16 ms·
Was there ever really a “sugar conspiracy”?
- amriksohata 9y agoRefined sugar and processed fatsare bad, naturally occuring fats like coconut oil have been lumped together with other fats as bad due to bad science
- ggg9990 9y agoWhere is the evidence that “processing” or “refining” makes anything worse? In what way is 300 calories of table sugar worse for you than 300 calories of watermelon?
- Tomte 9y agoWhy do you focus exclusively on calories? You could even ask why 300 calories of tar should be worse for you than 300 calories of apples. The reason is the many other effects stuff has, besides their nutritional stats.
- Valmar 9y ago300 calories of glucose is going to be far healthier than 300 calories of fructose, because of how they are metabolized by the body.
- rurban 9y agoYou mean obviously the other way round. It's the typical US/UK propaganda. Frucose doesn't go directly into blood as glucose (the basic energy form) and galactose (-> milk). Wikipedia: "The European Food Safety Authority stated that fructose is preferable over sucrose and glucose in sugar-sweetened foods and beverages because of its lower effect on postprandial blood sugar levels". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fructose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fructose "Fructose is often recommended for diabetics because it does not trigger the production of insulin by pancreatic β cells, probably because β cells have low levels of GLUT5, although the net effect for both diabetics and non-diabetics is debated. Fructose has a low glycemic index of 19 ± 2, compared with 100 for glucose and 68 ± 5 for sucrose. Fructose is also 73% sweeter than sucrose at room temperature, so diabetics can use less of it. Studies show that fructose consumed before a meal may even lessen the glycemic response of the meal. Fructose-sweetened food and beverage products cause less of a rise in blood glucose levels than do those manufactured with sucrose or glucose."
- orbifold 9y agoGlucose is harmless and can be metabolised by any cell in your body, while Fructose can only be metabolised by your liver and produced a bunch of undesirable metabolic end products in the process. It also blocks leptin, the antagonist of insulin and therefore messes with your metabolic regulation, while glucose does none of that. If you feed rats large amounts of glucose they will get a very big liver but stay otherwise healthy, if you feed them fructose they will develop diabetes... This is all very well known.
- rurban 9y agoGlucose being harmless is the understatement of the year. In the end fructose and every other carb is split up to glucose. And glucose (the simple monosaccharide sugar) is one of the most powerful medicines and drugs, stronger, cheaper and better than cocaine, and responsible for many severe illnesses: * Retinal damage to the eye * Arterial blockage * Oxidative stress * Increased inflammation * Endothelial dysfunction * Reduced coronary blood flow * Increased cancer risk Let me just point to http://www.lifeextension.com/magazine/2011/1/glucose-the-silent-killer/page-01 http://www.lifeextension.com/magazine/2011/1/glucose-the-sil... or https://www.atkins.com/how-it-works/library/articles/10-ways-sugar-harms-your-health https://www.atkins.com/how-it-works/library/articles/10-ways... This is all very well known and ignored by the US sugar industry which rather blames other factors. If you feed americans large amounts of glucose (they do), they will get obese and die early. You cannot argue with the numbers, because it's mostly only affecting americans who do consume sugar levels above the health risk. Blaming fructose and the liver alone is dangerous. It's the end product, glucose, and the fat reserves, not the carb. metabolism.
- maloney 9y agoFructose is metabolized almost entirly by the liver which might make it better for blood sugar levels but it’s signifacantly worse on the liver.
- contravariant 9y agoSure, but it's not like you have to choose one or the other. You can have the beneficial short term effects while avoiding the long term effects by using moderation (which is key in any diet).
- Valmar 9y agoFructose, maybe? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- alecco 9y agohttps://nutritionfacts.org/2016/08/09/what-about-all-the-sugar-in-fruit/ https://nutritionfacts.org/2016/08/09/what-about-all-the-sug...
- keymone 9y agoHow about the fact that you have to eat a kilogram of watermelon to get 300cal but less than tenth of that with sugar?
- endless1234 9y agoSo why is a kilogram of watermelon better than 75 grams of sugar?
- chepaslaaa 9y agowater and fiber are great for you
- croon 9y agoBecause one will leave you wanting more while the other one will leave you full, so you don't get (or at least get less) fat.
- chepaslaaa 9y agoThe body has a much harder time digesting sugar (and other nutriments too) without fiber, the refining process removes the fiber from the plants that contain sugar.
- croon 9y agoI think you mean easier. Being hard (taking a lot of time) to digest is good.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 9y agoFor starters, because you can much more quickly and easily eat "300 calories of table sugar" (e.g. by drinking sodas or some sweet) than 300 calories of watermelon. Second, because 300 calories of watermelon will come with all kinds of vitamins (including C and A), and lots of water.
- exhilaration 9y agoAnd fiber. That's the important component of fruit that will buffer the sugar.
- coldtea 9y agoYep, in general yes, though watermelon doesn't have much fiber IIRC.
- alecco 9y agoActually, extracted coconut oil is as bad as butter. But whole coconut is good. Probably because of all the fiber it has.
- qyv 9y agoThe case against saturated fats is far from conclusive. Let alone coconut oil, with is mostly MCT's (medium chain triglycerides) as opposed to the more common LCT's (long chain triglycerides).
- sgift 9y ago> extracted coconut oil is as bad as butter So, it's great as there's no evidence that butter is bad.
- Valmar 9y agoI wonder... how common was heart disease before saturated fats were demonized, and ultra-processed plant oils were pushed as the "healthier" alternative? What about after?
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThe problem with that claim is that you have to go back decades, where general quality of life was different, life expectancy was lower and the causes of death were different - or harder to assess. as this chart shows, average life expectancy has gone up from 50 to 75 in the past 50 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy#/media/File:Life_Expectancy_at_Birth_by_Region_1950-2050.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy#/media/File:Li..., while this page (http://www.fauxpress.com/kimball/med/heart/h2/coronaryd.htm http://www.fauxpress.com/kimball/med/heart/h2/coronaryd.htm) indicates most heart disease only starts to show up after the age of 50. So yeah, a bit hard to assess combined with higher life expectancy. Not impossible though, I'm sure there's good research out there.
- Valmar 9y agoYeah, this could make it slightly difficult. Good thing I asked the question, though, because this answers it in a way, unlike the other unhelpful commentor.
- montyf 9y agoIf you're in the US or Europe, you don't have access to fresh coconuts. The oil you buy comes from far away (do you even know from where?), was processed under God knows what conditions, likely melted and resolidified several times as it changed hands in transit, only to sit in a store for who knows how long and what corners they cut. And this is healthier than eating locally-produced oils that your body is more genetically disposed to eating -- how exactly? Edit: don't want to rag on you too much, but modern healthy eating trends are saturated with all kinds of insanity.
- stevenwoo 9y agoCoconuts are commonly available in Asian markets in the USA. Heck, half the fruits and veggies in grocery stores in fall/winter have South American labels.
- SCdF 9y ago> If you're in the US or Europe, you don't have access to fresh coconuts. What does fresh mean in this context? I can buy them whole from the supermarket…
- amriksohata 9y agoYou can get cold pressed coconut oil which isn't processed as much at all, also: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-42608071 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-42608071
- asokoloski 9y agoCoconut oil is not a naturally occurring fat, unless you're eating it as part of a coconut. It's just as bad for you as other saturated fats (unfortunately, because it's super tasty): https://nutritionfacts.org/video/coconut-oil-and-the-boost-in-hdl-good-cholesterol/ https://nutritionfacts.org/video/coconut-oil-and-the-boost-i...
- cgh 9y agoSaturated fats are not bad for you. Listen to the science, not biased websites.
- montyf 9y agoThe statements "sugar is bad", "fat is bad", "fat is good" are all equally simplistic and misleading. Fruits are high in naturally-occurring sugars and they are among the healthiest things you can eat. Turns out that nutrition is a pretty complicated science, and there existing various political and special interests influencing the science doesn't help. It's 2018 and I don't think there's even remotely a scientific consensus on what food is healthy or not, but classic common sense and listening to your body's reactions to food can go pretty far for an individual. Nutrition is something we need to figure out as public health is declining, and I'm saddened to say the problem goes beyond the US based on what I've seen traveling. Psychology needs to get involved as well. Why do people make such bad eating decisions? I'm in Thailand and I see tons of tourists eating hamburgers instead of the tastier and healthier traditional cuisine... sigh.
- keymone 9y agoWhile it is tricky with fats, sugar is never good for you (unless some genetic disease where you die if you don’t consume sugar?). Fruits are to various degrees beneficial but not in unlimited amounts. Fruits also don’t have a lot of sugar, see the watermelon comment in the other thread. The problem with sugar is how easy it is in our diets to consume ridiculous amounts of it and how nobody understands that even a little of table sugar is already a ridiculous amount. P.S. even bigger problem is that people don't understand that all the flours and starches are for all intents and purposes sugar, so it doesn't matter that you only have one teaspoon of sugar with your coffee if you consume it in large quantities in other forms.
- starpilot 9y agoWhy did we evolve to enjoy the taste of sugar?
- keymone 9y agoi don't think it is a right question. it's like asking why did we evolve to get high on morphine? sure, there definitely are evolutionary benefits to being able to taste sugar and like it, as that will help you to spot nutrients, but this has little to do with the way we industrialized sugar production and consumption in last 200 years. rice, wheat and potatoes are not even sweet but in some countries those are primary sources of glucose.
- keymone 9y agoAncel Keys study which started the low fat craze was absolutely bad science. The way John Yudkin’s career was subverted is certainly evidence of conspiracy. The article doesn’t make a good job of refuting those claims, especially considering quotes like this one: > the sugar industry convened a panel of heart disease consultants, including a National Institutes of Health (NIH) scientist, which debated a possible “anti-Yudkin” effort because “although British scientists are critical of him and his flimsy data, he does have the interest of the press.”
- JeremyNT 9y agoI think the point of the article is a little more nuanced. The claim doesn't seem to be about the accuracy of any particular study, rather that both sides were 1) funded by industry and 2) lacking evidence to really support any intervention at the time. It's making the case that scientists were working on incomplete information, and that while industry pressure informed what research was done and publicized, there also simply wasn't at the time enough evidence for anybody to have known the effects of sugar were so problematic. So the article is really considering intent, and the idea is that the outcome was a result of understandable ignorance rather than malice and coverup. I find that plausible, at least initially. The nature of science is that consensus evolves over time, and while industry funding may have skewed what research was done and publicized, thus allowing incorrect assumptions to live longer than ideal, it is possible that people were all still acting in good faith along the way.
- RaceRealist 9y agoA cursory examination and comparison of our anatomy to other mammals makes plain to any impartial observer that we, like other apex predators, are naturally hypercarnivores, if not obligate carnivores, but for reasons of pragmatism, this simply cannot be countenanced, for we cannot feed everyone on meat and animal fat. Indeed, people practicing a carnivorous diet have found relief from all manner of reputedly incurable conditions and diseases, particularly autoimmune and metabolic disorders.
- franky_g 9y agoArticles like these are there to simply confuse the reader. Have a read of "The case against Sugar" by Gary Taubes. That will surely fill in the missing blanks for ya!
- simias 9y ago>Articles like these are there to simply confuse the reader. What makes you say that? Why do you think Gary Taubes is a better source than the authors of this article? I haven't a strong opinion on the subject but if you think the article is purposefully misleading I would be very interested to know why and how.
- John_KZ 9y agoThe industry maliciously amplifies our innate tendency to find a "one-fits-all" solution. The bogeyman used to be fat, now it's sugar. Soon, people will realize that getting 90% of your caloric intake from protein powders is bad, the industry will get ahold of the new trend, and they'll start going back to "healthy carbs" or something stupid like that, and people will forget the meat rush of the 2010s and move onto something else that's equally retarded. Nutrition isn't a solved problem and it won't be for many decades. There's one piece of advice that holds for a long time, and that's to eat a diverse diet and exercise within reasonable extends. Interpretations vary, but giving up on fruit or grain and starch is obviously not part of it.
- dalbasal 9y agoNutrition isn't a solved problem This is very true, and a fact that we have trouble digesting, pardon the pun. This jumping around between completely contradictory nutritional prescriptions is nuts. Then a moderate minded person comes in and hedges their bets with an impossibke compromise (reduce both fat and carbs). Meanwhile disproven myths like nutricional cholesterol still affect people's eating habits. It just does not seem possible to doctors, health nuts and everyone else that we just dont know much about nutrition. It seems like we should and that our best theories should be reasonably certain, but they just aren't.
- gerardnll 9y agoThat's because people expect the food industry to solve the same nutrition problems they put you into. Nutrition is solved if you take veggies, fish, meat, etc. Whole foods, not ultraprocessed. And make exercise. But that doesn't give them money and does not attach you to ultraprocessed foods like a drug (yes, simple sugars found in ultraprocessed foods keep you attached at them like a drug. It has been proved to affect your mood.). Nutrition is hard nowadays because we have a supermarket full of bad nutrition value. We wouldn't be that fat without ultraprocessed food or fast food chains. Also, it's your choice if you just eat eggs or take protein shakes because you want to look like Arnold. You want fast and unrealistic results without working hard. That's not a balanced diet and I'm sure it will take a toll on your body. I've gone from 82kg (20% fat) to 75-76kg (17,88% fat) in 6 months, taking it easy, without doing exercise, just lowering my daily intake of calories and mostly avoiding ultraprocessed foods. I enjoy weekends by having great meals at restaurants or at home. Of course I also take a chocolate bar or another other sweet ultraprocessed food, because drugs (sugar) are hard to keep away. Now I exercise an hour twice a week and I expect to keep loosing fat and gaining muscle, I don't want to hurry, I'm trying to create a lifestyle not something I'll keep doing intermittenly. I don't take any suplement as I want to make progress by my own effort and in a natural and healthy way as if my daily life was more physical.
- gerardnll 9y agoWant a simple nutrition tip? Just eat the food that you can recognise at simple sight, the ingredients it's made from. And lower meat consumption to 30% of your diet. Avoid ultraprocessed food and eat what you'll burn.
- slampig 9y agoWhy would eating processed food be bad? What does it matter if the ingredients are recognizable.
- seren 9y agoIt seems to increase the risk of cancer by 10%, even if the exact mechanism or cause, is still unknown. http://www.bmj.com/content/360/bmj.k322 http://www.bmj.com/content/360/bmj.k322
- saosebastiao 9y agoEverything causes cancer. The reason is that the vast majority of cancer risk studies are done with insufficient control methodologies, have weak effect magnitudes, but are affected by positive finding publication bias and are published anyway. And then they get cherry picked by diet fad promoters to support their crackpot theories and sell books. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/everything-we-eat-causes-cancer/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/everything-we-eat-causes-ca...
- gerardnll 9y agoI said ultraprocessed, not processed. It's not the same a can of chickpeas than a 'chocolate' bar. What I said about the ingredients It's just an easy tip to differentiate ultraprocessed foods from just processed or healthy ones. Another 'rule' could be avoiding food with more than 4-5 ingredients.
- Rainymood 9y agoEat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. Personally, I conjured up the following hypothesis and think it might be somewhat correct. Note that I am not a biologist/nutritionist (I'm an applied mathematician) so bear with me. What I claim is the following: > The less some kind of food wants to be eaten, the healthier it is. For example, fruit wants to be eaten (hence its sweet) to reproduce and spread it seeds. Verdict? Not so healthy. Offal, however, is significantly harder to acquire (you'd have to kill a beast, which is a group task). Verdict? Extremely healthy. I'd love to have some comments on my theory from more knowledgeable people.
- shlant 9y ago> Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. This is the simplest and most sound nutritional advice so far. Nothing complicated, has stood the test of time, maintainable when done reasonably, shown over and over again to be extremely healthy [1][2][3][4][5] 1. https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/plant-based-diet-reduced-diabetes-risk-hu-satija/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/plant-based... 2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3565018/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3565018/ 3. http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PII0140-6736(90)91656-U/abstract http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PII0140-673... 4. https://www.health.harvard.edu/heart-health/halt-heart-disease-with-a-plant-based-oil-free-diet- https://www.health.harvard.edu/heart-health/halt-heart-disea... 5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4315380/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4315380/
- ghusbands 9y agoGetting the liver of polar bears is particularly tricky. And it will kill you. As will any number of hard-to-extract things. Turning a correlation from a series of facile observations into a rule rarely ends well.
- Rainymood 9y ago>Getting the liver of polar bears is particularly tricky. And it will kill you. Interesting. Consider my view partially changed. I did not know that the liver of polar bears is toxic to humans. I say this because I eat a lot of offal (liver, heart, stomach, etc.) and thought all offal was safe for human consumption, guess not.
- chisleu 9y agoThe song "sugar conspiracy theory" is one of my favorites on the arcade game "pump it up" because it taught me that I can eat pretty much anything I want if I play that game for a couple hours a day. I get a 75 calorie last year rainbow twist after I play that song. I've lost 40lbs in 3 months. My point is, a sedentary lifestyle is the cause of most of our health problems and beyond that, various nutrition science will have a much larger effect. I'm on the zone diet, but I eat lots of nuts and fruit.
- iambateman 9y agoPerhaps there was no sugar conspiracy. In that case, an entire industry (along with government nutrition teams) went along with an incorrect theory for so long that it accounted for millions of chronic illnesses and trillions of dollars spent in the wrong direction. So there was no conspiracy. It seems - in either case - to be one of the greatest misapplications of science in history. At least the “flat earth” theory didn’t pump people full of expensive “alternative foods” while making generations progressively sicker. Even if there was no conspiracy, I think consumers ought to be furious that they were “fed” 50 years of bad info. We will spend generations trying to undo the habits and ingrained “wisdom” that have developed around fat and sugar. Meanwhile the food industry is allowed to put in as much sugar as they like. You can’t give a child a cigarette, but you can hand them 17 teaspoons of sugar for lunch in the form of a single Coca Cola. I feel like we within HN live in an echo chamber with respect to nutrition. The reality is that I worked at Chick fil A for 5 years and probably served 5,000 milkshakes for breakfast. Who cares if there was a conspiracy in the 60’s. We need way more cultural attention on this issue for today.
- FussyZeus 9y agoI always find it interesting that it's never enough for any given person or group (be it corporation, Government agency, etc.) to be simply wrong, they also have to be evil in some capacity in order for people to get interested in retelling the story. IMHO, no, there was no sugar "conspiracy" merely the financial motives at play where companies wanted to continue producing foods they knew were unhealthy, addictive and extremely profitable. Wanting to be profitable doesn't make a company intrinsically evil, that's what companies are for. There is plenty to say about many industries where it's clear they didn't know certain things about their products because they didn't want to know those things, but retroactively trying to hold them responsible is ridiculous. Instead, focus on companies pulling that exact same stunt right now when it's useful.
- IntronExon 9y agoI don’t know if it’s a need, or just an awareness of history which leads people to search for malice when misinformation and tons of money converge.
- appleshore 9y agoWhile I appreciate the article, it seems analogous to asking, was there ever really a "drug dealing conspiracy"? When you have an industry worth hundreds of billions, individuals will "collaborate" and "market" their interests in the most "effective" way possible. If you doubt that a conspiracy exists, watch Fed Up narrated by Katie Couric. If Michelle Obama, as the First Lady to the President of the United States, can't reform the food industry without serious pressure on her, causing her to modify her stance, then yes there is a real sinister force promoting cheap, profitable food that happens to be carbohydrate-based.
- coatmatter 9y agoHonest/naïve question: Regardless of how good or bad sugar is, is it possible that cars and televisions have both separately contributed more harm than sugar over the past century? Both encourage sedentary habits and in the case of television, the advertising within is insidious. I personally believe that cars and TV are the two most misused inventions from last century, but so rarely see them mentioned when health, food and diet is mentioned.
- cryptonector 9y agoWe, humans, are susceptible to group delusions, probably because we are such social animals and have a strong "run with the heard" reflex. We see this in many mammals and other animals (e.g., birds, fish, ...). This was either a conspiracy, or a group delusion -- or even both. Either way, we now know the truth about sugar. We now get to fix things. It won't be easy.
- GeekyBear 9y agoThere is a new study out from The Journal of the American Medical Association that backs up the notion that people who want to lose weight need to cut the sugar from their diet. >people who cut back on added sugar, refined grains and highly processed foods while concentrating on eating plenty of vegetables and whole foods — without worrying about counting calories or limiting portion sizes — lost significant amounts of weight over the course of a year. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/20/well/eat/counting-calories-weight-loss-diet-dieting-low-carb-low-fat.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/20/well/eat/counting-calorie... Interestingly, this held true on two separate diets. One diet accomplished the above while also reducing other carbs and another that did the above while reducing fats.