22 ms·
How Apple Plans to Root Out Bugs, Revamp iPhone Software
- steve19 9y agoI wish they would put focus on macOS. The recent bugs have been laughable. I am seriously considering switching for the first time in about 16 years. The lure of better more affordable dev hardware is almost to much.
- dijit 9y agoThe options are not strong elsewhere though. I went with a precision because I assumed linux support would be top notch, and it was. But I widely suspect other similarly classed devices are not. (see also; the comparatively buggy XPS series also from Dell)
- computerex 9y agoXPS is amazing.
- walterbell 9y agoPlease enable per-app VPNs via Apple Configurator, i.e. without an enterprise MDM. This will allow separation of work and personal VPNs. Please allow auto-connect VPN profiles to be associated with a whitelist of SSIDs, so that insecure networks (e.g. coffee shop) will auto-connect to a VPN. Finally, please add a Control Center button to reconnect the default VPN profile.
- mrkstu 9y agoAgreed on all of those. Additionally make re-connecting an iPad to an iPhone sharing a connection automatic (optionally) if no known wifi networks are available.
- aetherspawn 9y agoFor those of us with personal data limits, that could be annoying. I did that once, forgot to disconnect and it used like 2gb (of monthly 8gb) performing sync “over WiFi”. And Apple cares about this problem you can tell because the WiFi off button now only lasts 24hr before automatically turning back on (to avoid data waste).
- izacus 9y agoDoesn't iPad recognise tethered connections as mobile connections (like Android tablets do)?
- rconti 9y agoNot a UI feature, but I found this guide last fall and have been using it flawlessly since. I whitelisted a few SSIDs and everything else goes through the VPN. Even works with walled auth garden networks like xfinity wifi. https://thomas-witt.com/auto-connect-your-ios-device-to-a-vpn-when-joining-an-unknown-wifi-d1df8100c4ba https://thomas-witt.com/auto-connect-your-ios-device-to-a-vp...
- TheAceOfHearts 9y agoIt's not perfect, but I think that's what network location is meant to be used for. Check out: How to use network locations on your Mac [0]. I wish you could trigger more preferences automatically based on location or other factors. For example: I only want to enable certain sharing features when I'm at home. [0] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202480 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202480
- reaperducer 9y agoGood. Let's hope that other companies follow (MS, Google, Adobe, etc...). What I want for Christmas is to swap phones with Tim Cook for a week. I think it would be eye-opening for him to have to use an iPhone that isn't fresh out of the box for once.
- jzawodn 9y agoLOL! You said Adobe...
- vxNsr 9y ago>The company will continue to update its software annually, but internally engineers will have more discretion to push back features that aren't as polished to the following year. Let's hope Microsoft follows suit. I would much rather have a product that works the same way every time over one that can do 1000 things half the time. Hopefully this will also give them time to reconsider some of the more ill-conceived UX choices they've made in recent years. If they'd spent more than 6 months using the iPhone X I doubt it would've been released as is.
- GirlsCanCode 9y agoMicrosoft? Windows 10 is rock-solid. So much so that I've "switched back" to windows about 2 years ago and don't regret it.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI don't think Microsoft has a code quality problem at all. On the contrary I'm hard pressed to point at any recent Microsoft software and say it's bug ridden or low quality or badly designed. From iOS to Android to Windows, Microsoft software is excellent.
- megaman22 9y agoHave they fixed the issues with the Fall Creator Update of Windows 10 yet? It basically bricked every workstation that we let update to it, and we had to wipe them and put LTSB on to get back to work.
- computerex 9y agoThe constant nagging for updates could be considered a flaw in design. I think Microsoft has always had the reputation of producing buggy software with usability issues. I think they have gotten a lot better at all that.
- arvinsim 9y ago> The constant nagging for updates could be considered a flaw in design. That's not a code quality problem.
- suyash 9y agoThis is a very common problem in large software companies that I can relate to. There is always pressure of the next big release and as a result bugs get punted, code starts to get out of order but there is not time to refactor and pause as the next release is just behind waiting for more features and limited bug fixes. Software Engineers and Management need to re-think of a better strategy to deal with these issues.
- askafriend 9y agoThis comment from a former employee on the iOS team provides some more context around the software quality issues. I think this is the more interesting point around which we should have this discussion. https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/7x0eif/how_apple_plans_to_root_out_bugs_and_revamp/du4z6bx/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/7x0eif/how_apple_pla...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- objclxt 9y agoI have a slightly different perspective (I worked on iOS 7 - 11). One of the things about Apple that's different to many of the other tech conglomerates is that engineering teams are given huge freedom to work the way they want (for better and for worse). Because engineering is so fragmented you should always take what one person says about the process with a pinch of salt. So that means there are hundreds of source repos, patch review systems, and the like. When I was there I saw teams using Phabricator, GitLab, GitHub, plain e-mailed diffs, and more. In the same way EPMs and project process varies massively across teams, so what that employee experienced is by no means the norm. Certainly I didn't find this to be true at all: > Nothing could be worked on if it wasn’t in Radar with a priority number attached and signed off by the teams’ EPM. No room for a side project or time away from your daily duties because there were always P1s to fix. In fact, I worked on a major feature that was keynoted one year that came out purely because of my side project work. If anything it was a frustration to enter the "real world" where PMs had so much more power and influence than they did when I was at Apple (where PMs didn't really exist, and EPMs existed only to manage project timelines and drive features that HI / ID came up with).
- chuckdries 9y agoDo you think some level of standardization of process would help apple as a whole? Would it help eliminate the relatively poor experience of reddit-OP?
- 9y ago
- staunch 9y agoWhat originally made the iPhone unique and powerful was that it included a full blown web browser, in the form of the Safari app. Steve Jobs announced the iPhone as a "Phone," "iPod," and "Internet Communicator." The name "Internet Communicator" indicates how different it is from the other two apps. The Phone and iPod functionality are really a subset of the Internet Communicator. And because the future is open web technologies, not propriety platforms like iOS, Apple should move towards that world by making advanced PWA (Progressive Web Apps) the future of all apps on iOS. It will make installing apps on your phone as safe and easy as bookmarking a web site. It will be much closer to an optimal experience for users and developers. It's the future and Apple should be first.
- mkhalil 9y agoThat would be great, but the web is still not as fast as native. So either these PWA's are slightly different than web sites, or Apple works hard to expand OS APIs that are accessible via modern web browsers.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoThat’s definitely not what made the iPhone unique. It was one benefit, but hardly the only one, or even the main one. You hope that open technologies are the future, but it remains to be seen. Regardless, a rapid shift to PWAs is not at all in Apple’s interest, and I highly doubt they’re going to do that. They want all the best apps, developers, and customers to be concentrated on iOS. That’s how things are now (I’m sure many will disagree), and making it easier for users to exit the Apple ecosystem will only hurt them. Apple’s strategy is to invite users into a high-quality, comprehensive ecosystem, and then sell them more devices (and increasingly services) over time. The best way to do that is to provide a differentiated experience that can’t be replicated elsewhere. Given that, why on earth would they shift to focus on PWAs over increasing their hold on the factors that differentiate them?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- staunch 9y ago
- IBM 9y agoSteven Sinofsky has a good Twitter thread about this [1]. He's one of the few people actually qualified to talk about managing platforms and operating systems at Apple's scale. [1] https://twitter.com/stevesi/status/963142502604779520 https://twitter.com/stevesi/status/963142502604779520
- pjmlp 9y agoGiven what he pushed for with Windows 8, and killing WP 7 alongside XNA, I am not so sure.
- IBM 9y agoThe alternative is hearing what web and app developers think Apple should/shouldn't be doing, which Twitter and HN are full of.
- runjake 9y agoIf you keep up with Sinofsky's writings, it seems like he's learned a lot of tough lessons from making some pretty big mistakes and come out the better for it.
- mathattack 9y agoYes. I enjoy his blog and twitter postings, but somehow his book didn't come alive for me.
- hyperrail 9y agoSteven Sinofsky wasn't in charge of Windows Phone when that division decided to have no device upgrade path from WP7 to WP8 (or, for that matter, no upgrade path _or_ application compatibility from WP6.5 to WP7.0). The person in charge of Windows Phone then was Terry Myerson, who had an entirely different reporting chain to Steve Ballmer from Sinofsky's. Myerson was later promoted to run R&D for all Microsoft operating systems in early 2014. (Yes, that means he was also the person responsible for killing Windows on phones most recently, at least for now.) The death of XNA also didn't happen under Sinofsky's watch. XNA came out of the Xbox division and was abandoned by the same division, before it was combined with Windows under Myerson. If anything, Myerson kept XNA alive longer by making sure it was still supported on WP8.0 and WP8.1 when he ran Windows Phone, and by ensuring that Windows continued to fund MonoGame as an open-source successor/replacement for XNA.
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoThis is sorely needed. Every iOS update has introduced bugs and UX gremlins that have been dragging Apple's software quality through the mud. Chief among them is Apple Music, since it is a huge part of Apple's service initiative. - Their latest update now wastes space to tell me it isn't playing anything! - Often times just refuses to work. No error, no graceful recover. Just silence. https://imgur.com/a/VrO1Y https://imgur.com/a/VrO1Y - Airdrop seems to only work if I have a cable near me. When I really need it, it fails miserably and I end up using dropbox or even emailing things to myself.
- cm2187 9y agoITunes on windows has just become unusable to me. Right now when I open it it gets caught in an inifinite loop of login prompts, even if the credentials are correct. It has never been good but right now it is just utterly broken. And every new update brings new catastrophes to the point that I delay them as much as I can.
- dingo_bat 9y agoiTunes on windows and Apple music on Android made me cancel my subscription and switch to google play music. I was amused that Apple software was so bad across two different systems.
- wil421 9y agoI open iTunes like maybe twice a year. Last night I opened it and only logged in once. I plugged in an old iPad 3 the hadn’t charged in 9 months or so and I discovered one thing. The password it was asking for to access the iPad wasn’t my current iCloud password. It was the iCloud password I used to setup the iPad. A little frustrating when I didn’t remember it but once I removed the device from find my iPhone everything worked.
- csomar 9y agoAre you sure you got the last update? Because Apple music has been a PITA for me too (especially that I use it with my car bluetooth) and I had the same issues you mentioned here. However, all the issues were fixed in the last update and so far it is pretty solid. No complaints. (iOS v11.2.5)
- heavymark 9y agoThis rumor has been around past few months, hoping it's true. Though while us technies in the minority would rather bug fixes than new features that don't apply for us, the general public would be very upset if iOS12 changes are all under the hood, as they would say Apple has fallen behind and people will insert common statements every years like they are finally considering switching etc. So while I hope the do fix long standing small bugs, I think the average user would lose their mind if they do. I imagine it will be a mix, some new features and some fixes.
- bsimpson 9y agoThe Mac has had an optimization-centric release following a feature release many times (all the Snow releases, El Capitan). I don't remember mass complaints. (By its name, High Sierra ought to be an optimization of Sierra also, but its bugginess suggests otherwise.)
- username223 9y agoThere wouldn't be mass complaints. My family are absolute non-techies, while I am something like a techie, and none of us would complain if Apple did a few pure bug-fix releases. Non-techies don't completely understand the current situation where developers care far more about themselves than their users, but they have learned that software "upgrades" will usually waste their time and make their lives worse. Apple can actually fight this, since their users are their customers.
- david-cako 9y agoI think the iPhone has historically had more of an attitude of "look at all of the awesome new computer-ey things your phone can do!", whereas computers have always been treated more like appliances. It's much easier to tell a user "the new version of Mac/Windows has absolutely nothing new you care about." than to sit by the wayside while android devices have split-screen and curved displays. Consumers and shareholders like cell phones because they're shiny.
- cm2187 9y agoThe next update will bring a revolutionary new feature, an original invention by Apple, a courageous leap forward. It will bring STEREO playback to its homepods!
- freejulian 9y agoThey should start by getting rid of Swift and all their proprietary APIs. Xcode is a never ending exercise in frustration. Their storyboard UI builder is even worse. And API's are constantly being deprecated and "best development practices" constantly changing.
- saagarjha 9y ago> They should start by getting rid of Swift and all their proprietary APIs. Swift is open source, and parts of Foundation are as well. As for their UI design toolkit, you can't possibly expect them to match that of their competitors, right? > API's are constantly being deprecated and "best development practices" constantly changing. Believe it or not, but writing apps in a 32-bit C API (Carbon) may not be the best way to do it. Modernization is crucial to making your platform better.
- sjg007 9y agoI thought Apple cut their QA department a few, maybe 5 years ago.
- minimaxir 9y ago[deleted]
- x0x0 9y agoYeah, but you get releases where I could hard lock the OS by plugging/unplugging an HDMI monitor approx 20 times (7 MBPs bought over the course of 3 months in late 2014; 3 different brands of HDMI monitor) and that's the only way you can make sense of someone letting a bug like that out the door.
- saagarjha 9y agoGiven that they're hiring for QA currently…
- randyrand 9y agoIf they just added the ability to jump to a given date in text messages, I'd be happy. That's a long overdue simple feature.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoHonestly, this sounds like the kind of niche feature that leads to bloatware. I can’t imagine hardly anyone would use this often, and really hope they don’t add it.
- eightysixfour 9y agoThis would not be necessary if search weren’t awful, but as is they need to do one or the other. The inability to look for multiple instances of a word in a single conversation is insane.
- dkonofalski 9y agoThat seems a lot less useful than a functional search for messages. I hate the fact that I can only search for 1 instance of my search within a conversation. There's no way to go to a previous or next instance from the instance that the search feature already found. That sucks.
- Kognito 9y agoThis! The Mac Messages app has the same UI for search and its possible to jump between the found messages using a keyboard shortcut. Makes me wonder if the functionality exists in iOS too but someone forgot to build it into the UI.
- randyrand 9y agoI agree, but perhaps a functional search is asking for too much. I'd be happy with either. If you don't have a good key word to use, then jumping to a date range is the next best thing.
- abimaelmartell 9y agoAutoplay video, just what i wanted.
- andrewstuart 9y agoI tried to upgrade OSX the other day and the upgrade hung half way, leaving me to restore my hard disk from backup. More quality assurance and testing would be welcomed.
- rusk 9y agoAt last
- tempodox 9y agoI'll hold my praises until I see how this actually works out. Xcode behaves more like a roulette wheel with every update and by now, even Terminal crashes on me every time I use it. It has gotten to the point where I consciously avoid using Apple apps because It Just Doesn't Work. Thank the gods of FOSS for iTerm2.
- chime 9y agoAfter one of the recent updates, if I use a keyboard shortcut to switch to a tab while the mouse is over the Terminal window, it starts to rapidly cycle between tabs and will not stop until I move the mouse away. You can try to reproduce this by opening two tabs in Terminal, moving the mouse over it, then pressing Cmd+Shift+] for more than a few tens of ms. This has interrupted my workflow enough that I started to look for alternatives to Terminal.
- gergles 9y agoI just hope they can make Spotlight work. I can drag down from the home menu, type the full name of an app on the phone, and only get random other results (or the App Store link to the app.) e.g.: https://imgur.com/a/jYE9M https://imgur.com/a/jYE9M (reminders is a built-in app but apparently Spotlight's never heard of it)
- whitehouse3 9y agoYou can manually select which apps can be found with Spotlight in the settings app. I had the same problem finding 1Password until I went into settings and explicitly added it. This is terrible UX, but that’s how to fix it on your device until Apple sorts it out.
- gergles 9y agoThank you for this! I had no idea, but about half the apps on my phone were randomly set as "do not show in search". I definitely never had seen these settings before, so am boggled as to why Apple just randomly decided to ship an ineffective search.
- skittleson 9y agoBeing customer obsessed is what this implies in my mind. "The renewed focus on quality is designed to make sure the company can fulfill promises made each summer at the annual developers conference and that new features work reliably and as advertised..."
- mosselman 9y agoI Just opened the website on my phone and was greeted with some auto playing video. How much of my monthly data that costs? No idea, but it is probably more than I cared for. How much of it did I watch and hear? Nothing seeing as I am on the bus. Not so strange as I am on a _mobile_ phone. I wouldn’t even watch it on desktop let alone now. Bad practice
- bsaul 9y agoI hope they don’t only focus on some minor app bugs, but also address the big giant elephant in the room : speed has been going down in a dramatric fashion release after release since ios 7. There’s one word i wish i’d seen and haven’t so far : refactoring.
- kvczor 9y agoThat's what I expect from Apple and that's why I'm buying their stuff - I want it to work not to have all unnecessary whistles and bells.
- jrobichaud 9y agoAnother step toward “OS as a service” like many games and softwares. I hope they will not fall in that pattern.
- EADGBE 9y agoAs boring at it sounds, this is probably more important that most people think. The "just works" mentality of iOS/Apple products is the key factor for keeping it in our family ecosystem. Just last night, I tried my damnedest to print an IRS PDF form online. Printer's on, wifi is the same as my Thinkpad, printer is visible to laptop, etc. Nothing worked. Print was "offline" for the print queue. Just pulled out my phone, searched for the form name, opened the pdf and hit "Print" from the share screen. It's always worked, and did perfectly again. That's the greatest thing about it. I didn't want to debug. I do enough of that shit at work.
- musha68k 9y agoThis is happening almost exactly three years after many of us came to the conclusion that “Apple has lost the functional high ground”. Relieving to learn that Apple tries to get back into shape again! Marco was right: https://marco.org/2015/01/04/apple-lost-functional-high-ground https://marco.org/2015/01/04/apple-lost-functional-high-grou... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8836734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8836734
- aj7 9y agoThis totally off subject but how bout a charger cable with a 2-year lifespan. So give me my negative points.
- CodeSheikh 9y agoI wonder if the mixed reviews of iOS 11 have led them to do such major overhaul. Say if iOS was responsibility of one software dev team, and they recently hired a new project manager to overlook iOS 11 development and release then I would definitely transfer that PM somewhere else in the corp along with QA guys. For example that bug "typing the letter 'I' autocorrects to an 'A; with a unicode [?] symbol instead" might not be that big of a deal, but as we all noticed how such minute change had drastic ripple effect in entire Apple's ecosystem.
- pdimitar 9y agoThe smartphone market isn't fiercely contested anymore IMO. The features that Android and iOS offer are very similar. I am still very annoyed that I can't make my iPhone X automatically increase ringer volume when it gets out of range of my home WiFi (read: when I get out) while I can do that on my Android (with automation apps) but truthfully, such complaints are 3-4 at the most and I barely even notice the annoyance (at least not often). So the fierce competition is a moot point nowadays. I applaud Apple for recognizing they need to focus on quality and I hope the results will come soon.