9 ms·
Sweden tried to drop Assange extradition in 2013
- slivym 9y agoEveryone is owed due process to some extent. But in this case, are we really bothered about a guy who isn't in the UK, has broken UK bail conditions, and is quite likely to have actively participated in attacks against some of the UK's closest allies. I think he should go round to his local lawyer and ask about taking the UK police to court. He deserves to see stand in that court room and hear them answer for why this happened. He doesn't seem to want to though... He just seems to want to moan on twitter without leaving his home...
- Retric 9y agoAs an activist the goal is often to create noise rather than to avoid prison. People don't want to portray him in that light as it elevates his position and might not be accurate.
- elif 9y agoWhich publication do you consider an attack?
- sschueller 9y agoStop spreading FUD. Wikileaks has not actively participated in any attacks. Wikileaks has exposed some of the most horrific crimes committed by the Unites States and others yet we are still trying to kill the messenger.
- thrillgore 9y agoCollateral Murder was an eye opener, but now he's a lapdog of Russia, and a martyr to Trump. Julian is useless now.
- openasocket 9y agoSerious question, what crimes has Wikileaks exposed? I'm sure there are some, but off the top of my head the most serious crimes the US has committed in recent history have been exposed by Snowden or Congressional investigations.
- zanny 9y agoThey leaked the Baghdad airstrike video that got people mad for a few days before not doing anything about it. They also released tons of military files relating to the Iraq / Afghan war and Gitmo that confirmed a lot of popular theory about the goings on over there - torture, Geneva violations, etc.
- openasocket 9y agoSure, but torture in Guantanamo Bay was also the subject of a lot of coverage, including the results of an extremely detailed and exhaustingly documented Congressional inquiry, that I found to be of much greater value. I consider that inquiry to be much more valuable because, not only did it go into great detail when and why torture took place, but also demonstrated that torture resulted in no useful intelligence data.
- randcraw 9y agoThe persistence of the British CPS in pursuing Assange shows how tight the militaries are between the US and Commonwealth nations. AFAIK, Britain had no personal stake in Wikileaks / Assange. But because America badly wanted to suppress Wikileaks and its ilk from future revelations, Britain has persisted in its surrogate prosecution of Assange. I wonder, is there no blowback among Brits for the Crown so baldly adopting the role of America's attack dog? Or is that de rigueur now?
- saiya-jin 9y agoIs this surprising at all? I recall when Bush jr told those fairy tales about Iraq WMD in UN, everybody stared in disbelief how badly he/they tried to desperately create a pretext for a massive invasion/declaring a war to a sovereign nation without any solid reason. I recall well how Germans and French who opposed were openly mocked by US politicians and media (french fries -> freedom fries, anybody?). UK was the only nation who stood by US in this joke of a politics without questions, and were very happy to begin invasion along US. I mean come on, that's not more than 15 years ago and was well covered by all major media.
- jacquesm 9y agoI don't think it is that simple. You thumb your nose at a judge at your own peril, regardless of how much merit there was to the original case and regardless of where your sympathies lie with respect to WL and Assange the fact is that there is absolutely no way the UK govt/judicial branch would let a known fugitive skip like this even after the original case was dropped. It is bordering on the farcical how much money they have spent on this and just because of that they eventually have to show a result. The only other alternative is that Assange leaves the embassy in a coffin.
- revelation 9y agoThis isn't even a UK case. What do they care if Sweden wants to drop it?
- jacquesm 9y ago
- callesgg 9y agoI don't like when things that are clearly not nation state issues is written about as if it was nation state issues.
- acct1771 9y agoWho would you put the blame on?
- notahacker 9y agoJudicial systems consist of individual people attempting to interpret sets of rules, sometimes with conflicting opinions over interpretations and priorities that change over time. It's reasonably evident even from the limited number of emails quoted that this was not "Sweden wanting to do X, but the UK prevented them because $politicalagendaofUK" but prosecutor Marianne Ny notifying her UK counterpart that Swedish procedure may require her to drop the case and the counterpart expressing exasperation given the amount of resources the UK had dedicated to fulfilling their own obligations to honour European Arrest Warrants...
- barking 9y agoI'd like the press to shine a light on the lawyer who was so keen to get Sweden to pursue the case. I'm sure he prefers being nameless.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt wasn't a lawyer, it was the Swedish prosecutor that did this, and it wasn't a 'he' but a 'she' (Marianne Ny). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assange_v_Swedish_Prosecution_Authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assange_v_Swedish_Prosecution_...
- barrkel 9y agoThat's not who the parent is talking about - who was on the UK side, the person who retired and caused their email archives to get deleted.
- jacquesm 9y agoRight, my bad. Weirdest thing though, you'd think that they would at least preserve any and all emails related to a case that is so strongly in the public eye. And for the longest time the UK was if not outright promoting the idea that the Swedes wanted the case to be continued definitely not denying that and claiming that instead the UK was pushing things forward.
- guitarbill 9y agoOr the CPS' policy of email "retention". In this day and age, something like that cannot be allowed to happen by accident. There should be backups, and there's no reason not to keep emails he wrote in his professional capacity as a part of the judiciary. By the way, the lawyer's name is Paul Close [0], and it's shockingly difficult to find anything about him on on search engines, but more so on Google than others IMO. (Although given his age, this isn't too surprising in context to personal artefacts, but journalistically speaking it's interesting why he's mentioned so little.) [0] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/oct/19/julian-assange-lawyers-may-launch-new-appeal-emails https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/oct/19/julian-assange...
- jvehent 9y agoThis is much more complex than a lone hacker being persecuted by an oppressive US government. There is suspicion that Wikileaks is one arm of Russian propaganda, and while I do not know if this is true or not, it does turn the entire Assange story into an intricate mess of international politics and power plays.
- achileas 9y agoWhile circumstantial, the timeline of WL threatening to release leaked Putin documents (~2010, IIRC), never releasing those docs, then getting spots on RT is fairly damning, as well as the Russian bot amplification of WL document drops, especially during the 2016 election.
- cryoshon 9y agocounterpoint: putin is willing to befriend enemies for pragmatic reasons, as is WL. i believe that this is actually the case rather than longstanding collaboration based on WL originating as a russian intelligence program. anything is possible, of course.
- sschueller 9y agoThis one arm of Russian propaganda is US propaganda. Just another current "enemy" that the US is trying to link with Wikileaks because it's convenient. Watch this shift to China or NK when Russia is no longer a "current enemy".
- jacquesm 9y ago> There is suspicion that Wikileaks is one arm of Russian propaganda You can sufficiently explain all WL actions by simply assuming that they will do whatever it takes to hurt US interests.
- wernercd 9y agoAs a US Veteran and a US Citizen... if exposing truth hurts US interests - maybe US interests deserve to be hurt? All politics aside (as if that's possible), we should always strive to learn and expose truth...
- gaius 9y agoThe Lauri Love case proves there’s zero probability of Assange being extradited to the US. He’s wanted here for skipping bail. The government can’t let the precedent be set that you can get away with it, or everyone would do it.
- jacquesm 9y agoI don't think it proves that. I think that the US would like to get their hands on JA a lot more than they ever wanted to get their hands on Lauri Love.
- gaius 9y agoAlso, Gary McKinnon in 2012.
- jacquesm 9y agoBoth are UK citizens, Assange definitely is not, besides that he was never - as far as we know - on a wanted list of people wanted specifically for any computer related crimes but for an arguably much more serious offense. Also: Assange's fear was not to be extradited from the UK to the USA but from Sweden. Whether that is realistic or not is another matter entirely but there is some precedent.
- gsnedders 9y ago> Also: Assange's fear was not to be extradited from the UK to the USA but from Sweden. Whether that is realistic or not is another matter entirely but there is some precedent. If he's extradited from the UK to Sweden, they then they UK consent to a further extradition from Sweden, and he can fight extradition in both the UK and Sweden. (Unless, of course, they go for an "extraordinary" extradition, which seems unlikely in such a high-profile case.)
- rbobby 9y agoHow afraid is he though? Not afraid enough to tweet an offer to "agree to US extradition" if Obama showed clemency to Manning.
- felipelemos 9y agoThis whole situation is a laugh at the "democratic freedom" situation that we live today. At least in some countries ruled by a dictatorship there is no such hypocrisy.
- IntronExon 9y agoOh yeah, dictatorships are famously irony-free. cough Democratic People’s Republic of Korea cough
- FireBeyond 9y ago"Every faction in Africa calls themselves by these noble names - Liberation this, Patriotic that, Democratic Republic of something-or-other... I guess they can't own up to what they usually are: the Federation of Worse Oppressors Than the Last Bunch of Oppressors. Often, the most barbaric atrocities occur when both combatants proclaim themselves Freedom Fighters." -- Lord of War
- felipelemos 9y agoI'm not in favour of a dictatorship, but I neither think that our democracy is so much better in the current state, with border patrol with almost unlimited power for ex.
- 23443463454 9y agoIt's quite a lopsided relationship humans have developed with the elite that control their lives and use the mechanisms of facade democracies and process to appease and distract those who want to believe that things are legitimate and honest and good, when reality is the opposite. The Obama administration and it's origins in the globalist elite cabal trying to reestablish elite domination over the whole planet is just a clear example of that dynamic. The vast majority of people seem to think that the Obama administration was some sort of force for good, when reality is quite the opposite and the vast majority of humanity was being (and quite possibly still is being) led to a horrible outcome. Reality simply is when you relinquish power and control over yourself and your live's choices, you will never get that back and it is far more likely than not that those you entrust with control and power over your life will not be making choices that are in your best interest.
- Tomte 9y agoMy prediction is the same that it has been for the last years: At some point, Assange will leave the embassy, possibly for medical reasons, be arrested and extradited to Sweden In Sweden he will be interrogated and set free without any conditions. Not "illegally rendered" to America, but "you're free, go wherever you want". At that point Assange will be able to ponder his need for drama and attention on the one hand. And all those lost years on the other hand. But hey, he got Pamela Anderson! I would find that ending almost poetic.
- tmalsburg2 9y agoThe article says (paragraph 4) that Sweden dropped the arrest warrant last year. So I'm afraid that your preferred ending of the story is unlikely.
- belorn 9y ago> The CPS lawyer also told Ny that year: “It is simply amazing how much work this case is generating. It sometimes seems like an industry. Please do not think this case is being dealt with as just another extradition.” Pure government corruption and waste. If those lawyers was speaking of an official policy decision of the CPS, how many laws would they be breaking?
- singularity2001 9y agoSeparately, Pompeo described WikiLeaks as a “non-state hostile intelligence service”. ... as opposed to a certain state-hostile intelligence service
- RuggeroAltair 9y agoI am just sad for all the victims of rape in the UK that haven't probably seen, even remotely, the same police efforts made for this accusation. It happened in a different country, and parts of the accusation wouldn't even be a crime in the UK, and obviously there are political goals behind, given the strange sequence of police work. I'm thinking about what would happen if instead of Assange we were dealing with a person from a country where religion and government are intertwined, and that person was asking for asylum to the UK for accusations that are not crimes in the UK.