5 ms·
Facebook plans to use U.S. mail to verify IDs of election ad buyers
- adamnemecek 9y agoWho designs this shit? How is this preventing anything? Russian intelligence agencies definitely can't crack this defense measure. /s They should also require the buyer take a photo saluting the American flag while eating a hamburger.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoPeople who have never done this before. To be good at something, you must first be bad at it. Although I'm smh considering Facebook resources. "“If you run an ad mentioning a candidate, we are going to mail you a postcard and you will have to use that code to prove you are in the United States,” Harbath said at a weekend conference of the National Association of Secretaries of State, where executives from Twitter Inc and Alphabet Inc’s Google also spoke. “It won’t solve everything,” Harbath said in a brief interview with Reuters following her remarks. But sending codes through old-fashioned mail was the most effective method the tech company could come up with to prevent Russians and other bad actors from purchasing ads while posing as someone else, Harbath said." Less postcards, more unraveling shell corporations using their corporate metadata. Authenticate political ad buyers using LexisNexis, IRS tax IDs/political org registrations, perhaps going so far as to implement KYC [1] controls and procedures. It's not going to scale, plan on hiring if this matters. Otherwise, this is going to be defeated with a UPS store mailbox. "KYC controls typically include the following: * Collection and analysis of basic identity information such as Identity documents (referred to in US regulations and practice as a "Customer Identification Program" or CIP) * Name matching against lists of known parties (such as "politically exposed person" or PEP) * Determination of the customer's risk in terms of propensity to commit money laundering, terrorist finance, or identity theft * Creation of an expectation of a customer's transactional behavior * Monitoring of a customer's transactions against expected behavior and recorded profile as well as that of the customer's peers" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer Source: I work in risk management for a financial services firm.
- adamnemecek 9y agoNot running some ads (like political) is also an option.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoFacebook is only going to turn money down as a last resort, either because the PC backlash is too intense or it's regulated by the government. I assure you, they're not at the point where they'll turn political ad money away.
- markholmes 9y agoSometimes, the answer isn’t more technology, I guess.
- datboitom 9y agoLob.com (YC13) will service this?
- natch 9y agoNo envelope? Sort of invites cultivation of corruption in the USPS, unless the codes are further protected by something like a scratch-off layer.
- eganist 9y agoI'm getting a suspicious feeling that this product (I'm calling it a product at this point rather than a mitigation as it seems like it's intended to enhance election ad buys rather than actually mitigate a particular risk) wasn't actually designed with Alex Stamos' team's involvement. Which somewhat surprises me considering it's essentially acting as a second-factor for authenticating your physical location. Expanding on your point, the biggest risk I see with postcards rather than really plain security envelopes would be that savvy postal workers may become acquainted with what even ambiguous or anonymous-sender postcards would look like, enabling them to literally deny service (acting, again literally, as a web service DoS) to particular street addresses making election ad buys by suppressing delivery. With time-critical ad purchases just weeks or even potentially <7 days before election day, this would seem like a legal pandora's box, and even anonymizing postcards wouldn't sufficiently mitigate the risk of an employee blackballing a postcard with an exposed PIN or scratch-off on it that's heading e.g. to Koch HQ or MoveOn.org within weeks of election day.
- eganist 9y agoI mean...... were foreign agents so obviously involved that they were buying election ads on foreign cards/wires with foreign billing addresses? This honestly seems like it solves literally nothing. I'd be shocked to hear that foreign powers didn't already have e.g. diplomatic staff living in the US who were buying ads and listing their home or non-consular work addresses... Actually, is there any indication that listing a consular address is prohibited? Because if not, then not only does this seem to not solve anything, it would in fact fail with certainty to solve anything at all, except maybe give the USPS some extra much-needed revenue. Seriously, what am I missing here?
- ejstronge 9y ago> I mean...... were foreign agents so obviously involved that they were buying election ads on foreign cards/wires with foreign billing addresses? Yes. I think I've heard an egregious story in late 2016 but can't find a reference. For something less concrete, see RT's complaint against Twitter [1]. And a few other equally less-than-concrete report regarding Facebook[2] and others [3]. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2017/oct/27/russias-rt-reveals-twitters-pitch-to-sell-millions-of-dollars-in-2016-election-ads https://www.theguardian.com/media/2017/oct/27/russias-rt-rev... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/sep/06/facebook-political-ads-russia-us-election-trump-clinton https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/sep/06/facebook-... [3] https://www.recode.net/2017/10/6/16419388/facebook-google-twitter-russia-ads-2016-election-president-donald-trump https://www.recode.net/2017/10/6/16419388/facebook-google-tw...
- eganist 9y agoThe conclusion I've reached is that this is a control against footgunning yourself as a foreign agent.
- bemmu 9y agoThey need to show that they are doing something to combat this problem, and this is something.
- pmorici 9y ago
- farseer 9y agoDoes this apply to all countries or only the United States? Doesn't seem fair if American orgs are allowed to purchase ads to influence foreign elections.
- jonnydubowsky 9y agoWhat do you mean by "fair"?
- farseer 9y agoFacebook, while registered in the United States is a truly global multi-national with a majority of the users based outside the US. Users and legislators from other countries would soon start demanding similar treatment to protect their own democratic process from foreign intelligence. So yeah fair treatment of all users is kind of expected if facebook hopes to legally operate in all those countries.
- rhizome 9y agoSurely this will be one thing Facebook will default to opt-in.
- duxup 9y agoRichard Pinedo pleaded guilty to selling information and identities to foreigners who then used that to appear as someone(s) inside the US. I'm guessing folks like him will be happy to offer some mail related services as well. Although it would provide yet another link to possibly track someone down, if only after the fact... https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/02/mueller-flips-american-who-unwittingly-sold-bank-info-to-russian-trolls/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/02/mueller-flips-am...
- ppbutt 9y ago"Facebook to put out PR story to try to stay relevant"
- justboxing 9y agoThis is D.O.A, because most of the Russians indicted were charged with identity theft. They stole US Ids / SSNs and made all their ad buys using US IDs. Source: Russia’s troll identities were more sophisticated than anyone thought => https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/16/17021684/facebook-twitter-mueller-russia-troll-factory https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/16/17021684/facebook-twitter...
- justonepost 9y agoIt'll have to go to a residential / business address. I suspect that theses addresses and contact information will be provided to the FEC for double checking against internal DHS lists.
- DrScump 9y agoIt'll have to go to a residential / business address How about "1050 Kiely Blvd #666, Santa Clara CA 95055"? That's actually a PO Box. (Replace 666 with a real number) Do you think Facebook would care?
- justonepost 9y agoThere's a way to get a list of PO boxes, banks use them and so do other orgs.
- DrScump 9y agoThat's just a USPS example. Anybody can open up their own private mailbox center. At worst, you have to live with some address standardization software sticking a "Unit" in front of the number.
- max452 9y agoYou can use a real address from a virtual mailbox providers like www.postscanmail.com where you can verify anything with a real US address and get your mails and packages also if you live abroad. Guess facebook would not mind that!
- shard972 9y agoWhy bother when you can still vote in American federal elections without being required to show ID? As an Australian i just find this refusal to do this as bonkers considering we have a much lesser issue when it comes to election fraud.
- stevenwoo 9y agoSend in my ballot by mail for all elections and sign it. Election fraud is a miniscule problem in the USA, there's probably a bigger problem with e-voting not counting the votes correctly with all the unauditable systems being used currently. The only people who claim the USA has a signficant voter fraud problem are trying to suppress turnout among minorities.
- shard972 9y agoI'm sorry but what is your counterpoint? That you don't provide ID so voter fraud is not an issue? This is kind of what i'm saying, that in a system where there is no ID checks, what stops fraud from occurring other than people stating "we haven't found it at a large scale at this time". I live in Australia, why would i be interested in suppressing minority voters in the USA? I don't even get the chain of logic in claiming this. How does asking for ID when voting suppress minorities? Are minority citizen entitled to ID?
- stevenwoo 9y agoSuppressing minority voters is the reason it is called for in the United States. The only people who think it is widespread in the United States are members of right wing organizations and generally states that had to have the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (made to stop the suppression of minority voters) imposed upon them by the federal government. The reason the type of voter fraud you are suggesting is rare is because it's not that effective at swinging an election and it's cheaper to buy a politician's vote legally in the USA. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/11/upshot/vote-fraud-is-rare-but-myth-is-widespread.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/11/upshot/vote-fraud-is-rare...
- 9y ago
- askafriend 9y agoIt seems like they took a page out of Nextdoor.com's playbook. That's another social network that verifies identity by postcard. I haven't really seen this technique used elsewhere at scale.
- acct1771 9y agoBesides Google Places/Maps/Business whatever listings, you mean?
- askafriend 9y agoDidn't know they used postcard, that's interesting! I've never listed a place on those platforms so I wouldn't know..
- stevenwoo 9y agoState of California made me use mail for some tax related PIN, I think the Federal government did as well for verification of something to start my automatic tax deductions for self employment but it's been a while.
- throwaway1748 9y agoThis is a good step, but more reforms are needed for political ads on Facebook. One of the most glaring problems is dynamic ad pricing. Ads from different candidates can see wildly different prices based on how 'engaging' their ads are. In my mind this gives a clear advantage to incendiary, sensational, populist candidates. In some cases the difference in pricing between ads can be as much as 10X, based on how 'engaging' each ad is. That's fundamentally unfair for someone running a clean, policy-driven campaign.