7 ms·
YouTube CEO on Facebook video ambitions: 'They should get back to baby pictures'
- jsnk 9y agoI cannot believe I am saying this, but I am rooting for Facebook to build a competition against Youtube.
- malandrew 9y agoDitto. It's nice to see this kind of hubris and dismissal be beaten.
- pythonaut_16 9y agoYoutube seems to be one of the more egregious parts of the Google ecosystem. Like sure Gmail has its problems, but ultimately it is an excellent web based email system that's hard to beat because it's a great product. Youtube's main strength seems to be primarily its first mover advantage, and the fact that building a video hosting site is a rather costly venture. Neither of those are a very defensive moat against competitors like Amazon and Facebook
- holydude 9y agoI do not think gmail is an excellent product. For me it's backed by a giant that guarantees its availability and functionality almost anywhere in the world (looking at you China). I would use something else in a blink of an eye.
- iaml 9y agoYeah, my hate for facebook is not going to stop me from enjoying some schadenfreude when facebook hits them hard.
- MarkMc 9y agoWhy? What's wrong with YouTube? Wouldn't Facebook video have the same problems?
- minimaxir 9y agoThat particular comment has generated a lot of appropriate snark in light of YouTube's recent controversies involving disturbing children videos and Logan Paul: https://twitter.com/cwarzel/status/963268727646035968 https://twitter.com/cwarzel/status/963268727646035968
- mad44 9y agoOh my God. She just gave Mark Zuckerberg a rallying chant; he will write this on all Facebook walls and rally developers to improve Facebook video.
- sjg007 9y agoSimilar to what Dell said about Apple back in the day.
- thatgerhard 9y agoAnd change the api the next day destroying all work done by said developers.
- jrs95 9y agoIMO that’s probably good for Google because it’s likely going to be a wasted effort. Even if they built great stuff, I can’t see this being more successful than something like Google+ or Facebook’s attempts at making an Android launcher. There’s just no motivation for users to get on board with this. In terms of video, I think they may be able to do something similar to what Snapchat has done, but that’s about it.
- ebikelaw 9y agoIt will sure end badly for Google, just like that time that Zuck decided to go head-to-head against Gmail. Everybody remembers when Facebook took over from Gmail, right?
- racl101 9y agoToo bad you have to be on Facebook to use Facebook video.
- Kenji 9y agoHahaa sick burn!
- hugh4life 9y agoI actually think there is a huge opportunity for there to be competition with youtube... but not directly under the facebook brand. It'll have to be something like Instagram.
- mslate 9y agoWhy?
- ibdf 9y agoBecause a lot of people don't want all the other stuff that comes with having a facebook.
- gressquel 9y agoYou're right, whenever I see embedded FB-video on forums or reddit I avoid it. If its really a must-see video, I open it in incognito mode.
- Splines 9y agoYoutube gets this right and puts the content first, on all endpoints. I see a youtube video and click it, I get a video. If I see a facebook link, there are many problems: - I don't know if it's a video - I don't know if I'll see a login page or if I'll get to the content - I don't know if the content is viewable by me because of privacy settings And then this works the other way - why should I share a video on facebook when I can't tell if my recipient will be able to see the video? I don't know if they'll get a login prompt. I don't know if they have the permissions to see the video. All this friction doesn't exist with youtube, or at least is extremely minimal.
- rootlocus 9y ago> Youtube gets this right and puts the content first, on all endpoints. I see a youtube video and click it, I get a video. More like "I see a youtube video and click it, I get a 10s commercial"
- dmitrygr 9y agoUnderestimating competition is never a good idea, especially publicly like this. Horse carriage drivers also laughed about automobiles... initially
- IntronExon 9y agoThe early automobiles were a joke, so they called it like they saw it. You can hardly blame people for not seeing where it would lead, often beyond their professional lives. Take for contrast the reaction of French factory workers when automated textile production started to come online, or cabbies when automated fare metering hit.
- revelation 9y agoThis coming from the same YouTube CEO that can't even be arsed to update her own channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCg7fzx4PEk96-7Ec2Ol2dJA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCg7fzx4PEk96-7Ec2Ol2dJA And it's not like nothing happened in those past 4 months.. "I wanted to start a YouTube channel [..] to test and to use all of these creator features myself" She probably gave up after her videos were reported unsuitable, blocked, demonetized, silently delisted, ..
- shiftpgdn 9y agoIt seems very obvious none of the YouTube exec team use the product as a creator. Casey Neistat even interviewed one of their executives this week and his opening question of "Have you ever made a YouTube video?" was hit with a fast "No."
- mmackh 9y agoInstagram is Facebook's attempt to dethrone YT as the dominant player in the video sector. Once they remove time limits and allow some form of basic player controls, we're probably going to see some sort of shift. Instagram's UX/UI is, in my opinion, smoother than that of the YT app.
- jrs95 9y agoIf the content and discoverabilty isn’t there, it’s not going to matter. No matter what Microsoft does with Bing, they’re not going to win for the same reason.
- ggg9990 9y agoInterestingly, we don’t post any baby photos on Facebook because it’s too toxic of an environment. We use WhatsApp, which is still owned by Facebook but much harder for them to monetize.
- steve-benjamins 9y agoYouTube has been an incredible place for building an audience for me. I started publishing videos in November of last year and growth has been dramatic (for me at least— my content is pretty niche, I review website builders): http://s3.amazonaws.com/sitebuilderreport-assets/images/files/000/000/016/original/stats.png?1518544653 http://s3.amazonaws.com/sitebuilderreport-assets/images/file... Facebook on the other hand turned my Facebook "page" into a payola scheme where I had to pay to access my audience. Lame.
- dave84 9y agoIs that all organic traffic?
- steve-benjamins 9y ago41% Youtube suggested videos 31% embeds on my website 19% Youtube search 3% Youtube browse features 3% Youtube channel page
- Siecje 9y agoAssuming no new growth, in 10 months you will be able to make money from YouTube. Do you think the 4000 watch hours in the past 12 months is too high or just right?
- steve-benjamins 9y agoI'm probably not a good person to ask. I make money through affiliate links in my video descriptions— so I have no plans to use Youtube's official monetization programs.
- newbuser 9y agoIf your goal is affiliate clicks, why do views & mins of engagement matter? Seems like the measure would be which platform generated more clicks that convert.
- 9y ago
- cflewis 9y agoDisclaimer: Am Googler My 2c is that for mass consumption, streaming is where the puck is going, not short-form videos. Kids are watching Minecraft streaming, they're not watching punks like Logan Paul until they are in their teens, and my guess is as those younger kids get older, tastes will change and Paul et al will be done. And even when you think about teens, streamers like Dr Disrespect seem to capture far more zeitgeist than YouTubers. Is Casey Neistat really a thing anymore? IMHO Facebook really should be doubling-down on local sharing and improving that experience, Google Photos is far and away the best photo product for me. Replicating YouTube won't work, the quality of the platform and the network effects are too strong. Whether Facebook can do something disruptive like Twitch I don't know. Maybe IRL streaming of C-list celebrities like Snoop or Kylie Jenner?
- MarkMc 9y ago> IMHO Facebook really should be doubling-down on local sharing and improving that experience, Google Photos is far and away the best photo product for me. Do you mean that Google Photos is a better way for you to share your photos than Facebook?
- cflewis 9y agoIt's better for my immediate family, worse for my social network as a whole.
- kenning 9y agodisagree, youtube is the place people go for better-edited, entertainment-focused video game content. pewdiepie is still #1 on youtube and has survived criticisms of being alt-right. also, vloggers and music videos will always be popular with the huge parts of the population that don't play 'core' games. online UGC video is still an immature industry so some of the best content for the average reddit user (20-30 y.o. male) is just mature vloggers criticizing immature vloggers (idubbbz, h3h3) but in the long run better things will surface ('every frame a painting' is an actually great channel for example) twitch has cut out a new market IMO, it's not directly replacing youtube. i expect different things on twitch -- generally speaking, more boring, unprofessional and unedited content that's focused almost entirely on learning how to play games better and occasional audience interaction. as for facebook, i have no idea what they should do because i don't know anyone who likes it anymore
- ilamont 9y agoShe may be right. Facebook has a lot of problems on its plate right now, but one of the worst trends has been the poorly thought out march to video. It came from Zuckerberg (1 and 2) and was repeated by senior FB executives, and then became a mantra for publishers. Many made large investments in video programming for Facebook, only to find the money isn't there and Facebook later decided to demote publisher content (3 and 4). This is not just large media companies that got burned, I know some smaller producers who believed the "five years the feed will be all video" baloney and shifted their efforts accordingly. Some were doing really important work, too, around causes or local news. What a waste. Meanwhile, it seems that overall video consumption in Facebook is declining, and it's the one percent that get the most engagement, regardless of who the publisher is (5). I personally would not mind if Facebook turned back the clock 10 years, when most conversations seemed to be personal and text-based, and the truckloads of memes, ads, gaming achievements, real and fake news, and videos of cats playing the piano had yet to be shoved down Facebook's maw and into our feeds. Old-school text discussions seem to work for HN, why can't it work for Facebook? 1. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-news-feed-784376 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/mark-zuckerberg-faceb... 2. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/facebook-shares-up-revenue-growth-970957 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/facebook-shares-up-re... 3. https://www.recode.net/2017/1/17/14269406/facebook-live-video-deals-paid https://www.recode.net/2017/1/17/14269406/facebook-live-vide... 4. https://digiday.com/media/digiday-research-publishers-making-money-facebook-video/ https://digiday.com/media/digiday-research-publishers-making... 5. https://www.wochit.com/blog/social-video-performance-index-2017/ https://www.wochit.com/blog/social-video-performance-index-2...
- eropple 9y ago> Old-school text discussions seem to work for HN, why can't it work for Facebook? People don't really read in the same way as you might have previously expected. ("Reading a short blurb or a tweet" is not the same thing.) Can't or don't want to, I don't know, but they don't. You see the edges of it here, too--tl;drs on HN posts, sometimes, that are less than a screenful of text. And people think you're "spending a lot of effort" when you bang out a post about as long as yours is--and, sometimes, try to frame it as a bad thing. I tend to think Thomas Pettitt has a point[1]. [1] - https://archives.cjr.org/the_audit/the_future_is_medieval.php https://archives.cjr.org/the_audit/the_future_is_medieval.ph...
- osrec 9y agoThere is certainly space to compete with YouTube. I think YouTube ads are getting a bit annoying, especially when you can't skip them. If a valid challenger were to arise, I feel monetisation strategy is where this battle will be lost or won. The least annoying/intrusive will win every time.
- Splines 9y agoIMO Facebook video is a non-starter because of branding. Facebook is not a destination for video. Facebook is to video as youtube is to social networking.
- stale2002 9y agoThis is true. There was recently a huge controversy in the Dota 2 community, because a major tournament exclusively moved to Facebook livestreaming (away from twitch). One of the most common complaints was something like "I'd never use Facebook, because I hate the company!" Also, frankly, the tech product for livestreaming isn't anywhere near feature competitive.
- oh_sigh 9y ago"I mean" said 7 times. Maybe that is the benefit of "umm" - when you have that verbal tic, it usually isn't included in transcriptions.
- rrggrr 9y agoFacebook isn't going away. However it seems to be coming apart because its hard to argue that FB improves, rather than burdens, people's lives. Its simply easier, less distracting and often happier connecting outside FB's walled garden. For example: Messenger --> rampant competition from about a dozen apps. Community --> reported audience declines. From participation fatigue, privacy concerns, and competing sites. Publishing --> push-back from content providers and publishers who don't wish to be assimilated into the 'borg'. Payments --> no real competitive offering. FederatedID/SSO --> rampant competition from Google, LinkedIN, Github, etc. I really believe Facebook is grossly overvalued as an internet property, much in the same way MySpace and AOL were in the 'old days'. I also suspect that Twitter remains undervalued in terms of influence and - importantly - 2nd/3rd order reach (eg. republishing). There's something to be said for building products that make people's lives easier and truly happier, and I'm not sure that FB does either anymore.
- dfabulich 9y ago> I really believe Facebook is grossly overvalued as an internet property You could have made this exact argument in 2012 when FB was worth $20/share. Was this argument wrong in 2012 but correct in 2018?
- thrillgore 9y agoOh man, don't be this smug. You be this smug, you regret it later.
- cgarduno1 9y agoYoutube isn't perfect but the facebook video player is terrible.
- solarkraft 9y agoFacebook isn't a good contender, not on its main website, but YouTube is falling quickly and this talk just motivates competitors more.