3 ms·
In line with the same type of intentionally forgotten history, US investors and business persons built and provided a large portion of the Soviet industrial cap
by adventured 9y ago
In line with the same type of intentionally forgotten history, US investors and business persons built and provided a large portion of the Soviet industrial capabilities prior to WW2 [1], which the Soviets later pretended were their own accomplishments. It's a theme that repeats throughout all of Soviet history, where Communist propaganda collides with market economy prosperity, on up to the famous 1959 Kitchen debate between Nixon and Khrushchev [2], or Yeltsin's visit to the Texas supermarket [3].
Communism universally, completely failed at providing superior material prosperity, which was one of its most touted foundational claims. Worse, it failed at providing nearly any consistent materialism at all, as witnessed by the second great Soviet famine under Stalin in 1932-33 [4], in which millions of people perished.
[1] http://www.americanheritage.com/content/how-america-helped-build-soviet-machine http://www.americanheritage.com/content/how-america-helped-b...
[2] http://adst.org/2015/07/nixon-vs-khrushchev-the-1959-kitchen-debate/ http://adst.org/2015/07/nixon-vs-khrushchev-the-1959-kitchen...
[3] https://blog.chron.com/thetexican/2014/04/when-boris-yeltsin-went-grocery-shopping-in-clear-lake/ https://blog.chron.com/thetexican/2014/04/when-boris-yeltsin...
[4] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2017/10/red-famine-anne-applebaum-ukraine-soviet-union/542610/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2017/10/re...
- ThrowMeDown01 9y agoYou are taking this way too far as an argument. Russia at the time was miles and miles behind any Western nation in terms of development. They knew it, which is why they thought their revolution would fail unless Western nations, German workers in particular, would start their own revolution. So they already started with a huge handicap - on top of that WWI and the civil war after the revolution, which was a fight tooth and nail, as bad as it gets, put them down even further. So even if the "experiment" would have stopped right then and there and they would have switched to pure capitalism, what kind of development would you have expected? This is not to take anything away from your mention of their propaganda efforts to appear a lot bigger than they are, but your argument leaves out some important "details".
- thriftwy 9y ago> So even if the "experiment" would have stopped right then and there and they would have switched to pure capitalism, what kind of development would you have expected? I would expect something more like 350 million strong Norway, not 140 million strong Honduras that is the result of a century of communist experiment. I am often reminded that Eastern Europe was always poor. Guess what? So were Norway at the time of divergence. Moreover, poverty and corruption is a direct result of communism that can't be ignored.
- ThrowMeDown01 9y agoRussia was not poor and corrupt under the Tsar, it was the Bolshevists that caused it all? Really? Yes, heroic efforts are possible, see Japan or South Korea. Doesn't change what I wrote, especially since the OP comment was about a time shortly after the revolution. Nobody is disputing the horrible and stupid things that happened in Russia at the time. Nothing worse than people on a mission to save the world at any cost.
- thriftwy 9y ago@ThrowMeDown01 Under Tsar Russia had a chance. Now it no longer has any because it is now dead and wasted away, just like your account (UPD: It's unblocked, so now Russia is in worse state than your account). It's an empty broken shell. And that, kids, is the result of communism. You die on that stuff.
- dang 9y agoYour comments are crossing both into ideological flamewar and personal attack. Please stop.
- tpm 9y agoWell, Norway discovered oil and managed to distribute the profits evenly (I think). Not many oil-rich countries did that. And regarding Eastern Europe, it was not always poor, for example the Czech part of Czechoslovakia was more prosperous than Austria both before and immediately after WW2, but that changed during communism and Austria is still much more prosperous nearly 30 years after the fall of communism.
- dang 9y agoLet's not have yet another battle about how bad communism was. On HN, generic tangents are always off topic because the discussions they produce are predictable. Ideological battle is the worst subtype of those. I know the theme is adjacent to the article's material, but so are plenty of other things, some of which are specific rather than generic, and those are the ones that can seed good conversation. Who even knew this massive event had taken place? or that Herbert Hoover played a central role? I sure didn't. Relitigating communism, on the other hand...not so much. Nearby generic themes trigger quick reactions because we all have many pre-existing associations to them. But for internet discussion, they are the black holes we need most to steer clear of. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- adventured 9y agoFair enough. I thought it fit well with the parent article. I get your point about how wandering anywhere near Communism as a discussion can quickly lead to low quality argumentation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]