4 ms·
So, took some UI classes, ate some bagels, gave some talks, met some interesting people, off to Burning Man. All wonderful things but none of them actually say
by pvg 16y ago
So, took some UI classes, ate some bagels, gave some talks, met some interesting people, off to Burning Man. All wonderful things but none of them actually say or show much about what they have got implemented and working.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoThat's a pretty horrible way to summarize someone's efforts. I'll resist the urge to describe pinboard.in the same way.
- peterbraden 16y agoIt's harsh but accurate. Not really deserving of your comment.
- DTrejo 16y agoBut would you say it them in person?
- pvg 16y agoI'll resist the urge to describe pinboard.in the same way. We're always delighted to receive feedback!
- j2d2 16y agoHead's up: You probably shouldn't have a testimonial from a guy who hasn't used your site in months (Prakash)
- pvg 16y agoHeads up: you probably don't know what you're talking about. But if you're curious, ask the user yourself if you happen to know him.
- j2d2 16y agoWhy the condescension? The user's name is clickable and his profile shows he hasn't used the site since March. Instead of being rude, perhaps consider why his experience wasn't sticky.
- iloveyouocean 16y agoI will resist the urge to say that your criticism was "relentlessly built".
- sumeetjain 16y agoA relevant bit of information missing from your summary: We have Diaspora working, we like it, and it will be open-sourced on September 15th. I don't know if everyone knew that already, but it was news to me.
- what 16y agoExcept they don't really have it working. http://pivotallabs.com/talks/107-diaspora http://pivotallabs.com/talks/107-diaspora (the first 30 min is stories about how they met and what they did in school, you can skip that)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- icey 16y agoThat was posted 8 days ago; I don't know how far away they had it from working but a lot can happen in that timeframe if you have people working like it's a startup.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI think this is a kind of mythical man-month moment. Some things can be put together with enough all nighters. But my hunch is a working distributed social networking system isn't one of them. And the reason is that, like operating systems, databases or sophisticated languages, you can't iteratively improve a badly designed complex system (and working with similar things, I've tried...). You especially can't do it at 3:00am. (And unless you've first debugged your design, the chances are your design is bad. Unlike, operating systems, databases or sophisticated languages, there aren't well known patterns for constructed distributed social networking sites... but the problems involved seem at least as hard)
- jlgbecom 16y agoExactly. I'm amazed that people think that Diaspora can accomplish in a few months what Elgg, Appleseed, Onesocialweb, etc. etc. have all been working on for YEARS. Especially when considering that these are being developed by professionals with industry experience, and Diaspora is four college kids. We all want to hear the story of the intrepid engineers working in their parents garage and changing the world, but let's be realistic here.