5 ms·
Sadly the biggest problems with Electron are not yet solved: 1) There is no way to separate the Electron engine from your app, so you have to bundle Chrome and
by pier25 9y ago
Sadly the biggest problems with Electron are not yet solved:
1) There is no way to separate the Electron engine from your app, so you have to bundle Chrome and Node with each app.
2) Electron has an autoUpdater API, but since Electron doesn't solve the installation/updates problem e2e (packager + installer + updates server) it's really a half baked solution. This is specially bad in Windows since Squirrel for Windows is in my experience a disaster.
I have a number of Electron apps in production, internally and for our customers, and for our next desktop project we won't be using Electron.
The idea of using web technologies for the UI is still very valid IMO, but considering the 2 previous problems it's way less of a headache to just make our own native wrapper in C# and Swift (sorry Linux) and finally distribute the app via the official stores. At least for our use case.
- solarkraft 9y agoOr release it as a web application and let the user use chrome's "add do desktop" ... I don't like that you're dropping Linux compatibility, but understand the the reasoning.
- pier25 9y agoWe've done that on mobile, but most of users don't even know that feature exists and another big chunk still don't trust a website vs an app. I've never seen this feature in desktop. Closes thing I know are these "hosted web app" in Windows 10. https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/porting/hwa-create-windows#step-1-pick-a-website-url https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/porting/hwa-cre...
- jamesgeck0 9y agoThe feature is only available in the Windows and Linux versions of Chrome. https://www.lifewire.com/create-shortcuts-in-google-chrome-for-windows-4103617 https://www.lifewire.com/create-shortcuts-in-google-chrome-f...
- gilrain 9y agoI've been using the Sciter bindings for Rust, lately. It might be worth a look if you want a more performant option for a HTML/CSS GUI. The documentation is pretty rough, though. https://sciter.com/ https://sciter.com/ https://github.com/sciter-sdk/rust-sciter https://github.com/sciter-sdk/rust-sciter
- clarkmoody 9y agoInteresting. Any indication of why Sciter seems to be the go-to UI framework for antivirus software?
- nickpsecurity 9y agoI appreciate you sharing that more for their shared-source licensing model than anything else. I don't have many examples of paid source to draw on in those discussions.
- justin66 9y ago> 1) There is no way to separate the Electron engine from your app, so you have to bundle Chrome and Node with each app. I'm really curious (as a non-Electron developer) why that's a problem at all, let alone a big problem. You have to provide the entire package, but you have control over what the user gets and ultimately, what you'll have to support.
- olympus 9y agoIt means a lot of extra space. You are duplicating installations of Chrome and Node for each Electron app that is installed, instead of having one install and each app using the common dependency. So yes, the developer gets complete control over which version of Chrome and Node is used, but you end up with a 150 MB text editor, a 150 MB chat app, and a 150 MB music streaming app, when you could probably get all three done with 152 MB using common dependencies.
- baby 9y agoI'm not sure that would fix the problem since the common dependencies would still be having to store different versions of Chrome.
- benologist 9y agoI think it worked pretty well for NPM where there was the high possibility of duplication between the modules you depend on and the additional modules required by them.
- overcast 9y agoIs storage space really that big of a concern, with many multiple terabyte drives being commonplace? Out of all of the issues with electron, I don't think wasting 150MB is one of them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- skrowl 9y agoSince you're doing .NET have you looked at https://github.com/AvaloniaUI/Avalonia https://github.com/AvaloniaUI/Avalonia for cross platform UIs? I haven't messed with it, but it just hit beta and I was hoping for some insights.
- bobwaycott 9y agoAvaloniaUI is only in alpha right now. Also, until there is integration with the native menu bar on macOS, it’s a non-starter for Mac apps[0]. [0]: Judging solely on the screenshots provided, which show a menu bar inside the app window on macOS. I’m sure things will improve with time.
- kekekeks 9y ago>AvaloniaUI is only in alpha right now Beta was released a week ago, actually - http://avaloniaui.net/blog/2018-02-18-avalonia-beta1.html http://avaloniaui.net/blog/2018-02-18-avalonia-beta1.html
- dugmartin 9y agoSadly all of this was solved years ago with Adobe Air (single engine, real automated updates, plus a more sane Javascript syntax with AS3). I haven't used it in years but I just took a quick look and the last release was today - https://labs.adobe.com/downloads/air.html https://labs.adobe.com/downloads/air.html I know there is a lot of Flash hate out there but Air+Flex(+FlashDevelop) was a pretty nice solution for building , debugging and distributing cross platform apps.
- zach43 9y agoMaybe I’m remembering this wrong, but doesn’t Adobe Air work on Windows and macOS only? I was trying to install an Adobe Air app on a Linux machine a while back and ran into this problem.
- dugmartin 9y agoThey stopped Linux support in 2011 - https://helpx.adobe.com/air/kb/install-air-2-64-bit.html https://helpx.adobe.com/air/kb/install-air-2-64-bit.html
- zwetan 9y agosupport has stopped true but it does not prevent to publish on Linux desktop targeting AIR 2.6 ironically you can also embed Flash into an Electron app to use the latest v28 runtime other workaround exists with the latest NPAPI that you can embed in a C++ app (like good old WxWidgets)
- pier25 9y agoI was a Flash dev for years, and then kept on doing Adobe Air apps for museums and mobile. Adobe dropped the ball on it pretty quick once HTML5 went mainstream. New features and bug fixes take ages. I still think AS3 is one of the best languages I've ever used. It was really ahead of its time.
- zwetan 9y ago