3 ms·
It really irritates me when "GMO" is categorically touted as beneficial or harmful. Each modification has to be evaluated individually, there is no blanket asse
by phkahler 9y ago
It really irritates me when "GMO" is categorically touted as beneficial or harmful. Each modification has to be evaluated individually, there is no blanket assessment for GMO in general.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis is a Syngenta/Monsanto sponsored website, it would be very surprising if they had anything critical to say about GMO.
- CreRecombinase 9y agoDo you have a source for that?
- jacquesm 9y agoAlready linked elsewhere in the thread: https://www.motherjones.com/food/2012/02/atrazine-syngengta-tyrone-hayes-jon-entine/ https://www.motherjones.com/food/2012/02/atrazine-syngengta-... Domain Name: GENETICLITERACYPROJECT.ORG Registry Registrant ID: C100814327-LROR Registrant Name: Jon Entine Registrant Organization: ESG MediaMetrics Registrant Street: 6255 So. Clippinger Dr. Note that both sides of the GMO debate are playing tricks and that it is usually good to research the source a bit before becoming an unwitting footsoldier in either army.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoI googled it for you... http://www.truthwiki.org/genetic-literacy-project/ http://www.truthwiki.org/genetic-literacy-project/ https://www.motherjones.com/food/2012/02/atrazine-syngengta-tyrone-hayes-jon-entine/ https://www.motherjones.com/food/2012/02/atrazine-syngengta-...
- kickout 9y agoIts a joint website amongst all the multinational players in the GMO space (Bayer, Dupont, Syngenta, Monsanto, BASF, etc.). It may look like a biased source, its not too bad. Most of the opinions/articles are backed by peer reviewed research. I think the purpose of the site it to put faces/ human touch on people that work directly with this stuff. Not some faceless corporation
- jacquesm 9y agoNo, the purpose is to be a PR vehicle to promote GMO. Peer reviewed research can be cherry picked to promote one view or another. There was a time when 'peer reviewed research' was a badge of merit that would lead to general unquestioned acceptance. But when this was noticed and subsequently weaponized it became just another weapon in the arsenal of companies. Here is another nice example of this (Big Tobacco & science): http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/welcome/features/20071114_cardio-tobacco/ http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/welcome/features/20071114_cardi...
- api 9y ago> There was a time when 'peer reviewed research' was a badge of merit that would lead to general unquestioned acceptance. But when this was noticed and subsequently weaponized... Everything is weaponized: science, religion, philosophy, any form of art or culture, any signifier of identity or group affinity, etc. If you think it and say it or express it publicly it will be used against you. Propaganda is the plague of our age. It's like the informatic equivalent of the Black Death in the Middle Ages. Edit: I'm not necessarily anti-GMO but I do not trust... anything. I just don't trust anything anymore. Every source of information is guilty until proven innocent.
- jacquesm 9y ago> I'm not necessarily anti-GMO but I do not trust... anything. I just don't trust anything anymore. Every source of information is guilty until proven innocent. I think that's the right attitude to take to media. You'd have to spend way too much time to follow the money trail in order to determine who is paying the piper this time around to get anything useful done.
- api 9y agoYes. I also tend to be suspicious of anti-GMO stuff which could just be shilling for organic food.
- 9y ago
- tonyg 9y agoWhat's being said here is that current commercial crops of GMO corn are seeing increased yields, and are not causing health problems. (The headline is, as usual, overstating things.) Separately, while you're right that each individual modification needs to be examined individually, the same is true of non-GMO foods, plastics, products, etc, etc. Singling out GMO is foolish. One might even expect, with time, enough evidence to accumulate to be able to answer the ("blanket") question "all other things being equal, does application of GMO as a modification technique cause problems?" Indications thus far are that the answer is "no".
- b0rsuk 9y agoYou can't make blanket statements about something as general as GMO, but you can make them about human nature and greed. I don't think GMO is fundamentally different from processed foods. Processed foods can, in theory, be beneficial for us. But in practice they add all sorts of crap to make it taste better and reduce costs. It's an arms race between food companies trying to find new, cheaper substitutes that haven't been proven harmful yet and others who are concerned about health effects of processed foods. If someone is messing with my food, I'd love to believe he's doing it for my benefit, but somehow greedy bastards are much more motivated and organized than altruists. Greedy bastards start companies and corporations, and it certainly helps to be one to rise to a CEO position. Food, like many products, is optimized to reduce production costs. I don't have good sources at hand, but I keep reading that processed foods are linked to X or Y disease or Z deficiency, or some civilizational disease like allergy or cancer. Norwegians start admirable initiatives by donating large sums of money to other countries for humanitarian efforts and preservation of natural environment... yet their fish farms are just awful. Industrial scale fish farming is awful, even though fish are very healthy to eat in theory. There's nothing inherently harfmul about panga fish, but the way they're farmed in China would make you throw up. Finally, I have an issue with GMO because we know so little about genetics and even plain old food and it often takes decades to find out some kind of food or ingredient is harmful. Look how long it took with sugar. Modifying one gene can affect others, unforeseen aspects of an organism. We don't have unit tests for DNA yet !! My conclusion: GMO is one more way to obfuscate my food.
- baud147258 9y ago> substitutes that haven't been forbidden yet FTFY
- daveFNbuck 9y agoYou can say that about any technological advance. If we're doing the evaluation and only picking the beneficial ones, doesn't that make the technology as a whole beneficial?