/16/nhs-cancels-thousands-of-operations-on-the-day-patients-association-study https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/aug/16/nhs-cancels-... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-01-03/frances-health-care-system-is-going-broke https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-01-03/frances-h... and let's just not mention Spain or Greece's health care system. [2] http://deredactie.be/cm/vrtnieuws.francais/Soci%25C3%25A9t%25C3%25A9/1.3151965 http://deredactie.be/cm/vrtnieuws.francais/Soci%25C3%25A9t%2...
- ageek123 9y ago"[W]e should curtail initial coursework in topics like genetics, developmental biology and biochemistry, making room for training in communication, interpersonal dynamics and leadership. Such skills would [...] strengthen our ability to advocate for health care as a human right and begin to rectify the broken economics and perverse incentives of the system." In other words, train doctors to be social justice activists rather than scientists? No thanks.
- abecedarius 9y ago> To restore balance between the art and the science of medicine, we should ... make room for training in communication, interpersonal dynamics and leadership. How would this help solve the problem the article started with, that patients don't heal because they're deprived of sleep by being woken up every 4 hours? It's a problem everyone knows about (I saw complaints about it online years ago) -- so it's not directly a communications problem. Leadership I can see: it seems needed to dig the system out of an inadequate equilibrium (https://equilibriabook.com/molochs-toolbox/ https://equilibriabook.com/molochs-toolbox/) but that's pretty different from college courses in leadership.
- ianai 9y agoProper communication includes proper action respecting that communication.
- aaavl2821 9y agoHealthcare in the US has left the era of the small business and is entering the era of the nameless corporation. What wal-mart did to all of the mom-and-pop shops is happening to healthcare. Except that instead of lowering prices, it is raising them Physicians have gone from small business owners to rank and file employees of large corporations. The burnout that is increasingly common among physicians is not unlike that of american office workers in the 1990s. I'd love for the next stage of the evolution of healthcare to see physicians as customer focused, tech savvy entrepreneurs
- bob_theslob646 9y agoArticle does not address the problem why the doctors' behave this way: insurance companies. Unfortunately, treating makes more money than curing and the United States is scared to death of what shall they do with all that free time if they actually do cure, while other countries do not work themselves to death because they do not have an artificially controlled supply of Doctors...
- robbiep 9y agoThis is an absurd and oft-repeated claim that taps into variations of the conspiracy thinking around 'doctors keeping the cure for cancer (or insert other condition here) secret' because powerful lobby groups insist that there is more money to be made in 'treating' than 'curing'. It is patently untrue. Firstly, it assumes that neither doctors, nor the scientists and researchers working in the companies and universities that drive medical progress forward, have an ounce of self-respect for either themselves, their family members or members of the community - because if true, either family members and themselves would never get cancer or other chronic diseases that we 'treat', or if they are somehow as vulnerable as the rest of the population to these conditions, that maybe there is a secret stash of 'cure' somewhere that they allow out to the people in the know. The conspiracy goes deep... Secondly, it throws out the window all the evidence around what we can actually cure and what health policy seeks to do. We have an entire field of medicine called preventative medicine that aims to stop conditions before they happen, by lobbying governments to ie. Ban or decrease rates of Smoking and alcoholism, to provide safe needle exchange so IV Drug Users don't get bloodborne diseases, to improve exercise rates, to provide vaccination programs - all of which stop disease from happening. The fact of modern life in a western country is that most of the burden of disease is related to lifestyle factors or age related - Osteoarthritis (Age and Obesity), Cancers (Lifestyle risks and age), Diabetes (Diet, exercise, genetics) Cardiovascular disease (Exercise, Age, Lifestyle risks, diet). It also ignores the tremendous advances that are still occuring. When I was in my final year of Medical school, 5 years ago, Metastatic Melanoma was a condition with an average survival of 6 months. It is now (thanks to some incredible, and incredibly expensive drugs - don't get into a debate about cost here, I live and practice in Australia and the cost for a patient is capped at $46.60 per year as it is on the PBS) more of a chronic disease with average survival in the 4-5 year range. Incredible, and this progress occured in 5 years. Similarly, Hepatitis C, a condition that in it's chronic form invariably results in liver cirrhosis and failure, can now be cured - this was unthinkable 5 years ago, and is now a fact, with a 12 week course of medicine. Please inform yourself and don't just trumpet that which you hear on the internet. Your ignorance is not as valid as my knowledge and to assume that in your version of this myth that insurance companies (but in the more common version of this myth, Doctors, Pharmaceutical Companies etc) are primarially interested in keeping the population teetering on the edge to milk them dry is disingenuous.
- bawana 9y agoHospitals should post prices of their procedures in the lobby. A surgeon gets $500 to repair a hernia and the hospital pulls in $5k for the ancillary services. The surgeon has to see the patient,make the diagnosis, provide the treatment, provide the aftercare and be the 'face'. The hospital-insurance complex has managed to create this fantasy world with complicated rules and somehow have sequestered themselves from the free market. They set their own prices and by virtue of being of local monopolies thwart the ability of the individual to choose. Hospitals have become like cable companies.
- geomark 9y agoWhere I live that is the case. Prices are not only made available, they are often advertised on websites and even on TV. Just one example of how it is done here https://www.bumrungrad.com/en/womens-center-obgyn-thailand/packages/delivery https://www.bumrungrad.com/en/womens-center-obgyn-thailand/p...
- savanaly 9y agoIt's not like hospitals are wildly profitable to run though? I think the inflated costs are due to the little understood phenomenon of "cost disease" rather than owners of hospitals extracting outrageous rent for themselves as I think you are implying.
- adventured 9y agoYou're correct about the spread of cost disease, it has essentially reached every corner of US healthcare. The part that hospitals are particularly guilty of, is unnecessary admin expense inflation. The US education system has seen an almost identical problem. Building buildings that aren't needed, hiring 10x the admin staff that the system had 30 or 40 years ago, etc. It's the system rewarding itself, bureaucrats hiring more bureaucrats, playing lords as they go on building sprees that aren't needed. There are very few readily available levers in the US healthcare system, that can be used to properly pull back against such cost spirals and spending behavior.
- 9y ago
- rdiddly 9y agoSo once again, and as usual, the missing ingredient ends up being human leadership, not technology.
- maxthegeek1 9y agoStupid.
- maxthegeek1 9y agostupid
- dang 9y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ardualabs 9y agoAs a survivor of stage IV cancer, I can say my experience strongly mirrors that. I would go further to say that the assembly/widget mentality in a health care setting made it difficult for some of the staff to see me as a human. Abuse or care-full neglect (is that a thing? working on the words) is, in my experience at least, common. It's not to say I don't appreciate being alive, but we can do better for those suffering.
- zoom6628 9y agoStories like this are not uncommon in so-called developed countries. Makes you realise why medical tourism industry does so well. From my own experience i would prefer to return to Guangzhou or Shanghai for procedures rather than anywhere else. Not really that much cheaper but at least i can determine up front the size of the bill. Added to that is that in spite of factory-scale medical care in China(remember there are basically no private medical practices - all doctors are linked with hospitals), they are actual (in my personal experience) quite caring and dont charge unnecessarily. But as with all things YMMV.
- jhanschoo 9y agoIt is a nice coincidence that a video by an educational YouTube channel Kurzgesagt discusses homeopathy and why it still remains popular—hypothesizing that one reason may be that their practicioners pay good attention and affection to their patients. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8HslUzw35mc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8HslUzw35mc
- Froyoh 9y agoImagine if something like "Chinese Citizens, Revolt" appeared in the headlines.
- JasonFruit 9y agoThis article and the comments here combine to illustrate for me the difficulty of making healthcare work in all the different ways it has to. I read the article, and I think, "Yeah! That's the kind of healthcare I want!" I read the comments with contrary opinions, and I think, "Those are great points — these counter-intuitive practices make sense when you need healthcare to scale." I talk to my wife, a physician, and I hear about what results in the rare cases when these protocols and consultations don't happen, and I think it's a wonder that hospitals function at all. I think it's not a matter of finding the solution to the problem, but a maximization problem, where we have: - patients who need to be cared for as human beings and allowed to make their own informed decisions, but who are generally not experts in medicine - physicians who have more patients than they can keep in their minds at once, and who are reliant on nurses and computerized systems to keep patients breathing and not get sued, but who are also skilled, highly-educated professionals whose human judgment is frequently superior to any algorithm - nurses who are both underpaid and responsible for more than their training considered - hospitals that need to pay the bills, pay salaries, attract new physicians, etc. There are so many conflicting aspects of this problem that any simple solution is probably unrealistic.