11 ms·
90% of American public schools now hold mass shooting drills for students
- malvosenior 9y agoIn my day we held nuclear attack drills. Not sure what is more terrifying/depressing tbh.
- lightbyte 9y agoConsidering school shooters actually happen, and quite often at that, I'd say it's a bit more scary than a nuclear drill. Nuclear drills don't really do anything anyway, if a nuke is coming you're going to be dead regardless of you hiding under your desk.
- gizmo686 9y agoThat depends on how far away you are. There is a radius within which you simply die, and a radius beyond which you will be fine regardless. Between those two radii, you can absolutely reduce your risk of death.
- dazc 9y ago...if a nuke is coming you're going to be dead regardless of you hiding under your desk. Ridiculous as it may seem, I remember some information in the late 1970's about 'what to do in the event of a nuclear attack' and 'underneath a table' was one of the places they advised as a good place to hide.
- azernik 9y agoThis is actually quite good advice. If you're close enough, you're dead regardless, but even miles away from an impact you still need to protect yourself against things like flying glass and falling debris. Kind of like the Israeli standard warning to get into a concrete stairwell if you hear a missile alarm and don't have a real bomb shelter available. In a direct hit you're dead anyway, but mild defensive measures can vastly reduce the lethal radius of an attack. EDIT: Here's a vintage poster on the subject. Fairly factually correct, but awful for morale: https://i.redd.it/fw2xx579qw401.jpg https://i.redd.it/fw2xx579qw401.jpg
- ahartmetz 9y agoThe instant death zone of nukes will kill, I believe, significantly less than half the victims. Many more people will die of fairly "pedestrian" causes like building collapses or even fire. In other words, a nuclear explosion at medium distance is pretty similar to a chemical bomb hitting somewhere close. So hiding under your desk isn't actually that useless.
- jdavis703 9y agoHow many people do you know who have been injured or killed from gun violence? How many do you know who have been victims of nuclear violence? I know for me personally I've witnessed gun violence, and know people who've been injured because of it. For me at least gun violence is much more personal, and thus more depressing and terrifying.
- gizmo686 9y agoGun violence frequently kills a small number of people. USA/USSR nuclear war is an extremely rare event (to the point where it never actually happened; but any reasonable reading of history recognizes that it could have happened), that kills a large number of people. Lets estimate between 70 and 160 million immediate deaths in the US. [0]. This would be between 35 and 80% of the population. Lets round this estimate to a flat 100 million. In 2013, there was about 100,000 firearm injuries (~34,000 of which were fatal. and 21,000 were suicide) [1] These two number are not directly comparable, because of population growth, and my considering non-fatal gun injuries but only immediately fatal nuclear injuries. However, both of these facts serve to make gun violence look relatively worse than nuclear violence. Even with these simplifications, our gun violence is equivalent to a nuclear war every 100 years. Readings of history may vary, but I doubt we could survive 100 years of cold war without starting a nuclear war. For simplicity, lets ignore population growth and just focus on the absolute numbers (which will make shootings look even worse, because the total population has increased). [0] http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/129966 http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/129966 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 9y ago> How many people do you know who have been injured or killed from gun violence? Um, none?
- 9y ago
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoPerhaps it is taboo to say this but it seems like a catch-22 to me: that in an effort to prevent mass murder with firearms, many US citizens would turn to the same government which has prepared to commit the greatest indiscriminant mass murder in history with their nuclear weapons.
- keeganjw 9y agoI'm American and I remember doing these in school. If people from other countries could weigh in here, is this common where you're from? Even though school shootings are far less common in most places, do you still have the drills?
- nothrabannosir 9y agoWow, no. No way. Western European; never ever heard of anything like it. School shootings are considered typically American, like hamburgers and Coca Cola.
- gutnor 9y agoAnother Western European, School Shooting was not even a thing at all when I was at school. Columbine is the event that made that phenomenon real, but, as you said, as a typical American thing. edit: and to illustrate, I had to look on wikipedia to be sure there had been any earlier than that.
- justaguyhere 9y agoNope, not common where I grew up. Why would it be common? Unless we are in a war situation or something - the drills are only for natural stuff like fire, not some crazy person spraying bullets. This seems like a uniquely American problem
- Havoc 9y ago>is this common where you're from? Never even heard of the concept of the mass shooting drill before this hn post. Seems bizarre frankly but I can see how it's a necessary consequence if one is determined to maintain a US style gun culture.
- danbruc 9y agoA fire drill once a year or so is all there is at German schools.
- lhorie 9y agoIn Brazil, there's no such thing as drills. In Australia, I didn't have any either. Neither did my brother in Canada. Japan has earthquake drills. AFAIK, the US is the only developed country with a systemic school shooting problem
- katzgrau 9y agoMy wife was a teacher and eventually principal. One time we were discussing the idea of buying a bullet proof vest just in case. Then the absurdity of what we are now accepting as normal struck me.
- garettmd 9y agoI'm kind of surprised the figure isn't 100%
- tenpies 9y agoI'm surprised it's that high at all given the likelihood that a child will ever be in a school shooting. It's not quite in lottery-winning territory, but as a child you are more likely to be killed by a vehicle than a gun by several orders of magnitude. It's not even close. It's a good example of the media shifting our fear to the wrong thing.
- egwynn 9y agoI completely agree regarding the media being terrible at discussing risk. However, I do think the attention is somewhat warranted because every other developed nation in the world has solved this problem (as is made abundantly clear in another thread in this same post). If the solution is so obvious, why not implement it and start saving lives? Lastly (and somewhat pedantically) I'm not sure about your "several orders of magnitude" remark. Could you elaborate? Wikipedia[0] says that about four times as many Americans die in traffic collisions each year as die from firearms (once you take out the 2/3 of firearms deaths that are suicides). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preventable_causes_of_death#Annual_number_of_deaths_and_causes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preventable_causes_of_death#An...
- nolite 9y agoWow. And back when I was in school, we only used to hide under furniture like that for tornado drills. What hte hell is the world coming to...
- Udik 9y agoIt sounds to me like the best way of perpetuating, spreading, and eventually somewhat normalizing the idea of entering a school and shooting everybody.
- ygaf 9y agoAgreed. It also makes me think, at a glance, you're teaching gunners how to do more damage. But I have no idea how shootings play out.
- zaidf 9y agoIn 1999, the middle school I attended required meshed or see-through bookbags. May be more schools should put in policies like these while we wait on our politicians to do something.
- jeanmichelx 9y agoYes and see-through clothes would also improve security
- wtvanhest 9y agoThat really doesnt make sense. I cannot imagine a single situation a clear backpack could stop or even reduce.
- cooper12 9y agoThat sounds useless [0] considering you could just cut out a hole in a textbook or hide a gun anywhere else. A lot of schools have metal detectors these days as well as random bag checks. Seems like that's the future we're choosing. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater
- jandrese 9y agoOr, you know, the shooter doesn't decide to spend the day at school before they start shooting. They just walk in the front door with guns blazing. Clear backpacks are more for spotting drugs I think, and even then it's pretty useless. Dealers in schools aren't carrying around kilos of coke, they're carrying easily concealable dime bags and the like.
- sjg007 9y agoThese mass shootings are mostly in rich white suburbs.. The shooters are largely white males. Good luck getting metal detectors in these communities. Even if you turn schools into a prison you will have large groups of kids lined up to get to class in morning, at sporting events, activities and the other functions. So a motivated shooter will get to people anyway. So even though high school can feel like it is a literal prison, actually making it so solves very little. The only reasonable and logical action to take is gun control. You can't ask teachers to make threat assessments, determine mental state or act be law enforcement. Teachers are there to teach.
- rubicon33 9y agoWe have such a strange culture of guns in this country. This point became poignantly clear to me once when I was a potential juror on a gun-murder case. I remember they were screening the potential jurors for biases and they asked the large group of us: "How many of you personally own a gun" I looked around the room and and figured out of the 30 or so people maybe 5 would raise their hand. It was more like 25. It was on that day that America's gun obsession became real, quantifiable for me. Here was a cross section of my community, and I was a significant minority when it came to firepower. Almost everyone in that group, young and old, black and white, you name it, had a gun. People I was sure wouldn't raise their hand, raised their hands.
- patorjk 9y agoBased on research, it looks like around 30% of Americans own a gun [1]. So you may just live in an area with a lot of gun owners. Also, not everyone owns a gun for the same reason. Some for protection, some for hunting, some for antiques, etc etc. I've owned my house for a few years and last year I found a couple of shotguns tucked away next to a bookcase in a closet. I eventually got rid of them, but for a few months I would have technically had to raise my hand for that question. [1] http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2017/06/22/the-demographics-of-gun-ownership/ http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2017/06/22/the-demographics-o...
- MollyR 9y agoI'm doubtful of that statistic. Many americans hate the government knowing what guns they have. Ghost guns are hugely popular for this reason, and only increasing in popularity https://www.cbsnews.com/news/law-enforcement-struggling-to-combat-unregulated-diy-ghost-guns/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/law-enforcement-struggling-to-c...
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThis is a poll done by Pew Research Center, not a registry of guns that the government knows about. Obviously there is still a possibility that people are lying to pollsters, but there are extremely frequent speculations about things like that (e.g. the "Shy Tory Effect") that almost never end up skewing things by more than a few percent.
- MollyR 9y agoIt should be a 100%. They also need to get armed security. My alma mater had its own police force, and it was really helped. It reduced not just shootings, but violent crime in general. EDIT: Also the FBI needs to be investigated. Apparently they were warned several times about that Florida shooter. It's just utterly unbelievable, Wray should be fired, and a special counsel set up to investigate this unbelievable failure. Ex. The Fbi said it couldn't verify the shooter, who used his own name on youtube with death threats. Unbelievable!
- FireBeyond 9y agoYou realize that most countries in the world have neither armed security, police, or even metal detectors in -any- of their schools and don't have these issues? Why is our solution here always "more guns!"?
- MollyR 9y agoI gave a realistic solution for the united states, One that I have personally seen work. You will not be able to do a gun grab without a civil war or extreme violence in the united states.
- FireBeyond 9y agoAnd yet as an EMS responder, I've seen and heard personally of the challenges that come with it. There are cases where shooters have been brought down by "a good guy with a gun". There are others where there have been plenty of armed security around, even police, and it's done nothing to stop things. And there's been cases where now you have a bunch of inconsistently trained people running around an active shooter scene, confused and terrified, possibly injuring bystanders or each other. "Hey, are you the shooter?" Shooter: "no, i'm just like you, hunting him too!" (if indeed the reaction is not "see gun, shoot").
- MollyR 9y agoI'm not advocating for random people with guns, but law enforcement officers. >There are others where there have been plenty of armed security around, even police, and it's done nothing to stop things. Just because a small number of bad cops haven't done their job, doesn't I mean I think we get should get rid of all cops.
- danschumann 9y agoAre there any states where guns are allowed and prevalent in schools? Seems like a mass shooter would want to go to a place where he knows he is the only person with a gun. On one hand, if there a tons of guns in schools, perhaps kids would randomly shoot eachother during fights. On the other hand, there are mass shooters who see schools as easy targets. The shooter in FL apparently had lots of FBI data on him. He told kids about guns, he posted weird comments on youtube.
- throwaway5752 9y agoAre there any states where guns are allowed and prevalent in schools? Seems like a mass shooter would want to go to a place where he knows he is the only person with a gun. I don't know. But Florida is notorious for having some of the loosest gun laws in the country and it didn't seem to affect the outcome here at all (or in the Orlando nightclub). The Texas army base shooting seems like a double whammy: extremely loose gun laws, and highly armed target. The recent church shooting happened in Texas, too. It is fascinating. It seems like the availability/nearyby availability of guns seems correlated with the occurrence of mass shootings, but has no correlation with prevention. I wonder if the CDC has been able to conduct any research on this subject using data that state level law enforcement collects?
- AcerbicZero 9y agoIt's a fairly common misconception that military bases are full of people running around with guns. Generally speaking, the Army loves soldiers, and loves guns, but hates soldiers with guns. Gate guards, MPs, and soldiers on an active firing range would (generally) be the only ones equipped to defend themselves.
- btgeekboy 9y agoIsn’t the CDC specifically prohibited from doing studies involving firearms?
- egwynn 9y agoIt's not quite that general, but is pretty close. The "Dickey Amendment" requires that "none of the funds made available for injury prevention and control at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) may be used to advocate or promote gun control." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dickey_Amendment_(1996) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dickey_Amendment_(1996)
- alphabettsy 9y agoMy school- district started right after Columbine and the less notable incidents that followed.
- cletus 9y agoAh, America, the land prepared to allowed the continued slaughter of children and other innocents on a scale that would take a civil war anywhere else, all for a particular interpretation of the Second Amendment. "There's nothing we can do" from a country with a problem that literally no one else has. The slaughter goes well beyond the borders of the US too. Handing out opiates like candy without holding doctors responsible has created a zombie army of heroin addicts. The war on cannabis in the 1970s and beyond was so successful that cannabis became harder to get and more expensive than meth or heroin. Good call that. And that market demand drives drug cartels in search of the billions of dollars US citizens spend on illegal drugs and that war is fueled by... guns from the USA. Watch any of these reality border shows and you'll see the trafficking trade is in drugs going north and money and guns going south. But sure, let's argue that the founders meant for every idiot with anger issues to have an AR-15 with a bump stock and that the slaughter of children is the price of "freedom". Good call.
- watertom 9y agoWe as a society are fine with mentally unstable individuals having access to multi-shot, and semi-automatic handguns and assault weapons. When a person takes one of these weapons and begins indiscriminately killing people it's not an "evil" act, it's the act of a mentally ill individual, plain and simple. When we label it as "evil" we absolve ourselves of our duty to act, because evil is a nameless, faceless, and uncontrollable entity, it's just something we must live with. When in reality what's causing these shooting is the crisis of mental illness that is facing this country, and that is something we can control, but we've chosen to ignore. Mental illness is one of those topics that can't be discussed, it's private, and it's embarrassing, but it's killing us. Mentally unstable individuals have unlimited access to weapons and ammunition is fully supported by our laws, and by the majority of the population. It's only prudent for schools to hold drills for dealing with active shooters because it's an accepted and encouraged part of our culture.
- gnu8 9y agoI suspect that both the willingness to attribute shootings to "evil" and the reluctance to address mental health both stem from the religious belief that still pervades American society to a much greater extent than it does other western countries. I have actually had a person tell me that this is a "sin-sick country" as his explanation for the recent event. Perhaps things will improve gradually as the population becomes less religious.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI don't know about that. If you take the doctrine of human sinfulness as a hypothesis, and read the news for a month, you could reasonably regard it as empirically proven...
- FireBeyond 9y agoHere's the challenge with "more arms". We talk about the "need to protect against an unjust government" (going back to the original reasoning why 2A was enshrined)... You basically have two scenarios there, as we've seen play out around the world: 1. The military / soldiers revolt, 'remember the patriotism', whatever you want to call it. The government is toothless because their military isn't going to quell civil uprising. 2. A general or colonel decides it's his time, and has the backing of the military. A military with access to fighter jets, armored helicopters, bombers, not to mention the actual big guns, NBC weaponry. And then we have the 'militia' populace, limited to largely semi automatic small arms or less. Is the military going to "play fair", or are they, per current US doctrine, "shock and awe" a demonstrative show of force. Either way, largely, we'd be fucked. The days of rebel insurgencies hanging out in the jungle/desert/ wherever providing credible resistance to a tyrannical government never really applied to the US.
- clarkmoody 9y agoWhat percentage of public schools allow teachers to carry firearms? I know a couple schools in Texas went forward with proper training for a few teachers who wanted to carry in school. Frangible ammo, clearing tactics, proper concealment. I'm sure if there were any incidents at those schools, it would be all over the national news, but I haven't heard anything yet. It seems like teachers with guns would be a better option than teachers as [temporary] shields for students. Also seems better than "turn the lights off and hide." I've heard all the arguments about students getting ahold of a teacher's gun, accidental discharge, etc. If you're making those sorts of arguments, do you also carry a gun? As others have mentioned, the gun culture in America is not going to change any time soon, so the politicians are not going to "take away the guns." We're also continuing to pump psychotropic drugs into our children by the millions. Add to that the environment of public school: raging hormones, toxic bullying, dehumanizing suppression of individuality. Not exactly a recipe for peace. Perhaps it's time to try something different?
- FireBeyond 9y ago> We're also continuing to pump psychotropic drugs into our children by the millions. Add to that the environment of public school: raging hormones, toxic bullying, dehumanizing suppression of individuality. Whilst simultaneously both decreasing mental health funding, AND increasing availability of weapons to people with mental health issues. It's not just that we're "not doing something good" for the problem... We're _actively_ making the problem worse, in some of the most obvious / blatant ways.
- idoh 9y agoAs a purely practical matter, does it really make sense to prioritize the arming of millions of teachers to handle this? I know a lot of teachers and they are really busy with all the other stuff that they have to do, what would you trade off in favor of training? Without getting into the politics of this, the fact of the matter is that these types of shootings are really rare, and if I had to draft up a list of problems that schools face then mass shootings would certainly not crack the top 10, or even top 100 problems / priorities to focus on.
- 9y ago
- wufufufu 9y agoIn elementary school and middle school we had "lockdown" drills, which as a kid I did not associate with mass shooting. No teacher mentioned guns, terrorism, or anything scary. It was just "lockdown".
- eftychis 9y ago>> While one of the primary goals of crisis preparedness is to develop a sense of empowerment and control, armed assailant drills not conducted appropriately may cause physical and psychological harm to students, staff, and the overall learning environment. This is the most interesting comment in the article. The purpose of a school is to introduce a functioning person to the society. How long will it take till kids feel school shootings are a norm, they are terrified or worse a viable approach to release your frustrations and end your life. I don't think people realize the effect various solutions have to future generations. One could consider Metal detectors in schools as a stepping stone to feeling it is normal to be considered as a threat by the society as a kid and ok to be watched by the Big Brother. (Where I grew up, I remember they added a fence at some point and people were negative (on average) as "it will make kids feel like they are, or it is acceptable, to be caged and not free citizens." To that society, saying you are doing a shooting drill will appear as a post-apocalyptic universe idea.) P.S. FYI gun ownership is high in that area (from hunting rifles to operational WWII assault rifles).
- Balgair 9y agoMy SO is a teacher and has them monthly, randomly scheduled. They just lock the door, turn out the lights, and play with their phones in the corner until the all clear bell. It messes up the curriculum and learning to just stop-drop and chill for 30 minutes. 'Fortunately' the largest concern they have is the suicide cell currently working it's way through. Turns out, suicide is pretty contagious: http://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-colorado-springs-511365.html http://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-c...
- gremlinsinc 9y agoThis is scary... kids are impressionable, and having drills like this may actually backfire and romanticize the idea of becoming the shooter for a number of kids who already could be prone to doing that. When we had fire drills I'd often imagine pulling the red lever walking back into the school... to trigger another... not the same thing, and I never thought of starting a fire -- but I also often kind of hoped that one of these drills would be the real thing so we wouldn't have to go back into school.
- Gys 9y agoI wished Americans were as obsessed with keeping their privacy as they are with keeping their guns. Then the internet would be an entirely different place.