2 ms·
Musk offered NASA the opportunity to put something meaningful on the test launch. They declined because they view the Falcon Heavy as a competitor. According t
by adventured 9y ago
Musk offered NASA the opportunity to put something meaningful on the test launch. They declined because they view the Falcon Heavy as a competitor.
According to the former Deputy Administrator of NASA, Lori Garver.
"SpaceX offered NASA the opportunity to get a free ride on this first launch. But the space agency viewed commercial development of this rocket as "competition" and refused their offer. Instead, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk put his own Tesla Roadster onboard, turning the event into a brilliant cross-marketing event."
http://thehill.com/opinion/technology/372994-spacex-could-save-nasa-and-the-future-of-space-exploration http://thehill.com/opinion/technology/372994-spacex-could-sa...
- cheeko1234 9y agoWoah, didn't know this. I'd be very interested in finding out the source of their quote. Who at NASA would ever say that?
- adventured 9y agoI would expect that the former Deputy Administrator of NASA would know people all up and down the current chain of command at NASA. Garver appears to still be active in that world. It makes sense as well, considering NASA's massive investment in the SLS program; they've put billions of dollars into it so far. She has pretty serious credentials to be saying it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lori_Garver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lori_Garver
- bryananderson 9y agoI’m on the same page as Garver on space policy, but I suspect she is wrong about NASA’s (and the Air Force’s) motivation for declining. Anything that NASA wants to launch into space is an extremely expensive, one-of-a-kind science instrument that a team has spent years of their time on. It would be highly imprudent to launch something like that on a test mission. No one does that. The usual payload for a first flight is a concrete block or other mass simulator. NASA and the Air Force made the right call in saying no. And Elon made the right call in turning this into a phenomenally inspiring event instead of a boring launch of a concrete block.
- dmurray 9y agoYou've got to think there are plenty of scientists at NASA who would jump at an offer like "you have two weeks to put an experiment together for this launch, it can't cost more than $50k and you have to be ok with losing it". Just because NASA normally optimizes for expensive projects with years of design time doesn't mean those are the only possible space projects with scientific value. If NASA declined the spot, it's a failure of bureaucracy, not of scientific imagination. Launching a car is still great though. Scientific data isn't the only possible benefit from a space mission.