4 ms·
"Minimum wage was created specifically to stop abuse of large numbers of people." Yes, but A: goals and effects are two very different things and B: it was cre
by jerf 16y ago
"Minimum wage was created specifically to stop abuse of large numbers of people."
Yes, but A: goals and effects are two very different things and B: it was created in an increasingly foreign world and every year it is less obvious that the original logic holds. (I mean that in a very general sense, not in an immediate "discard minimum wage and return to a libertarian paradise" sense; as robots become more and more capable and really start eating into the low wage jobs we may have to consider things like guaranteed minimum incomes or other radical proposals.)
"Employers as a rule extract a multiple of value from their employees time, not just a little bit over."
In my opinion, not if you do a full accounting. Profit margins for established, successful companies in the vast majority of industries tend to run in the single digits percentages, bursting up to 10% or the low teens for some rare cases. And then there's the tech industry, which is another story altogether. It may be true in some abstract sense that companies extract multiples of value over what they pay but it isn't true in a useful sense.
Generally speaking, I deny that there's a huge amount of room for people to cut minimum wages, because employers do not make radical profits on their employees. The job market isn't perfectly efficient, but it's more efficient than that. A person/task that can't justify minimum wage in the modern economy is a person not hired and a position not created, not a person generating 2$/hr of value but forcibly paid minimum wage.
Now, if the economy was grotesquely inefficient and the average company made 200% profit and the only way to pry money out of their hands was with a minimum wage, I'd agree, but that's not the world we live in. It's certainly a world we hear about a lot in propaganda but it doesn't correspond to reality.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoI have to agree with jacquesm here. You're right that many homeless individuals can't produce a minimum wage's worth of value for an employer, and you're right that the requirement of a minimum wage then makes it nearly impossible for them to get work that has any chance of improving their situation. However, jacquesm is right that the minimum wage exists as a lower threshold that prevents the exploitation of workers, and that's as true today as it was in the 1920s. Reducing or abolishing the minimum wage would certainly lead to powerful economic deflation, and while that looks great on paper, in reality it leads to lots more homeless and poor people. In practice, game theory does not apply to economics as often as theorists think it does. For example, you'd think that if some employer wasn't offering a decent wage, then they'd be unable to get workers, so they're forced to maintain the same wages as everyone else. However, eventually there will be an economic depression like the one we have now, and that will result in huge numbers of able employees, and a ripe opportunity for would-be employers to exploit that situation in a way that wouldn't fix itself for decades. I am an employer. And, yes, although my margins are ridiculously thin after you count up all the money that goes in to everything, the truth still is that I do make sure I get multiples of value from my employees (or contractors); otherwise, I simply wouldn't bother having them. Homelessness and the problems of the poor are something that I think about a lot, and as I said, I have no idea what the solutions are. I do know that merely reducing or eliminating minimum wage requirements -- even only for their specific case -- is not a viable solution.
- thaumaturgy 16y ago> I have no idea what the solutions are. ...actually, that's not quite true. I think I know of one solution, I just don't talk about it much because it's unrealistic. But here goes: the real colonization of space. I think that extreme poverty and conflict are symptoms of a deeper problem in human societies. Unfortunately, at this stage of our technological development, human economies must be continually and steadily growing in order to be "healthy" (low rates of unemployment, reasonable consumer price indexes, low homelessness, etc.). Further, while it's theoretically possible that the planet could support vastly greater human populations, you must take into account human territorialism, cultural divides, and other social-psychological factors. So, in practice, it's hard to imagine the planet supporting, say, twice as many humans, in peaceful conditions, at our current moral and psychological development. So, there's a kind of "rebound" effect in population growth: rather than trying to grow in the most efficient, compact manner possible, human populations tend instead to grow and explore as quickly as possible, until some barrier stops the growth. When that happens, two interesting effects seem to occur: the barrier area tends to develop denser populations, and the original population centers tend to decay. Also, you have individuals (and groups of individuals) that tend to vastly out-produce the rest of their society. This is one of the parts of the engine that causes human population growth. However, it also has a tendency to create greater efficiency, which both takes advantage of the poor as well as creates more poor people. (There is a counter-argument that this also leads to better living conditions for the poor, and it's true, but that doesn't resolve the much greater economic divide between the various socio-economic classes.) If these industrialists don't have some kind of frontier to grow into, then they inadvertently magnify the problems of barrier growth: they create lots of wealth for a small group, at the expense of a much larger group. This is a very poor, hasty description, but the basic essence of it all is that at this point humans simply need some frontier to expand into in order to maintain reasonably healthy societies, and we don't have one. I don't think we'll be getting one anytime soon, so I expect the human condition to get a little grim for the next century or so.
- arghnoname 16y agoWhy not colonize the ocean floor instead or as well? I'd be as excited as anyone if we were colonizing space. If humanity survives long enough and manages to avoid too many dark ages, it is an inevitability, but at the present time, doing so would be terribly expensive. I'm not sure if you could honestly classify spending trillions of dollars on space colonization is the best way to allocate resources for a poverty reduction program. In some distant future where such things _are_ financial feasible or necessary, I would imagine that economic opportunities would be traded to the earlier pioneers who would suffer under what would surely be difficult and dangerous circumstances.
- jacquesm 16y agoIf minimum wage was not needed today we'd see nobody earning minimum wage, but only people making comfortably above it. As long as there are plenty of people earning just minimum wage we need minimum wage. You can't argue that if we removed or lowered the minimum wage that employers would not take advantage of that and would reduce the pay of those that currently earn minimum wage given that evidence.
- grandalf 16y agoBased on the normal distribution of worker skills there will aways be plenty of people earning just minimum wage, but you can't infer that far more people are earning $6/hour at a $6/hour minimum wage than would be earning that wage if no minimum wage existed. Such large scale market inefficiencies would not last for long. Surely there will be some workers who are paid marginally more because of minimum wage laws, but not much more. Because of the large quantity of low paid workers, the gains from automation are significant. One wheat combine does the work of thousands of laborers. Firms do not "take advantage" any more than workers do. Surely some workers would be paid somewhat less without minimum wage, but surely more people would be employed, gaining skills and experience, etc. Who really knows what the impact of this would be on various industries over time. The modern world has done away with low skilled manufacturing jobs (which might have been the first rung on a ladder to more skilled jobs) and replaced hundreds of thousands of workers with a far smaller number of robots. Most advocates of minimum wage prefer to look at the world as a single slice of time in which it's obvious that someone is benefitting from the policy. Over a longer period of time, the benefit is far more difficult to detect and the case for minimum wage evaporates. Imagine a world in which people could be hired for $2 per hour (where that's all their skills were worth). The state could simply subsidize their paid work. Then it's not a welfare system but a subsidized job training program. Far preferable both for outcomes and for the self identity of those working in the program.
- jacquesm 16y ago> Based on the normal distribution of worker skills there will aways be plenty of people earning just minimum wage Why? Wasn't the wage you made supposed to be based on the value you added? Or has that argument gone out the window? I really don't see any reason why there ought to be a normal distribution of wages. Also, the wages are not distributed that way at all, it's a power law distribution, relatively large numbers of people make little money and relatively few people an enormous amount. > but you can't infer that far more people are earning $6/hour at a $6/hour minimum wage than would be earning that wage if no minimum wage existed. Sure you can. That's unassailable logic. Every person earning minimum wage is a datapoint that you can use as evidence. How many people do you suppose are earning minimum wage right now? > Such large scale market inefficiencies would not last for long. In countries without minimum wage they last up to today, in countries with they lasted up to the moment that minimum wage was introduced. > Surely some workers would be paid somewhat less without minimum wage, but surely more people would be employed, gaining skills and experience, etc. Right. You mean "would be locked in to wages below subsistence level without much chance of improvement". Gaining skills and experience doing what? Flipping burgers? Checking out at the register? > Who really knows what the impact of this would be on various industries over time. Shareholder value would increase :) > The modern world has done away with low skilled manufacturing jobs (which might have been the first run on a ladder to more skilled jobs) and replaced hundreds of thousands of workers with a far smaller number of robots. You must live in a different world than the one where I live. Where I live we've outsourced those manufacturing jobs to places where there is no minimum wage and there is a disregard to job safety and public health. And in more than just a few cases where there is no age limit for full time work either. > Imagine a world in which people could be hired for $2 per hour (where that's all their skills were worth). Imagine a world in which people could be hired for $7 per hour (where that's all their skills were worth). We already live in that world. So firms do take advantage. > Firms do not "take advantage" any more than workers do. Right. Workers have yet to take advantage of their employers in a single instance, whereas employers have historically abused their workers routinely and still do so today in many places, and would do so in many more given the chance. The worst thing a worker can do is to strike. And that is - in most places - a government protected right. Coincidentially, most of the places where you can't legally strike also don't have a minimum wage. Really, I can see a lot of advantages to Capitalism but there are limits to what it can achieve and if it was a perfect system then we wouldn't need minimum wage, and we wouldn't need unions either. In the real world, unfortunately, we need both. Capitalism is like democracy, it's not perfect but it seems to be the best we've got. Hopefully in the longer term it will turn out that we can and will do better. Then, on top of all that there is one more factor. The minimum wage sets the base level for all other wages. There would be a tremendous knock-on effect from removing the minimum wage. When minimum wage was introduced everybody benefited (well, except for the highest segment, maybe).