4 ms·
Probably because research dating back to 1980s (see Peopleware) shows that shared offices are objectively less productive and result in less happy workforce?
by izacus 9y ago
Probably because research dating back to 1980s (see Peopleware) shows that shared offices are objectively less productive and result in less happy workforce?
- kerkeslager 9y agoDid that research make any attempt to distinguish between extroverts and introverts in the workforce? Because if it didn't, it is irrelevant to the post chain you're responding to.
- drstewart 9y agoSo the fact that I'd prefer an open plan office over private offices is? What? I'm lying?
- izacus 9y agoWhy would you be lying? It seems more like either of: - You're mixing up the difference between personal preferences of an individual and emergent results of groups of people. - The fact that you prefer something doesn't mean it's best for general productivity (or even your productivity for that matter).
- dalyons 9y agoIt’s been awhile since I read it, so correct me if I’m wrong, but I thought peopleware was advocating for the same as the GP - mixed spaces that suit the individual preferences of teams/individuals.
- izacus 9y agoIt was advocating for more old Microsoft-style layout, with a few smallish private offices (2-4 people IIRC) and common spaces for debates/planning/socializing between them.
- Marazan 9y agoI find the small private offices (say 4 people) the worst of all worlds.
- dasmoth 9y agoVery much depends on the people. Two people can work okay, the chance of adding someone incompatible increases rapidly from there. There seems a lot of reluctance to give the worker bees privacy. I don’t know if it’s a status thing or a “how do I know whether they’re goofing off on HN” thing. Maybe it amounts to the same issue.
- ken 9y agoThe experiment I remember from Peopleware (at Cornell, IIRC?) is that some people preferred quiet and some people did not, but when measured they all were more efficient at completing tasks in the quiet environment.