7 ms·
edit: downvoters, feel free to correct what I'm saying if you can. I'm going by the factual history of what actually happened, what role the US actually played
by adventured 9y ago
edit: downvoters, feel free to correct what I'm saying if you can. I'm going by the factual history of what actually happened, what role the US actually played in the conflict (barely any), and the trivial scale of that role.
It's not mentioned because the US was not a major part of any invasion into Russia and did not contribute to the famine. Factually the US involvement in that conflict was something below trivial. Although feel free to explain how a couple hundred US soldiers contributed to the forced famine of a nation of tens of millions of people.
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-i/the-day-that-the-usa-invaded-russia-and-fought-with-the-red-army-x.html https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-i/the-day-that-th...
- gumby 9y agoThough I disagree with you I gave you an upvote -- the right way for people to disagree is to comment, so thank you for adding that edit and alerting me to the downvoting. I agree that in a country the size of russia the counterrevolutionary invasion was, in a sense, trivial (as had been the counterrevolutionary invation of revolutionary France). However it had various long term consequences in terms of policy, resentment, pride etc which, sad to say, do effect politics in international relations today as well. However on the subject of the invasion itself, there were about 150K invaders of various nationalities (about 100K in the north, of which the US personnel was about 10%). However US materiel support was substantial, as they had barely entered WWI and had plenty to supply. in addition the blosheviks -- not particularly well organized or rational) were quite distracted by this force. You can see from the treaty of Brest-Lutovsk that they were quite eager to be shed of foreign obligations, wanting to consolidate domestic control. I don't claim the invasion was the cause of the famine, nor do I believe the bolsheviks would have been competent to deal with it without the invasion, but it has a significant distractor as you can see from their records. But to present the article as the US being the rescuing heros without mentioning their bloody opposition in the years immediately leading up to the famine I do consider rediculous.
- adventured 9y agoThe fundamental problem I have with the premise, is that the US soldiers played no role in the actual famine and its causes. The US role in that conflict was as glorified guard duty. Lenin's policy of prodrazvyorstka, was not caused by the small US involvement in that conflict. Lenin's land & production seizure policies were also not caused by US supplies to the allies in WW1. "Unlike his Allied counterparts, General Graves believed their mission in Siberia was to provide protection for American-supplied property and to help the Czechoslovak Legion evacuate Russia, and that it did not include fighting against the Bolsheviks. Repeatedly calling for restraint, Graves often clashed with commanders of British, French and Japanese forces, who also had troops in the region and who wanted him to take a more active part in the military intervention in Siberia." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Expeditionary_Force_Siberia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Expeditionary_Force_S...
- mirimir 9y agoI've also read that Kaiser Wilhelm II's government funded Lenin, intending that the revolution would keep Russia out of WW I.
- gumby 9y agoThey extracted Lenin from Switzerland and transported him in a sealed train ("like a bacillus") during the war in the hope he would destabilize Russia. Which he did.
- Fins 9y agoOf course in this case US were rescuing heroes... And just how bloody was their opposition given the very limited effort expended. Besides, would it be US' fault that by 1945 Germans were rather starving, too? After all, armed opposition to communism is no less justified than armed opposition to nazis.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoWhat "bloody opposition"? Proof please. The fact that we got involved on the side of the Royalist does not prove we oppressed anyone. The largest damage ever done to the population of the USSR was always by their own government, FULL STOP.
- Svettie 9y agoI think "Bloody opposition" in this context is a sensationalized way to say "military involvement", it doesn't refer to the magnitude of the blood spilt nor of oppression.
- myrandomcomment 9y ago“But to present the article as the US being the rescuing heros without mentioning their bloody opposition in the years immediately leading up to the famine I do consider rediculous.” I do not think so. Pretty much is an direct statement accusing the US of it. So I say again, proof please?
- Tech-Noir 9y agoPerhaps you're being downvoted for claiming it was a "forced famine", a claim not supported by either your own link or the submission link itself.
- Fins 9y agoIt was a forced famine, this is a common historical knowledge. Of course the link does not talk of it because is is about entirely different thing.
- Tech-Noir 9y ago> It was a forced famine, this is a common historical knowledge. Let's see a link to a credible source that states it was a forced famine then. Edit: The only sites I can find that share your view are anti-Semitic neo-Nazi blogs like: zionistreport.com/2016/08/video-terror-under-the-jewish-bolshevik-forced-famine-in-russia-1921-1923/ holodomorinfo.com/glossery/bolshevik-atrocities/russian-forced-famine/ Is that where you're getting your "historical knowledge"? > Of course the link does not talk of it because is is about entirely different thing. What is it you think the submitted link is about then?
- Fins 9y agoI did not know that Wikipedia was a Nazi resource: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kazakhstan_famine_of_1932%E2%80%931933 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kazakhstan_famine_of_1932%E2%8... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1932%E2%80%9333 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1932%E2%80%93... If you were googling for it, maybe Google knows something interesting about you that it redirects you to nazi sites? Just because some nazis might want to blame only Jews for forced Soviet famines it does not mean that Soviets did not exterminate millions of their own citizens, often by forced starvation.
- Tech-Noir 9y agoSo despite 7 out of 72 comments on this submission being yours, you don't even know what it's actually about. > If you were googling for it, maybe Google knows something interesting about you that it redirects you to nazi sites? Then, as I asked, show me site that isn't an anti-Semitic neo-Nazi blog that agrees with you that this was a "forced famine".