3 ms·
Once upon a time, there was something called a "personal computer", which executed any program chosen by the person who paid for the device. There is no techni
by walterbell 9y ago
Once upon a time, there was something called a "personal computer", which executed any program chosen by the person who paid for the device.
There is no technical reason why an Apple speaker could not be connected to Alexa, Google or private/niche speech recognition, when desired by the person who paid for the speaker.
This is a $350 device which runs only one app. Why?
- falcolas 9y agoPeople pay $800+ for home entertainment systems which run no apps, for the singular purpose of playing music. If the sound is as good as the Reddit comment said, I can see people thinking "yeah, that's worth it."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nemothekid 9y agoIgnoring the technical reasons (for which there are a couple, non-standard software APIs for one), In that same time, you would have likely paid a fee to have Alexa/Google/Private app to run on your "personal computer".
- askafriend 9y ago> This is a $350 device which runs only one app. Why? Because the consumer doesn't care about the things you care about - they truly don't care at all. Zero. Nil. The consumer wants to play music, they want it to sound good, they want zero setup or calibration involved, they want good software integration with the ecosystem they're already familiar with and they want the device to look good alongside their home decor. Oh and they want reliable, no-lag, multi-room audio so that their setup can expand throughout their home. Now go in the market and tell me which device accomplishes these things. The answer is very very very few. There's Sonos, and really that's about it. There are a bunch of major drawbacks with Sonos: the Sonos app is complete garbage, there's calibration required, it doesn't sound as good, it doesn't look as good and the software integration with any ecosystem let alone Apple's is subpar. With HomePod, those in the Apple ecosystem finally have a best-in-class sounding speaker which is deeply integrated into the software they already know and use throughout their life (Mac, iPad, iPhone, Watch, etc), looks beautiful, is small, and just works with no setup (AirPlay, Real time whole room calibration). To achieve that in one elegant package is no small feat. The reason many people are getting mad is because it's not a device that's for them - which is completely OK. This is a product that is targeted at Apple's consumer base which if you're counting is at nearly a billion users or more. They do not need to appeal to those with an Android phone or those who use Spotify to sell this thing at scale and be successful by any reasonable metric. They simply don't have to, and people can get angry about it all they want.
- refulgentis 9y agoI'd be careful drawing definitive conclusions about the success of a product that shipped last week, then using them to drive larger generalizations about what "many people" think, and after setting up the strawmen, knock them down with arguments about market share in unrelated products. It's okay to criticize flaws in a product, even if this modern-day golden examplar of a vertically integrated company can leverage its integration to move a ton of product.
- askafriend 9y agoI've drawn no conclusions about the success of HomePod. I'm explaining why consumers have indicated that they want it, and why people are excited by it despite it being a "dumb computer" as so many others seem to think. The thing is, whether you like HomePod or not depends on if you want a smart assistant or if you want a really good speaker for your home. If you want the latter, there are few good solutions as elegant as HomePod and if you're in the Apple ecosystem - it's a no brainer at the $350 price point - it really is. It will sell and I think anyone in the market for a high quality audio solution for their home recently will agree (if this is you, then chime in with your experience!). If you want a smart assistant and don't care about the speaker quality as much, then there are tons of alternatives in the market for you at far cheaper price points. HomePod doesn't make sense if all you care about is a smart assistant. Now if you think the metric of success always has to be "Oh but it doesn't match iPhone sales numbers" then Apple will never succeed in your eyes. iPhone is perhaps one of the greatest businesses to have ever been conceived in history by all metrics. Grading a business against that kind of success for literally every subsequent product is not realistic (not saying you are, but many people do tend to do this and it baffles me).
- refulgentis 9y agoI stopped at "Customers have indicated they want it": that's vague enough to be unassailable, yet crucial backbone for 2 essays about how "many people" are fundamentally misunderstanding consumer electronics demand, thus they're not qualified to critique HomePod as a product. I don't think there's much chance of having a productive conversation
- vbezhenar 9y agoMy chipset contains another built-in CPU with flash storage and dedicated RAM. It runs UNIX-like operating system, presumably to act as a backdoor. There's no technical reason why I can't install another operating system and use this hardware for my own tasks (for example remote control like HP iLO). And my motherboard have price around $350 as well. Companies like to abuse their users into locked-down ecosystems, that's why. And the only way to resist it is to hack device and develop your own software.