4 ms·
>If someone with the right technical skills wants to generate a profit that consistently beats the market, they can do so [...] by playing on-line Poker?!? Ju
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
>If someone with the right technical skills wants to generate a profit that consistently beats the market, they can do so [...]
by playing on-line Poker?!?
Just because clever people win doesn't mean you will win because you're clever. In order for you to win someone else has to lose.
"But I'm recognising inherent market inefficiencies and adding value, not profiting off other's failed gambles". Phooey.
- dsacco 9y ago> Just because clever people win doesn't mean you will win because you're clever. No, there is no guarantee. But you can develop an edge that is statistically distinguishable from random outcomes, and less formally, that distinguishes your activity from gambling. > In order for you to win someone else has to lose. Single trades imply a zero sum game in which one counterparty has to lose for the other to profit, yes. But the market itself is not a zero sum game. The net, aggregate result of trading activity is positive value. > "But I'm recognising inherent market inefficiencies and adding value, not profiting off other's failed gambles". Phooey. You’re doing both, if we’re being frank about it. This is a positive statement - it’s plainly true and follows from reasonably agreed upon definitions. You can assign a normative (moral) value to the concept of arbitrage in zero sum games one way or the other, but that’s not really relevant to the discussion at hand. If you don’t want to participate in active trading, you don’t have to - you can invest in passive index funds, which is a perfectly sane and well-reasoned decision. Professional traders don’t try to disguise the fact that they profit from a zero sum activity between consenting adults. But that has nothing to do with the process of price discovery, which is a well-recognized economic concept that is facilitated by active trading. Price discovery is not a moral imperative, it’s just a thing that happens through economically incentivized asset exchange.
- roenxi 9y ago> No, there is no guarantee. But you can develop an edge that is statistically distinguishable from random outcomes, and less formally, that distinguishes your activity from gambling. Sure, it isn't gambling, but there are lies, damn lies and statistics. The effect of survivorship bias in this field is massive. Consider that the random element isn't necessarily the stock performance over 12 months. The indicators the traders use are, in a sense, randomly determined by the trader's personality and knowledge. If the stock market operates in a deterministic fashion for, say, 10 year stretches (which I think is about the time between major recessions) then the rules get changed in a major way, this "statistically distinguishable" edge may well disappear taking a hypothetical small-time saver's retirement fund with it. We see this every time there is a crash, where a bunch of firms with a clear statistical edge go bankrupt because the statistical edge relied on some specific market condition. A lot of people make more money than me with clever deals, but at the end of the day the only strategy that everyone can follow simultaneously is creating more than they consume and stockpiling the excess. Maybe stockpile a little on the low side if they have faith in continuing benefits from technology growth outpacing population growth.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y ago>> In order for you to win someone else has to lose. Please explain why this is necessarily true in the stock market. You buy X at $Y. Then sell X to me for $Y+1. You won. I then sell X to someone else for $Y+2. I won. Hence in that transaction, we both win.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 9y agoWhich of the two transactions you described is the win-win?
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoThey are both win-win, even if the wins are not simultaneous.
- ceejayoz 9y agoSure, if you ignore the impact on the third party you've introduced. That's like calling a pyramid scheme a win-win-win-win-win-win-OHFUCK situation.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoI see your point. However, there are outcomes where I buy a stock and hold it. The company's profits increase over time. They start paying dividends, and I never sell. There are many companies that generate enduring profit and thereby enable win-win.
- auntienomen 9y agoI make some money holding Amazon, and decide to rebalance because I'm uncomfortable with my portfolio concentration. You buy Amazon shares from me. Amazon continues to go up. Which of us just won?