3 ms·
It's an interesting pattern. Frankly I think I may have rubbed enough people the wrong way over time across a thousand discussions that I've got a following of
by adventured 9y ago
It's an interesting pattern. Frankly I think I may have rubbed enough people the wrong way over time across a thousand discussions that I've got a following of persistent downvoters. My simple reply one level above you is currently enjoying the downvote parade.
A year ago, I rarely to never saw that kind of pattern, now every other thing I post is instantly downvoted, usually aggressively (even simple questions). I don't know what to make of it, except it drives me to not want to participate in discussions here.
The biggest downvote parade I think I've ever received on this site, was for defending gay rights a few months back. I upset a bunch of downvoters by discussing the facts of inequality globally around gay marriage (emphasis on that I was relying on facts, not emotional argumentation). How do you deal with that kind of intellectual mob mentality however? Do you ask for an explanation from the downvoters, or do you just leave the voting unchallenged? Sometimes it seems so bizarre, I can't help but ask.
- IntronExon 9y agoI don’t know what you’re experiencing, but this leaped out at me. ...except it drives me to not want to participate in discussions here. Sounds like the purpose of the behavior you’re describing.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI appear to be the only woman to have ever made the leaderboard (under a different handle). I absolutely get downvotes that I suspect boil down to "shut up, bitch." I have handled it by doing some of the following things: 1. Make sure I am actually being respectful and not an asshole. 2. Walk the fuck away and shut up sometimes. 3. I left for 18 months, to work on my issues and to give someone breathing room that I had friction with whom I felt saw me as personally threatening. I didn't have specific plans to return. I did return in part because posting something one day went better than I expected. 4. Drop it from my end when there is personal friction. This gets vastly better results when I point out someone is behaving poorly towards me. Sometimes they listen. If they don't, the mods (and community as a whole) are much more likely to be sympathetic if I am not putting out the fire with gasoline. I routinely comment on hot button topics. I have extremely controversial views on some things. But I go out of my way to not piss on people to the best of my ability. This has included changing my handle after hitting the leaderboard because I concluded that it didn't matter that it wasn't chosen as a feminist handle. What matters is that it is an overwhelmingly male forum and I want no appearance of impropriety as the first woman on the leaderboard. The perception of disrespect became apparent to me and was not something I wanted. So I started over. I am vastly more satisfied with posting under this handle. Lots of people recognize me as also being Mz. So the difference is not due to being anonymous. (This comment is not comprehensive. Just a nutshell version of 8.5 years of navigating an overwhelmingly male forum while posting as openly female.)
- dragonwriter 9y agoI'd normally leave something that is already this meta alone with just an upvote, but even though I've often clashed with you on this board, I had to comment to say this is the best advice on handling downvotes I have ever seen posted on HN and I kind of wish it (well, at least the #1, #2, and #4; #3 is probably to specific to the specific circumstances to work as any kind of general guideine) would be attached to the commenting guidelines.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThank you. #3 is probably to specific to the specific circumstances to work as any kind of general guideine) I can think of some folks who would be better off taking a break and sorting their personal problems rather than continuing to piss and moan about what meanies the mods are or whatever. I am far from the only person here whose personal issues are sometimes a significant part of the problem.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I can think of some folks who would be better off taking a break and sorting their personal problems rather than continuing to piss and moan about what meanies the mods are or whatever. I am far from the only person here whose personal issues are sometimes a significant part of the problem. Oh, I certainly agree; what I meant would perhaps be more clearly expressed as "#3 probably has more need of rewriting into a more general form before being included as a general guideline"; recognizing and, where appropriate, taking an extended break to address personal issues is something that makes a good bit of general advice, the other three were just more in a form that worked as general advice without rewriting from the account of what had worked for you than that one was, IMO.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYeah, I agree that I would not want official guidelines to sound like "The problem is you and we wish you would go the fuck away and stop bothering us." Which number 3 could easily sound like if not stated very carefully.