6 ms·
More simply, Facebook will change when users stop using it. People vote with their time and attention. Many complain about Facebook's stance towards privacy or
by jseliger 9y ago
More simply, Facebook will change when users stop using it. People vote with their time and attention. Many complain about Facebook's stance towards privacy or whatever, but they say one thing and then go back to using it (yes, I know, you, the person about to reply, you are different; that's great, but you're statistically invisible).
Facebook measures how people behave, not what pundits say.
- IntronExon 9y agoyes, I know, you, the person about to reply, you are different; that's great, but you're statistically invisible Sort of like non-smokers in the fifties, but times change. More predictable and depressing than people who don’t use FB chiming in are the people who have endless rationalizations for why they need it. Often the reasons boil down to “network effects” which fits with the tendency of some here to cite Tragedy of The Commoms whenever a hard problem crops up.
- ryandrake 9y agoI’m so tired of the “I won’t know about my friends’ parties without Facebook” excuse. If you don’t have even enough IRL contact with them, or contact through other channels, to discover all these parties, then... well... hate to break it to you but they might not really be friends. Willing to admit I’m wrong though. I just don’t think FB is as necessary as you think it is. How did you all manage to have social lives before FB existed?
- dragonwriter 9y agoPeople had social lives before phones existed; people without phones were socially disadvantaged when the common norm became to communicate by phone. Social interaction mechanisms are pretty much the poster child for network effects, where using what other people are using matters a lot to utility.
- IntronExon 9y agoI think your argument works better as s comparison between mediums, such as telephone vs. letters/meetings and telephone vs. internet. Despite what they would like, FB is not the medium.
- dragonwriter 9y agoNetwork effects aren't just between mediums as you are defining them: one might call “the internet” a medium, but it's clear that someone using the internet but not Facebook is as locked out and disadvantaged if social communication is occurring on FB as someone who isn't using the internet at all.
- IntronExon 9y agoIt isn’t clear to me at all, given the wealth of options. Someone using an encrypted messenger for example, strikes me as being quite connected.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Someone using an encrypted messenger for example, strikes me as being quite connected. To the network of people using a compatible encrypted messenger, not to people using "the internet" in some generic sense. Network effects definitely apply to each of the options at the level that they have their own network (e.g., "email" is a network, to the extent that it is interoperable; "Facebook" and any particular encrypted messaging system are each their own networks. The utility of each is determined largely by how many and which other people are using them and what those other people are using them for.)
- KozmoNau7 9y agoNo, FB is not necessary to keep up with events (10-15 concerts/month for me, on average), but it makes it a lot easier and more convenient, especially if you follow the relevant venues and artists. It makes it very easy to invite other people to come along. I pull my FB list of upcoming events via CalDAV to my local calendar, for local handling of reminders. So yes, I could invite people manually, but it would be a bit of a mess. FB has all the artists and all the venues in one place. The convenience should not be underestimated.
- IntronExon 9y agoI guess you have to ask yourself is supporting FB and ceding your privacy is worth it for... convenience.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoIt's a choice everyone has to make for themselves. I have absolutely nothing on Facebook that isn't related to either bands or musical venues.
- johnnybones 9y agoThis is it, in a nutshell. I wish I had a dollar for everyone I've heard or read about, complaining about Facebook, yet they continue to use it. People treat it like it's mandatory, or something. Just dump it, already.
- dade_ 9y agoI also really annoy my friends. Essentially Facebook has redefined a friend as someone that will still bother to contact you and invite you to things even though you aren't on Facebook. Banner adds since I switched to Android this year were interesting as I used to use my gmail account for FB. First, a week of banner ads saying "come back to Facebook"; Very Uber-creepy. Then a week of sign up for Instagram! Followed by a week of "Facebook messenger doesn't require a facebook account!" which I don't understand. At that point, I created a new Google account and deleted my old one. Now I see ads for foot fungus!
- dieterrams 9y ago> "Facebook messenger doesn't require a facebook account!" which I don't understand. You can actually sign up for a Messenger account independently of a Facebook account. However, this doesn't seem to be well supported. There is no way that I can tell to delete a Messenger-only account, or to remove contacts that were automatically uploaded from your phone.
- jimmies 9y agoBad news for you: when you use Messenger without a Facebook account, Facebook still makes a Facebook account for you. It's just invisible to you and maybe they don't want you to have the impression that it is, indeed, just a Facebook account. I could trigger Messenger to log in to your shadow Facebook account. It will work mostly like a regular account with the exception you (mostly) can't interact with your friends. I reported it as a security bug last year. Somehow after I reported it, the app doesn't do it anymore. Fb security took another 6 months to discard it as a security bug. I was too disappointed by how much they cared, so I don't even bother to make a blog post about that. I trust both Facebook and Facebook security less after working with them. I don't have a Messenger only account anymore (but then, my Messenger-only account was never deleted). But do they care? Probably not. Do I care? Maybe - but what can I do about it? Here is the draft that I wrote up but didn't publish about the experience: https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSa-LjM5IzyTWJuD1rDj6H9v0gBafi_cNZ7zQZkbpwDf6qIzXXv3jutgfLcDF6jpLfk7CaJKgtLGy5H/pub https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSa-LjM5IzyTWJuD...
- fnayr 9y agoMy problem as a mobile developer is being practically required to use it to not hinder my app's adoption rate. My personal facebook has been disabled for 9 months and I had to recently reactivate it because you can't have an app (for using their auth) without a personal account. So yeah until the network effect they have changes (the majority leave), people are "trapped" using it.
- taytus 9y agoThey are not, and neither are you. It may affect the adoption rate of your app if you don't include a "login with facebook" option, maybe. But that is a small price we all have to pay to influence change.
- alexdrans 9y agoHaha, you first.
- nugi 9y agoThis is the kind of comment that really hits hard how unwilling tech workers are to stand up for ethics. "My cog in the machine is not hurting anyone, why should I care" is how things get very, very bad.
- leetcrew 9y agoit's more like "I am a tiny replaceable cog in a huge money-printing machine. if somebody is going to collect the paycheck anyway, why shouldn't it be me?" making the hard choice is easy when you have nothing to lose, and it's even easier when you're so rich that the losses don't matter. the folks in the middle have just enough that it would really hurt to lose it. I can't say I blame them for guarding that jealously.
- taytus 9y agoI'm already doing it ;-)
- 9y ago
- at-fates-hands 9y ago> More simply, Facebook will change when users stop using it. While I totally agree with this, I'm wondering where that tipping point would be with them. They have (depending on who you believe) somewhere north of 200 million users with some estimates in the 500 million range. Does losing 100 million users impact them at all or their bottom line? At what point do you think they would actually start changing? How much revenue would they have to lose before they started to make noticeable reforms?
- v_lisivka 9y agoI already see that users are moving out of FaceBook. FakeBook is not delivering value it promised. Some my friends are banned by FB, some are just not using it anymore. I personally was hit by FB moderators because of comment with few first lines from well known poem («Katerina» by Shevchenko, circa 1838). Moderators deny that first, then stop responding, so they know that they are doing wrong and still doing that. Moreover, I noticed that my comments with links to laws and court decisions on government sites were silently marked as spam and hidden by FB. Moderators are helped me once to fix that, then it happens again and again, and FB refuses to fix that. I made backup accounts on G+ and local social networks just in case I will be banned again by FB for posting well known poems or links to laws. I see also that traffic is increased a bit on these sites. I also looking for way to setup my own node of a federated social network, such as Mastodon or PeerTube, but they are too heavyweight.
- BartBoch 9y agoI think this might have a snowball effect. The new disruptor will appear that will initiate a huge shift in users. Facebook will have no time to react quickly enough, which will cost them some chunk of core users. The new platform, since it will be "new" and will initially fix all the Facebook problems will become a cool thing, magnet. Since some core users will be already using it, they will take users with them. Snap had a chance of becoming that but lost. Let us wait for a new disruptor. This is a very dangerous game, with a lot to lose. It was the same with any other, now dead, giant on the web. Only because people are still using Facebook now, does not mean, that as soon as a worthy competitor will appear, people will move et masse. Facebook is a necessity now, but it might be not, for example, tomorrow.
- naravara 9y ago>The new disruptor will appear that will initiate a huge shift in users. Kind of. But it shouldn't be a mental model where something like Facebook, but better, comes along. Rather, you should expect something that fulfills the same emotional, practical need or occupies time that makes people use Facebook less, but fulfills a need that better clicks with what people want. As an analogy, consider how Apple and Microsoft flipped places. It's not that Mac OS was like Windows but better and supplanted them. Rather, smartphones changed the game in such a way that Microsoft's core strengths didn't seem so strong anymore. Apple was able to innovate in such a way because of their DNA as a design focused product company, but those strengths didn't get to shine until the paradigm shifted to favor cohesive product experiences rather than versatile software platforms. So the thing that supplants Facebook won't look like Facebook, it'll be some better way to keep in touch with people from previous walks of life, get in arguments with your distant family members, and share photos. And it won't happen all at once either. It'll probably sit as some obscure niche for a while as it slowly refines itself and evolves.
- RestlessMind 9y agoIt actually happened in the form of whatsapp and Snapchat. Facebook tried to acquire both, succeeded with former and somewhat successful copied the later.
- 9y ago
- c0mments 9y ago>> Facebook measures how people behave, not what pundits say. Not that I am disagreeing, but I once read an essay by a famous economist who pointed out that criminals are not as stupid as people think they are because their behavior makes a lot of economic sense if they can lower their risk of getting caught. Combine that with the "1% of turnover" fine that FB copped from the EU, and you can see how they can get away with this kind of stuff. When you think about it, FB is doing a sort of "micro-doxing" of its user base on a regular basis. But since it happens invisibly, and over a long time frame, they are generally getting away scot free. One day it will catch up to them, and you will start to see folks who worked at FB trying to hide that fact from their resume.
- stepvhen 9y agoi deleted my facebook last year and i tell everyone i can at every opportunity to do so as well. statistically invisible isnt actually invisible. whats frustrating is blogs and comments that carry an air that facebook can change in the user's favor, much less that it ever will. i have read quite a few complaints myself that backtrack once it gets to presenting a positive, constructive solution to the problem (i.e. deleting your facebook) and suggest that facebook can be used by users for their benefit if users change their behavior. this puts an insurmountable burden on users to change a product that they are not in any way shape or form in control of. truly the only thing users have in their control regarding facebook is whether or not they have and/or use an account. deleting facebook is exhibiting control, and i believe everyone should do so.
- aplorbust 9y agoIt appears that the "statistically invisible" commenter is at the forefront of your thoughts, to an extent where you feel the need to address her/him specifically. "Many people vote with their time and attention." . Of course. We could argue that you have voted with your comment. The "statistically invisible" commenter got your time and attention (=vote). "Facebook measures how people behave, not what pundits say." There is a saying that goes something like, "What you measure you can control." It follows that what the "pundits" posit outside of Facebook is not something Facebook can control. Its simple. Users and non-users will stop publishing comments about Facebook when Facebook loses popularity.